Pragmatic Randomised Controlled Trial of an Exercise Programme to Improve Wellbeing Outcomes in Women with Depression: Findings from the Qualitative Component

Abstract

This paper reports the qualitative component from a pragmatic randomized controlled trial (PRCT), the quantitative component is reported in Callaghan, Khalil, Morres and Carter (2011). Exercise may be effective in treating depression, but trials testing its effect in depressed women are rare. Our previous research found that standard exercise programmes, prescribed by General Practitioners and based on national guidelines of intensity levels thought to produce health benefits, are not suitable for this group, as they find them discouraging and lonely, with many dropping out very early on. Exercise that is matched to participants’ preferred intensity improves mental health outcomes and attrition rates. Our aim was to develop such a programme. This study addressed the question: does mentored exercise of preferred intensity lead to better psychological, physiological and social wellbeing outcomes and improved adherence rates when compared with exercise of prescribed intensity in 38 depressed women? Focus groups were conducted with participants from both arms of the study, to explore their experience of the exercise programme and to gather information that might help to explain the quantitative outcomes, a technique recommended by previous researchers conducting pragmatic trials. Women in the experimental programme experienced a statistically significant improvement in their mood, physical health, sense of wellbeing, self-esteem and quality of life. They reported achieving these gains via a positive experience which encouraged continued attendance. In contrast, women who received the “exercise as usual” programme experienced no significant benefits, were less likely to continue attending, and markedly less enthusiastic.

Share and Cite:

Khalil, E. , Callaghan, P. , Carter, T. & Morres, I. (2012). Pragmatic Randomised Controlled Trial of an Exercise Programme to Improve Wellbeing Outcomes in Women with Depression: Findings from the Qualitative Component. Psychology, 3, 979-986. doi: 10.4236/psych.2012.311147.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

