https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1914-6144
Figures
Abstract
Introduction
Modern health services utilization in developing countries has continued low. Financial shortage to access health-care services might be averted by stirring from out-of-pocket payment for health care at the time of use. The government of Ethiopia; depend greatly on foreign aid (50%) and out-of-pocket payments (34%) to fund health services for its population. This study was aimed to identify factors associated with households’ enrollment to CBHI scheme membership.
Methods
Case-control study design was conducted from May 18–July 27, 2019 among 332 participants (166 enrolled and 166 non-enrolled to CBHI scheme). Simple random sampling technique was used to select the study participants. Bi-variable and multivariable logistic regression model were fitted to identify factors associated with enrollment to community based health insurance. Adjusted odds ratio (AOR) with 95% CI was used to report association and significance was declared at P<0.05.
Result
A total of 332 (100% response rate) were involved in the study. Educational status (College and above, AOR = 3.90, 95%CI; 1.19, 12.75), good awareness about CBHI scheme (AOR = 21.595, 95% CI; 7.561, 61.681), affordability of premium payment (AOR = 3.403, 95% CI; 5.638–4.152), wealth index {(Poor, AOR = 2.59, 95%CI; 1.08, 6.20), (Middle, AOR = 4.13, 95%CI; 1.11, 15.32)} perceived health status (AOR = 5.536; 95% CI; 1.403–21.845), perceived quality of care (AOR: 21.014 95%CI; 4.178, 105.686) and treatment choice (AOR = 2.94, 95%CI; 1.47, 5.87) were factors significantly associated with enrollment to CBHI.
Conclusion
Enrolment to CBHI schemes is influenced by educational level, awareness level, affordability of premium, wealth index, perceived health status, perceived quality of care and treatment choice. Implementation strategies aimed at raising community awareness, setting affordable premium, and providing quality healthcare would help in increasing enrollment of all eligible community groups to the CBHI scheme.
Citation: Fite MB, Roba KT, Merga BT, Tefera BN, Beha GA, Gurmessa TT (2021) Factors associated with enrollment for community-based health insurance scheme in Western Ethiopia: Case-control study. PLoS ONE 16(6): e0252303. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0252303
Editor: Ramesh Kumar, Health Services Academy Islamabad Pakistan, PAKISTAN
Received: October 17, 2020; Accepted: May 13, 2021; Published: June 10, 2021
Copyright: © 2021 Fite et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper.
Funding: The authors received no specific funding for this work.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Abbreviations: CBHI, Community-Based Health Insurance; EDHS, Ethiopian Demographic and Health Survey; WHO, World Health Organization
Introduction
The 2030 Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) emphasizes ensuring all peoples’ access to quality healthcare services without financial hardship [1]. Modern health services utilization in developing countries has continued to be low. These countries have insufficient access to and utilization of modern health care services due to shortage of finance [2]. Worldwide, yearly estimation shows that 44 million household’s face disastrous healthcare expenses, whereas 25 million households are unplanned because of direct health care payments [3]. Financial shortage to access health-care services might be averted by moving from out-of-pocket payment (OOP). Community-Based Health Insurance (CBHI) is a platform accomplished and functioned by a community-based organization, exclusive of government or a private for-profit company, that offers risk-pooling to cover the expenses of health care services [4].
A number of counties have contained Community-Based health insurance as part of general health financing strategy [5].Underprivileged people are excluded from formal insurance system in most of developing countries. Hence, recently a plenty of assessment have made suggestion on possible of community health insurance in escalation access to care and deal financial shield alongside the expenses of illness for these Underprivileged people [6].
Ethiopia is the second largest county, next to Nigeria in terms of population size in Africa. However the country ranks low in access to modern healthcare services compared to African countries [7]. Even though Ethiopia has been implementing the primary health-care approach since mid-1970s, the country was quietly continued with a basic challenge comprised: insufficient coverage of services, disproportion of access, inadequate quality of care, and high out-of-pocket expenditure [8].
In Ethiopia, CBHI scheme have been introduced to reduce the financial shock due to unexpected and irregular out-of-pocket payments and to increase the resource pooling for healthcare that would improve access and utilizations of health services [9,10]. The government of Ethiopia depend greatly on outdoor supporters (50%) and out-of-pocket payments (34%) to fund health services for its population [10,11].
