ALL Metrics
-
Views
-
Downloads
Get PDF
Get XML
Cite
Export
Track
Review

Exploring the Synergistic Potential of Pectin-Chitosan Composites for Advanced Drug Delivery and Biomedical Implant Applications: A Comprehensive Review and Future Perspectives

[version 1; peer review: awaiting peer review]
PUBLISHED 21 Mar 2024
Author details Author details
OPEN PEER REVIEW
REVIEWER STATUS AWAITING PEER REVIEW

This article is included in the QUVAE Research and Publications gateway.

Abstract

The polysaccharides pectin and chitosan are derived from the fruit peels and exoskeletons of crustaceans and insects, respectively. Their biocompatibility and renewability make them suitable for use in food products. The size of the swelling and degradation of these cells can be controlled using different combinations. Pectin and chitosan are useful as medication delivery systems, where they can be integrated to control the dosages and residence times of pharmaceuticals. They have a wide range of applications such as wound dressings, body fat reducers, tissue engineering agents, and drug delivery agents. Addressing teeth loss with the use of dental implants is a critical element of dental care. In most cases, healing is time-consuming and painful. As a result of adding new materials to the implant surface, the healing process would accelerate, and medications would be delivered to the implant site with greater efficiency.

Keywords

Natural Polysaccharides, Pectin, Chitosan, Drug delivery systems, Targeted drug delivery, Implant materials.

Introduction

Polysaccharides such as chitosan and pectin are found in nature.1 Chitin is derived from crustaceans and insect exoskeletons, whereas pectin is derived from apple and citrus fruit peel.2 The use of pectin as a stabilizing and texturizing agent in food is safe.3 Cell walls make up approximately one third of pectin in higher plants.4 There are usually differences in the molecular structure and degree of esterification of pectins derived from different sources. Citrus peel typically contains 20-30% pectin, whereas apple pomace typically contains 10-15% pectin.5,6 In pectin, there are regions that are smooth and other regions that are hairy branched.3 The biocompatibility of pectin is generally considered to be high.7 Generally, pectin is stable between pH 2 and 4.5, although it may become unstable at extreme pH values.7 There are several combinations of pectin that exhibit distinct properties, including enhanced peptide medication-controlled release efficiency, enhanced drug loading efficiency, and improved biocompatibility.8 Due to its biodegradability, pectin is ideal for drug delivery applications because of its minimal accumulation and long-term safety.9 Furthermore, by combining pectin, the swelling size and degradation can be managed to meet drug requirements.10 Several uses for pectin have been demonstrated, including its application to obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease.11

Chitosan was first discovered in 1859 by Rouget.12 Among natural biopolymers, it is the second most prevalent.13 It is estimated that 55–85% of chitin in crustacean cuticles originates from a layer of epidermal cells.14 Since chitin and cellulose share the same sugar unit and glycosidic bond type, they share several structural characteristics.15 Chitosan with a nitrogen content of approximately 6.9% is useful for chelation. Fibers, coatings, and beads made of chitosan can also be used instead of powders and solutions.16 Chitosans decompose prior to melting when heated.17 They possess strong bioadhesive properties that make them useful for adding bioadhesive properties to various drug delivery systems.18 The stability of chitosan can be challenged in highly acidic settings, which can be addressed through modifications, as it is most suitable for delivering drugs to the gastrointestinal system under neutral to acidic pH conditions.19 The inherent biodegradability of chitosan and its non-toxic degradation products make it an ideal material for biomedical applications, minimizing exposure to long-term toxic effects.20 Chitosan also possesses DNA-binding, biocompatibility, hemostatic, fungistatic, spermicidal, and anticholesteric properties and accelerates bone growth.21