References

[1] Alaoui-Isma?li, O., Robin, O., Rada, H., Dittmar, A., Vernet-Maury, Barbui, C., Butler, R., Cipriani, A., Geddes, J. & Hatcher, S. (2007). Depression in adults (drugs and other physical treatments). BMJ Clinical Evidence, 6, 1-27.
[2] Biddle, S. J. H. (2000). Emotion, mood and physical activity. In: S. J. H. Biddle, K. R. Fox, & S. H. Boutcher (Eds.), Physical activity and psychological well-being (pp. 63-87). London: Routledge.
[3] Blumenthal, J. A., Babyak, M. A., Moore, K. A., Craighead, E., Her man, S., Khatri, P. et al. (1999). Effects of exercise training on older patients with major depression. Archives of Internal Medicine, 159, 2349-2356. doi:10.1001/archinte.159.19.2349
[4] British Heart Foundation (2003). BHF coronary heart disease statistics. London: British Heart Foundation.
[5] Callaghan, P., & Norman, P. (2000). Motivations and predictors of exercise in Chinese high school children. International Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 7, 23-24.
[6] Callaghan, P., Eves, F. F., Norman, P., Cheung, Y. L., & Chang, A. M. (2002). Applying the transtheoretical model of change to exercise in young Chinese people. British Journal of Health Psychology, 7, 267 282. doi:10.1348/135910702760213670
[7] Callaghan, P., & Norman, P. (2004). A prospective evaluation of the theory of planned behaviour (TPB) and the transtheoretcial model of change (TTM) on exercise in young people. Psychology and Health, 19, 29-30.
[8] Callaghan, P. (2004). Exercise: A neglected intervention in mental health care? Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 11, 476-483. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2850.2004.00751.x
[9] Callaghan, P., Khalil, E., Morres, I., & Carter, T. (2011). Pragmatic randomised controlled trial of preferred intensity exercise in women living with depression. BMC Public Health, 11, 465-472. doi:10.1186/1471-2458-11-465
[10] Cohen, A., & Hove, M. (2001). Physical health of the severe and enduring mentally ill: A training pack for GP educators. London: Sainsbury Centre for Mental Health.
[11] Craft, L. L., & Landers, D. M. (1998). The effect of exercise on clinical depression and depression resulting from mental illness: A meta analysis. Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 20, 339-357.
[12] Department of Health (1999). The national service framework for mental health. London: The Stationary Office.
[13] Department of Health (2001). The national quality assurance framework for exercise. London: Department of Health.
[14] Department of Health (2003). Womens’ mental health: Into the mainstream. Strategic development of mental health care for women. London: The Stationary Office.
[15] Department of Health (2004). At least five a week: Evidence on the impact of physical activity and its relationship to health. A report from the Chief Medical Officer. London: HMSO.
[16] Department of Health (2004). Choosing health: Making healthier choices easier. London: HMSO.
[17] Department of Health (2006). From values to action: The chief nursing officer’s review of mental health nursing. London: HMSO.
[18] Dunn, A. L., Trivedi, M. H., & O’Neal, H. A. (2001). Physical activity dose-response effects on outcomes of depression and anxiety. Medi cine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 33, 87-597. doi:10.1097/00005768-200106001-00027
[19] Ekkekakis, P., Hall, E. E., VanLanduyt, L. M., & Petruzzello, S. J. (2000). Walking in (affective) circles: Can short walks enhance af fect? Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 23, 245-275. doi:10.1023/A:1005558025163
[20] Fox, K. R. (2000). Self-esteem, self-perceptions and exercise. International Journal of Sport Psychology, 31, 228-240.
[21] Friedli, L., & Dardis, C. (2002). Not all in the mind: Mental health service user perspectives on physical health. Journal of Mental Health Promotion, 1, 36-46.
[22] Hippisley-Cox, J. (1998). Depression as a risk factor for ischaemic heart disease in men: Population based case control study. British Medical Journal, 316, 1714-1719. doi:10.1136/bmj.316.7146.1714
[23] Hotopf, M. (2002). The pragmatic randomised controlled trial. Advances in Psychiatric Treatment, 8, 326-333. doi:10.1192/apt.8.5.326
[24] Kubitz, K. A., Landers, D. M., Petruzzello, S. J., & Han, M. (1996). The effects of acute and chronic exercise on sleep: A metaanalytic review. Sports Medicine, 21, 277-291. doi:10.2165/00007256-199621040-00004
[25] Lacey, A., & Lacey, L. D. (2001). Framework analysis. Qualitative data analysis. UK: Trent Focus for Research and Development in Primary Care.
[26] Lawlor, D. A., & Hopker, S. W. (2001). The effectiveness of exercise as an intervention in the management of depression: Systematic re view and meta-regression analysis of randomised controlled trials. British Medical Journal, 322, 1-8. doi:10.1136/bmj.322.7289.763
[27] McGeorge, S. (2004). Couch kids: The continuing epidemic. London: British Heart Foundation.
[28] Mead, G. E., Morley, W., Campbell, P., Greig, C. A., McMurdo, M., & Lawlor, D. A. (2009). Exercise for depression (review). Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 3, Article ID: CD004366. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD004366.pub4
[29] Mental Health Foundation (2004). Up and running: Exercise therapy and the treatment of mild or moderate depression in primary care. London: Mental Health Foundation.
[30] Mental Health Foundation (2006). Feeding minds. London: Mental Health Foundation.
[31] Morgan, W. P. (2001). Prescription of Physical activity: A paradigm shift. Quest, 53, 366-382. doi:10.1080/00336297.2001.10491754
[32] Mutrie, N. (2002). Healthy body, healthy mind? The Psychologist, 15, 412-413.
[33] Nocon, A. (2004). Equal treatment: Closing the gap. London: Disability Rights Commission.
[34] Oakley, A., Strange, V., Bonell, C., Allen, E., & Stephenson, J. (2006). Process evaluation in randomised controlled trials of complex inter ventions. British Medical Journal, 332, 413-416. doi:10.1136/bmj.332.7538.413
[35] Ostir, G. V., Markides, K. S., Peek, M. K., & Goodwin, J. S. (2001). The association between emotional well-being and the incidence of stroke in older adults. Psychosomatic Medicine, 63, 210-215.
[36] Owen, S., & Khalil, E. (2006). Meeting the physical health needs of adults with serious and enduring mental illness in community settings. UK: The University of Nottingham.
[37] Paffenberger, R., Lee, I., & Leung, R. (1994). Physical activity and personal characteristics associated with depression and suicide in American college men. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 377, 16-22. doi:10.1111/j.1600-0447.1994.tb05796.x
[38] Phelan, M., Stradins, L., & Morrison, S. (2001). Physical health of people with severe mental illness. British Medical Journal, 322, 443 444. doi:10.1136/bmj.322.7284.443
[39] Richardson, C. R., Faulkner, G., McDevitt, J., Skrinar, G. S., Hutchinson, D. S., & Piette, J. D. (2005). Integrating physical activity into mental health services for persons with serious mental illness. Psychiatric Services, 56, 324-331. doi:10.1176/appi.ps.56.3.324
[40] Robson, D., & Gray, R. (2007). Serious mental illness and physical health problems: A discussion paper. International Journal of Nurs ing Studies, 44, 457-466. doi:10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2006.07.013
[41] Scully, D., Kremer, J., Meade, M., Graham, R., & Dudgeon, K. (1998). Physical exercise and psychological well-being: A critical review. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 32, 111-120. doi:10.1136/bjsm.32.2.111
[42] Seymour, L. (2003). Not all in the mind: The physical health of mental health service users. Radical mentalities briefing paper 2. London: Mentality.
[43] Sherrill, D. L., Kotchou, K., & Quan, S. F. (1998). Association of phy sical activity and human sleep disorders. Archives of Internal Medi cine, 158, 1894-1898. doi:10.1001/archinte.158.17.1894
[44] Thompson, W. G. (1994). Exercise and health: Fact or hype? Southern Medical Journal, 87, 567-574.
[45] Turner, J., & Kelly, B. (2000). Emotional dimensions of chronic dis ease. British Medical Journal, 172, 124-128.
[46] WHO (2007). URL (last checked February 2012). http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs220/en/
[47] Youngstedt, S. D., O’Conno, P. J., & Dishman, R. K. (1997). The ef fects of acute exercise on sleep: A quantitative synthesis. Sleep, 20, 203-214.

Journals Menu
Follow SCIRP
Contact us
+1 323-425-8868
customer@scirp.org
WhatsApp +86 18163351462(WhatsApp)
Click here to send a message to me 1655362766
Paper Publishing WeChat

Copyright © 2024 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.

Creative Commons License

This work and the related PDF file are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.