Novel Nanohybrids Based on Supramolecular Assemblies of Meso-tetrakis-(4-sulfonatophenyl) Porphyrin J-aggregates and Amine-Functionalized Carbon Nanotubes.

The ability of multiwalled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) covalently functionalized with polyamine chains of different length (ethylenediamine, EDA and tetraethylenepentamine, EPA) to induce the J-aggregation of meso-tetrakis(4-sulfonatophenyl)porphyrin (TPPS) was investigated in different experimental conditions. Under mild acidic conditions, protonated amino groups allow for the assembly by electrostatic interaction with the diacid form of TPPS, leading to hybrid nanomaterials. The presence of only one pendant amino group for a chain in EDA does not lead to any aggregation, whereas EPA (with four amine groups for chain) is effective in inducing J-aggregation using different mixing protocols. These nanohybrids have been characterized through UV/Vis extinction, fluorescence emission, resonance light scattering and circular dichroism spectroscopy. Their morphology and chemical composition have been elucidated through transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM). TEM and STEM analysis evidence single or bundles of MWCNTs in contact with TPPS J-aggregates nanotubes. The nanohybrids are quite stable for days, even in aqueous solutions mimicking physiological medium (NaCl 0.15 M). This property, together with their peculiar optical features in the therapeutic window of visible spectrum, make them potentially useful for biomedical applications.


Introduction
Carbon nanotubes (CNTs) are intriguing materials with applications ranging from nanotechnology-related devices (i.e., in electronics, energy storage, water treatment, as sensor/biosensor) [1] to drug/probes delivery systems for therapy and diagnosis [2,3].
Functionalized CNTs are widely used to reduce the intrinsic toxicity of "as produced" (pristine) CNTs by increasing the tolerability and the biodegradability in vivo [4,5]. Furthermore, opportunely
Carboxylated multiwalled carbon nanotubes (MWCNT-Ox) were prepared by the oxidation of MWCNTs (mean diameter 5-10 nm; average length 10-20 µm) with sulfuric acid/nitric acid (3:1 v/v, 98% and 69%) according to the protocol previously reported [50]. MWCNT-Ox (100 mg) in 25 mL of dry DMF were sonicated for 30 min, then EDC (112 mg, 0.58 mmol) and HOBt (40 mg, 0.30 mmol), were added and the black suspension was stirred at room temperature for one hour. EDABoc (55 mg, 0.24 mmol) was added and the reaction was stirred for 72 hours. Water/ethanol (1:1 mixture) was added and the crude reaction mixture was filtered under vacuum (Millipore, 0.1 µm), washed with an excess of water/ethanol and finally diethyl ether. The resulting MWCNT-EDABoc were dispersed in dioxane (10 mL) and treated with 5 mL of HCl 4 M at room temperature for 4 h. The mixture was filtered under vacuum (Millipore, 0.1 µm) and the precipitate was treated with 5 mL of triethylamine/water (1:4), thus obtaining MWCNT-EDA. This was washed several times with water/ethanol by successive bath sonication and centrifugation (8000 rpm 10 min) procedures and finally dried at 60 • C to give 60 mg of material. The amount of free amine groups on MWCNT-EDA was estimated by Kaiser test (0.22 mmol/g).
MWCNT-EPA were prepared by the coupling of MWCNT-Ox and EPA, in presence of EDC/HOBt, according to the amidation reaction procedure above described. The resulting MWCNT-EPA were washed several times with water/ethanol by successive bath sonication and centrifugation (8000 rpm 10 min) procedures and finally dried at 60 • C. Termogravimetric analysis (TGA) data indicated a weight loss of about 4.3% at 500 • C, which roughly corresponds to 0.22 mmol/g of EPA. The ninhydrin assay indicated an amount of free amino groups of 0.44 mmol/g. Primary amine loadings were measured spectroscopically using the colorimetric Kaiser conditions [51,52]. Commercial Kaiser test kit is composed of three solutions as it follows: (a) 0.5 g/mL of phenol in absolute EtOH; (b) 2 mL of potassium cyanide 1 mM (aqueous solution) dissolved in 98 mL of pyridine; (c) 0.05 g/mL of ninhydrin in absolute EtOH. Briefly, 0.5 mg of MWCNT-EDA or MWCNT-EPA were treated in sequence with 75 µL of solution (a), 100 µL of solution (b) and 75 µL of solution (c). The dispersion was sonicated in a water bath and then was heated at 120 • C for 5 min, diluted with 4750 µL of absolute EtOH and centrifugated at 14,000 rpm. The absorbance at 570 nm of supernatant was correlated to the amount of free amine groups on MWCNTs surface (NH 2 loading (mmol/g)); using the following equation: where dilution was fixed to 5 mL, optical path was 1 cm; sample weight was 0.5 mg; extinction coefficient (ε) was 15,000 M −1 cm −1 .
