Abstract
Language-music comparative studies have highlighted the potential for shared resources or neural overlap in auditory short-term memory. However, there is a lack of behavioral methodologies for comparing verbal and musical serial recall. We developed a visual grid response that allowed both musicians and nonmusicians to perform serial recall of letter and tone sequences. The new method was used to compare the phonological similarity effect with the impact of an operationalized musical equivalent — pitch proximity. Over the course of three experiments, we found that short-term memory for tones had several similarities to verbal memory, including limited capacity and a significant effect of pitch proximity in nonmusicians. Despite being vulnerable to phonological similarity when recalling letters, however, musicians showed no effect of pitch proximity, a result that we suggest might reflect strategy differences. Overall, the findings support a limited degree of correspondence in the way that verbal and musical sounds are processed in auditory short-term memory.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anvari, S. H., Trainor, L. J., Woodside, J., &Levy, B. A. (2002). Relations among musical skills, phonological processing, and early reading ability in preschool children.Journal of Experimental Child Psychology,83, 111–130. doi:10.1016/S0022-0965(02)00124-8
Ayotte, J., Peretz, I., &Hyde, K. (2002). Congenital amusia: A group study of adults afflicted with a music-specific disorder.Brain,125, 238–251. doi:10.1093/brain/awf028
Baddeley, A. D. (1966). The influence of acoustic and semantic similarity on long-term memory for word sequences.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,18, 302–309.
Baddeley, A. [D.] (2000). The episodic buffer: A new component of working memory?Trends in Cognitive Sciences,4, 417–423. doi:10.1016/S1364-6613(00)01538-2
Baddeley, A. [D.] (2007).Working memory, thought, and action. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Baddeley, A. [D.], Chincotta, D., &Adlam, A. (2001). Working memory and the control of action: Evidence from task switching.Journal of Experimental Psychology: General,130, 641–657. doi:10.1037/0096-3445.130.4.641
Baddeley, A. [D.], Gathercole, S. [E.], &Papagno, C. (1998). The phonological loop as a language learning device.Psychological Review,105, 158–173.
Baddeley, A. D., &Hitch, G. J. (1974). Working memory. In G. H. Bower (Ed.),The psychology of learning and motivation: Advances in research and theory (Vol. 8, pp. 47–89). New York: Academic Press.
Baddeley, A. [D.], &Larsen, J. D. (2003). The disruption of STM: A response to our commentators.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,56A, 1301–1306.
Baddeley, A. D., Lewis, V., &Vallar, G. (1984). Exploring the articulatory loop.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,36A, 233–252.
Baddeley, A. [D.], Papagno, C., &Vallar, G. (1988). When longterm learning depends on short-term storage.Journal of Memory & Language,27, 586–595. doi:10.1016/0749-596X(88)90028-9
Berz, W. L. (1995). Working memory in music: A theoretical model.Music Perception,12, 353–364.
Besson, M., Schön, D., Moreno, S., Santos, A., &Magne, C. (2007). Influence of musical expertise and musical training on pitch processing in music and language.Restorative Neurology & Neuroscience,25, 399–410.
Brandler, S., &Rammsayer, T. H. (2003). Differences in mental abilities between musicians and non-musicians.Psychology of Music,31, 123–138. doi:10.1177/0305735603031002290
Brown, S., &Martinez, M. J. (2007). Activation of premotor vocal areas during musical discrimination.Brain & Cognition,63, 59–69. doi:10.1016/j.bandc.2006.08.006
Brown, S., Martinez, M. J., Hodges, D. A., Fox, P. T., &Parsons, L. M. (2004). The song system of the human brain.Cognitive Brain Research,20, 363–375. doi:10.1016/j.cogbrainres.2004.03.016
Brown, S., Martinez, M. J., &Parsons, L. M. (2006). Music and language side by side in the brain: A PET study of the generation of melodies and sentences.European Journal of Neuroscience,23, 2791–2803.
Callan, D. E., Tsytsarev, V., Hanakawa, T., Callan, A. M., Katsuhara, M., Fukuyama, H., &Turner, R. (2006). Song and speech: Brain regions involved with perception and covert production.NeuroImage,31, 1327–1342. doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2006.01.036
Chan, A. S., Ho, Y.-C., &Cheung, M.-C. (1998). Music training improves verbal memory.Nature,396, 128.
Chase, W. G., &Ericsson, K. A. (1981). Skilled memory. In J. R. Anderson (Ed.),Cognitive skills and their acquisition (pp. 141–189). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Clark, H. H. (1973). The language-as-fixed-effect fallacy: A critique of language statistics in psychological research.Journal of Verbal Learning & Verbal Behavior,12, 335–359.
