Index

Critical Perspectives on Educational Policies and Professional Identities

ISBN: 978-1-83753-333-6, eISBN: 978-1-83753-332-9

Publication date: 4 June 2024

This content is currently only available as a PDF

Citation

(2024), "Index", Waller, R., Andrews, J. and Clark, T. (Ed.) Critical Perspectives on Educational Policies and Professional Identities, Emerald Publishing Limited, Leeds, pp. 273-279. https://doi.org/10.1108/978-1-83753-332-920241017

Publisher

:

Emerald Publishing Limited

Copyright © 2024 Richard Waller, Jane Andrews and Timothy Clark. Published under exclusive licence by Emerald Publishing Limited


INDEX

Ability labelling
, 192

Academic attainment
, 248–249

Accountability
, 73

Action research
, 175–178

Activists
, 222–223

Advanced Clinical Practice (ACP)
, 30

Advanced Clinical Practitioner (ACP)
, 31

Agency
, 100

Analysis
, 15–16

Aspiration
, 195

Assessment for Learning (AfL)
, 162–163

Assimilators
, 240–241

Association for Science Education Annual (ASE)
, 115

Association of Colleges (AoC)
, 174–175

Asymmetry of power
, 196

Autoethnography
, 50

Autonomy
, 92

Avoiders
, 221–222

Barriers
, 192

Bourdieu
, 49

Bourdieusian lens
, 193

Bourdieusian perspective
, 202–203

Braun and Clarke
, 147

Bricolage
, 15–16

British Educational Research Association (BERA)
, 2, 146

Bullock Report (1975)
, 250–252

Capitals
, 49

Career changers
, 158–159

Carter Review
, 140

Case study
, 107, 195–196

Change
, 165–167

Children, ethical issues surrounding conducting research with
, 196–197

Class
, 48

Classroom complexity
, 92

Classroom relationships
, 200

Classroom teaching
, 91

Close-to-practice research
, 3

Community of practice (CoP)
, 108

Competitive mediation
, 73, 75–76

Complexity Theory
, 88–90

Compliance
, 69–70

Confidence
, 165–167

Consciousness
, 165–167

Consolidatory focus group
, 179–180

Constructivist grounded theory (CGT)
, 158–159

Containers
, 220–221

Contingent choosers
, 59–62

Continuing Professional Development (CPD)
, 30, 106–107, 121–123, 268

regeneration
, 185–186

Core Content Framework (CCF)
, 94–95

Core PGCE (Core) provision
, 140

Counter-Terrorism and Security Act
, 230

Counter-terrorism measures
, 230

data collection
, 235–237

epidemiological justification for Prevent
, 231

findings
, 237–242

governmentality, freedom of speech and surveillance
, 231–233

new taxonomy of policy enactment work
, 238–239

Critical discourse analysis (CDA)
, 236–237

Critical realism
, 233–234

Critical Realist World Systems Model (CReWS)
, 230

Critical-realist analytical method
, 236–237

Data analysis
, 236–237

Department for Education (DfE)
, 249

Diagrammatic modelling
, 161

Doctoral practitioner research
, 1–2

challenging educational policy and practice
, 5

constructions of professional and society
, 5

interrogating approaches
, 5

process
, 5–7

rationale
, 3–4

researcher development
, 2–3

structure
, 4–5

Doctoral students
, 141

Doctoral study
, 88, 90, 252, 259

Doctorate in Education (EdD)
, 1

Doubters
, 241–242

Early Career Framework (ECF)
, 94–95, 158–159

Early career researchers (ECRs)
, 1–2

Early Years Education and Care (ECEC)
, 13–14

Early years educators, mapping roles of
, 21–23

Ecological systems theory
, 91–92

Education and Training Foundation (ETF)
, 125

Education policy and simple view of teaching and learning
, 93–95

Education policymakers
, 88

Educational Endowment Foundation (EEF)
, 97

Emancipatory discourses of professionalism
, 127

Embedded choosers
, 59–62

Emergency Department (ED)
, 32–33

Emergency Nurse Practitioner (ENP)
, 30

Emotional conceptualisations
, 184

Emotional health
, 182–183

English as an additional language (EAL)
, 248

Epistemology
, 97

Ethics
, 71, 180–181

Every Child Matters
, 12

Evidence-based training model
, 174–175

Feedback
, 199

Fixed ability
, 192–193

Focus groups
, 147

‘Football managers’ syndrome
, 74–75

Foucauldian discourse analysis (FDA)
, 236–237

Foucault
, 231–232

Freedom of speech
, 231–233

Fundamental British values (FBV)
, 232, 241–242

Further and Higher Education Act (1992)
, 124

Further education (FE)
, 66–67, 121–122, 174–175, 267–268

analysis
, 72–73

brief history of FE policy
, 123–125

conceptualisations of professionalism
, 125–127

effects on professional learning in
, 127–133

ethics
, 71

experience in
, 67–69

findings
, 73–77

insider research
, 70

method
, 71–72

methodology
, 70–72