Drug delivery systems based on pectin and chitosan: benefits and effects

In addition to increasing the delivery of specific drugs, pectin improves their absorption.3 Oral administration is widely used as the easiest and most convenient method of drug delivery. When a drug is orally administered, the dosage can be adjusted based on how quickly the digestive system absorbs the dose. Two factors that may affect oral medications administered via the gastrointestinal tract are a low stomach pH and poor stomach peristalsis. Furthermore, the enzymatic activity and digestive properties of gastric content, as well as the duration of drug residence in the stomach and intestine, are important factors.22 Different methods for encapsulating or incorporating drugs into tablets, capsules, or nanoparticles can protect them from degradation.23 Drugs can be encapsulated to mask their taste or modify their release.24 As shown in Tables 1 and 2, pectin is an effective material for the preparation of oral drug carriers.25 Over the past two decades, it has inspired academia and manufacturers to develop more effective drug delivery systems. In addition to being used as wound dressings, body fat reduction agents, and tissue engineering agents, they are also used in drug delivery systems (Table 1). Chitosan, the only biodegradable polymer with a positive charge, has distinctive properties and characteristics among the biodegradable polymers used by pharmaceutical companies. The primary amino group of chitosan is responsible for its cationic charge, which results in the ability to deliver drugs.26 Chitosan has also been shown to improve saturation, stable gelling, mucoadhesive, and efflux pump inhibitor properties. In addition, cationic interactions can be used to deliver drugs through nanoparticles based on DNA and RNA.27 Numerous studies have demonstrated that chitosan is an effective drug delivery system. The characteristics of chitosan differ depending on the salt form, degree of deacetylation, and molecular weight.27 Dornish et al. showed that high-grade and ultra-pure chitosan was safe for use in biological and physiological systems.28 Drug carriers can enhance drug bioavailability by providing mucoadhesive doses, extending release times, and maintaining drugs at absorption sites for longer durations. Chitosan has osteoinductive properties, allowing it to promote cell proliferation, adhesion, and differentiation in bone defects, in addition to biocompatibility and mechanical properties.29 Drug absorption across mucosal membranes can also be improved by chitosan depending on how it is delivered.

Table 1. Chitosan-based systems for targeted delivery of drugs.