Clarke, E. F. (1988). Generative principles in music performance. In J. A. Sloboda (Ed.),Generative processes in music: The psychology of performance, improvisation, and composition (pp. 1–26). Oxford: Oxford University Press, Clarendon Press.
Colle, H. A., &Welsh, A. (1976). Acoustic making in primary memory.Journal of Verbal Learning & Verbal Behavior,15, 17–31. doi:10.1016/S0022-5371(76)90003-7
Conrad, R. (1964). Acoustic confusions in immediate memory.British Journal of Psychology,55, 75–84.
Conrad, R., &Hull, A. J. (1964). Information, acoustic confusion and memory span.British Journal of Psychology,55, 429–432.
Croonen, W. L. M. (1994). Effects of length, tonal structure, and contour in the recognition of tone series.Perception & Psychophysics,55, 623–632.
Darwin, C. (1871).The descent of man and selection in relation to sex. New York: Appleton.
Deutsch, D. (1970). Tones and numbers: Specificity of interference in immediate memory.Science,168, 1604–1605.
Dowling, W. J. (1991). Tonal strength and melody recognition after long and short delays.Perception & Psychophysics,50, 305–313.
Dowling, W. J. (1994). Melodic contour in hearing and remembering melodies. In R. Aiello & J. A. Sloboda (Eds.),Musical perceptions (pp. 173–190). New York: Oxford University Press.
Ericsson, K. A., &Kintsch, W. (1995). Long-term working memory.Psychological Review,102, 211–245.
Franklin, M. S., Moore, K. S., Yip, C.-Y., Jonides, J., Rattray, K., &Moher, J. (2008). The effects of musical training on verbal memory.Psychology of Music,36, 353–365. doi:10.1177/0305735607086044
Gaab, N., &Schlaug, G. (2003). The effect of musicianship on pitch memory in performance matched groups.NeuroReport,14, 2291–2295.
Gaab, N., Tallal, P., Kim, H., Lakshminarayanan, K., Archie, J. J., Glover, G. H., &Gabrieli, J. D. E. (2005). Neural correlates of rapid spectrotemporal processing in musicians and nonmusicians. In G. Avanzini, L. Lopez, & S. Koelsch (Eds.),The neurosciences and music II: From perception to performance (Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, Vol. 1060, pp. 82–88). New York: New York Academy of Sciences.
Gathercole, S. E., &Baddeley, A. D. (1990). Phonological memory deficits in language disordered children: Is there a causal connection?Journal of Memory & Language,29, 336–360. doi:10.1016/0749-596X(90)90004-J
Greene, R. L., &Samuel, A. G. (1986). Recency and suffix effects in serial recall of musical stimuli.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, & Cognition,12, 517–524.
Hadlington, L. [J.], Bridges, A. M., &Darby, R. J. (2004). Auditory location in the irrelevant sound effect: The effects of presenting auditory stimuli to either the left ear, right ear or both ears.Brain & Cognition,55, 545–557. doi:10.1016/j.bandc.2004.04.001
Halpern, A. R., Kwak, S., Bartlett, J. C., &Dowling, W. J. (1996). Effects of aging and musical experience on the representation of tonal hierarchies. {Psychology & Aging}11, 235–246.
Hanley, J. R., &Bakopoulou, E. (2003). Irrelevant speech, articulatory suppression, and phonological similarity: A test of the phonological loop model and the feature model.Psychonomic Bulletin & Review,10, 435–444.
Henson, R., Hartley, T., Burgess, N., Hitch, G., &Flude, B. (2003). Selective interference with verbal short-term memory for serial order information: A new paradigm and tests of a timing-signal hypothesis.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,56A, 1307–1334. doi:10.1080/02724980244000747
Hickok, G., Buchsbaum, B., Humphries, C., &Muftuler, T. (2003). Auditory-motor interaction revealed by fMRI: Speech, music, and working memory in Area Spt.Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience,15, 673–682. doi:10.1162/jocn.2003.15.5.673
Ho, Y.-C., Cheung, M.-C., &Chan, A. S. (2003). Music training improves verbal but not visual memory: Cross-sectional and longitudinal explorations in children.Neuropsychology,17, 439–450.
Jakobson, L. S., Lewycky, S. T., Kilgour, A. R., &Stoesz, B. M. (2008). Memory for verbal and visual material in highly trained musicians.Music Perception,26, 41–55. doi:10.1525/mp.2008.26.1.41
Jones, D. [M.] (1993). Objects, streams, and threads of auditory attention. In A. [D.] Baddeley & L. Weiskrantz (Eds.),Attention: Selection, awareness, and control: A tribute to Donald Broadbent (pp. 87–104). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Jones, D. M., &Macken, W. J. (1993). Irrelevant tones produce an irrelevant speech effect: Implications for phonological coding in working memory.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, & Cognition,19, 369–381.