Dispersions of MWCNT-EDA and MWCNT-EPA (0.43 mg/mL) were prepared in 10 mM citrate buffer by bath sonication for 20 min. For the experiments, a volume of 100 µL has been used and diluted to a final concentration of 0.02 mg/mL. The interaction of TPPS with the two batches of MWCNTs has been investigated in citrate buffer solution (10 mM, pH 2.4) following two different mixing order procedures: (i) porphyrin-first protocol (PF) and (ii) porphyrin-last protocol (PL), consisting of the addition of a proper volume of MWCNTs dispersion to a diluted TPPS solution in citrate buffer and of the addition of TPPS from a stock solution to a diluted MWCNTs dispersion, respectively [43,53].
In some experiments MWCNT-EPA in citrate buffer has been previously mixed with NaCl (0.15 M), followed by the addition of TPPS. In all the experiments, the final concentration of TPPS was 5 µM.
UV-Vis spectra have been collected on a diode-array spectrophotometer Agilent model 8452. The circular dichroism (CD) spectra were recorded on a JASCO J-720 spectropolarimeter, equipped with a 450 W xenon lamp. CD spectra were corrected both for the cell and buffer contributions. A Jasco mod. FP-750 spectrofluorometer has been used to record fluorescence emission and Resonance Light Scattering (RLS) spectra. Emission spectra were not corrected for the absorption of the samples and a synchronous scan protocol with a right angle geometry was adopted for collecting RLS spectra [54]. All the aqueous dispersions were analysed by using a 1 cm optical path cuvette.
TGA was performed by using PerkinElmer Instruments Pyris1 TGA at a heating rate of 10 • C/min over the range from room temperature (r.t) to 1000 • C under N 2 atmosphere.
A TEM, JEM2100 LaB, working at 100 kV, and a digital Scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) set with BF & DF STEM Detectors plus SE/BSE detector (University of Exeter, UK) were used to investigate morphology of MWCNTs and MWCNTs/TPPS J-aggregates. Samples were prepared by evaporating ten drops of the aqueous dispersions of the investigated system more days after mixing (1-3 days) on 300 mesh holey-carbon coated copper grids.

Synthesis and Characterization of Amine Multiwalled Carbon Nanotubes
Amine multiwalled carbon nanotubes, MWCNT-EDA and MWCNT-EPA, were prepared by coupling of carboxylated MWCNTs (MWCNT-Ox) with tert-butyl 2-aminoethylcarbamate (EDABoc) or tetraethylenepentamine using EDC/HOBt in DMF according to Figure 1A,B, respectively. MWCNT-Ox were prepared by the oxidation (HNO 3 /H 2 SO 4 1:3, 6 h, 60 • C) of commercially available multiwalled carbon nanotubes according to a previously reported procedure [8,50]. citrate buffer and of the addition of TPPS from a stock solution to a diluted MWCNTs dispersion, respectively [43,53]. In some experiments MWCNT-EPA in citrate buffer has been previously mixed with NaCl (0.15 M), followed by the addition of TPPS. In all the experiments, the final concentration of TPPS was 5 µM. UV-Vis spectra have been collected on a diode-array spectrophotometer Agilent model 8452. The circular dichroism (CD) spectra were recorded on a JASCO J-720 spectropolarimeter, equipped with a 450 W xenon lamp. CD spectra were corrected both for the cell and buffer contributions. A Jasco mod. FP-750 spectrofluorometer has been used to record fluorescence emission and Resonance Light Scattering (RLS) spectra. Emission spectra were not corrected for the absorption of the samples and a synchronous scan protocol with a right angle geometry was adopted for collecting RLS spectra [54]. All the aqueous dispersions were analysed by using a 1 cm optical path cuvette.