Application siteFormulation of materialsIn-vitro/in-vivo/Ex-vivoDescription of key featuresDrugDate and reference
ColonEudragit: An entanglement of chitosan microcores and acrylic microspheresIn-vivoThe pH was a determining factor for Eudagrit. Following Eudagrit dissolution, the chitosan core swelled, leading to the dissolution and diffusion of drug. A molecular weight-dependent effect on drug release was found with chitosan.Sodium diclofenac30, 2009
Crosslinked chitosan film containing citrateIn-vivoThe chitosan film was sensitive to pH. Chitosan swelling was accelerated, and drug release was faster in an acidic medium. Over the course of 24 h, 40% of the drug was released at neutral pH.Riboflavin30, 2009
Chitosan succinate and chitosan phthalateIn-vivopH affected the dissolution of the combination, with acidic conditions causing a decrease in the release of the drug and alkaline conditions increasing dissolution.Sodium diclofenac31, 1999
Chitosan capsuleIn-vivoThe amount of drug directly absorbed by the cecum of rats is higher. Animals with induced colitis were treated with chitosan-based capsules which accelerated the healing process.5-Aminosalicylic acid32, 2002
Liposomes coated with chitosanIn-vivoIn rats, coated liposomes increased alendronate oral bioavailability, and in Caco-2 cells, their absorption was also enhanced.Alendronate33, 2012
Chitosan CapsulesIn-vivoThe therapeutic effect was increasedR68070 (thromboxane synthase inhibitor)34, 1999
N-(2-hydroxypropyl)-3-trimethylammonium chitosan chlorideIn-vitro/Ex-vivoIt inhibited the reproduction of SARS-CoV-2 and MERS-CoV virusAntiviral35, 2021
Carboxymethyl chitosan nanoparticles cross-linked with Ca2+ ionsIn-vitroThe nano film provided an extended-release patternClindamycin HCl36, 2022
Crosslinked carboxymethyl chitosan nanoparticlesIn-vivoIn addition to the high encapsulation efficiency (90%), its controlled release was also observedMetformin hydrochloride37, 2021
Chitosan capsulesIn-vivoIt increased the concentration of prednisolone in the large intestinal mucosaPrednisolone38, 2007
Cholesterol-modified glycol chitosanIn-vivoThe compound showed prolonged circulation time in rat plasma as well as a stronger antitumor effect.Doxorubicin39, 2009
Linoleic acid-modified glycol chitosanIn-vivoDrug release from the nanoparticles was reduced.
The nanoparticles demonstrated stronger anti-tumor efficacy in tumor bearing mice
Paclitaxel40, 2015
Methoxy poly (ethylene glycol)-grafted-chitosanIn-vivoIn 48 h, more than 50% of the product was continuously released.Methotrexate41, 2008
N, O-carboxymethyl chitosan (NOCC)In-vitroNOCC nanoparticles loaded with insulin are released more slowly at higher pH levels of phosphate buffered salineInsulin42, 2009
Folate-conjugated chitosanIn-vitroThe drug is condensed efficiently, has good tumor-targeting abilities, and has a low cytotoxicity levelPaclitaxel43, 2008
pH-sensitive self-aggregated nanoparticles, amphiphilic deoxycholic acid modified carboxymethyl chitosanIn-vitroEnhanced cellular uptake and greater retentionDoxorubicin44, 2012
Systemiclinoleic acid/poly (β-malic acid) double grafted chitosanIn-vivoNanoparticles were safe drug carriers, showed significantly potent tumor inhibition efficacyPaclitaxel45, 2009
OralMono- and bi-layered mucoadhesive films using CSIn-vitroThe model drug has increased tensile strength and antimicrobial activityCefuroxime46, 2019
Buccal film based on Chitosan in mixture with polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP)In-vitro/In-vivoThe drug release at therapeutic concentrations for 6 h was continuous, but at a lower dosage than usual, because the film exhibited satisfactory mechanical and bio adhesive propertiesTenoxicam47, 2020
Blended CS film with PVAEx-vivoThe antimicrobial activity against Streptococcus mutans was effective, with a good kill timeCetylpyridinium chloride48, 2020
Chitosan and sodium alginate pecIn-vivoPresented a relative bioavailability of 246%Zolmitriptan49, 2022
Chitosan and sodium alginate pecIn-vivoPresented a relative bioavailability of 142%Etodolac49, 2022
OcularAn anionic chitosan hydrogel enhanced by disodium α-dglucose 1-phosphateIn-vivoThe drug penetrates deeply into the cornea when it is released rapidly. An exceptional level of ocular tolerance is achieved by this hydrogel. Residency in the ocular region for a prolonged period.Levocetirizine dihydrochloride50, 2012
The liposomes are coated with chitosan that has a low molecular weightIn-vivoUsing chitosan with a low molecular weight, the coating improved trans-corneal drug penetration.Diclofenac sodium51, 2009
Nanocapsules of polycaprolactone coated with chitosanIn-vivoBioavailability of indomethacin in the eye was increased.Indomethacin52, 1997
LiverNanoparticles based on chitosan and poly ethylene glycol modified with glycyrrhetinic acidIn-vivoA long-term storage of high medication concentrations is dependent on nanoparticles in the liver. Animals bearing H22 cells were not subject to tumor development when nanoparticles were applied.Doxorubicin53, 2010
PEG-grafted lactose conjugated chitosan micelles derived from methyl grafted chitosanIn-vivoThe drug molecules had a higher concentration of molecules and specifically targeted the liver in mice.Diammonium glycyrrhizinate54, 2009
Nanoparticles of galactosylated chitosanIn-vitro/In-vivoThe 5-Fluorouracil nanoparticles released at a sustained rate. Mouse orthotropic liver hepatic cancer cells are more effectively targeted with this drug.5-Fluorouracil55, 2012
Conjugated chitosan nanoparticles containing glycyrrhizin (GL)In-vivoThe loading efficiency of medication was 91.7%. Nanoparticles accumulate preferentially in hepatocytes, and cellular uptake depends on both time and dose.Adriamycin56, 2008
KidneyChitosan with a low molecular weightIn-vivoThere was a 13-fold increase in prednisolone dose in the kidney region when chitosan was loaded with prednisolone.Prednisolone57, 2009
LungNanoparticles made of chitosan and poly (lactic coglycolic acid)In-vitroAn enhanced absorption of nanoparticles by lung cancer cells.Paclitaxel58, 2009
Nanoparticles made of chitosan and poly (lactic coglycolic acid)In-vivoA negative charge on tumor cells causes nanoparticles to interact strongly with them under acidic conditions.Paclitaxel59, 2009

Table 2. Pectin-based systems for targeted delivery of drugs.