Jones, D. M., Macken, W. J., &Harries, C. (1997). Disruption of short-term recognition memory for tones: Streaming or interference?Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,50A, 337–357.
Jones, D. M., Macken, W. J., &Murray, A. C. (1993). Disruption of visual short-term memory by changing-state auditory stimuli: The role of segmentation.Memory & Cognition,21, 318–328.
Jones, J. L., Lucker, J., Zalewski, C., Brewer, C., &Drayna, D. (2009). Phonological processing in adults with deficits in musical pitch recognition.Journal of Communication Disorders,42, 226–234. doi:10.1016/j.jcomdis.2009.01.001
Keller, T. A., Cowan, N., &Saults, J. S. (1995). Can auditory memory for tone pitch be rehearsed?Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, & Cognition,21, 635–645.
Kishon-Rabin, L., Amir, O., Vexler, Y., &Zaltz, Y. (2001). Pitch discrimination: Are professional musicians better than non-musicians?Journal of Basic & Clinical Physiology & Pharmacology,12, 125–143.
Koelsch, S., Schulze, K., Sammler, D., Fritz, T., Müller, K., &Gruber, O. (2009). Functional architecture of verbal and tonal working memory: An fMRI study.Human Brain Mapping,30, 859–873. doi:10.1002/hbm.20550
Kraus, N., &Banai, K. (2007). Auditory-processing malleability: Focus on language and music.Current Directions in Psychological Science,16, 105–110. doi:10.1111/j.1467-8721.2007.00485.x
Krumhansl, C. L. (1990).Cognitive foundations of musical pitch. New York: Oxford University Press.
Levitin, D. J. (2006).This is your brain on music: The science of a human obsession. New York: Dutton.
Liefooghe, B., Barouillet, P., Vandierendonck, A., &Camos, V. (2008). Working memory costs of task switching.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, & Cognition,34, 478–494. doi:10.1037/0278-7393.34.3.478
Luria, A. R., Tsvetkova, L. S., &Futer, D. S. (1965). Aphasia in a composer.Journal of the Neurological Sciences,2, 288–292.
Macken, W. J., Tremblay, S., Houghton, R. J.,Nicholls, A. P., &Jones, D. M. (2003). Does auditory streaming require attention? Evidence from attentional selectivity in short-term memory.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception & Performance,29, 43–51.
Macmillan, N. A., &Creelman, C. D. (2005).Detection theory: A user's guide (2nd ed.). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
Mandell, J., Schulze, K., &Schlaug, G. (2007). Congenital amusia: An auditory-motor feedback disorder?Restorative Neurology & Neuroscience,25, 323–334.
Marcus, G. F., Vouloumanos, A., &Sag, I. A. (2003). Does Broca's play by the rules?Nature Neuroscience,6, 651–652.
Marin, O. S. M., &Perry, D. W. (1999). Neurological aspects of music perception and performance. In D. Deutsch (Ed.),The psychology of music (2nd ed.), (pp. 653–724). San Diego: Academic Press.
Micheyl, C., Delhommeau, K., Perrot, X., &Oxenham, A. J. (2006). Influence of musical and psychoacoustical training on pitch discrimination.Hearing Research,219, 36–47. doi:10.1016/ j.heares.2006.05.004
Miyake, A., Friedman, N. P., Emerson, M. J., Witzki, A. H., Howerter, A., &Wager, T. D. (2000). The unity and diversity of executive functions and their contributions to complex “frontal lobe” tasks: A latent variable analysis.Cognitive Psychology,41, 49–100. doi:10.1006/cogp.1999.0734
Moore, B. C. J. (2003).An introduction to the psychology of hearing (5th ed.). San Diego: Academic Press.
Nairne, J. S. (1990). A feature model of immediate memory.Memory & Cognition,18, 251–269.
Neath, I. (2000). Modeling the effects of irrelevant speech on memory.Psychonomic Bulletin & Review,7, 403–423.
Neath, I., &Brown, G. D. A. (2006). SIMPLE: Further applications of a local distinctiveness model of memory. In B. H. Ross (Ed.),The psychology of learning and motivation. (Vol. 46, pp. 201–243). San Diego: Academic Press.
