Skip to content
Licensed Unlicensed Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter (A) November 17, 2022

Publius at Naupaktos: The First Macedonian War and Phlegon of Tralles’ anti-Roman Prophecies in De Mirabilia 3

  • Juan P. Prieto ORCID logo EMAIL logo
From the journal Klio

Summary

A brief state of the art for Phlegon of Tralles’ De Mirabilia 3 anti-Roman prophecies is followed by a reassessment of four of its components: the historical identification of the Roman protagonist “Publius”, Naupaktos as the main stage for the prophecies, the multiple meanings of the Red Wolf as well as the Oak Tree, and the Roman military retreat. By analyzing these specific elements, it will be argued that these presages were not only associated with events during the Antiochean and Mithridatic Wars, but were also related with historical experiences from the First Macedonian Conflict.

Acknowledgements

I would like to acknowledge with gratitude the help received in writing this article from Professors François Cadiou, Moya Jones, Álvaro Moreno-Leoni and Felipe Soza, specially for their valuable advises in improving my argument. All errors are, of course, mine alone.

Bibliography

Amandry 1959: P. Amandry, Oracles, littérature et politique, REA 61.3/4, 1959, 400–413.10.3406/rea.1959.3630Search in Google Scholar

Arafat 1996: K. W. Arafat, Pausanias’ Greece. Ancient artists and Roman rulers, Cambridge – New York – Melbourne 1996.Search in Google Scholar

Askold 1993: I. Askold, Les Guerriers-Chiens. Loups-garous et invasions scythes en Asie Mineure, RHR 210.3, 1993, 305–330.10.3406/rhr.1993.1478Search in Google Scholar

Balland 1974: A. Balland, Un taureau dans un arbre, Rome 1974.Search in Google Scholar

Balsdon 1954: J.P.V.D. Balsdon, Rome and Macedon, 205–200 B.C., JRS 44, 1954, 30–42.10.2307/297553Search in Google Scholar

Baronowski 2011: D. W. Baronowski, Polybius and Roman Imperialism, London – New York 2011.Search in Google Scholar

Bellinger 1961: A. Bellinger, Troy, The Coins, Princeton 1961.Search in Google Scholar

Boulay 2014: T. Boulay, Arès dans la cité. Les poleis et la guerre dans l’Asie mineure hellénistique, Pisa – Rome 2014.Search in Google Scholar

Bragg 2010: E. Bragg, Roman Seaborne Raids During the Mid-Republic. Sideshow or Headline Feature?, G&R 57.1, 2010, 47–64.10.1017/S0017383509990271Search in Google Scholar

Breglia 1984: L. Breglia, Oracoli Sibillini Tra Rituali e Propaganda, Napoli 1984.Search in Google Scholar

Briscoe 1973: J. Briscoe, A Commentary on Livy, Books XXXI–XXXIII, Oxford 1973.Search in Google Scholar

Burkert 1975: W. Burkert, Apellai und Apollo, RhM 118, 1975, 1–21.Search in Google Scholar

Burkert 1997: W. Burkert, Euenios der Seher von Apollonia und Apollon Lykeios. Mythos jenseits der Texte, Kernos 10, 1997, 73–81.10.4000/kernos.647Search in Google Scholar

Castrucci 2012: G. Castrucci, Dodona versus Delphi in Greek Tragedy. The Wanderings of the Hero between Expiation and Ties of Genos, Logeion 2, 2012, 1–25.Search in Google Scholar

Champion 1997: C. Champion, The Nature of Authoritative Evidence in Polybius and Agelaus’ Speech at Naupactus, TAPhA 127, 1997, 111–128.10.2307/284389Search in Google Scholar

Chapinal-Heras 2021: D. Chapinal-Heras, Experiencing Dodona. The Development of the Epirote Sanctuary from Archaic to Hellenistic Times, Berlin – Boston 2021.10.1515/9783110727593Search in Google Scholar

Compatangelo-Soussignan 2012: R. Compatangelo-Soussignan, Apollon en Cisalpine: philosophie, religion et idéologie des élites romaines au IIe siècle av. n. è., MEFRA 124.1, 2012, 123–150.10.4000/mefra.152Search in Google Scholar

