Abstract
Attempts to explore empirically the link between HRM and firm performance are numerous. Yet, research on this link remains restricted to large companies. Little is known about the extent to which the existing results extend to small businesses. The purpose of the present study is to develop and test a conceptual framework linking HRM to financial performance that fits small businesses. The central question is whether the development of an intensive HRM is profitable for smaller organizations. For the development and optimization of the conceptual framework, we rely on human capital theory and bankruptcy prediction models. Using structural equation modeling, we study the mediating effect of voluntary turnover and productivity on the relationship between HRM intensity and one year lagged financial performance. The results show both productivity and profitability enhancing effects as well as a cost increasing impact of HRM intensity.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Daron Acemoglu Jörn-Steffen Pischke (1998) ArticleTitle‘Why do Firms Train? Theory and Evidence’ Quarterly Journal of Economics 113 IssueID1 79–120 Occurrence Handle10.1162/003355398555531
John T. Addison W. Stanley Siebert Joachim Wagner Xiangdong Wei (2000) ArticleTitle‘Worker Participation and Firm Performance: Evidence from Germany and Britain’ British Journal of Industrial Relations 38 IssueID1 7–48 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-8543.00150
Howard Aldrich Ellen Auster (1986) ‘Even Dwarfs Started Small: Liabilities of Age and Size and their Strategic Implications’ Barry M. Staw Larry L. Cummings (Eds) Research in organizational behaviour JAI Press Greenwich
Sita C. Amba-Rao Dilip Pendse (1985) ArticleTitle‘Human Resource Compensation and Maintenance Practices’ American Journal of Small Business 10 IssueID2 19–29
Jeffrey B. Arthur (1994) ArticleTitle‘Effects of Human Resource Systems on Manufacturing Performance and Turnover’ Academy of Management Journal 37 IssueID3 670–687
Nicolas Bacon Peter Ackers John Storey David Coates (1996) ArticleTitle‘It’s a Small World: Managing Human Resources in Small Business’ International Journal of Human Resource Management 7 IssueID1 82–100
Johngseok Bae John J. Lawler (2000) ArticleTitle‘Organizational and HRM Strategies in Korea: Impact on Firm Performance in an Emerging Economy’ Academy of Management Journal 43 IssueID3 502–517
Ann P. Bartel (1994) ArticleTitle‘Productivity Gains from the Implementation of Employee Training Programs’ Industrial Relations 33 IssueID4 411–425
Dave Bartram Patricia A. Lindley Linda Marshall Julie Foster (1995) ArticleTitle‘The Recruitment and Selection of Young People by Small Businesses’ Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology 68 IssueID4 339–358
José Alberto Bayo-Moriones Javier Merino-Díaz de Cerio (2001) ArticleTitle‘Size and HRM in the Spanish Manufacturing Industry’ Employee Relations 23 IssueID2 188–206
Gary S. Becker (1964) Human Capital: A Theoretical Analysis with Special Reference to Education Columbia University Press New York
Brian Becker Barry Gerhart (1996) ArticleTitle‘The Impact of Human Resource Management on Organizational Performance: Progress and Prospects’ Academy of Management Journal 39 IssueID4 779–801
Brian Becker Mark A. Huselid Peter S. Pickus Michael F. Spratt (1997) ArticleTitle‘HR as a Source of Shareholder Value: Research and Recommendations’ Human Resource Management 36 IssueID1 39–47 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1099-050X(199721)36:1<39::AID-HRM8>3.0.CO;2-X
Michael Beer Bert Spector Paul R. Lawrence Richard E. Walton (1984) Managing Human Assets Free Press New York
Martin R. Binks Christine T. Ennew (1996) ArticleTitle‘Growing firms and the credit constraint’ Small Business Economics 8 IssueID1 17–25 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00391972
Sandra Black Lisa M. Lynch (1996) ArticleTitle‘Human Capital Investments and Productivity’ American Economic Review 86 IssueID2 263–268