TGA was performed by using PerkinElmer Instruments Pyris1 TGA at a heating rate of 10 °C/min over the range from room temperature (r.t) to 1000 °C under N2 atmosphere.
A TEM, JEM2100 LaB, working at 100 kV, and a digital Scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) set with BF & DF STEM Detectors plus SE/BSE detector (University of Exeter, UK) were used to investigate morphology of MWCNTs and MWCNTs/TPPS J-aggregates. Samples were prepared by evaporating ten drops of the aqueous dispersions of the investigated system more days after mixing (1-3 days) on 300 mesh holey-carbon coated copper grids.

Synthesis and Characterization of Amine Multiwalled Carbon Nanotubes
Amine multiwalled carbon nanotubes, MWCNT-EDA and MWCNT-EPA, were prepared by coupling of carboxylated MWCNTs (MWCNT-Ox) with tert-butyl 2-aminoethylcarbamate (EDABoc) or tetraethylenepentamine using EDC/HOBt in DMF according to Figure 1 A,B, respectively. MWCNT-Ox were prepared by the oxidation (HNO3/H2SO4 1:3, 6 h, 60 °C) of commercially available multiwalled carbon nanotubes according to a previously reported procedure [8,50]. The degree of functionalization of MWCNTs was investigated by TGA analysis (Figure 2) and the primary amines loadings was determined using the colorimetric Kaiser test [51,52].  The degree of functionalization of MWCNTs was investigated by TGA analysis (Figure 2) and the primary amines loadings was determined using the colorimetric Kaiser test [51,52].
According to literature data, a higher thermal stability of MWCNTs containing free amine groups has been detected with respect to the MWCNTs sample containing Boc-amine groups (MWCNT-EDA vs. MWCNT-EDABoc, Figure 2B) [55,56]. The significant weight loss of MWCNT-EDABoc in the range 100-300 °C (see DTG, inset Figure 2B) can be attributed to the thermal decomposition and rearrangement of the tert-butoxyl groups. On the basis of TGA data, it was not realistic to determine the degree of functionalization in terms of weight loss (∆m ≈ 0.9-1%) [57]. Thus, we have estimated the amount of free amine functional groups by the Kaiser test (0.22 mmol/g). TEM analyses of functionalized MWCNTs indicated that the chemical functionalization with amine groups preserved the characteristic morphology of multiwalled tubes scaffold. An average external diameter of 10 nm, corresponding to an average number of 8-10 layers were found. MWCNT-ox appeared strongly aggregates in bundles ( Figure 3A), whereas well distinct isolated MWCNTs are observed in TEM image of amine functionalized MWCNTs (MWCNT-EDA, Figure 3B and MWCNT-EPA, Figure 3C). Moreover, all the functionalized MWCNTs (MWCNT-Ox, MWCNT-EPA and MWCNT-EDA) were shortened by oxidation: the length was reduced from the micrometre (pristine MWCNTs, see Supplementary Figure S1) to nanometre scale [8,50].  The TGA curve of MWCNT-Ox shows a gradual weight loss of about 15.5% at 500 • C ( Figure 2A). MWCNT-EPA TGA profile displays two weight loss steps in the range 100-400 • C, likely due to decomposition of polyamine alkyl chain (inset of Figure 2A). From TGA data, a weight loss of about 4.3% at 500 • C which roughly corresponds to 0.22 mmol/g of EPA ( Figure 2A) has been estimated. By the correlation with the absorbance at 570 nm using the ninhydrin assay, an amount of free amino groups of 0.44 mmol/g has been determinated, probably suggesting a role of secondary amine groups in the amidation reactions ( Figure 1B).
According to literature data, a higher thermal stability of MWCNTs containing free amine groups has been detected with respect to the MWCNTs sample containing Boc-amine groups (MWCNT-EDA vs. MWCNT-EDABoc, Figure 2B) [55,56]. The significant weight loss of MWCNT-EDABoc in the range 100-300 • C (see DTG, inset Figure 2B) can be attributed to the thermal decomposition and rearrangement of the tert-butoxyl groups. On the basis of TGA data, it was not realistic to determine the degree of functionalization in terms of weight loss (∆m ≈ 0.9-1%) [57]. Thus, we have estimated the amount of free amine functional groups by the Kaiser test (0.22 mmol/g).