Given the significant importance of community based health insurance in improving access to and utilization of healthcare service, in 2016 only 5% of Ethiopian were enrolled for CBHI schemes membership [12]. Having information on the determinants of enrollment into the CBHI scheme would help in devising strategies that promote communities’ enrollment into the CBHI scheme. Hence, this study aimed at assessing determinants of enrollment into CBHI scheme membership.
Methods
Study design, period and study setting
Case-control study was conducted from May 18–July 27, 2019 in Gida Ayana district. Gida Ayana is one of the districts in east Wollega Zone, Oromia regional state, Western Ethiopia. Ayana town is the administrative town of the District which is located 110 km from Nekemte (the Zonal capital), 443 km from Addis Ababa. Administratively, the district is divided into 7 urban Kebeles and 24 rural kebeles. The district has 145,712 populations of which 106,038(72.772%) were living in rural areas and directly engaged in agriculture. There are 3 government health centers, 23 governmental health post and six private health facilities in the district. According to the District CBHI scheme office there were an estimated 30,357 households in the District among this, 14670(48.3%) households were enrolled in CBHI [13].
Source population and study population
Households who were resided for at least six month in Gida Ayana district during the study period were source population and selected households from 6 kebeles were study population. Household heads employed in formal sector and or covered by other insurance scheme for health and unable to communicate (Critically ill) during data collection were excluded from the study
Sample size determination, sampling procedure and technique
The sample size was estimated by using Epi info, version 7.0. Similar study conducted in Achefer District, North- West, Ethiopia: P1 = 35%, P2 = 20% CBHI non-member and member households respectively [14], with the following assumptions: 80% statistical power with a level of significance at 95%, insured to uninsured ratio of 1:1 and 10% non-response rate was used. Accordingly, total a total sample size of 332 household s was calculated (166 members and 166 non-members).
The study participants were drawn using a multi-stage sampling technique. In the first stage, six Kebeles were selected randomly (lottery method) out of thirty one kebeles considering the representativeness of the kebeles. The second stage involved the selection of households from six kebeles. List of households for cases (enrolled) and controls (non-enrolled) obtained from each kebele’s administration household record list which was used as a sampling frame. The sample size was proportionally allocated for selected kebeles based on each kebele’s number of households. Then simple random sampling (lottery method) was employed to select the cases and controls by taking their list as a frame and labeling continuous numbering.
Data collection tools and techniques
Data were collected using a structured interviewer administered questionnaire which is adapted from Ethiopian Demographic and Health Survey [12]. The questionnaire contains: Socio-demographic characteristics, health care access-related factors and Health perception and health-care needs variables. The questionnaire was prepared first in English and it was translated in to local language (Afaan Oromo) and back to English to check for its consistency. Four BSc nurses and 2 Public Health officers were involved for data collection and supervision respectively. The supervisors were recruited to check daily for the completeness, clarity and consistency of the questionnaire and to give appropriate support during the data collection process.
Data quality assurance
Two day training was given for each data collectors and supervisors. The training was also emphasized on the importance of the privacy and confidentiality of respondents. Regular supervision was given during data collection. Collected data was checked by supervisors before sent to the data entree on daily basis. Data collection material was pretested in 10% using similar set up at Kiramu district. To ensure the quality of data, collected data were evaluated daily for completeness and consistency.
Data processing and analysis
Data were cleaned and edited after entering into Epi data version 5.3.1 and then exported to SPSS version 20 for analysis. Descriptive statistics were computed and presented using frequencies, proportions, summary statistics, graphs and tables. Variables that have P-value < 0.25 on bivariate analyses were entered in the multivariate logistic regression model to identify independent predictors of enrollment into CBHI. P<0.05 was considered as statistically significant. The strength of association and precision were examined using adjusted odds ratio at 95% confidence interval. The model fitness was checked by Hosmer and Lemeshow goodness of fit test.