Dan A. Black Brett J. Noel Zheng Wang (1999) ArticleTitle‘On-the-job Training, Establishment Size and Firm Size: Evidence for Economies of Scale in the Production of Human Capital’ Southern Economic Journal 66 IssueID1 82–100
Charles Brown James Medoff (1989) ArticleTitle‘The Employer Size-Wage Effect’ Journal of Political Economy 97 IssueID5 1027–1059
Thomas Brytting (1991) Organizing in the Small Growing Firm: a Grounded Theory Approach Stockholm School of Economics, The Economic Research Institute Stockholm
Peter Cappelli David Neumark (2001) ArticleTitle‘Do ‘High Performance’ Work Practices Improve Establishment Level Outcomes?’ Industrial and Labor Relations Review 54 IssueID4 737–775
Marilyn Caroll Mick Marchington Jill Earnshaw Stephen Taylor (1999) ArticleTitle‘Recruitment in Small Firms: Processes, Methods and Problems’ Employee Relations 21 IssueID3 236–250
Catherine Cassell Sara Nadin Melanie Gray Chris Clegg (2002) ArticleTitle‘Exploring Human Resource Management Practices in Small and Medium Sized Enterprises’ Personnel Review 31 IssueID5/6 671–693
Gaylen N. Chandler Glenn M. McEvoy (2000) ArticleTitle‘Human Resource Management, TQM and Firm Performance in Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises’ Entrepreneurship: Theory & Practice 25 IssueID1 43–57
Neil C. Churchill Virginia L. Lewis (1983) ArticleTitle‘The Five Stages of Small Business Growth’ Harvard Business Review 61 IssueID3 30–50
James Curran (1988) ArticleTitle‘Training and Research Strategies for Small Businesses’ Journal of General Management 13 IssueID3 24–37
Charles-Henri D’Arcimoles (1997) ArticleTitle‘Human Resource Policies and Company Performance: A Quantitative Approach Using Longitudinal Data’ Organization Studies 18 IssueID5 857–874
Jan M. P. Kok Particlede (2003) Human Resource Management within Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises doctoral dissertation, Erasmus University Rotterdam
Jan M. P. Kok Particlede Loraine M. Uhlaner (2001) Organization Context and Human Resource Management in the Small Firm Tinbergen Institute Amsterdam, Rotterdam
Jan M. P. Kok Particlede Loraine M. Uhlaner A. Roy Thurik (2002) Human Resource Management within Small and Medium-Sized Firms: Facts and Explanations Zoetermeer EIM/Erasmus University Rotterdam
John T. Delaney Mark A. Huselid (1996) ArticleTitle‘The Impact of Human Resource Management Practices on Perceptions of Organizational Performance’ Academy of Management Journal 39 IssueID4 949–969
John E. Delery (1998) ArticleTitle‘Issues of Fit in Strategic Human Resource Management: Implications for Research’ Human Resource Management Review 8 IssueID3 289–309 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S1053-4822(98)90006-7
John E. Delery Jason D. Shaw (2001) ArticleTitle‘The Strategic Management of People in Work Organizations: Review, Synthesis and Extension’ Research in Personnel and Human Resource Management 20 165–197
Gregory G. Dess Jason D. Shaw (2001) ArticleTitle‘Voluntary Turnover, Social Capital and Organizational Performance’ Academy of Management Review 26 IssueID3 446–456
Joanne P. Duberley Paul Walley (1995) ArticleTitle‘Assessing the Adoption of HRM by Small and Medium-Sized Manufacturing Organisations’ International Journal of Human Resource Management 6 IssueID4 891–909
InstitutionalAuthorNameDun and Bradstreet Corporation (2001) The Business Failure Record Dun & Brandstreet Corporation New York
Lee Dyer Todd Reeves (1995) ArticleTitle‘Human Resource Strategies and Firm Performance: What do We Know and Where do We Need to Go?’ International Journal of Human Resource Management 6 IssueID3 656–670
Barry Elliott Janie Elliott (2002) Financial Accounting and Reporting Pearson Education Harlow
Faems, Dries, Luc Sels, Sophie De Winne and Johan Maes, in press, ‘The Effect of Individual HRM-Domains on Financial Performance: Evidence from Belgian SMEs’, International Journal of Human Resource Management.
