Medical Populism and the Moral Right to Healthcare
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
Medical populism, as a political style of handling the challenges of a public health crisis, has primarily been analyzed in terms of its influence on the efficacy of governmental efforts to meet the challenges of the current pandemic (such as those related to testing, vaccination, and community restrictions). As these efforts have moral consequences (they, for instance, will affect people’s wellbeing and may lead to suffering, loss of opportunities, and unfair distributions), an analysis of the ethics of medical populism is much needed. In this essay, we address the need to analyze the moral dimension of medical populism by relating it to issues in healthcare ethics. Specifically, we identify the moral significance of medical populism by demonstrating how it contributes to the failure of governments to discharge their moral duty to provide for the healthcare needs of their people, and, correlatively, to the violation of the people’s moral right to healthcare. We argue that with medical populism, governments tend to mishandle the constraints that would morally justify their shortcomings in fulfilling such duty. We identify such constraints as mainly referring to the governments’ given (economic and institutional) capacities and the relative degree of incumbency of their competing duties.
Downloads
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
By submitting his/her work to the Editorial Board, the author accepts, upon having his/her text recommended for publication, that Diametros applies the Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license to the works we publish. Under this license, authors agree to make articles legally available for reuse, without permission or fees. Anyone may read, download, copy, print, distribute or reuse these articles without asking prior permission from the publisher or the author, as long as the author and original source are properly cited. The author holds the copyright without any other restrictions. Full information about CC-BY: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode.
References
Arguelles C.V. (2021), “The Populist Brand is Crisis: Durable Dutertismo Amidst Mismanaged COVID-19 Response,” Southeast Asian Affairs 2021: 257–274.
Barberia L.G., Gómez E.J. (2020), “Political and Institutional Perils of Brazil’s COVID-19 Crisis,” Lancet 396 (10248): 367–368.
Batino C., Jiao C. (2020), “The Philippines Has Just 2,000 Virus Testing Kits and Cases are Rising,” URL = https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-10/philippines-has-just-2-000-virus-testing-kits-as-cases-rise?srnd=premium [Accessed 30.05.2022].
Béland D., Rocco P., Segatto C.I., Waddan A. (2021), “Trump, Bolsonaro, and the Framing of the COVID-19 Crisis: How Political Institutions Shaped Presidential Strategies,” World Affairs 184 (4): 413–440.
Bonikowski B., Gidron N. (2016), “Multiple Traditions in Populism Research: Toward a Theoretical Synthesis,” APSA Comparative Politics Newsletter 26 (12): 7–14.
Brubaker R. (2017), “Why Populism?,” Theory and Society 46 (5): 357–385.
Brubaker R. (2020), “Paradoxes of Populism during the Pandemic,” Thesis Eleven 164 (1): 73–87.
Buchanan A. (2009), “Health-Care Delivery and Resource Allocation,” [in:] A. Buchanan, Justice and Health Care: Selected Essays, Oxford University Press, Oxford: 37–76.
Calonzo A., Jiao C. (2020), “Philippines Now Has Worst Covid Outbreak in Southeast Asia,” URL = https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2020/08/07/asia-pacific/philippinescoronavirus-southeast-asia/ [Accessed 15.01.2023].
Canineu M.L., Muñoz C. (2021), “The Toll of Bolsonaro’s Disastrous Covid-19 Response [EN/PT],” URL=https://reliefweb.int/report/brazil/toll-bolsonaro-s-disastrouscovid-19-response-enpt [Accessed 30.05.2022].
Cohen S. (2011), Folk Devils and Moral Panics, Routledge.
Corella Á.S. (2018), “The Political, Legal and Moral Scope of the Universal of Human Rights: Pending Issues,” The Age of Human Rights Journal 11: 1–23.
Daniels N. (1981), “Health-Care Needs and Distributive Justice,” Philosophy and Public Affairs 10 (2): 146–179.
Daniels N. (1985), Just Health Care, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Daniels N. (2001), “Justice, Health, and Healthcare,” The American Journal of Bioethics 1 (2): 2–16.
Daniels N. (2009), “Is There a Right to Health Care and, if so, What Does It Encompass?,” [in:] A Companion to Bioethics, H. Kuhse, P. Singer (eds), John Wiley & Sons Ltd, Oxford: 362–372.