TEM analyses of functionalized MWCNTs indicated that the chemical functionalization with amine groups preserved the characteristic morphology of multiwalled tubes scaffold. An average external diameter of~10 nm, corresponding to an average number of 8-10 layers were found. MWCNT-ox appeared strongly aggregates in bundles ( Figure 3A), whereas well distinct isolated MWCNTs are observed in TEM image of amine functionalized MWCNTs (MWCNT-EDA, Figure 3B and MWCNT-EPA, Figure 3C). Moreover, all the functionalized MWCNTs (MWCNT-Ox, MWCNT-EPA and MWCNT-EDA) were shortened by oxidation: the length was reduced from the micrometre (pristine MWCNTs, see Supplementary Figure S1) to nanometre scale [8,50].
The TGA curve of MWCNT-Ox shows a gradual weight loss of about 15.5% at 500 °C ( Figure  2A). MWCNT-EPA TGA profile displays two weight loss steps in the range 100-400 °C, likely due to decomposition of polyamine alkyl chain (inset of Figure 2A). From TGA data, a weight loss of about 4.3% at 500 °C which roughly corresponds to 0.22 mmol/g of EPA ( Figure 2A) has been estimated. By the correlation with the absorbance at 570 nm using the ninhydrin assay, an amount of free amino groups of 0.44 mmol/g has been determinated, probably suggesting a role of secondary amine groups in the amidation reactions ( Figure 1B).
According to literature data, a higher thermal stability of MWCNTs containing free amine groups has been detected with respect to the MWCNTs sample containing Boc-amine groups (MWCNT-EDA vs. MWCNT-EDABoc, Figure 2B) [55,56]. The significant weight loss of MWCNT-EDABoc in the range 100-300 °C (see DTG, inset Figure 2B) can be attributed to the thermal decomposition and rearrangement of the tert-butoxyl groups. On the basis of TGA data, it was not realistic to determine the degree of functionalization in terms of weight loss (∆m ≈ 0.9-1%) [57]. Thus, we have estimated the amount of free amine functional groups by the Kaiser test (0.22 mmol/g). TEM analyses of functionalized MWCNTs indicated that the chemical functionalization with amine groups preserved the characteristic morphology of multiwalled tubes scaffold. An average external diameter of 10 nm, corresponding to an average number of 8-10 layers were found. MWCNT-ox appeared strongly aggregates in bundles ( Figure 3A), whereas well distinct isolated MWCNTs are observed in TEM image of amine functionalized MWCNTs (MWCNT-EDA, Figure 3B and MWCNT-EPA, Figure 3C). Moreover, all the functionalized MWCNTs (MWCNT-Ox, MWCNT-EPA and MWCNT-EDA) were shortened by oxidation: the length was reduced from the micrometre (pristine MWCNTs, see Supplementary Figure S1) to nanometre scale [8,50].  In order to obtain MWCNT-EDA/TPPS J-aggregates hybrids, the two aforementioned mixing order protocols (both PF and PL) have been used under mild acidic condition. Whatever of the procedure employed, we found that the extinction features of free diacid porphyrin (B band centered at 434 nm and Q bands at 592 and 645 nm) remained unchanged even after 1 day ( Figure 4A). No TPPS J aggregates were formed and no interaction between TPPS and MWCNT-EDA was revealed. This behavior could be ascribable to the presence of only one pendant amino group for chain in EDA, and this observation agrees with previous results on the role of the amine chain length in inducing the aggregation of TPPS [53]. In order to obtain MWCNT-EDA/TPPS J-aggregates hybrids, the two aforementioned mixing order protocols (both PF and PL) have been used under mild acidic condition. Whatever of the procedure employed, we found that the extinction features of free diacid porphyrin (B band centered at 434 nm and Q bands at 592 and 645 nm) remained unchanged even after 1 day ( Figure  4A). No TPPS J aggregates were formed, and no interaction between TPPS and MWCNT-EDA was revealed. This behavior could be ascribable to the presence of only one pendant amino group for chain in EDA, and this observation agrees with previous results on the role of the amine chain length in inducing the aggregation of TPPS [53]. On the other hand, upon the addition of the porphyrin to the MWCNT-EPA dispersion, the UV-Vis profile shows the spectral signatures both of the diacid form of TPPS (B-band at 434 nm) and of J-aggregates evidenced by their typical extinction band arising at 489 nm. During the time, we observed the decrease of the intensity of the diacid band accompanied by the increase of the intensity of J-band, which furthermore undergoes a bathochromic shift from 489 to 493 nm. After one day, at the end of the aggregation process, UV-Vis spectrum of MWCNT-EPA/TPPS exhibits the B and Q bands ascribable to the residual monomeric diacid form of TPPS and J-aggregates ( Figure  4B). It is noteworthy that the formation of J-aggregates does not occur under the same experimental conditions in absence of MWCNT-EPA, but it can be forced by decreasing the pH of the medium [42]. On the bases of the experimental evidences, we suggest that only EPA functionalized MWCNTs are able to trigger the TPPS aggregation process. This could be ascribable to the occurrence of an initial electrostatic interaction among a sufficient number of positively charged protonated amino groups on the CNTs surface and negatively charged sulfonated groups