Carl F. Fey Ingmar Björkman Antonina Pavlovskaya (2000) ArticleTitle‘‘The Effect of Human Resource Management Practices on Firm Performance in Russia’’ International Journal of Human Resource Management 11 IssueID1 1–18
Charles J. Fombrun Noel M. Tichy Mary A. Devanna (1984) Strategic Human Resource Management John Wiley and Sons New York
Duncan Gallie Alan Felstead Francis Green (2001) ArticleTitle‘Employer Policies and Organizational Commitment in Britain 1992–1997’ Journal of Management Studies, 38 IssueID8 1082–1101 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-6486.00273
Robert D. Gatewood Hubert S. Field (1987) ArticleTitle‘A Personnel Selection Program for Small Business’ Journal of Small Business Management 25 IssueID4 16–24
Barry Gerhart George T. Milkovich (1992) ‘Employee Compensation: Research and Practice’ Marvin D. Dunnette Leaetta Hough (Eds) Handbook of Industrial and Organizational Psychology NumberInSeriesvol. 3 Consulting Psychologists Press Palo Alto, CA 481–569
Damodar Y. Golhar Satish P. Deshpande (1997) ArticleTitle‘HRM Practices of Large and Small Canadian Manufacturing Firms’ Journal of Small Business Management 35 IssueID3 30–38
Graydon, 2001. The GRAYDON Database Yearly Releases Data on all Bankruptcies in Belgium. We used the Data to Calculate the Bankruptcy Rates for Companies of Different Size. For More Information, Consult the Website http://www.graydon.be/.
David E. Guest Jonathan Michie Neil Conway Maura Sheehan (2003) ArticleTitle‘Human Resource Management and Corporate Performance in the UK’ British Journal of Industrial Relations 41 IssueID2 291–314 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-8543.00273
James P. Guthrie (2001) ArticleTitle‘High-Involvement Work Practices, Turnover, and Productivity: Evidence from New Zealand’ Academy of Management Journal 44 IssueID1 180–190
Gedaliahu H. Harel Shay S. Tzafrir (1999) ArticleTitle‘The Effect of Human Resource Practices on the Perceptions of Organizational and Market Performance of the Firm’ Human Resource Management 38 IssueID3 185–199 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1099-050X(199923)38:3<185::AID-HRM2>3.0.CO;2-Y
Larry Hatcher (1994) A Step-by-step Approach to Using the SAS System for Factor Analysis and Structural Equation Modeling SAS Institute Cary, NC
Herbert G. Heneman Robyn A. Berkley (1999) ArticleTitle‘Applicant Attraction Practices and Outcomes Among Small Businesses’ Journal of Small Business Management 37 IssueID1 53–74
Robert L. Heneman Judith W. Tansky S. Michael Camp (2000) ArticleTitle‘Human Resource Management Practices in Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises: Unanswered Questions and Future Research Perspectives’ Entrepreneurship: Theory & Practice 25 IssueID1 11–26
Jacky Holloway Jenny Lewis Geoff Mallory (1995) Performance Measurement and Evaluation Sage London
Harry J. Holzer (1987) ‘Hiring Procedures in the Firm: their Economic Determinants and Outcomes’ Morris M. Kleiner Richard N. Block Myron Roomkin Sidney W. Salsbury (Eds) Human Resources and the Performance of the Firm BNA Press Washington DC
Kim Hoque (1999) ArticleTitle‘Human Resource Management and Performance in the UK Hotel Industry’ British Journal of Industrial Relations 37 IssueID3 419–443 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-8543.00135
Jeffrey S. Hornsby Donald F. Kuratko (2003) ArticleTitle‘Human resource management in U.S. small businesses: a replication and extension’ Journal of Developmental Entrepreneurship 8 IssueID1 73–92
Jeffrey S. Hornsby Donald F. Kuratko (1990) ArticleTitle‘Human Resource Management in Small Business: Critical Issues for the 1990s’ Journal of Small Business Management 28 IssueID3 9–18
John E. Hunter Ronda F. Hunter (1984) ArticleTitle‘Validity and Utility of Alternative Predictors of Job Performance’ Psychological Bulletin 96 IssueID1 72–98 Occurrence Handle10.1037//0033-2909.96.1.72
Mark A. Huselid (1995) ArticleTitle‘The Impact of Human Resource Management Practices on Turnover, Productivity, and Corporate Financial Performance’ Academy of Management Journal 38 IssueID3 635–672