Ethical consideration
Ethical approval was secured from Santé Medical College (SMC), department of public health. A formal letter written from the university was submitted to CBHI Gida Ayana District health offices and the District administration offices to obtain their co-operation. Then support letter was written to each selected Kebeles. The purpose of the study was described to the study participants. All study participants were also informed about their right of not participating in the study at any time and written informed consent was obtained from the study participants. Privacy and confidentiality of collected information was assured.
Result
Socio-demographic characteristics
A total of 332 Households’ heads were looked over in this study; and the study response rate was 100%. Household’s socio-demographic characteristic by current CBHI scheme is described in (Table 1). Majority of households’ heads were male both in CBHI member s130 (78.3%) and non- members134 (80.7%). Regarding the marital status of the respondents most of households head were married in both CBHI member 154 (92.8%) and non-members 157(94.5%). More than half of households have 4–6 f family size both in CBHI members 104(62.7%) and non- member 86(51.8%). Greater proportion of sample households were protest region follower both in CBHI member 52(31.37%) and non-member 47(28.3%). Moreover, concerning occupational status, more than half of household’s head who are farmers; comprising 52(31.3%) and 113(68.1%) both in CBHI scheme members and non- members respectively.
Factors affecting enrolment for CBHI schemes membership
In the Bivariable analysis variables that were found be significant at p-value <0.25 with 95% CI selected were fitted for further analysis in multivariable logistics regression model to control confounders and to ascertain the effect of each independent variables on the likelihood of CBHI enrolment. A final multivariable logistic regression analysis was performed to assess the impact of a number of factors on the likelihood that household heads to enroll in CBHI.
Multivariable binary logistic regression model indicate respondents who had college and above education level were 3.90 times more likely to be enrolled into CBHI scheme compared to those with no education (AOR = 3.90, 95%CI; 1.19, 12.75).
Respondents with good awareness level on CBHI scheme membership were 4.74 times more likely to be enrolled for CBHI compared to those with poor awareness level (AOR = 4.74, 95% CI; 2.50, 8.99). Respondents who perceived premium of payment for CBHI as cheap were found to be 5.82 times more likely to be enrolled CBHI scheme membership compared to those who perceived premium of payment for CBHI as expensive (AOR = 5.82, 95% CI; 2.49, 13.60).
Households from poor and middle wealth index were more likely to be enrolled into CBHI compared to those from rich wealth index ((Poor, AOR = 2.59, 95%CI; 1.08, 6.20), (Middle, AOR = 4.13, 95%CI; 1.11, 15.32)).
Respondents who perceived their own health status as good during data collection were found to be 5.58 times more likely enrolled for CBHI scheme membership compared to those perceived as poor their own health status (AOR: 5.58, 95%CI: 2.87, 10.87).
Respondents who perceived high quality of care were found to be 8.37 times more likely enrolled in CBHI scheme membership compared to those perceived low quality of care (AOR = 8.37; 95% CI; 3.62, 19.38). Households whose treatment choice modern healthcare were 2.94 times more likely to be enrolled compared to those who treatment choice was traditional/home healing (AOR = 2.94, 95%CI; 1.47, 5.87) (Table 2).
Discussion
This study identified factors affecting enrollment into CBHI scheme membership in Gida Ayana district. Educational status, awareness about CBHI, affordability of premium payment, wealth index, perceived health status, perceived quality of care, and treatment choice were independent determinants of CBHI enrollment.
Having a college and above level of education was positively associated with enrollment into CBHI schemes. This finding is in agreement with studies conducted in western Ethiopia and Senegal [15,16]. This could be because an educated people might understand the CBHI scheme principles, and benefit packages. The study revealed that respondents who had good awareness level on CBHI scheme were more likely to be enrolled into CBHI compared to those with poor awareness level. The finding is consistent with study conducted in Nigeria [17], Ethiopia [18]. This may be due to the fact that individuals with better information may ask details of the services and get more understandings of its advantage that drives them to be enrolled in CBHI. This implies that raising community awareness may help in the successful implementation of the scheme.