present in the periphery of the dyes [31,58]. Moreover, the observed red-shift of the extinction B-band of J-aggregates in the time On the other hand, upon the addition of the porphyrin to the MWCNT-EPA dispersion, the UV-Vis profile shows the spectral signatures both of the diacid form of TPPS (B-band at 434 nm) and of J-aggregates evidenced by their typical extinction band arising at 489 nm. During the time, we observed the decrease of the intensity of the diacid band accompanied by the increase of the intensity of J-band, which furthermore undergoes a bathochromic shift from 489 to 493 nm. After one day, at the end of the aggregation process, UV-Vis spectrum of MWCNT-EPA/TPPS exhibits the B and Q bands ascribable to the residual monomeric diacid form of TPPS and J-aggregates ( Figure 4B). It is noteworthy that the formation of J-aggregates does not occur under the same experimental conditions in absence of MWCNT-EPA, but it can be forced by decreasing the pH of the medium [42]. On the bases of the experimental evidences, we suggest that only EPA functionalized MWCNTs are able to trigger the TPPS aggregation process. This could be ascribable to the occurrence of an initial electrostatic interaction among a sufficient number of positively charged protonated amino groups on the CNTs surface and negatively charged sulfonated groups present in the periphery of the dyes [31,58]. Moreover, the observed red-shift of the extinction B-band of J-aggregates in the time could suggest a rearrangement of the aggregates due to an interaction with different amine-modified carbon nanotubes or their location in a different microenvironment with respect to the aqueous solution.
The emission spectrum (λ exc 455 nm), at the end of the aggregation process, shows the typical fluorescence emission of the diacid form of TPPS centered at 669 nm. Further, upon excitation on the J-aggregates band (λ exc 493 nm), an emission band at 717 nm can be also detectable ( Figure 5). The different ratio of the bands intensity at 669 and 717 nm at the two distinctive excitation wavelengths is due to the fluorescence emission generated from the aggregated species. This evidence is confirmed by the related excitation spectra (Figure 5 inset) showing spectral features for both the diacidic TPPS and J-aggregates. However, the monomeric porphyrin is the predominant species in the excitation profile at both emission wavelengths, due to its longer lifetime value with respect to the J-aggregate one [59,60]. could suggest a rearrangement of the aggregates due to an interaction with different amine-modified carbon nanotubes or their location in a different microenvironment with respect to the aqueous solution.
The emission spectrum (exc 455 nm), at the end of the aggregation process, shows the typical fluorescence emission of the diacid form of TPPS centered at 669 nm. Further, upon excitation on the J-aggregates band (exc 493 nm), an emission band at 717 nm can be also detectable ( Figure 5). The different ratio of the bands intensity at 669 and 717 nm at the two distinctive excitation wavelength is due to the fluorescence emission generated from the aggregated species. This evidence is confirmed by the related excitation spectra (Figure 5 inset) showing spectral features for both the diacidic TPPS and J-aggregates. However, the monomeric porphyrin is the predominant species in the excitation profile at both emission wavelengths, due to its longer lifetime value with respect to the J-aggregate one [59,60]. The RLS spectra recorded soon after mixing shows a very sharp peak in the red region of the extinction band which increases in intensity at the end of the aggregation process. These findings agree with our previous results [42], pointing to the formation of self-assemblies of electronically coupled porphyrins, which cause a large enhancement of the resonant light scattering [54] at the red-edge of the extinction peak ( Figure 6). The RLS spectra recorded soon after mixing shows a very sharp peak in the red region of the extinction band which increases in intensity at the end of the aggregation process. These findings agree with our previous results [42], pointing to the formation of self-assemblies of electronically coupled porphyrins, which cause a large enhancement of the resonant light scattering [54] at the red-edge of the extinction peak ( Figure 6). J-aggregates of TPPS induced by MWCNT-EPA were stable in acidic aqueous dispersion for a day or more after preparation. In difference with our previous findings on polyamine-mediated J-aggregates [30,31,61], the optical profiles are in line with the usual Frenkel exciton theory, rather than in terms of an extended network formed by the J-aggregates and amine modified MWCNTs in which dipole-dipole coupling among single porphyrins takes place. J-aggregates of TPPS induced by MWCNT-EPA were stable in acidic aqueous dispersion for a day or more after preparation. In difference with our previous findings on polyamine-mediated J-aggregates [30,31,61], the optical profiles are in line with the usual Frenkel exciton theory, rather than in terms of an extended network formed by the J-aggregates and amine modified MWCNTs in which dipole-dipole coupling among single porphyrins takes place.
