Published online Jan 31, 2008.
https://doi.org/10.5395/JKACD.2008.33.1.020
In vitro evaluation of the consistency of two electronic apex locators
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the consistency of two electronic apex locators in vitro model.
Materials consisted of fifty two extracted premolars and two electronic apex locators; Root ZX (J. Morita, Osaka, Japan) and E-Magic Finder Deluxe (S-Denti, Cheonan, Korea). After access preparation, the teeth were embedded in a saline-mixed alginate model. Canal lengths of each tooth were measured at "0.5" and "Apex" mark of the apex locators, respectively so that each tooth had two measurements from 0.5 and Apex points. The file was fixed at final measurement using a glass ionomer cement. The apical 4 mm from the apex was exposed to measure the distance from the file tip to the major apical foramen of each tooth. Average distances and standard deviations were used to evaluate the consistency.
Results showed that all measurements of both Root ZX and E-Magic Finder located the major foramen the range of ± 0.5 mm level. Both apex locators showed better consistency at Apex mark than at 0.5 mark. The average distance of file tip-major foramen was - 0.18 mm at 0.5 mark and - 0.07 mm at Apex mark in Root ZX, - 0.25 mm at 0.5 mark and - 0.02 mm at Apex mark in E-Magic Finder. Standard deviation was 0.21 at 0.5 mark and 0.12 at Apex mark in Root ZX, 0.12 at 0.5 mark and 0.09 at Apex mark in E-Magic Finder.
Figure 1
Root ZX.
Figure 2
E-Magic Finder.
Figure 3
Length measurements with digital caliper.
Figure 4
Distance from file tip to major foramen with EasyDent Viewer.
Figure 5
Box plots: Quartile of file tip-major foramen distance at 0.5 mark and Apex mark.
Table 1
Distance of file tip-major foramen at 0.5 mark and Apex mark (mm)
Table 2
Difference of the length at 0.5 mark and Apex mark
Table 3
Range of Apex band
References
-
Sunada I. New method for the measuring the length of the root canal. J Dent Res 1962;41:375–387.
-
-
Inoue N. An audiometric method for determining the length of root canals. J Can Dent Assoc (Tor) 1973;39:630–636.
-
-
Kobayashi C, Okiji T, Kaqwashima N, Suda H, Sunada I. A basic study on the electronic root canal length measurement: Part 3. Newly designed electronic root canal length measuring device using division method. Jpn J Conservative Dent 1991;34:1442–1448.
-
-
Riccuci D, Langeland K. Apical limit of root canal instrumentation and obturation. Int Endod J 1998;31:394–409.
-