participants
, 70

post-match analysis
, 78–79

procedure and sampling
, 72

professionalism in FE contexts
, 69–70

recommendations
, 78

research study
, 65–66

terms
, 122–123

Gender
, 48

General Certificate of Secondary Education (GCSE)
, 111

Generic CPD
, 131–132

Georgie Ford (GF)
, 174

Governmentality
, 231–233

Habitus
, 109

Healthcare policy

findings
, 36

insider knowledge and ethical issues
, 33–35

photograph elicitation
, 35–36

policy context
, 30–31

research methods
, 31–33

role
, 36–38

role socialisation
, 40–41

role transition
, 39–40

Sally’s professional story and context
, 30

third space
, 41–42

Hierarchies of professionalism

distinct professionalism
, 13–14

identities and professionalism through insider research
, 12–13

interprofessional partnerships for inclusion
, 16–21

mapping roles of early years educators
, 21–23

methodology
, 15–16

theorising early years educators’ professional roles and identities
, 14–15

High expectation teachers
, 192

Bourdieusian perspective
, 202–203

context and methods
, 197–198

ethical considerations
, 196–197

implications for practice
, 203–204

learning from research design
, 204

methodology
, 195–196

research findings
, 198–202

social mobility
, 193–194

impact of socio-economic factors
, 194–195

theoretical framework
, 192–193

Higher education (HE)
, 30, 66

History teachers, categorisation of
, 213–214

Home language (HL)
, 248–249

case for HL policy
, 259–260

challenges
, 260

doctoral study
, 252–259

exploring changing policy perspectives on
, 251–252

findings from semi-structured interviews and HL assessments
, 256–259

setting scene
, 249–250

Horizontal surveillance
, 215

Hybrid space
, 42–43

Identity
, 12–13, 30, 61–62, 106, 141

convergence
, 165–167

development
, 161–165

In-service education and training (INSET)
, 122–123

Inclusion
, 158–159

Initial teacher education (ITE)
, 140, 158

diagrammatic modelling
, 161

identity convergence, change, consciousness and confidence
, 165–167

middle placement and identity development
, 161–165

policy context
, 158–159

prompted monologue
, 160–161

study
, 159

Insider knowledge
, 33–35

Insider research
, 70

Insider-researcher in educational setting
, 197

Institute for Learning (IfL)
, 125

Interactive learning
, 90

Interpretivism
, 215

Interpretivist paradigm
, 144

Interprofessional partnerships for inclusion
, 16–21

Interviews
, 210

Jane Andrews (JA)
, 1

Language interdependence hypotheses
, 248–249

Learning
, 88

communities
, 142–143

as complex phenomena
, 91–93

from research design
, 204

Lecturer-centred approach
, 123–124

Legitimate peripheral participation
, 108

Legitimators
, 239

Lingfield Review
, 125

Long Term Workforce Plan (LTWP)
, 31

Mediation
, 69–70

Mental conceptualisations
, 184

Mental health
, 174–175

Mental Health First Aid (MHFA)
, 176

pre-implementation trial
, 178–179

Mentor
, 142

Mentoring
, 142

Methodology
, 110–111

Middle placement
, 161–165

Minor Injury Unit (MIU)
, 32–33

Misrecognition of social coercion
, 48

Mixed methods social network analysis (MMSNA)
, 88–90

Motivation
, 148

Multi Academy Trust (MAT)
, 224–225

Narrative inquiry
, 50

National Curriculum for History
, 211, 218

National Curriculum of England (NCE)
, 250, 252

National Health Service (NHS)
, 5

Neo-liberal policy
, 123–124

New roles
, 31

New taxonomy of policy enactment work
, 238–239

Newly Qualified Teacher (NQT)
, 111–112

Non-compliance
, 69–70

Nurse education
, 267

Nursing
, 30

Objectivity
, 160

One-to-one coaching
, 123

Ontology
, 233–234

Organisational analysis
, 195–196

Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
, 96

Panopticism
, 231–232

Panopticon
, 231–232

Pedagogy
, 61–62, 210

Pedagopticon
, 214

Perceived impacts of sporting experiences on professional practice
, 75–77

Performance management in FE contexts
, 73–75

Performativity
, 73

Personal, Social, Health and Economic education programme (PSHE education programme)
, 241–242

Photograph elicitation
, 35–36

Physical Education (PE)
, 67

Physician Associate (PA)
, 31

Poetry
, 50–51

Policy
, 142, 210

Polyhedron of intelligibility
, 144–145

Post-Graduate Certificate in Education (PGCE)
, 67

Post-match analysis
, 78–79

Postgraduate
, 158–159

Postgraduate research (PGR)
, 110

Power
, 109

Practice-based doctoral studies

critical perspectives on educational policies and professional identity
, 266, 270–271