Application siteFormulation of materialsIn-vitro/in-vivo/Ex-vivoDescription of key featuresDrugDate and reference
ColonCoating of pectin at a ratio of 5:1In-vitroThe release of drug molecules at pH 6 is significant even in the absence of enzymes.Indomethacin60, 1998
The coating is made up of pectin and calcium chlorideIn-vitroThe pharmacokinetics of compression-coated tablets were slower and sustained than those of core tablets.Indomethacin61, 2015
Eudagrit S-100In-vivoAs a result of colonic enzymatic activity, drug release is delayed in the colon, and due to a high pH in the stomach, no drug release is observed.Metronidazole62, 2009
Hydroxypropyl-methylcellulose
Pectinate beads
In-vivoDue to colonic pectinolytic enzymes, drug release in the colon is delayed. During the reticulation process, counterion concentration allows better control of release.Ketoprofen63, 2013
Pectin with a high esterification level and a high molecular weightIn-vivoProtection for mucosa provided by coating.
Reduced production of gastric acid, reduction of pepsin secretion, and scavenging of radicals. Reduction in the reabsorption of bile acid. A reduction in cholesterol absorption and the production of volatile fatty acids.
Efficacy in lowering lipids and cholesterol64, 2020
Pectin with high methoxylationIn-vivoThere is a delay in drug release specific to the colon. No interference with the normal enzymatic activity of the upper gastrointestinal tract.Ropivacaine hydrochloride monohydrate65, 2000
Pectin/anhydrous dibasic calcium phosphate (ADCP) matrix tabletsIn-vitroWater-soluble drugs are released into the gastrointestinal tract in a controlled manner.Theophylline66, 2015
Eudragit S and Eudragit L doubly enteric-coatedIn-vivoDiminished intestinal irritation and profound drug liberation was attainedBisacodyl67, 2017
Hydroxypropyl methylcellulose mixed with pectinIn-vitro/In-vivoSustained release inside the colon and reached the colon without disturbing in the upper gastrointestinal system5-fluorouracil68, 2020
OcularNanoparticulate of thiolate pectinEx-vivoAqueous solution releases and permeates more drugs in goat corneas than normal aqueous solution.Magnesium chloride69, 2012
LiverPectin with a low esterification level and a high molecular weightIn-vivoHarmful substances are eliminated from the body via the kidney and the intestine.
The gut flora is in balance, which contributes to antioxidant properties. The harmful metal ions are removed from the system. Pectin bacterial fermentation produces short-chain fatty acids.
Hepatoprotective effects70, 2008
Concentration of apple and orange pectin of 5%In-vivoAmong all pectin-fed groups, hepatic cholesterol concentrations decreased significantly. The serum cholesterol level was significantly reduced only in groups that received apples. The levels of cholesterol in the liver decreased, while the levels of cholesterol in the serum and feces increased.Cholesterol levels71, 1998

Pectin-chitosan composite materials

Pectin-chitosan composites have emerged as versatile materials in medicine.72 These composites possess different properties and offer various benefits in the fields of drug delivery and release, pH sensitivity, adhesion to mucosal surfaces, and enhanced stability.73 The use of pectin-chitosan composites for drug delivery offers many advantages, making them an attractive choice for drug delivery applications.74 These advantages include biocompatibility, bio-adhesiveness, and the ability to tailor drug release to ensure safe drug administration.75 In addition, their encapsulation properties are useful in protecting sensitive drugs.76 Pectin-chitosan composites for drug delivery can be formulated through various methods, providing flexibility to meet specific requirements. Common techniques include layer-by-layer assembly, gelation, cross-linking, solvent evaporation, spray drying, compression, and freeze-drying.73,77–79 The choice of method depends on the desired particle size and drug-release profile. The pectin-chitosan composite is a highly promising material for drug delivery, as it ensures biocompatibility with minimal adverse effects on living tissues. The composite shows strong bioadhesive capabilities for effective mucosal adhesion and can maintain stability within a suitable pH range.80,81 Its biodegradability and eco-friendliness reduce concerns about long-term toxicity and environmental impact, while its adaptability to a variety of drug types and ability to tailor its properties through formulation adjustments make it a versatile choice.82

The rate at which drugs are released from pectin-chitosan composites in drug delivery systems is influenced by multiple factors, necessitating the precise control of tailored drug release kinetics.83 Key factors affecting drug release include the composition of pectin and chitosan, degree of cross-linking, drug properties, composite formulation, pH, ionic strength, temperature, geometry, mechanical properties, swelling, erosion behavior, drug loading, release mechanisms, external stimuli, release mode, drug loading techniques, and degradation rate of pectin and chitosan.84 The use of pectin-chitosan composites for drug delivery is generally safe and biocompatible; however, potential side effects exist. Controlling drug release is essential for preventing overdosing or underdosing, and drug interactions should be considered.85 Systemic side effects depend on the drug and the route of administration.