D’Agostini 2019: M. D’Agostini, The Rise of Philip V. Kingship and Rule in the Hellenistic World, Alessandria 2019.Search in Google Scholar

Dakaris 1996: T. Dakaris, Dodona, Athens 1996.Search in Google Scholar

Demma 2011: F. Demma, Leucado cepit. Praeneste, Roma e la Conquista dell Oriente, RPAA 3.83, 2011, 3–57.Search in Google Scholar

Diels 1890: H. Diels, Sibyllinische Blätter, Berlin 1890.10.1515/9783111718804Search in Google Scholar

Eckstein 1976: A. M. Eckstein, T. Quinctius Flamininus and the Campaign against Philip in 198 B. C., Phoenix 30.2, 1976, 119–142.10.2307/1087088Search in Google Scholar

Eckstein 2002: A. M. Eckstein, Greek Mediation in the First Macedonian War, 209–205 B.C., Historia 51.3, 2002, 268–297.Search in Google Scholar

Eckstein 2008: A. M. Eckstein, Rome Enters the Greek East. From Anarchy to Hierarchy in the Hellenistic Mediterranean, 230–170 BC, Malden – Oxford – Victoria 2008.10.1002/9781444301564Search in Google Scholar

Eidinow 2007: E. Eidinow, Oracles, Curses, and Risk among the Ancient Greeks, Oxford 2007.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199277780.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Eidinow 2014: E. Eidinow, Oracles and Oracle-Sellers. An Ancient Market in Futures, in: D. Engels – P. Van Nuffelen (eds.), Religion and Competition in Antiquity, Brussels 2014, 55–95.Search in Google Scholar

Emperius 1847: A. Emperius, Opuscula philologica et historica, Göttingen 1847.Search in Google Scholar

Errington 1976: R. M. Errington, Alexander in the Hellenistic World, in: E. Badian (ed.) Alexandre le Grand. Image et réalité, Geneva 1976, 137–179.Search in Google Scholar

Errington 1990: R. M. Errington, A History of Macedonia, Berkeley – Los Angeles – New York 1990.Search in Google Scholar

Ferrary 1988: J.-L. Ferrary, Philhellénisme et impérialisme. Aspects idéologiques de la conquête romaine du monde hellénistique, Rome 1988.10.3406/befar.1988.1222Search in Google Scholar

Fewerda 2004: R. Fewerda, Phlegon van Tralles. Wonderbaarlijke verschijnselen – Mensen die lang hebben geleefd – Olympiaden, Budel 2004.Search in Google Scholar

Fontenrose 1978: J. Fontenrose, The Delphic Oracle. Its Responses and Operations, with a Catalogue of Responses, Berkeley – Los Angeles – London 1978.10.1525/9780520331310Search in Google Scholar

Frank 1941: E. Frank, s. v. Phlegon, in: G. Wissowa, RE 1.39, 1941, 261–264.Search in Google Scholar

Freitag 2001: K. Freitag, Der Golf von Korinth. Historisch-topographische Untersuchungen von der Archaik bis in das 1. Jh. v. Chr., Munich 2001.Search in Google Scholar

Funke 2000: S. Funke, Aiakidenmythos und epeirotisches Königtum: der Weg einer hellenischen Monarchie, Stuttgart 2000.Search in Google Scholar

Gabba 1974: E. Gabba, Storiografia greca e imperialismo romano (III–I a. C.), RSI 86, 1974, 625–642.Search in Google Scholar

Gabba 1975: E. Gabba, P. Cornelio Scipione Africano e la leggenda, Athenaeum 53, 1975, 3–17.Search in Google Scholar

Gauger 1980: J.-D. Gauger, Phlegon von Tralles, mirab. III. Zu einem Dokument geistigen Widerstandes gegen Rom, Chiron 10, 1980, 225–261.Search in Google Scholar

Gauger 1995: J.-D. Gauger, Orakel und Brief. Zu zwei hellenistischen Formen geistiger Auseinandersetzung in: C. Schubert – K. Brodersen –U. Huttner (eds.), Rom und der Griechische Osten: Festschrift für Hatto H. Schmitt zum 65. Geburtstag, Stuttgart 1995, 51–67.Search in Google Scholar