value of practitioner research
, 265–266

Practitioner-researcher
, 266

Prevent Duty Strategy
, 210, 212–213, 219

Prevent policy
, 230, 233, 235

epidemiological justification for
, 231

Primary science
, 106

case study teachers
, 111–112

findings
, 112–116

methodology and methods
, 110–111

national context
, 106–107

professional identity
, 107–110

Private, voluntary and independent settings (PVI)
, 16

Professional doctorates
, 50

Professional identity
, 30, 48–49, 59, 88, 107, 110, 140–142

gaining insights into
, 235–236

as teacher
, 150–152

theoretical framework
, 108–110

Professional learning effects in FE
, 127–133

Professional socialisation
, 40–41

Professionalism

conceptualisations of
, 125–127

in FE contexts
, 69–70, 73, 75

Prompted monologue (PM)
, 160–161

Psychology
, 91–92

Pupils
, 88

Purposive sampling
, 145

Qualified Teacher Learning and Skills (QTLS)
, 125

Qualified teacher status (QTS)
, 15

Questioning
, 199

Questionnaires
, 72

Random controlled trials (RCT)
, 97–98

Reflective practice
, 142

Relationships
, 142

on forming an identity
, 149–150

Research engagement
, 197

Research ethics
, 159

Research Excellence Framework (REF)
, 3

Research methods
, 160

Researcher Concordat
, 2–3

Researching Educational Policy and Professional Identities (REPPI)
, 1

Richard Waller (RW)
, 1, 174

Risk takers
, 220

Schemas
, 179

School Direct (SD)
, 140

School leaders
, 88

Schools
, 106–107

Science
, 106

capital
, 107, 109

Science, Technology, Engineering and Maths (STEM)
, 112

Securitisation
, 233

Self-confidence
, 37–38

Self-esteem
, 37–38

Self-surveillance
, 215

Semi-structured interviews
, 235–236

Sensitive and controversial
, 210

Social class
, 195

Social constructivism
, 128

Social justice
, 193

Social mobility
, 193–194

Social practice theory model
, 109

Social space
, 109

Society for Education and Training (SET)
, 125

Society for Research into Higher Education (SRHE)
, 7

Somali-origin pupils
, 259

Special educational needs and disabilities (SEND)
, 13, 98

Special Educational Needs Co-ordinator (SENCo)
, 14

Special Educational Needs Code
, 12

Sports lecturers
, 74–75, 77

Staff development
, 122–123

Surveillance
, 214–215, 223, 225

Surveillance
, 231–233

Survey
, 235

Symbolic violence
, 48

embedded and contingent choosers
, 59–62

ethical considerations
, 52–53

methodological journey
, 50–52

participant data
, 54

sample
, 53

setting scene
, 48–49

society’s invisible force
, 55–57

teaching
, 57–59

theoretical framework
, 49

theorising marginal voices
, 53

Teacher expectation
, 192

Teacher judgement
, 94–95

Teacher professional identity
, 96

Teacher training
, 144–145

data analysis
, 147

ethical considerations
, 146–147

key findings and recommendations
, 147–152

literature review
, 141–143

methodology and methods
, 144–146

research questions
, 140–141

theoretical framing
, 143–144

Teachers
, 88, 210

activists
, 222–223

avoiders
, 221–222

categorisation of history teachers
, 213–214

containers
, 220–221

findings
, 217–218

literature review
, 210–211

methodology
, 215–217

National Curriculum for History
, 211, 218

Prevent Duty
, 212–213, 219

risk takers
, 220

surveillance
, 214–215, 223, 225

Teachers’ Standards
, 211–212, 218–219

Teachers’ Standards
, 210–212, 218–219

Teaching
, 88

as complex phenomena
, 91–93

doctoral study
, 88–90

education policy and simple view of teaching and learning
, 93–95

implications for teacher identity and development
, 95–97

lessons for doctoral students
