Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-45l2p Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-26T16:27:14.891Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Nonrevolutionary Peasantry of Modern Iran

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2022

Farhad Kazemi  and
Ervand Abrahamian
Farhad Kazemi
Affiliation:
New York University Baruch College of the City University, New York
Ervand Abrahamian
Affiliation:
New York University Baruch College of the City University, New York
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The persistence of tradition needs explanation as much as change. It may be that people cleave to ancestral ways through general inertia, but it is more likely that there are good and sufficient reasons behind such persistence, much as there are good and sufficient reasons for change.

The social scientist studying the modern world is inevitably struck by the importance of peasant rebellions. In some countries--such as Russia, Yugoslavia, Albania, China, Cuba, and Vietnam--peasant rebellions have helped bring about communist revolutions. In others--such as Mexico, Algeria, Kenya, and recently Angola--they have contributed toward the success of nationalist revolutions. In yet other countries--including Spain, Greece, Peru, India, Phillippines, Malaya, and Indonesia--they have helped shake, even though they have not destroyed, the foundations of the old order. The social scientist studying Iran, however, is struck not by the importance but by the conspicuous absence of any large-scale peasant rebellions in the modern era.

Type
Research Article
Information
Iranian Studies , Volume 11 , Issue 1-4: State and Society in Iran , 1978 , pp. 259 - 304
Copyright
Copyright © Association For Iranian Studies, Inc 1978

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

This is a joint enterprise and the order of the authors’ names does not imply seniority of authorship. Earlier versions of this paper were presented at the Tenth Annual Meeting of the Middle East Studies Association, Los Angeles, November 1976, and at the University of Chicago, February 1977. We would like to thank Shahen Abrahamian, Ali Banuazizi, James A. Bill, Dale Eickelman, Grace Goodell, Eric Hooglund, Nikki R. Keddie, Joseph Upton, and Marvin Zonis for commenting extensively on earlier drafts of this paper. Of course, they are not responsible for any errors and opinions found in the paper.

References

Notes

1. Wolf, Eric Peasant Wars in the Twentieth Century (New York, 1969), p. xxiii.Google Scholar

2. British Consul in Tabriz to the Foreign Office, Tabriz Diaries (9 July 1943), British Foreign Office (F.O.) 371, Persia 1943, 80-35093.

3. Lambton, A. The Persian Land Reform (Oxford, 1962), p. 30.Google Scholar

4. Keddie, N. “Stratification, Social Control, and Capitalism in Iranian Villages,” Rural Politics and Social Change in the Middle East, ed. Antoun, R. and Harik, I. (Bloomington, Ind., 1972), pp. 365-372.Google Scholar Describing Iranian villages in the 1850s, Lady Sheil commented: “There is considerable air of substantial comfort, which I often envied for our countrymen.” Glimpses of Life and Manners in Persia (London, 1856), p. 100.Google Scholar

5. Safinezhad, J. Talebabad (Tehran, 1966), pp. 136, 336.Google Scholar

6. Vieille, P. La féodalité et l'état en Iran (Paris, 1975), pp. 51-56.Google Scholar

7. Perkins, J. Eight Years in Persia (New York, 1843), p. 284.Google Scholar

8. James Fraser, an early nineteenth-century traveler, found that whole villages often fled to escape high exactions: “In Persia, the seduction of peasantry from one district to another is held to be a deadly crime… .All such attempts therefore are put down, where possible, by force, and bitter quarrels are often the consequence” (Narrative of a Journey into Khorasan [London, 1825], pp. 115-116Google Scholar, and A Winter's Journey from Constantinople to Tehran [London, 1838], II, 289Google Scholar). This geographical mobility substantially decreased by the second half of the century partly because debts tied peasants to their landlords and partly because plagues no longer devastated whole regions. For a general discussion of peasants fleeing from landowners in Iranian history see Petroshevsky, I. Keshāvarzī va munāsebāt-i arzī dar Iran: ˓Ahd-i Mughul [Agricultural and Agrarian Relations in Iran: The Moghul Era], trans, from the Russian by Keshavarz, K. (Tehran, 1965), II, pp. 156-190.Google Scholar

9. For example, Dad Shah, a notorious brigand who killed two American employees of the Point Four Program in March 1957, successfully hid among the Baluchi peasantry until he was killed in a bloody confrontation with government troops in January 1958. Similar examples of bandits successfully evading government forces can be found in most regions, especially in the period before Reza Shah.