Role of dental implants

Dental implants are in high demand owing to widespread tooth loss.86 In 1957, Per-Ingvar Brånemark discovered that titanium enhances bone healing properties and their regeneration.87 In the case of titanium implants, the rate of bone healing is like that following a fracture or injury to bone.88 The role of an implant and the function is to act as an osteoconductive substrate, allowing new tissue to grow around the defect.89 Blood clots, cell activation and responses to an implant wound are the three stages of wound healing.90 An implant or body surface treated with a new material elicits different biological responses. In order to improve osseointegration between implant surfaces and bone, microlevel characteristics can be applied to implant surfaces.91,92 As the implant contact surface and bone surface become more intimate, the implant acquires stronger anchorage.93 The rough texture of the surface encourages osteoblastic cell adhesion more quickly than the smooth texture.93,94 Implants with a rough surface provide a larger surface area and enhance the attachment of cells from the bone to implants. In addition to increasing attachment, biochemical interactions between the implant surface and the bone also increase. A variety of treatments and ceramic-like elements can be applied to implant surfaces to enhance osseointegration.95

According to Wennerberg, the surface roughness of implants can be classified into three levels: minimal, intermediate, and rough.96 Based on the texture, the implants were found to have concave or convex surfaces. Irregularities on the surface can be isotropic or anisotropic, giving the surface roughness a particular orientation.97 Surface roughness can be increased using various methods including blasting,98 chemical etching,99 plasma-sprayed surfaces, ion-sputtering coating,100 and anodized surfaces.100 Many materials can be used to coat the surfaces of dental implants depending on their function and intended use.101 There are two types of coating: inorganic layers (hydroxyapatite or calcium phosphate) and organic layers (growth factors).102 Among inorganic phases, ceramics dominate.103 Adding calcium phosphate to implant surfaces improves osteoconductive properties, accelerating the development of bone around the implants.104 The addition of a hydroxyapatite film to implants causes the release of fluoride ions, resulting in bone calcification.105 Hydroxyapatite also acts as a mechanical stabilizer as well as a chemical bonding agent between tissues and implant surfaces.106 As a result of adding organic phases or bioactive materials to implant surfaces, biochemical bonding capacity, hydrophilicity, and osseointegration can be enhanced, depending on the desired outcome, for example, increasing cell adhesion and growth factors or acting as local drug delivery systems.107,108

Pectin and chitosan as implants: a rationale for their use

A new implant coating can enhance the properties of dental implants with the potential to improve attachment, mineralization, and protein deposition by creating a coating for osteoblasts that identify and interact with particular molecules.99 New methods of local antimicrobial prophylaxis are needed to ensure that dental prostheses are protected from infections. Implants can enhance biological reactions in situ and promote long-term bone healing. This would allow for faster recovery and a quicker return to normal activity for patients and doctors. The application of nanocoating with organic molecules can have a positive effect on osseointegration and cell behavior. In the vicinity of implants with polysaccharide nanocoating, Bone-to-implant surface contact, and bone mineral density improved.108 Biopolymers derived from marine and agricultural sources are readily available and replenishable, making them useful in the medical life sciences. Owing to their biocompatibility and biodegradability, these polymers offer ecological security and the ability to be modified by enzymes, giving them a unique set of properties.109 The anticoagulant properties of sulfated chitosan have also been demonstrated. A biopolymer membrane-covered wound showed better hemostatic properties and healed faster.110 Improvements in epithelialization and collagen deposition have been demonstrated using biopolymer-based membranes. In addition to inhibiting fibrin formation, chitosan-based dressings reduce scarring in wounds.111 Because of chitosan membranes, wounds are less likely to lose water, oxygen permeability is increased, fluid drainage is promoted, and foreign microorganism contamination is reduced.112 Chitosan and pectin are both capable of forming thin membranes that can be used to improve the delivery of medications in various ways.113 A major component of future implant technologies is the fibrin scaffold provided by biopolymers. Bone and implant surfaces can form covalent bonds with the scaffold, thereby mediating cell adhesion.107