CD spectra were recorded after freshly mixing of the components and at the end of the aggregation process ( Figure 7). As expected for achiral MWCNT-EPA, CD spectrum is silent before the addition of the chromophoric species, so confirming the absence of optical activity for amine modified CNTs. On the other hand, when TPPS was added a slight bisegnate positive Cotton effect in the aggregates absorption region has been observed. At the end of the aggregation process, an increase in intensity and a red shift of the CD profile were observed. This behavior, observed by means of spectroscopic and light scattering techniques, is due to the formation of large and rearranged structures as the result of the interactions among porphyrin aggregates and functionalized MWCNTs. CD spectra were recorded after freshly mixing of the components and at the end of the aggregation process ( Figure 7). As expected for achiral MWCNT-EPA, CD spectrum is silent before the addition of the chromophoric species, so confirming the absence of optical activity for amine modified CNTs. On the other hand, when TPPS was added a slight bisegnate positive Cotton effect in the aggregates absorption region has been observed. At the end of the aggregation process, an increase in intensity and a red shift of the CD profile were observed. This behavior, observed by means of spectroscopic and light scattering techniques, is due to the formation of large and rearranged structures as the result of the interactions among porphyrin aggregates and functionalized MWCNTs. J-aggregates of TPPS induced by MWCNT-EPA were stable in acidic aqueous dispersion for a day or more after preparation. In difference with our previous findings on polyamine-mediated J-aggregates [30,31,61], the optical profiles are in line with the usual Frenkel exciton theory, rather than in terms of an extended network formed by the J-aggregates and amine modified MWCNTs in which dipole-dipole coupling among single porphyrins takes place.
CD spectra were recorded after freshly mixing of the components and at the end of the aggregation process ( Figure 7). As expected for achiral MWCNT-EPA, CD spectrum is silent before the addition of the chromophoric species, so confirming the absence of optical activity for amine modified CNTs. On the other hand, when TPPS was added a slight bisegnate positive Cotton effect in the aggregates absorption region has been observed. At the end of the aggregation process, an increase in intensity and a red shift of the CD profile were observed. This behavior, observed by means of spectroscopic and light scattering techniques, is due to the formation of large and rearranged structures as the result of the interactions among porphyrin aggregates and functionalized MWCNTs. In agreement with the spectroscopic characterization, representative TEM images of MWCNT-EPA/TPPS J-aggregates pointed to the coexistence of both MWCNT-EPA and TPPS J-aggregates in the same area (Figure 8 and Supplementary Figure S2). In particular, TPPS J-aggregates with an average diameter of 45 nm and length of 250-500 nm seem to be wrapped by separate nanotubes or bundles of MWCNT-EPA having an average external diameter of about 15 nm.  Figure S3). Interestingly, in the marked area ( Figure  8 panel C), the total elements merging (Figure 8 panel B) appears to be similar to the carbon/sulfur merging (Figure 8 panel D). These results evidence the co-localization of TPPS J-aggregates and carbon nanotubes in the investigated samples. Since self-organization phenomenon is a hierarchical process, it is well known as the morphology of final aggregates can be controlled by the mixing order protocol [43]. In this framework, we performed experiments by adding amine carbon nanotubes to diacid TPPS (PF protocol). Surprisingly, at the end of the aggregation process, all the spectroscopic ( Supplementary Figures S4 and S5) and morphological features (Supplementary Figure S6) show no change with respect to that observed by previous reagent mixing order protocol (PL). Because, in the case of the self-aggregation of neat TPPS in acidic conditions [43], the mixing order protocol is strictly related to the occurrence of porphyrin nucleation phenomena, here, we are prone to think that MWCNT-EPA could act as nucleation centers, inducing dye aggregation independently by the mixing order protocol.