Nimmo, L. M., &Roodenrys, S. (2005). The phonological similarity effect in serial recognition.Memory,13, 773–784. doi:10.1080/ 09658210444000386
Overy, K. (2003). Dyslexia and music: From timing deficits to musical intervention. In G. Avanzini, C. Faienza, L. Lopez, M. Majno, & D. Minciacchi (Eds.),The neurosciences and music III: Disorders and plasticity (Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, Vol. 999, pp. 497–505). New York: New York Academy of Sciences. doi:10.1196/annals.1284.060
Patel, A. D. (2003). Language, music, syntax, and the brain.Nature Neuroscience,6, 674–681. doi:10.1038/nn1082
Patel, A. D. (2008).Music, language, and the brain. New York: Oxford University Press.
Patel, A. D. (2009). Language, music, and the brain: A resource- sharing framework. In P. Rebuschat, M. Rohrmeier, J. Hawkins, & I. Cross (Eds.),Language and music as cognitive systems. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Patel, A. D., Peretz, I., Tramo, M., &Labreque, R. (1998). Processing prosodic and musical patterns: A neuropsychological investigation.Brain & Language,61, 123–144. doi:10.1006/brln.1997.1862
Pechmann, T., &Mohr, G. (1992). Interference in memory for tonal pitch: Implications for a working-memory model.Memory & Cognition,20, 314–320.
Peretz, I., &Zatorre, R. J. (2005). Brain organization for music processing.Annual Review of Psychology,56, 89–114. doi:10.1146/ annurev.psych.56.091103.070225
Roberts, L. A. (1986). Modality and suffix effects in memory for melodic and harmonic musical materials.Cognitive Psychology,18, 123–157.
Rudner, M., Fransson, P., Ingvar, M., Nyberg, L., &Rönnberg, J. (2007). Neural representation of binding lexical signs and words in the episodic buffer of working memory.Neuropsychologia,45, 2258–2276. doi:10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2007.02.017
Salamé, P., &Baddeley, A. [D.] (1986). Phonological factors in STM: Similarity and the unattended speech effect.Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society,24, 263–265.
Salamé, P., &Baddeley, A. D. (1989). Effects of background music on phonological short-term memory.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,41A, 107–122.
Schendel, Z. A., &Palmer, C. (2007). Suppression effects on musical and verbal memory.Memory & Cognition,35, 640–650.
Schlittmeier, S. J., Hellbrück, J., &Klatte, M. (2008). Does irrelevant music cause an irrelevant sound effect for auditory items?European Journal of Cognitive Psychology,20, 252–271.
Semal, C., &Demany, L. (1991). Dissociation of pitch from timbre in auditory short-term memory.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,89, 2404–2410. doi:10.1121/1.400928
Semal, C., &Demany, L. (1993). Further evidence for an autonomous processing of pitch in auditory short-term memory.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,94, 1315–1322. doi:10.1121/1.408159
Semal, C., Demany, L., Ueda, K., &Hallé, P.-A. (1996). Speech ver sus nonspeech in pitch memory.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,100, 1132–1140. doi:10.1121/1.416298
Sloboda, J. A., &Parker, D. H. H. (1985). Immediate recall of melodies. In P. Howell, I. Cross & R. West (Eds.),Musical structure and cognition (pp. 143–168). London: Academic Press.
Stewart, L., von Kriegstein, K., Warren, J. D., &Griffiths, T. D. (2006). Music and the brain: Disorders of musical listening.Brain,129, 2533–2553. doi:10.1093/brain/awl171
Surprenant, A. M., Neath, I., &LeCompte, D. C. (1999). Irrelevant speech, phonological similarity, and presentation modality.Memory,7, 405–420.
Surprenant, A. M., Pitt, M. A., &Crowder, R. G. (1993). Auditory recency in immediate memory.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,46A, 193–223.
Williamon, A., &Egner, T. (2004). Memory structures for encoding and retrieving a piece of music: An ERP investigation.Cognitive Brain Research,22, 36–44. doi:10.1016/j.cogbrainres.2004.05.012
Williamon, A., &Valentine, E. (2002). The role of retrieval structures in memorizing music.Cognitive Psychology,44, 1–32. doi:10.1006/ cogp.2001.0759
Williamson, V. J. (2008).Comparing short-term memory for sequences of verbal and tonal materials. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of York.
Wong, P. C. M., Skoe, E., Russo, N. M., Dees, T., &Kraus, N. (2007). Musical experience shapes human brainstem encoding of linguistic pitch patterns.Nature Neuroscience,10, 420–422. doi:10.1038/nn1872
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
V.J.W. was supported by a University of York PhD studentship and an ESRC postdoctoral fellowship.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Williamson, V.J., Baddeley, A.D. & Hitch, G.J. Musicians' and nonmusicians' short-term memory for verbal and musical sequences: Comparing phonological similarity and pitch proximity. Memory & Cognition 38, 163–175 (2010). https://doi.org/10.3758/MC.38.2.163
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3758/MC.38.2.163