David R. (2020), “Optics of Power vs Voice of Science,” URL = https://opinion.inquirer.net/128030/optics-of-power-vs-voice-of-science [Accessed 15.01.2023].
de Arruda R.G., de Menezes T.A., dos Santos J.M.A., Paez A., Lopes F. (2021), “The Effect of Politician Denialist Approach on COVID-19 Cases and Deaths,” EconomiA 22 (3): 214–224.
de Lara-Tuprio E.P., Estuar M.R.J.E., Sescon J.T. et al. (2022), “Economic Losses from COVID-19 Cases in the Philippines: A Dynamic Model of Health and Economic Policy Trade-Offs,” Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 9: 111.
Delanty G. (2020), “Six Political Philosophies in Search of a Virus: Critical Perspectives on the Coronavirus Pandemic,” URL = http://www.lse.ac.uk/european-institute/Assets/Documents/LEQS-Discussion-Papers/LEQSPaper156.pdf [Accessed 25.01.2023].
Department of Health Republic of the Philippines Health Technology Assessment, “Universal Health Care Act,” URL = https://hta.doh.gov.ph/universal-health-care-act/ [Accessed 15.05.2022].
Fried Ch. (1976), “Equality and Rights in Medical Care,” Hastings Center Report 6 (1): 29–34.
Gostin L.O., Koh H.H., Williams M. et al. (2020), “US Withdrawal from WHO is Unlawful and Threatens Global and US Health and Security,” Lancet 396 (10247): 293–295.
Greer S.L. (2017), “Medicine, Public Health and the Populist Radical Right,” Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 110 (8): 305–308.
Hapal K. (2021), “The Philippines’ COVID-19 Response: Securitising the Pandemic and Disciplining the Pasaway,” Journal of Current Southeast Asian Affairs 40 (2): 224–244.
Harman E. (2016), “Morally Permissible Moral Mistakes,” Ethics 126 (2): 366–393.
Hedges K., Lasco G. (2021), “Medical Populism and COVID-19 Testing,” Open Anthropological Research 1: 73–86.
Hobsbawm E.J. (1990), Nations et nationalisme depuis 1780, Gallimard, Paris.
Janssen M., van der Voort H. (2020), “Agile and Adaptive Governance in Crisis Response: Lessons from the COVID-19 pandemic,” International Journal of Information Management 55 (102–180).
Jones P. (2013), “Moral Rights, Human Rights and Social Recognition,” Political Studies 61 (2): 267–281.
Laclau E. (2005), “Populism: What’s in a Name?,” [in:] Populism and the Mirror of Democracy, F. Panizza (ed.), Verso Books, London, New York: 32–49.
Lasco G. (2020), “Medical Populism and the COVID-19 Pandemic,” Global Public Health 15 (10): 1417–1429.
Lasco G., Curato N. (2019), “Medical Populism,” Social Science & Medicine 221: 1–8.
Mabaquiao N.M. (2020), “Justice in Healthcare: Welfare and Equal Opportunity,” Asia-Pacific Social Sciences Review 21 (2): 197–212.
Mabaquiao N.M., Dacela M.A.L. (2022), “Moral Right to Healthcare and COVID-19 Challenges,” Asia-Pacific Social Science Review 22 (1): 78–91.
Moffitt B. (2016), The Global Rise of Populism: Performance, Political Style, and Representation, Stanford University Press, Stanford.
Mudde C. (2017), “Populism: An Ideational Approach,” [in:] The Oxford Handbook of Populism, C. Rovira Kaltwasser, P.A. Taggart, P. Ochoa Espejo, P. Ostiguy (eds), Oxford University Press, Oxford: 24–47.
Mudde C., Rovira Kaltwasser C. (2017), Populism: A Very Short Introduction, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Mudde C., Rovira Kaltwasser C. (2018), “Studying Populism in Comparative Perspective: Reflections on the Contemporary and Future Research Agenda,” Comparative Political Studies 51 (13): 1667–1693.
Müller J.-W. (2016), What is Populism?, University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia.
O’Neill O. (2005), “The Dark Side of Human Rights,” International Affairs 81 (2): 425–439.
Ostiguy P. (2017), “Populism: A Socio-Cultural Approach,” [in:] The Oxford Handbook of Populism, C. Rovira Kaltwasser, P.A. Taggart, P. Ochoa Espejo, P. Ostiguy (eds), Oxford University Press, Oxford: 73–97.
Patel N. (2020), “Why the CDC Botched its Coronavirus Testing,” URL = https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/03/05/905484/why-the-cdc-botched-its-coronavirus-testing/ [Accessed 30.05.2022].
