This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Environmental Evaluation of Direct Hydrogen and Reformer-Based Fuel Cell Vehicles
Technical Paper
2002-01-0094
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Fuel cells have attracted a great deal of attention in the last few years as potential replacements for conventional gasoline- or diesel-powered internal combustion engines. This study evaluated the potential life-cycle environmental impacts of a fuel cell vehicle (FCV) using a 50 kW proton exchange membrane (PEM) fuel cell system (both with and without a fuel reformer), and compared them with those of a gasoline-fueled internal combustion engine vehicle (ICEV). The fuels considered for the fuel cell systems were direct hydrogen (without reformer), and methanol and gasoline (with reformer). Exclusive of the propulsion systems, the rest of the vehicle was assumed to be the same across all the profiles.
The hydrogen FCV is found to have the lowest impact scores in 12 of the 14 impact categories evaluated (see Appendix A for impact category definitions), mainly because of zero air emissions from driving and the lowest total lifetime quantity by mass of fuel (hydrogen) required during use. In 5 of these 12 categories, the gasoline FCV is a close second.
An additional long-term scenario for the gasoline FCV assumed a much lower platinum content and reduced overall weight (reduced by ∼ 220 kg). This vehicle has the lowest impact scores in 3 categories (nonrenewable resource use, energy use, and smog formation), while the hydrogen FCV still leads in the other nine impact categories. Also, the long-term gasoline FCV's scores are much closer to the hydrogen FCV's scores. The hydrogen FCV, however, still remains the most environmentally preferable vehicle.
Recommended Content
Authors
- Rajive Dhingra - Center for Clean Products and Clean Technologies - University of Tennessee
- Jonathan G. Overly - Center for Clean Products and Clean Technologies - University of Tennessee
- Gary A. Davis - Center for Clean Products and Clean Technologies - University of Tennessee
- Sujit Das - Oak Ridge National Laboratory
Citation
Dhingra, R., Overly, J., Davis, G., and Das, S., "Environmental Evaluation of Direct Hydrogen and Reformer-Based Fuel Cell Vehicles," SAE Technical Paper 2002-01-0094, 2002, https://doi.org/10.4271/2002-01-0094.Also In
References
- Life-Cycle Design for the Automobile - Environmental Technologies Initiative Project (Draft Report) The University of Tennessee Center for Clean Products and Clean Technologies September 30 2000
- Ecobilan (Ecobalance) Group 1999 Data for Environmental Analysis and Management (DEAM) lifecycle inventory database developed by the Ecobilan Group
- Arthur D Little, Inc. Personal communications with Eric Carlson May 2000 March 2001
- Automotive Engineering International Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) International March 2001 68
- GREET 1.5a Wang, M. Q. 2000 From the downloadable Excel version of GREET 1.5a Center for Transportation Research, Energy System Division, Argonne National Laboratory
- NREL's Center for Transportation Technology and Systems: ADVISOR Glossary http://www.ctts.nrel.gov/analysis/advisor_doc/glossary.htm
- Thomas, C. E. (Sandy) James Brian D. Lomax, Franklin D. Jr. Analysis of Residential Fuel Cell Systems &PNGV Fuel Cell Vehicles Proceedings of the 2000 DOE Hydrogen Program Review Directed Technologies, Inc. 2000 http://205.168.79.27/hydrogen/pdfs/28890mm.pdf 2
- GREET 1.5a Wang, M. Q. 2000 From the downloadable Excel version of GREET 1.5a Center for Transportation Research, Energy System Division, Argonne National Laboratory
- California Energy Commission's Web site: Fuel Cell Vehicles http://www.energy.ca.gov/education/AFVs/fuelcells.html
- Fuel Cells 2000 Web site: Fuel Cells 2000's Benefits of Fuel Cells Page http://216.51.18.233/fcbenefi.html “Fuel Cell Emissions.”
- Wilson, James H. Jr. Emissions Projections
- Automotive Engineering International Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) International March 2001 76
- Automotive Engineering International Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) International March 2001 65
- Automotive Engineering International Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) International March 2001 69
- General Motors Takes Steps Toward a Fuel Cell-Powered Vehicle for Commercial Use Today's Newsmaker PR Newswire November 16 2000
- GREET 1.5 Wang, M. Q. 2000 Greet 1.5 - Transportation Fuel-Cycle Model: Methodology, Use, and Results Center for Transportation Research, Energy System Division, Argonne National Laboratory 2 8 35
- (S&T)2 Consultants, Inc. Assessment of Emissions of Greenhouse Gases from Fuel Cell Vehicles Prepared for the Methanex Corporation June 5 2000
- Cost Analysis of Fuel Cell System for Transportation - Baseline System Cost Estimate Task 1 and 2 Final Report to: Department of Energy Arthur D. Little, Inc. March 2000