10. During the upheavals of the constitutional revolution, British consuls reported only three incidents of peasant protests. In Rasht, farmers from nearby villages took sanctuary in the town mosque to protest high taxes. In the Caspian town of Talesh, peasants demonstrating against high taxes burned the governor's mansion. And in Yezd, two thousand villagers marched through the streets to protest again against high taxes. See Britain, Great Correspondence Respecting the Affairs of Persia, December 1906-October 1913 (London, 1914), I, 26Google Scholar, 43, 122, and 144. For a general discussion of public protests in this period see Abrahamian, E. “The Crowd in Iranian Politics, 1905-1953,” Past and Present, 41 (December 1968), 184-210.CrossRefGoogle Scholar During the turbulent period of 1946-1963, the Iranian press reported only 22 incidents of peasant protests. Of these 22, 8 consisted of peaceful demonstrations in mosques, 4 involved rival villages, and only 10 directly challenged landowners. For a general discussion of political violence in this period see Kazemi, F. “Social Mobilization and Domestic Violence in Iran: 1946-1968” (Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Michigan, 1973), pp. 195-205.Google Scholar

11. The Babi uprisings of the mid-nineteenth century also had some rural and peasant support. There was apparently strong rural backing for the Babi movement in parts of Mazandaran, Azerbaijan, and Isfahan provinces. The Babis, however, also enjoyed substantial support in the urban areas. See Kazemi, Farhad “Some Preliminary Observations on the Early Development of Babism,” Muslim World, LXIII (April 1973), 119-131Google Scholar; Browne, Edward G. ed., A Traveller's Narrative written to Illustrate the Episode of the Bab (New York, reprint. 1930)Google Scholar; Browne, Edward G. ed., Materials for the Study of the Babi Religion (Cambridge, reprint. 1918).Google Scholar

12. The Organization for Freedom Fighters of Iran, Rūstā va inqilāb-i sefid: Barresī-yi sharāyiṭ-i inqilābiyi rustā-hā-yi Iran [Villages and the White Revolution: An Investigation into the Revolutionary Situation of the Iranian Countryside] (n.p., 1971), p. x.

13. Tse-Tung, Mao “Report on the Peasant Movement (1927),” reprinted in Revolutions: A Reader, ed. Mazlish, B. (New York, 1971).Google Scholar

14. For analytical studies of peasant rebellions see: Wolf, E. Peasant Wars in the Twentieth Century (New York, 1969)Google Scholar; Alavi, H. “Peasants and Revolution,” The Socialist Register, ed. by Miliband, R. and Saville, J. (New York, 1965), pp. 240-265Google Scholar; Alavi, H. “Peasant Classes and Primordial Loyalties,” Journal of Peasant studies, I, 1 (October 1973), 23-61CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Migdal, J. Peasants, Politics, and Revolution (Princeton, 1974)Google Scholar; Moore, B. Social Origins of Democracy and Dictatorship: Lord and Peasant in the Making of the Modern World (Boston, 1966)Google Scholar; Paige, J. Agrarian Revolution (New York, 1975)Google Scholar; Zagoria, D. “Ecology of Peasant Communism in India,” American Political Science Review, LXV, 1 (March 1971), 144-160CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Zagoria, D. ed., Special Issue on “Peasants and Revolution,” Comparative Politics, VIII, 3 (April 1976)Google Scholar; Wolf, E. ed., Special Issue on “Peasants and Political Mobilization,” Comparative Studies in Society and History, XVII, 4 (October 1975)Google Scholar; Stavenhagen, R. Social Classes in Agrarian Societies (New York, 1975)Google Scholar; Beqiraj, M. Peasantry in Revolution (Ithaca, 1966)Google Scholar; Hobsbawm, E. “Peasants and Politics,” Journal of Peasant Studies, I, 1 (October 1973), 3-22CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Stinchcombe, A. “Agrarian Enterprise and Rural Class Relations,” Class, Status, and Power, ed. Bendix, R. and Lipset, S. (Glencoe, 1966)Google Scholar; Shanin, T. “Peasantry as a Political Factor,” Peasants and Peasant Societies, ed. Shanin, T. (London, 1971), pp. 238-263.Google Scholar