The interaction between Fiekian diffusion and high-viscosity chitosan films has resulted in the constant release of drugs for prolonged periods of time.114 This has led to the development of antimicrobials for specific areas of periodontal therapy, addressing the disadvantages of systemic drug administration. The properties of pectin and chitosan derivatives make them ideal for local drug delivery systems because they enable easy delivery, long-term retention, and regulated medication release. These derivatives also allow for the acceptable penetration of medication into the oral cavity and sustained retention of medication. In addition to their antimicrobial properties, these compounds are highly effective and well tolerated in oral tissues. Pectin and chitosan derivatives have different chemical and physiological properties, including ionic charge, branching, various molecular weights, and enzyme modification properties, making them good candidates for biomaterial coatings.115 Chitosan and pectin with high levels of galactose and low levels of arabinose have been shown to reduce inflammation, which is vital for improving implant integration and reducing inflammation in patients with rheumatoid arthritis, periodontitis, and immunocompromised patients.116 It has been found that biopolymer derivatives inhibit a large number of gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria as well as fungi.117

Pectin and chitosan are effective and efficient because of their diverse modification capabilities. Altering the length of their side chains and removing acetyl groups from their hairy regions can change their polarity and wettability.118,119 Human tissue takes up covalently bonded pectin well in terms of immunological responses.120–122 Modifying the side chains of pectin or chitosan sugar molecules makes it easier to initiate bone cell attachment in a manner that is tailored to the human body. It would be beneficial to investigate the use of pectin or chitosan as implant nanocoating and to support their development with findings from previous studies of bone biology.

Conclusion

The efficacies of pectin and chitosan are supported by their diverse modification capabilities. It is possible to fabricate nanostructures and sizes made from these natural biopolymers for an array of innovative uses. Reviewing the application of pectin and chitosan, as well as their composites, for dental implant surface coatings is a promising endeavor because of the multifaceted benefits of the composites. These composites offer enhanced biocompatibility and can mitigate infection risks owing to their inherent antimicrobial properties. In addition, they have the potential to promote osseointegration by facilitating bone cell adhesion and growth. By enabling controlled drug delivery, these composites can release antimicrobial agents or growth factors, optimize tissue healing around implants, and minimize inflammation. The versatility of the formulation allows for tailored applications, whereas their natural sourcing contributes to eco-friendliness. This aim is to improve the safety, longevity, and success of dental implant procedures, making them an asset in dental implant technology. Studies and experimental tests should be conducted to determine the efficacy of pectin-chitosan composites as nanocoating for implants. Promising outcomes from in vitro and in vivo research may emerge in the near future.

Comments on this article Comments (0)

Version 1
VERSION 1 PUBLISHED 21 Mar 2024
Comment
Author details Author details
Competing interests
Grant information
Copyright
Download
 
Export To
metrics
Views Downloads
F1000Research - -
PubMed Central
Data from PMC are received and updated monthly.
- -
Citations
CITE
how to cite this article
Alsharbaty MHM, Naji GA and Ali SS. Exploring the Synergistic Potential of Pectin-Chitosan Composites for Advanced Drug Delivery and Biomedical Implant Applications: A Comprehensive Review and Future Perspectives [version 1; peer review: awaiting peer review] F1000Research 2024, 13:209 (https://doi.org/10.12688/f1000research.145101.1)
NOTE: it is important to ensure the information in square brackets after the title is included in all citations of this article.
track
receive updates on this article
Track an article to receive email alerts on any updates to this article.

Open Peer Review

Current Reviewer Status:
AWAITING PEER REVIEW
AWAITING PEER REVIEW
?
Key to Reviewer Statuses VIEW
ApprovedThe paper is scientifically sound in its current form and only minor, if any, improvements are suggested
Approved with reservations A number of small changes, sometimes more significant revisions are required to address specific details and improve the papers academic merit.
Not approvedFundamental flaws in the paper seriously undermine the findings and conclusions

Comments on this article Comments (0)

Version 1
VERSION 1 PUBLISHED 21 Mar 2024
Comment
Alongside their report, reviewers assign a status to the article:
Approved - the paper is scientifically sound in its current form and only minor, if any, improvements are suggested
Approved with reservations - A number of small changes, sometimes more significant revisions are required to address specific details and improve the papers academic merit.
Not approved - fundamental flaws in the paper seriously undermine the findings and conclusions
Sign In
If you've forgotten your password, please enter your email address below and we'll send you instructions on how to reset your password.

The email address should be the one you originally registered with F1000.

Email address not valid, please try again

You registered with F1000 via Google, so we cannot reset your password.

To sign in, please click here.

If you still need help with your Google account password, please click here.

You registered with F1000 via Facebook, so we cannot reset your password.

To sign in, please click here.

If you still need help with your Facebook account password, please click here.

Code not correct, please try again
Email us for further assistance.
Server error, please try again.