Affordability of premium for CBHI was found to be significantly associated with enrollment into CBHI schemes. This result is highly supported by evidence investigated in Ghana [19] and Mali [20]. Concurrently, finding of study conducted in North West Ethiopia [18], documented households who perceived amount of premium payment as affordable were more likely to enroll into CBHI. In Ethiopia [21], premium was collected from household for CBHI scheme membership at pre-defined fixed amount that is equal amount of money was charged to each household deprived of taking into account the capacity and features of the households including wealth or demographic factors. Hence, this might limit the enrollment of households for CBHI scheme membership.
The study revealed that households with poor and middle wealth index were more likely enroll into CBHI scheme compared to the rich wealth index. This result is supported by studies conducted in Ethiopia [22,23]. This might be explained by the target of CBHI scheme which mainly is increasing healthcare access of citizens recruited at informal sectors, and as a result the relative low premium payment [22].
Perceived quality of healthcare services is found to be factors significantly associated with enrollment into CBHI scheme. This finding is consistent with evidences from northwest Ethiopia and Nigeria [24,25]. This may be justified by, services with standard quality may attract more customers to utilize and enjoy the services. The same is true for CBHI scheme, the more the society perceive the quality of health services as good the more they will enroll into the scheme. Some studies report the same findings that support this study
Respondents who perceived their health status as poor had more probability of CBHI enrollment compared to those who claimed their health status as very good. And this may be justified as; household heads with perceived poor health status may believe on the importance of health service hence leading to health insurance enrollment. This finding is supported by other studies conducted in Bangladesh [26] and Mumbai [27].
Households whose treatment choice was modern healthcare had higher odds of enrollment into CBHI scheme as compared to those whose treatment choice was traditional or home healing. Similarly different studies revealed that those whose prefer modern healthcare as their first treatment choice utilize health service than those who prefer traditional healers [28]. Uninsured households refrain from facilities based healthcare (hospital, health center) and might increase attendance for traditional healer given lower service cost of healings and transportation compared to healthcare facilities did [29].
Conclusion
The study identified factors associated with enrollment to CBHI scheme memberships. Enrollment to CBHI schemes is influenced by educational status, awareness level, affordability of premium, wealth status, perceived health status, perceived quality of care and treatment choice. Implementation strategies aimed at raising community awareness on the premium, its principle, and benefits packages of CBHI membership should be given a due emphasis to attract more eligible community groups. Affordability of the premium determines the decision to enroll and renewal of the membership, therefore, setting affordable premium would help in successful enrollment of all eligible community groups to the CBHI scheme. Provision of quality healthcare would also be a focus of program implementers to increase enrollment CBHI scheme. To have more insight on sociocultural determinants of enrollment into CBHI, the prospective researchers would consider both qualitative and quantitative research that involve broad geographic areas and with large sample size.
Acknowledgments
Our special gratitude goes Gida Ayana district health office and kebele administrators for granted permission for data collection. Special thanks to data collectors and study participants involved in the study.
References
- 1.
Organization W.H., Primary health care on the road to universal health coverage: 2019 monitoring report: Executive summary. 2019, World Health Organization.
- 2. Garg C.C. and Karan A.K., Reducing out-of-pocket expenditures to reduce poverty: a disaggregated analysis at rural-urban and state level in India. Health policy and planning, 2009. 24(2): p. 116–128. pmid:19095685
- 3. Binnendijk E., et al., Estimating Willingness-to-Pay for health insurance among rural poor in India by reference to Engel’s law. Social science & medicine, 2013. 76: p. 67–73. pmid:23157931
- 4. Jütting J.P., Do community-based health insurance schemes improve poor people’s access to health care? Evidence from rural Senegal. World development, 2004. 32(2): p. 273–288.
- 5.
Wang H., et al., Health insurance handbook: how to make it work. Vol. 219. 2012: World Bank Publications.
- 6. De Allegri M., et al., Community health insurance in sub‐Saharan Africa: what operational difficulties hamper its successful development? Tropical Medicine & International Health, 2009. 14(5): p. 586–596. pmid:19389037
- 7. Organization W.H., World health statistics 2019: monitoring health for the SDGs, sustainable development goals. 2019.
- 8. Assefa Y., et al., Primary health care contributions to universal health coverage, Ethiopia. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2020. 98(12): p. 894. pmid:33293750
- 9.
FDRE, M.o.H., Ethiopia’s Fifth National Health Accounts Highlight of Major Findings Briefing Notes. 2014: Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. p. 28.
