Abstract
Since encephalitis lethargica’s (EL) prevalence in the 1920s, epidemiologic and clinical debate has persisted over whether EL was caused by, potentiated by, or merely coincident with the Spanish influenza pandemic. Epidemiologic analyses generally suggest that the disorders were coincidental. Beginning in the 1970s, modern experiments on archival brain samples mainly failed to confirm a direct relationship between influenza and EL. These experimental studies have technical limitations, e.g., the appropriateness of antibodies, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) primers and controls, and the extreme paucity and age of available material. These factors render the case against influenza less decisive than currently perceived. Nevertheless, there is little direct evidence supporting influenza in the etiology of EL. Almost 100 years after the EL epidemic, its etiology remains enigmatic, raising the possibility of a recurrence of EL in a future influenza pandemic.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abrahamsen H, Steiniche T, Nexo E, Hamilton-Dutoit J, Sorensen B (2003). Towards quantitative mRNA analysis of paraffin embedded tissues using real-time reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction. J Mol Diagn 5: 34–41.
Barrachina M, Castano E and Ferrer I (2006). TaqMan PCR assay in the control of RNA normalization in human post-mortem brain tissue. Neurochem Int 49: 276–284.
Bartholoma NY, Forbes BA (1989). Successful use of shell vial centrifugation and 16 to 18-hour immunofluorescent staining for the detection of influenza A and B in clinical specimens. Am J Clin Pathol 92: 487–490.
Basler CF, Reid, AH, Dybing JK, Janczewski TA, Fanning TG, Zheng H, Salvatore M, Perdue ML, Swayne DE, Garcia-Sastre A, Palese P, Taubenberger JK (2001). Sequence of the 1918 pandemic influenza virus nonstructural gene (NS) segment and characterization of recombinant viruses bearing the 1918 NS genes. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 98: 2746–2751.
Beverly BI, Sherman M (1924). Post-encephalitic behavior disturbance without physical signs. Am J Dis Child 27: 565–568.
Cattaneo R, Schmid A, Billeter M, Sheppard R, Udem S (1988). Multiple viral mutations rather than host factors cause defective measles virus gene expression in a subacute sclerosing panencephalitis cell line. J Virol 62: 1388–1397.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2000). Update: Influenza activity—United States and world-wide, 1999–2000 season, and composition of the 2000–01 influenza vaccine. MMWR Morbid Mortal Wkly Rep 49: 375–381.
Dale R, Church A, Surtees A, Lees A, Adcock J, Harding B, Neville B, Giovannoni G (2004). Encephalitis lethargica syndrome: 20 new cases and evidence of basal ganglia autoimmunity. Brain 127: 21–33.
DeJong MD, Bach VC, Phan TQ, Vo MH, Tran TT, Nguyen BH, Beld M, Le TP, Truong HK, Nguyen Q (2005). Fatal avian influenza A (H5N1) in a child presenting with diarrhea followed by coma. N Engl J Med 352: 686–691.
Delorme L, Middleton PJ (1979). Influenza A virus associated with acute encephalopathy. Am J Dis Child 133: 822–824.
Duvoisin RC, Yahr MD (1965). Encephalitis and parkinsonism. Arch Neurol 12: 227–239.
Ebaugh, FG (1923). Neuropsychiatric sequelae of acute epidemic encephalitis in children. Am J Dis Child 25: 89–97.
Elizan TS, Casals J (1989). No viral antigens detected in brain tissue from a case of acute encephalitis lethargica and another case of post-encephalitic Parkinsonism. J Neurol Neurosurg Psych 52: 800–801.
Fearnley JM, Lees AJ (1991). Ageing and Parksinson’s disease: substantia nigra regional selectivity. Brain, 114: 2283–2301.
Flexner S (1923). Epidemic (lethargic) encephalitis and allied conditions. JAMA 81: 1688–1693, 1785–1789.
Francis T, Moore A (1940). A study of the neurotropic tendency in strains of the virus of epidemic influenza. JExp Med 72: 717–728.
Frankova V, Jirasek A (1974). Immunofluorescence demonstration of influenza A virus in human brains. Acta Virol 18: 444.
Gamboa ET, Wolf A, Yahr MD, Harter DH, Duffy PE, Barden H, Konrad CH (1974). Influenza virus antigen in postencephalitic parkinsonism brain. Arch Neurol, 31: 228–232.
Gavrilov V, Asher D, Vyalushkina S, Ratushkina L, Zmeiva R, Tumyan B (1972). Persistent infection of continuous line of pig kidney cells with a variant of the WSN strain of influenza Ao virus (36405). Proc Soc Exp Biol Med 1972 40: 109–117.