, 101

sociograph graphic representation of small group interactions
, 89

strategies
, 199–200

‘what works’ mindset and allure of policy simplification
, 97–99

Thematic analysis
, 72–73, 147, 198, 216–217, 236–237

Third space
, 41–42

THRIVE
, 175

Tidy House, The (1982)
, 49

Top-down approach
, 124

Training
, 174–175

development and delivery of
, 179

route and impact on identity
, 149

style for mental and emotional health delivery
, 183–184

Transferability
, 180–181

Transformability
, 198

Transformational learning

action research
, 175–178

consolidatory focus group
, 179–180

context and FE challenge
, 174–175

development and delivery of training programmes
, 179

ethics and transferability
, 180–181

findings
, 181–182

literature review and rationale
, 175

pre-implementation fact-finding, problem formulation and action planning
, 178

pre-implementation trial of MHFA
, 178–179

recommendations for policy change
, 185–187

impact of research and reflection
, 187–188

research questions
, 177–178

study participants
, 177

Transformational learning theory (TLT)
, 176

Universal training
, 176, 185

University of the West of England (UWE)
, 1

Vertical surveillance
, 215

Visual aids
, 35–36

‘What works’ mindset
, 97–99

Working class students
, 195

Workload
, 148–149

Prelims
Chapter 1 Educational Policies and Professional Identities: Showcasing Lessons From Doctoral Practitioner Research
Section 1 Constructions of the Professional and Society
Chapter 2 Hierarchies of Professionalism in Interprofessional Partnerships for Inclusion: Mapping the Role and Professional Identities of Early Years Educators
Chapter 3 Professional Identity Within Changing Healthcare Roles: Exploring the Third or Hybrid Space
Chapter 4 The Impact of Symbolic Violence on the Perceived Choices of Trainee Primary School Teachers: A Poetic Perspective
Chapter 5 Further Education (FE) Sports Lecturer Professionalism: ‘Freedom to Play’, or ‘Do as I Say?’
Section 2 Interrogating Approaches to Becoming, Being and Developing as Education Professionals
Chapter 6 Teaching and Learning as Complex Phenomena: Implications for Policy and Teacher Professional Identity
Chapter 7 Mastering Professional Practices: Primary School Science Teacher Identity and Development
Chapter 8 Voices From the Staffroom: Impacts of Further Education Policy on CPD in the Sector
Chapter 9 Teacher Training in England: Exploring Trainee Teachers' Perspectives on Their Professional Identity Formation
Chapter 10 Convergence, Change, Consciousness and Confidence: The Impact of Initial Teacher Training Policy on Confident, Career Changing Practising Teachers
Section 3 Challenging Education Policy and Practice
Chapter 11 Changing the Narrative of Mental and Emotional Health Training in an FE Context: Explorations of Transformational Learning
Chapter 12 ‘It's Our Job to Take the Limits Away’: Exploring the Beliefs and Practices of High Expectation Teachers
Chapter 13 Context, Consciousness and Caution: Teachers of History in England and the Exploration of Sensitive and Controversial Issues in Practice
Chapter 14 Counter-Terrorism Measures in the Classroom: The Importance of Professionalism, Agency and Autonomy When Enacting the Prevent Duty
Chapter 15 Home Language Literacy Learning as an Extracurricular Activity by Pupils and Parents: Do the Findings Warrant a Case for Introducing Home Language Policy for Primary Education in England?
Chapter 16 Reviewing the Collection's Contribution and Value of Practice-Based Doctoral Studies
Index