Giannini 1964: A. Giannini, Studi sulla paradossografia greca II. Da Calimaco all’età imperiale: la letteratura paradossografica, Acme 17, 1964, 99–140.Search in Google Scholar

Giannini 1966: A. Giannini, Paradoxographorum Graecorum reliquiae, Milan 1966.Search in Google Scholar

Gómez Espelosín 1996: F. J. Gómez Espelosín, Paradoxógrafos griegos. Rarezas y maravillas, Madrid 1996.Search in Google Scholar

Grainger 1999: J. D. Grainger, The League of the Aitolians (238–197 BC), Leiden – Boston – Cologne 1999.10.1163/9789004351219Search in Google Scholar

Gruen 1984: E. S. Gruen, The Hellenistic World and the Coming of Rome, Berkeley – Los Angeles – London 1984.10.1525/9780520351233Search in Google Scholar

Habicht 1970: C. Habicht, Epigraphische Zeugnisse zur Geschichte Thessaliens unter der makedonischen Herrschaft, in: B. Laourdas – C. Makaronas (eds.), Ancient Macedonia. Papers Read at the First International Symposium Held in Thessaloniki, 26–29 August 1968, Thessaloniki 1970, 265–279.Search in Google Scholar

Hammond 1966: N.G.L. Hammond, The Opening Campaigns and the Battle of the Aoi Stena in the Second Macedonian War, JRS 55.1–2, 1966, 39–54.10.2307/300132Search in Google Scholar

Hammond – Walbank 1988: N.G.L. Hammond – F. W. Walbank, A History of Macedonia, III: 336–167 B.C., Oxford 1988.Search in Google Scholar

Hansen 1996: W. Hansen, Phlegon of Tralles’ Book of Marvels, Exeter 1996.Search in Google Scholar

Hardie 2009: P. R. Hardie, Introduction: Paradox and the Marvellous in Augustan Literature and Culture, in: P. R. Hardie (ed.), Paradox and the Marvellous in Augustan Literature and Culture, Oxford 2009, 1–18.Search in Google Scholar

Holleaux 1930: M. Holleaux, Sur un passage de Phlégon de Tralles, RPh 4, 1930, 305–309.Search in Google Scholar

Hornblower 2015: S. Hornblower, Lycophron, Alexandra: Greek Text, Translation, Commentary and Introduction, Oxford 2015.Search in Google Scholar

Hornblower 2018: S. Hornblower, Lykophron’s Alexandra, Rome, and the Hellenistic World, Oxford 2018.10.1093/oso/9780198723684.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Hoover 2011: O. D. Hoover, Handbook of Coins of the Peloponnesos. Achaia, Phleiasia, Sikyonia, Elis, Triphylia, Messenia, Lakonia, Argolis and Arkadia: Sixth to First Centuries BC, Lancaster – London 2011.Search in Google Scholar

Jacob 1983: C. Jacob, De l’art de compiler à la fabrication du merveilleux. Sur la paradoxographie grecque, Lalies 2, 1983, 121–140.Search in Google Scholar

Jacoby 1929: F. Jacoby, Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker, II B, Berlin 1929.Search in Google Scholar

Jacoby 1930: F. Jacoby, Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker, II D, Berlin 1930.Search in Google Scholar

Jameson 2014: M. H. Jameson, Cults and Rites in Ancient Greece. Essays on Religion and Society, Cambridge 2014.10.1017/CBO9781139023702Search in Google Scholar

Janda 1966: J. Janda, D’Antisthène, auteur des successions des philosophes, LF 89, 1966, 341–364.Search in Google Scholar

Jones 2014: K. R. Jones, Lycophron’s “Alexandra”, The Romans and Antiochus III., JHS 134, 2014, 41–55.10.1017/S0075426914000044Search in Google Scholar

Kallet 2016: L. Kallet, Naupaktos, Naupaktians and Messenians in Naupaktos in the Peloponnesian War, in: O. Palagia (ed.), Naupaktos, the Ancient City in the Peloponnesian War and the Hellenistic Period, Athens 2016, 15–41.Search in Google Scholar