Pavel C.E. (2019), “Healthcare: Between a Human and a Conventional Right,” Economics and Philosophy 35 (3): 499–520.
Perry M.J. (2020), “The Morality of Human Rights,” Human Rights Quarterly 42 (2): 434–478.
Pillay N. (2008), “Right to Health and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights,” Lancet 372 (9655): 2005–2006.
Recio-Román A., Recio-Menéndez M., Román-González M.V. (2022), “Political Populism, Institutional Distrust and Vaccination Uptake: A Mediation Analysis,” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 19 (6): 32–65.
Rogers S.L., Cruickshank T. (2021), “Change in Mental Health, Physical Health, and Social Relationships during Highly Restrictive Lockdown in the COVID-19 Pandemic: Evidence from Australia,” PeerJ 9 (e11767): 1–28, URL = https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8310621/pdf/peerj-09-11767.pdf [Accessed 15.10.2022].
Rovira Kaltwasser C., Taggart P.A., Ochoa Espejo P., Ostiguy P. (2017), The Oxford Handbook of Populism, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Ross W.D. (1930), The Right and the Good, Hackett.
Rueda D. (2020), “Is Populism a Political Strategy? A Critique of an Enduring Approach,” Political Studies 69 (2): 1–18.
Rutledge P.E. (2020), “Trump, COVID-19, and the War on Expertise,” The American Review of Public Administration 50 (6–7): 505–511.
Speed E., Carter S., Green J. (2022), “Pandemics, Infection Control and Social Justice: Challenges for Policy Evaluation,” Critical Public Health 32 (1): 44–47.
Speed E., Mannion R. (2020), “Populism and Health Policy: Three International Case Studies of Right-wing Populist Policy Frames,” Sociology of Health & Illness 42 (8): 1967–1981.
Speed E., Mannion R. (2021), “Performing Populist Health Policy: The Case of the English National Health Service,” [in:] Managing Healthcare Organisations in Challenging Policy Contexts, Organizational Behavior in Healthcare, R. Kislov, D. Burns, B.E. Mørk, K. Montgomery (eds), Palgrave Macmillan, Cham: 49–66.
Sreenivasan G. (2012), “A Human Right to Health? Some Inconclusive Skepticism,” Aristotelian Society Supplementary Volume 86 (1): 239–265.
Teehankee J.C. (2022), “The Philippines in 2021: Twilight of the Duterte Presidency,” Asian Survey 62 (1): 126–136.
Tohăneanu C. (2015), “Could Ross’s Pluralist Deontology Solve the Conflicting Duties Problem?,” Revue Roumaine de Philosophie 59 (1): 109–124.
UP COVID-19 Pandemic Response Team (2020), “Estimating Local Healthcare Capacity to Deal with COVID-19 Case Surge: Analysis and Recommendations,” URL = https://up.edu.ph/estimating-local-healthcare-capacity-to-deal-with-covid-19-case-surge-analysis-
and-recommendations/ [Accessed 28.05.2022].
Velasquez M.G. (2014), Business Ethics: Concepts and Cases: International Edition (7th edition), Pearson Education Limited, Edinburgh.
Vranas P. (2018), “’Ought’ Implies ‘Can’ but Does Not Imply ‘Must’: An Asymmetry Between Becoming Infeasible and Becoming Overridden,” Philosophical Review 127 (4): 487–514.
Walby S. (2021), “The COVID Pandemic and Social Theory: Social Democracy and Public Health in Crisis,” European Journal of Social Theory 24 (1): 22–43.
Weyland K. (2017), “Populism: A Political-Strategic Approach,” [in:] The Oxford Handbook of Populism, C. Rovira Kaltwasser, P.A. Taggart, P. Ochoa Espejo, P. Ostiguy (eds), Oxford University Press, Oxford: 48–72.
Wolff J. (2012), “Global Justice and Health: The Basis of the Global Health Duty,” [in:] Global Justice and Bioethics, J. Millum, E. Emanuel (eds), Oxford University Press, Oxford: 78–101.
Yamey G., Gonsalves G. (2020), “Donald Trump: A Political Determinant of Covid-19,” BMJ 369:m1643.
Zuchhino D., Abed F. (2021), “’Covid Can’t Compete.’ In a Place Mixed in War, the Virus is an Afterthought,” URL = https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/20/world/asia/covid- afghanistan-coronavirus.html [Accessed 28.05.2022].