- 10.
Berman P., Mann C., and Ricculli M., Financing Ethiopia’s Primary Care to 2035: A Model Projecting Resource Mobilization and Costs. Boston, Massachusetts: Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health, 2015.
- 11. Bank W., World Development Indicators 2014: Washington DC.
- 12.
Central Statistical Agency, E., Ethiopia Demographic and Health Survey 2016. 2016, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, and Rockville, Maryland, USA: CSA and ICF. 551.
- 13. Ayana G., Gida Ayana district Health office reprort. 2019.
- 14. Atnafu D.D., Tilahun H., and Alemu Y.M., Community-based health insurance and healthcare service utilisation, North-West, Ethiopia: a comparative, cross-sectional study. BMJ open, 2018. 8(8): p. e019613. pmid:30093509
- 15. Jütting J., Health insurance for the poor?: determinants of participation in community-based health insurance schemes in rural Senegal. 2003.
- 16. Negash B., Dessie Y., and Gobena T., Community Based Health Insurance Utilization and Associated Factors among Informal Workers in Gida Ayana District, Oromia Region, West Ethiopia. East African Journal of Health and Biomedical Sciences, 2019. 3(2): p. 13–22.
- 17. Ogben C. and Ilesanmi O., Community based health insurance scheme: Preferences of rural dwellers of the federal capital territory Abuja, Nigeria. Journal of public health in Africa, 2018. 9(1). pmid:30079158
- 18. Taddesse G., et al., Determinants of enrollment decision in the community-based health insurance, North West Ethiopia: a case-control study. Globalization and health, 2020. 16(1): p. 1–9. pmid:31898532
- 19. Kusi A., et al., Refusal to enrol in Ghana’s National Health Insurance Scheme: is affordability the problem? International journal for equity in health, 2015. 14(1): p. 1–14. pmid:25595036
- 20. Adebayo E.F., et al., A systematic review of factors that affect uptake of community-based health insurance in low-income and middle-income countries. BMC health services research, 2015. 15(1): p. 1–13. pmid:26645355
- 21. De Allegri M., et al., Step-wedge cluster-randomised community-based trials: an application to the study of the impact of community health insurance. Health Research Policy and Systems, 2008. 6(1): p. 1–8.
- 22.
Derseh A., et al., Enrolment in Ethiopia’s Community Based Health Insurance Scheme. 2013, International Institute of Social Studies of Erasmus University (ISS). p. 1–35. https://doi.org/10.1309/AJCPU1PLVOIN5JQI pmid:23955450
- 23.
Kado A., et al., Willingness to Pay for Community-Based Health Insurance Scheme and Associated Factors Among Rural Communities in Gemmachis District, Eastern Ethiopia. Clinicoeconomics and Outcomes Research: CEOR, 2020. 12: p. 609.
- 24.
Fonta W.M., Ichoku H.E., and Ataguba J.E., Paying for community-based health insurance schemes in rural Nigeria: the use of in-kind payments. African review of money finance and banking, 2010: p. 109–128.
- 25. Mirach T.H., Demissie G.D., and Biks G.A., Determinants of community-based health insurance implementation in west Gojjam zone, Northwest Ethiopia: a community based cross sectional study design. BMC health services research, 2019. 19(1): p. 1–8. pmid:30606168
- 26. Ahmed S., et al., Willingness-to-pay for community-based health insurance among informal workers in urban Bangladesh. PloS one, 2016. 11(2). pmid:26828935
- 27. Ghosh S. and Mondal S., Morbidity, health expenditure and willingness to pay for health insurance amongst the urban poor: A case study. Journal of Health Management, 2011. 13(4): p. 419–437.
- 28. Tilahun H., et al., Factors for healthcare utilization and effect of mutual health insurance on healthcare utilization in rural communities of South Achefer Woreda, North West, Ethiopia. Health economics review, 2018. 8(1): p. 1–7. pmid:29340855
- 29. De Allegri M., et al., Understanding consumers’ preferences and decision to enrol in community-based health insurance in rural West Africa. Health policy, 2006. 76(1): p. 58–71. pmid:15946762