Kittelä 2013: S.-L. Kittelä, Dodona and Neoptolemus. Heroic Genealogies and Claims of Ethnicity, Acta Instituti Romani Finlandiae 40, 2013, 29–45.Search in Google Scholar

Kosmin 2018: Paul J. Kosmin, Time and its Adversaries in the Seleucid Empire, Cambridge 2018.10.4159/9780674989634Search in Google Scholar

Lacroix 1992: L. Lacroix, À propos des offrandes à l’Apollon de Delphes et du témoignage de Pausanias: du réel à l’imaginaire, BCH 116.1, 1992, 156–176.10.3406/bch.1992.1699Search in Google Scholar

Lafargue 2011: P. Lafargue, Un rouquin à la tête de la cité. Sur l’ambivalence de la rousseur chez les Anciens, REA 113.2, 2011, 365–390.Search in Google Scholar

Lauffer 1989: S. Lauffer, Griechenland, Lexikon der historischen Stätten. Von den Anfängen bis zur Gegenwart, Munich 1989.Search in Google Scholar

Le Bohec-Bouhet 2002: S. Le Bohec-Bouhet, The Kings of Macedon and the Cult of Zeus in the Hellenistic Period, in: D. Ogden (ed.), The Hellenistic World. New Perspectives, London 2002, 41–58.10.2307/j.ctvd58srh.7Search in Google Scholar

Mastrocinque 1983: A. Mastrocinque, Manipolazione della storia in età ellenistica: i Seleucidi e Roma, Rome 1983.Search in Google Scholar

Mesk 1925: J. Mesk, Über Phlegons Mirabilia I–III, Philologus 80, 1925, 298–311.10.1515/phil-1924-0303Search in Google Scholar

Momigliano 1975: A. Momigliano, Alien Wisdom, The Limits of Hellenization, Cambridge 1975.10.1017/CBO9780511583773Search in Google Scholar

Mommsen 1891: T. Mommsen, Commentaria ludorum saecularium quintorum et septimorum, Eph.Ep.8, 1891, 225–301.Search in Google Scholar

Naas 2011: V. Naas, Imperialism, Mirabilia and Knowledge. Some Paradoxes in the Naturalis historia, in: K. Gibson – R. Morello (eds.), Pliny the Elder. Themes and Contexts, Leiden – Boston 2011, 57–70.10.1163/ej.9789004202344.i-248.22Search in Google Scholar

Nicholson 2018: E. Nicholson, Polybios, the Laws of War, and Philip V of Macedon, Historia 67.4, 2018, 434–453.10.25162/historia-2018-0017Search in Google Scholar

Nicholson 2020: E. Nicholson, Hellenic Romans and Barbaric Macedonians. Polybius on Hellenism and Changing Hegemonic Powers, AHB 34.1–2, 2020, 38–73.10.1353/apo.2020.0035Search in Google Scholar

Ogden 2021: D. Ogden, The Werewolf in the Ancient World, Oxford 2021.10.1093/oso/9780198854319.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Oliver 2016: D. H. Oliver, The Handbook of Greek Coinage Series, 3.1: Handbook of Coins of Macedon and Its Neighbors, 1: Macedon, Illyria, and Epeiros: Sixth to First Centuries BC., Lancaster – Pennsylvania – London 2016.Search in Google Scholar

Pajón Leyra 2011: I. Pajón Leyra, Entre ciencia y maravilla. El género literario de la Paradoxografía griega, Zaragoza 2011.10.26754/uz.978-84-15274-61-2Search in Google Scholar

Parroni 2013: P. Parroni, Nazioni ai confini del mondo tra realtà e tradizione classica, Sileno 39.1–2, 2013, 339–353.Search in Google Scholar

Pelling 1995: C.B.R. Pelling, Plutarch’s Method of Work, in: B. Scardigli (ed.), Essays on Plutarch’s Lives, Oxford – New York 1995, 265–318.Search in Google Scholar

Peretti 1984: A. Peretti, Una storia di fantasmi oracolanti, SCO 33, 1984, 39–81.Search in Google Scholar

