We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 February 2009
1 Viscount, Snowden, An autobiography, Vol. II. 1919–1934 (London, 1934), pp. 1029–30.Google Scholar
2 Viscount, Samuel, Memoirs (London, 1945), p. 209.Google Scholar
3 Wilson, T., The downfall of the Liberal party, 1914–1935 (London, Fontana edn, 1968), p. 411.Google Scholar
4 Skidelsky, R., Politicians and the slump: the Labour government of 1929–1931 (London, 1967), p. 423.Google Scholar
5 Douglas, R., The history of the Liberal party, 1895–1970 (London, 1971), pp. 233–4.Google Scholar
6 Stannage, C. T., Baldwin thwarts the opposition: the British general election of 1935 (London, 1980), pp. 30–2, 38–40.Google Scholar
7 Dutton, D., ‘John Simon and the post-war National Liberal party: an historical postscript’, Historical Journal, XXXII, 2 (1989), 357.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
8 Dutton, D., Simon: a political biography of Sir John Simon (London, 1992), pp. 109–10.Google Scholar
9 Douglas, , Liberal party, p. 257.Google Scholar
10 Dutton, , Simon, p. 315.Google Scholar
11 For further comment on the backgrounds of these figures, see Douglas, , Liberal party, p. 212Google Scholar, and Wilson, , Downfall of the Liberal party, pp. 390–1.Google Scholar
12 Hore-Belisha diary, 26 June 1931, Churchill College Archives Centre, Cambridge, Hore-Belisha papers, 1/1.
13 Hore-Belisha diary, 29 June 1931, Hore-Belisha papers, 1/1.
14 SirGeoffrey, Shakespeare, Let candles be brought in (London, 1949), p. 136.Google Scholar
15 This was at the National Liberal Federation conference at Buxton in May 1931. See Liberal Magazine, XXXIX, no. 453 (1931), 268Google Scholar for a full report of proceedings.
16 Shakespeare, , Let candles be brought in, p. 138.Google Scholar
17 Hore-Belisha diary, 18 Sept. 1931, Churchill College Archives Centre, Cambridge, Hore-Belisha papers, 1/1.
18 Shakespeare, , Let candles be brought in, p. 138.Google Scholar
19 The Times, 5 Oct. 1931.
20 SirHenry, Morris-Jones, Doctor in the whips' room (London, 1955), p. 87.Google Scholar
21 SirMorris-Jones, H., ‘Westminster diary’, 11 Sept. 1931Google Scholar, Clwyd Record Office, Hawarden, Morris-Jones papers, D/MJ/10.
22 Sir H. Morris-Jones, General diaries, 4 Oct. 1932, Morris-Jones papers, D/MJ/13.
23 Runciman to Godfrey Collins, 1 Sept. 1931, Robinson Library, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Runciman papers, WR 245. ‘The Jews’ were Samuel and Lord Reading, foreign secretary in the first National government. The original telegrams between Samuel and Runciman, dated 25 Aug. and 3 Sept. 1931, are in the Runciman papers, WR 215.
24 Hore-Belisha to Simon, 5 Nov. 1931, Bodleian Library, Oxford, MS Simon 69, fos. 55–6.
25 Hutchison to Simon, 6 Nov. 1931, MS Simon 69, fo. 97.
26 Stannage, , Baldwin thwarts the opposition, p. 30.Google Scholar
27 Hutchison to Simon, 21 Nov. 1935, Bodleian Library, Oxford, MS Simon 83, fo. 29.
28 Shakespeare, , Let candles be brought in, p. 139.Google Scholar
29 Shakespeare, , Let candles be brought in, p. 141.Google Scholar
30 Shakespeare to Simon, 23 Sept. 1932, Bodleian Library, Oxford, MS Simon 73, fo. 79. Shakespeare sent a copy to Runciman, which is to be found in the Runciman papers, WR 254.
31 Hore-Belisha to Simon, 7 Sept. 1932, Bodleian Library, Oxford, MS Simon 73, fo. 50.
32 Shakespeare to Simon, 30 Sept. 1932, MS Simon 73, fos. 113–14; Hore-Belisha to D. Rowland Evans, 6 Oct. 1932, MS Simon 73, fo. 147.
33 Simon to Baldwin, 28 Sept. 1932 (copy), MS Simon 73, fos. 108–10; Baldwin to Simon, 26 Oct. 1932, MS Simon 73, fos. 200–1.
34 Simon to Hutchison, 30 Dec. 1932, MS Simon 75, fo. 60.
35 Morris-Jones, General diaries, 2 Jan. 1933, Clwyd Record Office, Hawarden, Morris-Jones papers, D/MJ/14.
36 Simon to P. Duff, 23 Nov. 1932, Bodleian Library, Oxford, MS Simon 74, fos. 92–3.
37 Simon to James Blindell, 23 Nov. 1932, MS Simon 74, fos. 94–5. Blindell was the chief whip of the Liberal National party.
38 Simon to Shakespeare, 12 Dec. 1932, MS Simon 75, fo. 1.
39 Edgar Granville to Simon, 14 Dec. 1932, MS Simon 75, fo. 12.
40 Dutton, , Simon, especially pp. 207–10.Google Scholar
41 See, for example, The political diaries of C. P. Scott, 1911–1928, ed. Wilson, T. (London, 1970), p. 436Google Scholar, diary entry for 29 Jan. 1923. For the view of a Conservative observer, see Chips: the diaries of Sir Henry Channon, ed. Rhodes James, R. (London, 1967), p. 341Google Scholar, diary entry for 9 Dec. 1940.
