Abstract
Technique- or technology-transfer is based in many ways on technological and economic paths that were often created by European colonization and have been intensified by Industrialization and Globalization. On the one hand, the modern age is a constantly developing planetary truth, a truth that impacts every society in the world. On the other hand, societies in third world countries have not produced this condition themselves because modernity is an external imposition. This means the modern age turns to be an unavoidable destiny for them. Traditional modernization and technology transfer abstract from almost all contextual factors. That is why technological development and modernization are being compared across continents and assessed with more or less value, not considering the cultural and social contextual circumstances. This supposes on one hand that the western way into the modern age has a model character, is normative and there are no alternatives to it. Also, it is supposed that the modern age is a desirable objective and that compensation leads to equal final situations.
A requirement for technological standards and for technology transfer are innovations which constantly promise new development paths and stable institutional settings that can be monitored over a long period. These setting have to be ensured by the cultural system, especially by their social-economical dimensions. Also, the religious dimension is a part of this setting, and in Africa and South-east Asia is closely connected to the form and style of life and to culture. Secularization comparable to the western world only takes place in major cities, as they are islands of modernization. For thousands of years, technological process innovations such as technology transfer have been digested by cultural embedding and not through modernization. This might vary from place to place but in general it shows the same development. Heteronomous transfers meet culturally motivated resistance or are ignored, whereas the circumstances of technology transfer are a bit different. It is not being identified with culture transfer and does not automatically lead to a broad modernization but to a form of development with a speed of cultural adjustment - for sure slower than required by modernization. But this development can mostly be digested with the help of the embedding-paradigm. It is our task to generate forms of modernization with consideration for cultural embedding and traditions.
- Brackert, H., F. Wefelmeyer 1984: Naturplan und Verfallskritik. Zu Begriff und Geschichte der Kultur, Frankfurt.Google Scholar
- Chen, E. 1994: (Hg). Technology transfer to developing countries; London New York Habermas, J. 1988: Der philosophische Diskurs der Moderne; Frankfurt.Google Scholar
- Ihde, D. 1993: Philosophy of Technology. An introduction; New York.Google Scholar
- Irrgang, B. 2000: Technological Development and social progress; in: Instituto del Filosofia Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile; Seminarios de Filosofia 12/13 (1999/2000), 41-52.Google Scholar
- Irrgang, B. 2001: Technische Kultur. Instrumentelles Verstehen und technisches Handeln; (Philosophie der Technik Bd. 1) Paderborn {Technological Culture: Instrumental Understanding and Technological Action}.Google Scholar
- Irrgang, B. 2002a: Technische Praxis. Gestaltungsperspektiven technischer Entwicklung; (Philosophie der Technik Bd. 2) Paderborn {Technological Practice: Design Perspectives of Technological Development}.Google Scholar
- Irrgang, B. 2002b: Technischer Fortschritt. Legitimitätsprobleme innovativer Technik; (Philosophie der Technik Bd. 3) Paderborn {Technological Progress: Legitimacy Problems of Innovative Technology}.Google Scholar
- Irrgang, B. 2003a: Technologietransfer transkulturell als Bewegung technischer Kompetenz am Beispiel der spätmittelalterlichen Waffentechnologie; in: Wissenschaftliche Zeitschrift der Technischen Universität Dresden 52 (2003) Heft 5/6,91-95.Google Scholar
- Irrgang, Bernhard 2006: Technologietransfer transkulturell. Komparativ Hermeneutik von Technik in Europa, Indien und China; Peter Lang, Frankfurt am Main {Transcultural Technology Transfer: Comparative Hermeneutics of Technology in Europe, India and China}.Google Scholar
- Irrgang, Bernhard 2007: Hermeneutische Ethik. Pragmatisch-ethische Orientierung in technologischen Gesellschaften; Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, Darmstadt {Hermeneutical Ethics: Pragmatical-ethical Orientation in Technological Societies}.Google Scholar
- Lübbe, H. 1993: Globale Vereinheitlichung durch die Technik und die Vielfalt der Kulturen. Zur Kompensationstheorie der historischen Kulturwissenschaften; in: F. Rapp (Hg.): Neue Ethik der Technik. Philosophische Kontroversen; Wiesbaden, 15-51.Google Scholar
- Ogburn, W. 1969: Kultur und sozialer Wandel. Ausgewählte Schriften; ed. von O. D. Duncan; Neuwied, Berlin.Google Scholar
- Sahlins, M. 1994: Kultur und praktische Vernunft; übersetzt von B. Luchisi (11976); Frankfurt.Google Scholar
- Young, R. 1995: Colonial desire. Hybridity in theory, culture and race; London, New York.Google Scholar
Index Terms
- Technology transfer and modernization: what can philosophers of technology contribute?
Recommendations
Transfer of information technology to the Arab world: a test of cultural influence modeling
Advanced topics in global information managementThe complex societal beliefs and values of the Arab world provide a rich setting to examine the hypothesized influence of culture on information technology transfer (ITT). Two research questions arise in this context: (1) Do cultural beliefs and values ...
Looking for the Image of Modernization: The Story of Made in Taiwan (MIT)
IDGD '09: Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Internationalization, Design and Global Development: Held as Part of HCI International 2009Beginning in the 1980s, Taiwan's most vigorous global economic activity trade department faced several difficult issues in succession. Reversing this unfavorable situation by improving the MIT product image in international markets was seen as the ...
Charismatic technology
CA '15: Proceedings of The Fifth Decennial Aarhus Conference on Critical AlternativesTo explain the uncanny holding power that some technologies seem to have, this paper presents a theory of charisma as attached to technology. It uses the One Laptop per Child project as a case study for exploring the features, benefits, and pitfalls of ...
Comments