15. For social mobility in rural societies see Chayanov, A. The Theory of Peasant Economy (Illinois, 1966).Google Scholar

16. Wolf, Peasant Wars in the Twentieth Century, p. 291.

17. Ibid., p. 290.

18. Ibid., p. 291.

19. Alavi, “Peasant Classes and Primordial Loyalties,” p. 28. In another article analyzing the role of the Communist Party in the Chinese Revolution, Alavi has argued that Mao Tse-Tung recognized the crucial role of the middle peasantry but defined them in such a way as to include them among the poor peasantry. See Alavi, “Peasants and Revolution,” p. 257.

20. Wolf, Peasant Wars in the Twentieth Century, p. 292.

21. Migdal, Peasants, Politics, and Revolution, pp. 61-68.

22. Zagoria, “Peasants and Revolution,” pp. 3-5.

23. Ferguson, F. “Rural/Urban Relations and Peasant Radicalism,” Comparative Studies in Society and History, XVIII, 1 (January 1976), pp. 106-117.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

24. Safinezhad, J. Boneh (Tehran, 1972).Google Scholar In some areas, the boneh was known as sahra, haraseh, sarkar, paykal, pagav, or darkar.

25. Bahrier, J. Economic Development in Iran, 1900-1970 (Oxford, 1971), p. 27.Google Scholar

26. Homayoun, D. “Land Reform in Iran,” Tahqiaat-i Eqtesadi, II, 5, 6 (September 1963), 18-25Google Scholar; Rasekh, S. and Behnam, J. Jāme˓eh shenāsī-yi Iran [The Sociology of Iran] (Tehran, 1969), pp. 229-232Google Scholar; Khosravi, K. Jāme˓eh shenāsī-yi rūstā-yī Iran [The Rural Sociology of Iran] (Tehran, 1972), pp. 28-29.Google Scholar

27. Ajami, I. “Land Reform and Modernization of the Farming Structure in Iran,” The Social Sciences and Problems of Development (Princeton, 1976), pp. 191-192.Google Scholar

28. Mahdavi, H. “Iran's Agrarian Problems” (Unpublished paper delivered at a Seminar on Iranian Studies, Harvard University, April 1965), pp. 20-22.Google Scholar

29. Lambton, A. Landlord and Peasant in Persia (Oxford, 1953), pp. 280-281.Google Scholar

30. Lambton, The Persian Land Reform, p. 24.

31. Khosravi, Jāme˓eh shenāsī-yi rūstā-yī Iran, pp. 136-139.

32. K. Vadi˓i, Rūstā shināsī-yi Iran [Rural Sociology of Iran] (Tehran, 1973).Google Scholar

33. Rasekh and Behnam, Jāme˓eh shenāsī-yi Iran, pp. 232, 282.

34. Sternberg-Savel, B. “Revolution Blanche” Terre, Paysans et Politique, ed. Mendras, M. and Tavernier, Y. (Paris, 1969), p. 471.Google Scholar

35. Hooglund, E. “The Effects of the Land Reform Program on Rural Iran, 1962-1972” (Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Johns Hopkins University, 1975), pp. 23-24.Google Scholar