Hayase Y, Tobita K (1997). Influenza virus and neurological diseases. Psychiatry Clin Neurol 51: 181–184.
Hoehn MM, Yahr MD (1967). Parkinsonian onset, progression and mortality. Neurology 7: 427–442.
Hoult JG, Flewett TH (1958). Influenza encephalopathy and postinfluenza encephalitis. Lancet 2: 11–15.
Isocson S, Asher D, Gibbs C, Gajdusek D, Yahn M (1995). In situ RT-PCR detection of influenza viral RNA. Soc Neurosci Abstract 21: 1272.
Jenkins RL, Ackerson L (1934). The behavior of encephalitic children. Am J Orthopsychiatry 4: 499–507.
Johnson S, Morgan D, Finch C. (1986). Extensive postmortem stability of RNA from rat and human brain. J Neurosci Res 16: 267–280.
Jordon E (1927). Epidemic influenza: a survey. Chicago: American Medical Association.
Kash JC, Tumpey TM, Proll SC, Carter V, Perwitasari O, Thomas MJ, Basler CF, Palese P, Taubenberger JK, Garcia-Sastre A, Swayne DE (2006). Genomic analysis of increased host immune and cell death responses induced by 1918 influenza virus. Nature 443: 578–581.
Kobasa D, Jones SM, Shinya K, Kash JC, Copps J, Ebihara H, Hatta Y, Kim JH, Halfmann P, Hatta M, Feldmann F, Alimonti JB, Fernando L, Li Y, Katze M, Feldmann H, Kawaoka Y (2007). Aberrant innate immune response in lethal infection of macaques with the 1918 influenza virus. Nature 445: 319–323.
Krafft A, Duncan B, Bijwaard K, Taubenberger J, Lichy J (1997). Optimization of the isolation and amplification of RNA from formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue: the armed forces institute of pathology experience and literature review. Mol Diagn 2: 217–230.
Krafft AE, Russell KL, Hawksworth AW, McCall S, Irvine M, Daum LT, Connoly JL, Reid AH, Gaydos JC Taubenberger JK (2005). Evaluation of PCR testing of ethanol-fixed nasal swab specimens as an augmented surveillance strategy for influenza virus and adenovirus identification. J Clin Micro 3: 1768–1775.
Kramer PH (1924). Clinical and epidemiological study of encephalitis. Geneeskundige bladen uit kliniek en laboratorium voor de praktijk 24: 1–40.
Krasner-Khait B (2000). The impact of refrigeration. History Magazine February–March.
Laing P, Knight JG, Hill JM, Harris AG, Oxford JS, Webster RG, Markwell MAK, Paul SM, Pert CB (1989). Influenza viruses induce autoantibodies to a brain-specific 37-kDa protain in rabbit. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 86: 1998–2002.
Lee SH, Boutilier JE, MacDonald MA, Forward KR (1992). Enhanced detection of respiratory viruses using the shell vial technique and monoclonal antibodies. J Virol Methods 39: 39–46.
Li S, Schulman J, Itamura S, Palese P (1993). Glycosylation of neuraminidase determines the neurovirulence of influenza A/WSN/33 virus. Virology 67: 6667–6673
Litvan I, Jankovic J, Goetz C, Wenning G, Sastry N, Jellinger K, McKee A, Lai E, Brandel JP, Verny M, Ray-Chaudhuri K, Pearce R, Bartko J, Agid Y (1998). Accuracy of the clinical diagnosis of postencephalitic parkinsonism: a clinicopathologic study. Euro J Neurol 5: 451–457.
Lo KC, Geddes JF, Daniels RS, Oxford JS (2003). Lack of detection of influenza genes in archived formalin-fixed, paraffin wax-embedded brain samples of encephalitis lethargica patients from 1916 to 1920. Virchows Arch, 442: 591–596.
Masurel N, Heijtink R (1983). Recycling of H1N1 influenz A virus in man—a haemagglutinin antibody study. J Hyg Camb 90: 397–402.
Marttila RJ, Arstila P, Nikoskelaninen J, Halonen PE, Rinne UK (1977a). Viral antibodies in the sera from patients with Parkinson disease. Eur Neurol 15: 25–33.
Marttila RJ, Haloene P, Rinne UK (1977b). Influenza virus antibodies in Parkinsonism. Arch Neurol 34: 99–100.
Maurizi CP (1989). Influenza caused epidemic encephalitis (encephalitis lethargica): the circumstantial evidence and a challenge to the naysayers. Med Hypoth 28: 139–42.
McCall S, Henry JM, Reid AH, Taubenberger JK (2001). Influenza RNA not detected in archival brain tissues from acute encephalitis lethargica cases or in postencephalitic Parkinson cases. J Neuropathol Exp Neurol 60: 696–704.