Piccinini 2018: J. Piccinini, The Relationships among Greek Oracular Sanctuaries. Rivalry, Cooperation or Desistance?, in: A. J. Dominguez (ed.), Politics, Territory and Identity in Ancient Epirus, Pisa 2018, 171–192.Search in Google Scholar

Reinach 1910: A.-J. Reinach, Delphes et les Bastarnes, BCH 34, 1910, 249–330.10.3406/bch.1910.3197Search in Google Scholar

Rich 1984: J. W. Rich, Roman Aims in the First Macedonian War, PCPhS 210.30, 1984, 126–180.10.1017/S0068673500004673Search in Google Scholar

Rohde 1877: E. Rohde, Zu den Mirabilia des Phlegon, RhM32, 1877, 331–339.Search in Google Scholar

Salvo 2013: I. Salvo, Romulus and Remus at Chios Revisited. A Re-examination of SEG XXX 1073, in: P. Martzavou – N. Papazarkadas (eds.), Epigraphical Approaches to the Post-Classical Polis, Oxford 2013, 125–127.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199652143.003.0009Search in Google Scholar

Saránte 2016: P. Saránte, Το αρχαίο λιμάνι της Ναυπάκτου: Κατάλοιπα και μαρτυρίες, in: O. Palagia (ed.), Ναύπακτος: η αρχαία πόλη και η σημασία της κατά τον Πελοποννησιακό πόλεμο και τα ελληνιστικά χρόνια: πρακτικά της Διεθνούς Ημερίδας Αρχαία Ναύπακτος και Ναυπακτία, Ναύπακτος, 15 Νοεμβρίου 2014, Athens 2016, 43–63.Search in Google Scholar

Sassi 1993: M. M. Sassi, Mirabilia, in: G. Cambiando – L. Canfora – D. Lanza (eds.), Lo spazio letterario della Grecia antica, 1: La produzione e la circolazione del texto, Rome 1993, 449–468.Search in Google Scholar

Schepens 1996: G. Schepens, Ancient Paradoxography. Origin, Evolution, Production and Reception, I: The Hellenistic Period, in: O. Pecere – A. Stramaglia (eds.), La letteratura di consumo nel mondo greco-latino, Cassino 1996, 375–409.Search in Google Scholar

Scott 1985: James C. Campbell, Weapons of the Weak: Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance, New Haven – London 1985.Search in Google Scholar

Shannon-Henderson 2019: K. E. Shannon-Henderson, Phlegon of Tralles (257), in: S. Schorn (ed.), Fragmente der Griechischen Historiker Part IV, Leiden 2019.Search in Google Scholar

Shannon-Henderson 2020: K. E. Shannon-Henderson, Constructing a New Imperial Paradoxography. Phlegon of Tralles and His Sources, in: A. König – R. Langlands – J. Uden (eds.), Literature and Culture in the Roman Empire, 96–235, Cambridge 2020, 159–178.10.1017/9781108637336.010Search in Google Scholar

Stramaglia 2011: A. Stramaglia, Phlegon Trallianus. Opuscupula de rebus mirabilibus et de Longeavis, Berlin – New York 2011.10.1515/9783110239058Search in Google Scholar

Thomas 2004: J. Thomas, Mirabilia tropismes de l’imaginaire antique, in: O. Bianchi – O. Thévenaz (eds.), Conceptions et représentations de l’extraordinaire dans le monde antique: actes du colloque international, Lausanne, 20–22 mars 2003, Bern 2004, 1–13.Search in Google Scholar

Walbank 1940: F. W. Walbank, Philip V of Macedon, Cambridge 1940.Search in Google Scholar

Walbank 1967: F. W. Walbank, A Historical Commentary on Polybius, II: Books VII–XVIII, Oxford 1967.Search in Google Scholar

Zeller 1883: E. Zeller, Über Antisthenes von Rhodos, Sitzungsberichte der Königlich Preußischen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin XXXIX, Berlin 1883.Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2022-11-17
Published in Print: 2022-11-30

© 2022 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston

Downloaded on 1.5.2024 from https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/klio-2021-0047/html
Scroll to top button