36. ˓A. ˓Ayin, “The Pahlevi Dynasty, Agricultural Land, and the Peasantry,” Donya, XVI (February 1976), 72-73.Google Scholar

37. Keddie, “Stratification, Social Control, and Capitalism in Iranian Villages,” p. 373.

38. Tehran University, Research Group at the Institute of Social Research, Barresī-yi natāyej-i eṣlāḥāt-i ˓arẓī [A Study on the Effects of Land Reform] (Unpublished manuscript [Tehran, 1963]), pp. 300-301.Google Scholar

39. Goblot, H. “Le probleme de l'eau en Iran,” The Economic History of Iran, 1800-1914, ed. by Issawi, C. (Chicago, 1971), pp. 214-219.Google Scholar

40. American University, Area Handbook for Iran (Washington, D.C., 1971), pp. 381-395.Google Scholar

41. Various estimates are given by Dillon, R. “Carpet Capitalism and Craft Evolution in Kirman” (Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Columbia University, 1976), pp. 10-11.Google Scholar

42. Hayden, L. “Living Standards in Rural Iran,” Middle East Journal, III, 2 (April 1949), 140-150.Google Scholar

43. Ibid.

44. Hooglund, “Effects of the Land Reform Program on Rural Iran, 1962-1972,” pp. 39-40.

45. Safinezhad, Talebabad, pp. 83-90.

46. Ajami, I. Sheshdāngi [Six Dāngs] (Tehran, 1969), pp. 24-26.Google Scholar

47. Vieille, La féodalité et l'état en Iran, p. 53.

48. Lambton writes: “It is not surprising that debt should be one of the curses of Persian rural life. The peasant is constantly in need of money for capital requirements, to replace livestock and agricultural implements, for seed, and for other current expenses…. The rates of interest are almost always exorbitant.” Landlord and Peasant in Persia, p. 380.

49. Ibid., p. 339.

50. Ibid., p. 302.

51. Hooglund, “Effects of the Land Reform Program on Rural Iran, 1962-1972,” p. 62.

52. Alberts, R. “Social Structure and Cultural Change in an Iranian Village” (Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Wisconsin, 1963), p. 165.Google Scholar

53. Tehran University, Research Group at the Institute of Social Research, Barresī-yi natāyej-i eṣlāḥāt-i ˓arẓī, pp. 60-63.

54. Nowshirvani, V. and Knight, A. “The Beginnings of Commercial Agriculture in Iran” (Unpublished paper delivered at a Yale University Seminar, 1975), p. 2.Google Scholar

55. Lambton, A. Islamic Society in Persia (Oxford, 1954), p. 8.Google Scholar

56. Keddie, N. Historical Obstacles to Agrarian Change in Iran (Claremont, 1950), p. 5.Google Scholar

57. I. Harik, “The Impact of the Domestic Market on Rural-Urban Relations in the Middle East,” in Antoun and Harik, Rural Politics and Social change in the Middle East, p. 340.

58. deBode, C. Travels in Luristan and Arabistan (London, 1845), II, 138.Google Scholar

59. Foreign Office, “Report on Bushire” (reprinted in Issawi, The Economic History of Iran, 1800-1914), pp. 227-228.

60. Hooglund, E. “The Khwushnishin Population of Iran,” Iranian Studies, VI, 4 (Autumn 1973), 234.Google Scholar

61. Fraser, Narrative of a Journey into Khorasan, pp. 378-379, 405.

62. Pottinger, H. Travels in Belochistan (London, 1816), p. 73.Google Scholar

63. P. Sykes, “Report on the Agriculture of Khorasan,” reprinted in Issawi, The Economic History of Iran, 1800-1914, pp. 253-255.

64. Arnold, A. Through Persia by Caravan (London, 1877), II, 45.Google Scholar

65. E. Abrahamian, “The Causes of the Constitutional Revolution in Iran,” forthcoming in the International Journal of Middle East Studies.