Mizuguchi M, Abe J, Mikkaichi K, Noma S, Yoshida K, Yamanaka T, Kamoshita S (1995). Acute necrotizing encephalopathy of childhood: a new syndrome presenting with multifocal, symmetric brain lesions. J Neurol. Neurosurg Psychiatry 58: 555–651.
Mizuguchi M, Yamanouchi H, Ichiyama T, Shiomi M (2007). Acute encephalopathy associated with influenza and other viral infections. Acta Neurol Scand Suppl186: 45–56.
Neal JB (1920). Epidemic or lethargic encephalitis in children. Arch Ped 37: 321–337.
Oxford JS (2000). Influenza A pandemics of the 20th century with special reference to 1918: virology, pathology and epidemiology. Rev Med Virol 10: 119–133.
Polage CR, Petti CA (2006). Assessment of the utility of viral culture of cerebrospinal fluid. Clin Infect Dis 43: 1578–1579.
Ravenholt RT, Foege WH (1982). 1918 influenza, encephalitis, parkinsonism. Lancet 2: 860–864.
Reid AH, Fanning TG, Hultin JV, Taubenberger JK (1999). Origin and evolution of the 1918 “Spanish” influenza virus hemagglutinin gene. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 96: 1651–1656.
Reid AH, Fanning TG, Janczewski TA, Lourens, RM, Taubenberger JK (2004). Novel origin of the 1918 pandemic influenza virus nucleoprotein gene. J Virol 78: 12462–12470.
Reid AH, Fanning TG, Janczewski TA, McCall S, Taubenberger JK (2002). Characterization of the 1918 “Spanish” influenza virus matrix gene segment. J Virol 76: 10717–10723.
Reid AH, Fanning TG, Janczewski TA, Taubenberger JK (2000). Characterization of the 1918 “Spanish” influenza virus neuraminidase gene. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 97: 6785–6790.
Reid AH, Fanning TG, Slemons RD, Janczewski TA, Dean J, Taubenberger JK (2003a). Relationship of pre-1918 avian influenza HA and NP sequences to subsequent avian influenza strains. Avian Dis 47(3 Suppl) 921–925.
Reid AH, Janczewski TA, Lourens RM, Elliot, AJ, Daniels RS, Berry CL, Oxford JS, Taubenberger JK (2003b). 1918 influenza pandemic caused by highly conserved viruses with two receptor-binding variants. Emerg Infect Dis 9: 1249–1253.
Reid AH, McCall S, Henry JM, Taubenberger JK (2001). Experimenting on the past: the enigma of von Economo’s encephalitis lethargica. J Neuropathol Exp Neurol 60: 663–670.
Reinacher M, Bonin J, Narayan O, Scholtissek C (1983). Pathogenesis of neurovirulent influenza A ivVirus infection in mice: route of entry of virus into brain determines infection of different populations of cells. Lab Invest 49: 686–692.
Rekart M, Rupnik K, Cesario T, Tilles J (1982). Prevalence of hemagglutination inhibition antibody to current strains of the H3N2 and H1N1 subtypes of influenza A virus in sera collected from the elderly in 1976. Am J Epidemiol 115: 587–597.
Richman DD, Murphy BR, Baron S, Uhlendorf C (1976). Three strains of influenza A virus (H3N2): Interferon sensitivity in vitro and interferon production in volunteers. J Clin Microbiol 3: 223–226.
Ruest A, Michaud S, Deslandes S, Frost E (2003). Comparison of the Directigen flu A + B test, the QuickVue influenza test, and clinical case definition to viral culture and reverse transcription-PCR for rapid diagnosis of influenza virus infection. J Clin Microbiol 41: 3487–4393.
Schramm M, Falkai P, Tepest R, Schneider-Axmann T, Przkora R, Waha A, Pietsch T, Bonte W, Bayer T (1999). Stability of RNA transcripts in post-mortem psychiatric brains. J Neural Transm 106: 329–335.
Shinya K, Shimada A, Ito T, Otsuki K, Morita T, Tanaka H, Takada A, Kida H, Umemura T (2000). Avian influenza virus intranasally inoculated infects the central nervous system of mice through the general visceral afferent nerve. Arch Virol 145: 187–195.
Smolinski D, Leverkoehne I, Samson-Himmelstjerna G and Gruber A (2005). Impact of formalin-fixation and paraffin-embedding on the ratio between mRNA copy numbers of differently expressed genes. Histochem Cell Biol 124: 177–188.
Stuart-Harris C. A neurotropic strain of human influenza virus (1939). Lancet 1: 497–499.