Casey Ichniowski Kathryn Shaw Giovanna Prennushi (1997) ArticleTitle‘The Effect of Human Resource Management Practices on Productivity: a Study of Steel Finishing Lines’ American Economic Review 87 IssueID3 291–313
Paul A. Iles Ivan T. Robertson (1997) ‘The Impact of Personnel Selection Procedures on Candidates’ Neil Anderson Peter Herriot (Eds) International Handbook of Selection and Assessment Wiley Chichester
Susan E. Jackson Randall S. Schuler J. Carlos Rivero (1989) ArticleTitle‘Organizational Characteristics as Predictors of Personnel Practices’ Personnel Psychology 42 IssueID4 727–786
Pierre-André Julien (2001) The State of the Art in Small Business and Entrepreneurship Ashgate Aldershot
Jerome A. Katz Howard E. Aldrich Theresa M. Welbourne Pamela M. Williams (2000) ArticleTitle‘Guest Editor’s Comments, Special Issue on Human Resource Management and the SME: Toward a New Synthesis’ Entrepreneurship:Theory & Practice 25 IssueID1 7–10
Harry C. Katz Thomas A. Kochan Mark A. Weber (1985) ArticleTitle‘Assessing the Effects of Industrial Relations Systems and Efforts to Improve the Quality of Working Life on Organizational Effectiveness’ Academy of Management Journal 28 IssueID3 509–526
Robert K. Kazanjian (1988) ArticleTitle‘Relation of Dominant Problems to Stages of Growth in Technology-Based New Ventures’ Academy of Management Journal 31 IssueID2 257–279
Naresh Khatri (2000) ArticleTitle‘Managing Human Resource for Competitive Advantage: A Study of Companies in Singapore’ International Journal of Human Resource Management, 11 IssueID2 336–365 Occurrence Handle10.1080/095851900339909
Donald L. Kirkpatrick (1998) Evaluating Training Programs. The Four Levels Berrett-Koehler San Francisco
Brian S. Klaas John McClendon Thomas W. Gainey (2000) ArticleTitle‘Managing HR in the Small and Medium Enterprise: The Impact of Professional Employer Organizations’ Entrepreneurship: Theory & Practice 25 IssueID1 107–124
Marianne J. Koch Rita Gunther McGrath (1996) ArticleTitle‘Improving Labor Productivity: Human Resource Management Policies do Matter’ Strategic Management Journal 17 IssueID5 335–354 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1097-0266(199605)17:5<335::AID-SMJ814>3.0.CO;2-R
Edward E. Lawler SuffixIII (1999) Rewarding Excellence. Pay Strategies for The New Economy Jossey-Bass San Francisco
Edward P. Lazear (2000) ArticleTitle‘Performance pay and productivity’ The American Economic Review, 90 IssueID5 1346–1361 Occurrence Handle10.1257/aer.90.5.1346
Jangwoo Lee Danny Miller (1999) ArticleTitle‘People Matter: Commitment to Employees, Strategy and Performance in Korean Firms’ Strategic Management Journal 20 IssueID6 579–593 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1097-0266(199906)20:6<579::AID-SMJ37>3.0.CO;2-C
Don Y. Lee Eric W.K. Tsang (2001) ArticleTitle‘The Effects of Entrepreneurial Personality, Background and Network Activities on Venture Growth’ Journal of Management Studies 38 IssueID4 583–602 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-6486.00250
Jacques B. Liouville Mohammed Bayad (1998) ArticleTitle‘Human Resource Management and Performances: Proposition and Test of a Causal Model’ Human Systems Management 17 IssueID3 183–193
John Paul MacDuffie (1995) ArticleTitle‘Human Resource Bundles and Manufacturing Performance: Organizational Logic and Flexible Production Systems in the World Auto Industry’ Industrial and Labor Relations Review 48 IssueID2 197–221
Juliet MacMahon (1996) ArticleTitle‘Employee Relations in Small Firms in Ireland: An Exploratory Study of Small Manufacturing Firms’ Employee Relations 18 IssueID5 66–80 Occurrence Handle10.1108/01425459610129399
Maes, Johan, Luc Sels and Filip Roodhooft, 2001, Small Business Performance: Exploring the Link Between Management Practices and the Financial Performance of Small and Medium Sized Belgian construction Companies, Conference proceedings: RENT XV Research in Entrepreneurship and Small Business. Turku (Finland), November 22nd-23rd 2001.