66. Khamsi, F. “The Development of Capitalism in Rural Iran” (Unpublished M.A. thesis, Columbia University, 1968), p. 79.Google Scholar

67. Khosravi, K. “Irrigation and Rural Society in Iran,” ˓Ulum-i Ijtima˓i, I, 3 (February 1970), 48-56.Google Scholar

68. Lambton, Landlord and Peasant in Persia, pp. 3-4, 342.

69. British Consul in Shiraz to the Foreign Office, “Report on Tribal Areas,” F.O. 371, Persia 1944, 6844-155.Google Scholar

70. De Planhol, X. “Les villages fortifiés en Iran,” Annales de Geographie, 67, 1 (January 1958), 256-258.Google Scholar

71. Rabino, H. Mazandaran and Astarabad (London, 1928), p. 99.Google Scholar

72. Barth, F. The Nomads of Southern Persia (New York, 1959), p. 80.Google Scholar

73. Lambton, Landlord and Peasant in Persia, pp. 263-265.

74. For an analytical study of modern and traditional class relations see: Stinchcombe, A. “Social Structure and Organizations,” Handbook of Organizations, ed. March, J. (Chicago, 1965), pp. 143-197.Google Scholar

75. Moore, Social Origins of Democracy and Dictatorship, pp. 474-483.

76. Safinezhad, Boneh, pp. 42-43.

77. Ibid., pp. 87-89.

78. Ajami, “Land Reform and Modernization of the Farming Structures in Iran,” p. 191.

79. Löffler, R. “The Representative Mediator and the New Peasant,” American Anthropologist, 73, 5 (October 1971), 1084-1085.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

80. Amin al-Dawleh, M. Khāṭerāt-i siyāsī [Political Memoirs] (Tehran, 1962), p. 77.Google Scholar

81. Browne, E. The Persian Revolution of 1905-1909 (London, 1909), p. 137.Google Scholar For discussions of the weak Qajar state see: Abrahamian, E. “European Feudalism and Middle Eastern Despotisms,” Science and Society, XXXIX, 2 (Summer 1975), pp. 129-156Google Scholar; and Abrahamian, E. “The Crowd in the Persian Revolution,” Iranian Studies, II, 4 (Autumn 1969), pp. 128-150.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

82. British Consul in Shiraz to the Foreign Office, “Report on Tribal Areas,” F.O. 371, Persia, 1944, 6844-155.Google Scholar

83. New York Times, June 15, 1946.

84. The Tudeh Party, “The Program of the Peasant Union,” Rahbar, June 24, 1945; The Tudeh Party, “Program for the Peasantry,” Rahbar, February 2, 1943; Qassemi, A. Ḥezb-i Tudeh-i Iran cheh mīgūyad va cheh mīkhāhad [The Aims and Demands of the Tudeh Party] (Tehran, 1944), pp. 42-59.Google Scholar

85. Peasant Union, “Peasants: Wake Up!,” Rahbar, June 24, 1945.

86. The Tudeh Party, “Peasants of Azerbaijan!,” Rahbar, March 3, 1943.

87. ˓A. Kambakhsh, “The Tudeh Party's Struggle to Form a United and Democratic National Front,” Donya, V (Autumn 1964), 6.Google Scholar

88. ˓A. Kambakhsh, “The History of the Tudeh Party: From its Formation to the Birth of the Azerbaijan Movement,” Donga, IX (Winter 1968), 32.Google Scholar

89. P. Khala˓atbari, “The Tudeh Party and the Peasants,” Donya, IV (Autumn 1963), 68.Google Scholar

90. Descriptions of the incident have been obtained from: The National Assembly, Muzākerāt-i majles-i shurā-yi mellī [Parliamentary Debates], 14th Majlis, September 13, 1945; British Consul in Tabriz to the Foreign Office, “Tabriz Diaries (15 August 1945),” F.O. 371, Persia 1945, 80-45478.Google Scholar