Stuart-Harris C, Schild G (1976). Influenza: the viruses and the disease. Littleton, MA: Publishing Sciences Group.
Symonds CP (1921). Critical review: encephalitis lethargica. Quart J Med 14: 283–308.
Takahashi M, Yamada T (1999). Viral etiology for Parkinson’s disease—a possible role of influenza A virus infection. Japanese J Infect Dis 52: 89–98.
Taubenberger J (2006). The origin and virulence of the 1918 “Spanish” influenza virus. Proc Am Philosophical Soc 150: 86–112.
Taubenberger J, Layne S (2001). Diagnosis of influenza virus: coming to grips with the molecular era. Mol Diagn 2001 6: 291–305.
Taubenberger J, Reid A, Lourens R, Wang R, Jin G, Fanning TG (2005). Characterization of the 1918 influenza virus polymerase genes. Nature 437: 889–893.
Taubenberger JK, Reid AH (2002). The 1918 ‘Spanish’ influenza pandemic and characterization of the virus that caused it. Influenza, 101–122.
Taubenberger JK, Reid AH, Krafft AE, Bijwaard KE, Fanning TG (1997). Initial genetic characterization of the 1918 “Spanish” influenza virus. Science 275: 1793–1796.
Timme W, Bailey P, Barker LF, Brown S, Dana CL, Hunt JR, Kennedy F, Kirby GH, Patrick HT, Sachs B, Spiller WG, Strauss, I, Taylor EW, Tilney F, Weisenburg TH (1921). Acute epidemic encephalitis (lethargic encephalitis). New York: Hoeber.
Tumpey TM, Basler CF, Aguilar PV, Zeng H, Solorzano A, Swayne DE, Cox NJ, Katz JM, Taubenberger JK, Palese P, Garcia-Sastre A (2005). Characterization of the reconstructed 1918 Spanish influenza pandemic virus. Science 310: 77–80.
Tumpey TM, Garcia-Sastre A, Taubenberger, JK, Palese P, Swayne DE, Basler, CE (2004). Pathogenicity and immunogenicity of influenza viruses with genes from the 1918 pandemic virus. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 101: 3166–3171.
Tyrell DJA (1959). Interferon produced by cultures of calf kidney cells. Nature 184: 452–453.
Vilensky JA, Gilman S (2006). Encephalitis lethargica: could this disease be recognised if the epidemic recurred? Pract Neurol 6: 360–367.
Vilensky JA, Mukhamedzyanov RZ, Gilman S (2008). Encephalitis lethargica in the Soviet Union. Eur Neurol in press.
Vincent A (2004). Encephalitis lethargica: part of a spectrum of post-streptococcal autoimmune disease? Brain 127: 2–3.
von Economo C (1917). Encephalitis lethargica. Wien Klin Wochr, 30, 581–585. (Translated in Wilkins RH, Brody IA [1968] Arch Neurol 18: 324–328.
von Economo C (1931). Encephalitis lethargica: its sequelae and treatment (translated by K.O. Newman). London: Oxford University Press.
Washington Post (1929) Morgue Room at Gallinger Held Disgrace. 18 August, p M12.
Weitkamp J, Spring M, Brogan T, Moses H, Bloch K, Wright P (2004). Influenza A virus-associated acute necrotizing encephalopathy in the United States. Pediatr Infect Dis J 23: 259–263.
Wilkinson P, Borland R (1972). Persistent infection of human lung cells in influenza virus. Nature 238: 153–155.
Wilson-Smith WA (1920). Arsenic in lethargic encephalitis. BMJ 1: 655.
Wright P, Neumann G, Kawaoka Y (2006). Orthomyxoviruses. In: Fields virology, 5th ed. Philadelphia: Wolter Kluwer/Lippincott Williams and Wilkins, pp 1691–1740.
Yasojima K, McGeer E, McGeer P (2001). High stability of mRNAs postmortem and protocols for their assessment by RT-PCR. Brain Res Protocols 8: 212–218.
Zambon M, Hays J, Webster A, Newman R, Oliver K (2001). Diagnosis of influenza in the community. Arch Intern Med 161: 2116–2122.
Zitterkopf NL, Leekha S, Espy MJ, Wood CM, Sampathkumar P, Smith TF (2006). Relevance of influenza A virus detection by PCR, shell vial assay, and tube cell culture to rapid reporting procedures. JClin Microbiol 44: 3366–3367.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This research was also partially supported by the Intramural Research Program of the NIH and the NIAID (to J.K.T.).
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
McCall, S., Vilensky, J.A., Gilman, S. et al. The relationship between encephalitis lethargica and influenza: A critical analysis. Journal of NeuroVirology 14, 177–185 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1080/13550280801995445
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13550280801995445