Maes, Johan, Luc Sels and Filip Roodhooft, In press, ‘Modeling the Link Between Management Practices and Financial Performance. Evidence from Small Construction Companies’ Small Business Economics.
Sue Marlow (2000) ArticleTitle‘Investigating the Use of Emergent Strategic Human Resource Management Activity in the Small Firm’ Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development 7 IssueID2 135–148
Sue Marlow Dean Patton (1993) ArticleTitle‘Research Note: Managing the Employment Relationship in the Smaller Firm: Possibilities for Human Resource Management’ International Small Business Journal 11 IssueID4 57–64
Harry Matlay (1999) ArticleTitle‘Employee Relations in Small Firms: A Micro-Business Perspective’ Employee Relations 21 IssueID3 285–295 Occurrence Handle10.1108/01425459910273125
Harry Matlay (1997) ArticleTitle‘The Paradox of Training in the Small Business Sector of the British Economy’ Journal of Vocational Education and Training 49 IssueID4 573–589
Glenn M. McEvoy (1984) ArticleTitle‘Small Business Personnel Practices’ Journal of Small Business Management 22 IssueID10 1–8
Raymond E. Miles Charles C. Snow (1978) Organization Strategy, Structure and Process McGraw-Hill NewYork
John Milliman Mary Ann Von Glinow Maria Nathan (1991) ArticleTitle‘Organizational Life Cycles and Strategic International Human Resource Management in Multinational Companies: Implications for Congruence Theory’ Academy of Management Review 16 IssueID2 316–339
Ignace Ng Dennis Maki (1993) ArticleTitle‘Human Resource Management in the Canadian Manufacturing Sector’ International Journal of Human Resource Management 4 IssueID4 897–916
Riccardo Peccei Patrice Rosenthal (2001) ArticleTitle‘Delivering Customer-Oriented Behaviour through Empowerment: an Empirical Test of HRM Assumptions’ Journal of Management Studies 38 IssueID6 831–857 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-6486.00261
Jeffrey Pfeffer (1994) Competitive Advantage Through People: Unleashing the Power of the Work Force Harvard Business School Press Boston
Michael Poole Glenville Jenkins (1998) ArticleTitle‘Human Resource Management and the Theory of Rewards: Evidence from a National Survey’ British Journal of Industrial Relations 36 IssueID2 227–247 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-8543.00090
John Purcell (1999) ArticleTitle‘Best Practice and Best Fit: Chimera or Cul-de-sac?’ Human Resource Management Journal 9 IssueID3 26–41
Al Rainnie (1989) Industrial Relations in Small Firms, Small isn’t Beautiful Routledge London
Monder Ram Paul Edwards Mark W. Gilman James Arrowsmith (2001) ArticleTitle‘The Dynamics of Informality: Employment Relations in Small Firms and the Effects of Regulatory Change’ Work, Employment & Society 15 IssueID4 845–861 Occurrence Handle10.1177/095001701400438233
Harvie Ramsay Dora Scholarios Bill Harley (2000) ArticleTitle‘Employees and High-Performance Work Systems: Testing Inside the Black Box’ British Journal of Labour Relations 38 IssueID4 501–531
James A. Roberts Kevin R. Coulson Lawrence B. Chonko (1999) ArticleTitle‘Salesperson Perceptions of Equity and Justice and their Impact on Organizational Commitment and Intent to Turnover’ Journal of Marketing, Theory and Practice 7 IssueID1 1–16