91. For detailed descriptions of the Jangali movement see: Kasravi, A. Tārīkh-i hezhdah sāleh-i Azerbaijan [An Eighteen Year History of Azerbaijan] (Tehran, 1961)Google Scholar; Jowdat, H. Tārīkhcheh-i ferqeh-i demokrāt [An Historical Sketch of the Democratic Party] (Tehran, 1969)Google Scholar; I. Fakhra˓i, Sardār-i jangal [The Ruler of the Forest] (Tehran, 1969)Google Scholar; Taherzadeh-Behzad, M. Qiyām-i Azerbaijan dar inqelāb-i mashrūṭiyyat [The Revolt of Azerbaijan during the Constitutional Revolution] (Tehran, 1953)Google Scholar; Farrokh, M. Khāterat-i siyāsī-yi Farrokh [The Political Memoirs of Farrokh] (Tehran, 1969)Google Scholar; Taleqani, M. Duktur Heshmat keh būd? [Who Was Dr. Heshmat?] (Tehran, n.d.)Google Scholar; ˓A. Kambakhsh, “The October Revolution and the Liberation Movements in Iran,” Donya, VIII (Summer 1967), 34-57Google Scholar; Shamideh, A. “Haydar Khan,” Donya, IX (Spring 1970), 113-124Google Scholar; Akhundzadeh, M. “The Life of Akhundzadeh,” Donya, IX (Spring 1969), 55-58Google Scholar; Ra'in, I. Haydar Khan (Tehran, 1975).Google Scholar

92. Donohoe, M. With the Persian Expedition (London, 1919), p. 127.Google Scholar

93. The Revolutionary Tudeh Party of Iran, Junbesh-i kumunīstī-yi Iran [The Communist Movement in Iran] (n.p. 1969), p. 23.

94. The Jangali Party, “The Proclamation of the Party,” Donya, January 7, 1945; idem, “Telegraph to Tehran,” Donya, January 14, 1945; N. Najami, “The Situation in Gilan,” Donya, January 31, 1945; Editorial, “Gilan Also…,” Gileh Mard, May 10, 1946.

95. ˓A. ˓Amidi-Nuri, “Travels in Mazandaran and Gilan,” Dād, December 29, 1946-January 15, 1947.

96. British Ambassador to the Foreign Office, “Three Monthly Report for July-September 1945,” F.O. 371, Persia 1945, 45452-31.Google Scholar

97. Hindus, M. In Search of a Future (New York, 1948) pp. 68-69.Google Scholar

98. Ibid., p. 61.

99. Ganji, M. “Climate,” The Cambridge History of Iran, ed. Fisher, W. (Cambridge, 1968), pp. 212-249.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

100. Ministry of Interior, Sarshumāri-yi ˓umūmī-yi keshvar [Summary of the Population Census] (Tehran, 1960), I, 100-120.Google Scholar

101. Ibid.

102. Khamsi, “The Development of Capitalism in Rural Iran,” p. 71.

103. Khosravi, K. “Rural Bazaars in Iran,” Rahnema-yi Ketab, 19, 1-3 (April-June 1976), 21-29.Google Scholar

104. Ministry of Interior, Sarshumārī-yi ˓umūmī-yi keshvar, II, 78.Google Scholar

105. Vadi˓i, Rūstā shenāsī-yi Iran, p. 143.

106. Khamsi, “The Development of Capitalism in Rural Iran,” p. 62.

107. Quoted in Issawi, Economic History of Iran, 1800-1914, p. 225.

108. Research Group, “A Study of Rural Economic Problems in Gilan and Mazandaran,” Tahqiqat-i Eqtesadi, IV, 11 and 12 (January 1969), 135-141.Google Scholar

109. Moore, Social Origins of Democracy and Dictatorship, p. 470.