42 Morris-Jones, General diaries, 7 Apr. 1932, Clwyd Record Office, Hawarden, Morris-Jones papers, D/MJ/13. Runciman was another Liberal whom Morris-Jones preferred to Simon. In his memoirs he stated that Runciman ‘carried more weight amongst Liberals in the country than Simon’. See Morris-Jones, , Doctor, p. 96.Google Scholar
43 Morris-Jones, General diaries, 4 Jan. 1933, Clwyd Record Office, Hawarden, Morris-Jones papers, D/MJ/14.
44 Morris-Jones, General diaries, 5 June 1934, Morris-Jones papers, D/MJ/15.
45 Neville Chamberlain to Hilda Chamberlain, 22 May 1935, Birmingham University Library, Neville Chamberlain papers, NC 18/1/918, quoted in Cowling, M., The impact of Hitler: British politics and British policy, 1933–1940 (Cambridge, 1975), p. 33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
46 Simon diary, 28 May 1935, Bodleian Library, Oxford, MS Simon 7, fo. 31. Dutton, , Simon, pp. 221–2Google Scholar deals fully with Simon's fortunes in this reshuffle and the events leading up to it.
47 Hore-Belisha diary, 5 June 1935, Churchill College Archives Centre, Cambridge, Hore-Belisha papers, 1/2.
48 Hore-Belisha diary, 5 Mar. 1936, Hore-Belisha papers, 1/3.
49 Hore-Belisha diary, 7 Apr. 1936, Hore-Belisha papers, 1/3. Hore-Belisha was eventually given a cabinet seat in October of that year.
50 Shakespeare, , Let candles be brought in, p. 125.Google Scholar
51 Cleckheaton and Spenborough Guardian, 8 Nov. 1935.
52 ‘Report of the proceedings of the Liberal National convention, Central Hall, Westminster, 11 and 12 June 1936’, p. 49Google Scholar, Robinson Library, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Runciman papers, WR 279.
53 Liberal National Magazine, I, no. 4 (1 June 1936), 2–3, 5.Google Scholar
54 Liberal National Magazine, I, no. 6 (1 Aug. 1936), 49–50.Google Scholar
55 Stannage, , Baldwin thwarts the opposition, p. 217.Google Scholar
66 Liberal National Magazine, II, no. 3 (1 Jan. 1937), 165–8.Google Scholar
57 Liberal National Magazine, II, no. 4 (1 Mar. 1937), 271–5.Google Scholar
58 Mabane's outlook may have been influenced by the Samuelite leanings of the Huddersfield Liberal association. See Thorpe, A., The British general election of 1931 (Oxford, 1991), p. 176CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Many Liberal voters abstained in Huddersfield in the 1935 election. See Stannage, , Baldwin thwarts the opposition, p. 238.Google Scholar
59 Liberal National Magazine, II, no. 5 (1 Apr. 1937), 328, 330–1.Google Scholar
60 ‘Resolutions for the annual general meeting and conference of the Liberal National council, 24–25 June 1937’, pp. 4–5Google Scholar, Robinson Library, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Runciman papers, WR 279.
61 Manchester Guardian, 26 June 1937.
62 A copy of ‘Twenty Liberal National points of policy’ is to be found in the Runciman papers, WR 279.
63 This account is drawn from the Liberal Magazine, XLIV, no. 534 (Mar. 1938), 113–14.Google Scholar
64 ‘7 Mar. 1938. Re. Pamphlet “Twenty Liberal National points of policy”’, Robinson Library, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Runciman papers, WR 262.
65 Liberal National Magazine, new series, I, no. 1 (Oct. 1938), 15.Google Scholar
66 Liberal National Magazine, I, no. 3 (Dec. 1938), 146.Google Scholar
67 Liberal National Magazine, I, no. 4 (Jan. 1939), 226.Google Scholar
68 Liberal National Magazine, I, no. 7 (Apr. 1939), 428.Google Scholar
69 Cowling, , Impact of Hitler, p. 198, n. 115Google Scholar. Four of the other doubting ministers were Conservatives (Duff Cooper, Walter Elliot, Oliver Stanley, Earl Winterton) and the fifth was National Labour (Earl de la Warr).
70 The private papers of Hore-Belisha, ed. Minney, R. J. (London, 1960), p. 226Google Scholar. The other dissidents were Conservative (Elliot, Stanley, D. J. Colville, Sir Reginald Dorman-Smith, Euan Wallace), National Labour (de la Warr) and independent (Sir John Anderson).
71 Morris-Jones, General diaries, 10 Jan. 1940, Clwyd Record Office, Hawarden, Morris-Jones papers, D/MJ/21.
72 Morris-Jones, General diaries, 16 Jan. 1940, Morris-Jones papers, D/MJ/21. For Hore-Belisha's own bitterness towards Simon, see Crozier, W. P., Off the record: political interviews, 1993–1943, ed. Taylor, A. J. P. (London, 1973), pp. 130, 150.Google Scholar
73 Dutton, , Simon, p. 288.Google Scholar
74 Dutton, , Simon, pp. 292–3.Google Scholar
75 Morris-Jones, General diaries, 13 May 1940, Clwyd Record Office, Hawarden, Morris-Jones papers, D/MJ/21.
76 Morris-Jones, General diaries, 13 May 1940, Morris-Jones papers, D/MJ/21.
77 Middlemas, K., Politics in industrial society: the experience of the British system since 1911 (London, 1979). p. 328.Google Scholar
78 Cowling, , Impact of Hitler, p. 331Google Scholar. Hore-Belisha finally left the Liberal National party in February 1942. See Douglas, , Liberal party, p. 244.Google Scholar