Robert W. Rowden (2002) ArticleTitle‘High Performance and Human Resource Characteristics of Successful Small Manufacturing and Processing Companies’ Leadership & Organization Development Journal 23 IssueID2 79–83
Luc Sels (2002) ArticleTitle‘More is not Necessarily Better. The Relationship between the Quantity and Quality of Training Efforts’ International Journal of Human Resource Management 13 IssueID8 1279–1298 Occurrence Handle10.1080/09585190210149529
Jason D. Shaw John E. Delery G. Douglas Jenkins SuffixJr. Nina Gupta (1998) ArticleTitle‘An Organization-Level Analysis of Voluntary and Involuntary Turnover’ Academy of Management Journal 41 IssueID5 511–525
Paul Sparrow Jean Marie Hiltrop (1994) European Human Resource Management in Transition Prentice-Hall New York
Edward M. Shepard SuffixIII (1994) ArticleTitle‘Profit Sharing and Productivity: Further Evidence from the Chemicals Industry’ Industrial Relations 33 IssueID4 452–477
Robert P. Steel Rodger W. Griffeth Peter W. Hom (2002) ArticleTitle‘Practical Retention Policy for the Practical Manager’ Academy of Management Executive, 16 IssueID2 149–164
David J. Storey (2004) ArticleTitle‘Exploring the Link, among Small Firms, between Management Training and Firm Performance: A Comparison between the UK and other OECD countries’ International Journal of Human Resource Management 15 IssueID1 112–130 Occurrence Handle10.1080/0958519032000157375
Robert P. Tett John P. Meyer (1993) ArticleTitle‘Job Satisfaction, Organizational Commitment, Turnover Intention and Turnover: Path Analyses Based on Meta-Analytic Findings’ Personnel Psychology 46 IssueID2 259–292
Catherine Truss (2001) ArticleTitle‘Complexities and Controversies in Linking HRM with Organizational Outcomes’ Journal of Management Studies 38 IssueID8 1122–1149 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-6486.00275
Terry H. Wagar (1998) ArticleTitle‘Determinants of Human Resource Management Practices in Small Firms: Some Evidence from Atlantic Canada’ Journal of Small Business Management 36 IssueID2 13–23
Martin L. Weitzman Douglas L. Kruse (1990) ‘Profit Sharing and Productivity’ Alan S. Blinder (Eds) Paying for Productivity: A Look at the Evidence The Brookings Institution Washington 95–141
Paul Westhead David J. Storey (1996) ArticleTitle‘Management Training and Small Firm Performance: Why is the Link so Weak?’ International Small Business Journal 14 IssueID4 13–24
Retha Wiesner Jim McDonald (2001) ArticleTitle‘Bleak House or Bright Prospect? Human Resource Management in Australian SMEs’ Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources, 39 IssueID2 28–50 Occurrence Handle10.1177/103841110103900203
Hema Wijewardena Gary E. Tibbits (1999) ArticleTitle‘Factors Contributing to the Growth of Small Manufacturing Firms: Data from Australia’ Journal of Small Business Management 37 IssueID2 88–95
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sels, L., De Winne, S., Delmotte, J. et al. Linking HRM and Small Business Performance: An Examination of the Impact of HRM Intensity on the Productivity and Financial Performance of Small Businesses. Small Bus Econ 26, 83–101 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11187-004-6488-6
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11187-004-6488-6