In order to verify the stability of MWCNT-EPA/TPPS J-aggregates in mimicking physiological medium (NaCl 0.9% w/w  0.15 M), the system has been prepared by firstly dispersing MWCNT-EPA in NaCl 0.15 M aqueous solution and then adding TPPS. Under these conditions, the spectroscopic evidences of the final system remain almost unchanged (Figure 9) with respect to the unsalted solutions thus confirming the formation of chromophoric assemblies. The premixing of MWCNTs and NaCl, followed by the addition of porphyrin, seems to lead to a larger amount of J-aggregates due to the ionic strength effect [62]. Generally, optical stability for J-aggregates is difficult to achieve. Therefore, the use of surfactans or the entrapment in liposomes of the dye  Figure S3). Interestingly, in the marked area ( Figure 8C), the total elements merging ( Figure 8B) appears to be similar to the carbon/sulfur merging ( Figure 8D). These results evidence the co-localization of TPPS J-aggregates and carbon nanotubes in the investigated samples. Since self-organization phenomenon is a hierarchical process, it is well known as the morphology of final aggregates can be controlled by the mixing order protocol [43]. In this framework, we performed experiments by adding amine carbon nanotubes to diacid TPPS (PF protocol). Surprisingly, at the end of the aggregation process, all the spectroscopic (Supplementary Figures S4 and S5) and morphological features (Supplementary Figure S6) show no change with respect to that observed by previous reagent mixing order protocol (PL). Because, in the case of the self-aggregation of neat TPPS in acidic conditions [43], the mixing order protocol is strictly related to the occurrence of porphyrin nucleation phenomena, here, we are prone to think that MWCNT-EPA could act as nucleation centers, inducing dye aggregation independently by the mixing order protocol.
In order to verify the stability of MWCNT-EPA/TPPS J-aggregates in mimicking physiological medium (NaCl 0.9% w/w 0.15 M), the system has been prepared by firstly dispersing MWCNT-EPA in NaCl 0.15 M aqueous solution and then adding TPPS. Under these conditions, the spectroscopic evidences of the final system remain almost unchanged (Figure 9) with respect to the unsalted solutions thus confirming the formation of chromophoric assemblies. The premixing of MWCNTs and NaCl, followed by the addition of porphyrin, seems to lead to a larger amount of J-aggregates due to the ionic strength effect [62]. Generally, optical stability for J-aggregates is difficult to achieve. Therefore, the use of surfactans or the entrapment in liposomes of the dye forming J-aggregates were experienced in literature [21]. In our case, MWCNTs induce, whatever the preparation procedure, the formation of stable J-aggregates able to retain their optical properties even after more days (1-3 days). Therefore, no further manipulation to preserve their pristine optical properties was necessary. forming J-aggregates were experienced in literature [21]. In our case, MWCNTs induce, whatever the preparation procedure, the formation of stable J-aggregates able to retain their optical properties even after more days (1-3 days). Therefore, no further manipulation to preserve their pristine optical properties was necessary. Altogether, the combination of drug carrier ability of MWCNTs with the theranostic properties of porphyrins could allow the development of MWCNTs/TPPS J-aggregates nanohybrids for applications in biomedical field. Unlike from the others families of hybrid carbon nanomaterials [9], the potential applications in biological/pharmaceutical field of carbon based nanomaterialsporphyrins appear still scarcely investigated, especially for J-aggregates self-assemblies as well as their intracellular trafficking, therapeutic and imaging properties. In the literature, it was observed that hybrids nanomaterials based on porphyrinoids [24,63] were prepared at pH different from physiological conditions, and then treated with cells. In this context, future work will be devoted to studying the biocompatibility and cellular uptake of our hybrid MWCNTs/J-aggregates supramolecular systems. With these perspectives in mind, this research could lay the groundwork for the incoming biological assessment of MWCNT-EPA/TPPS J-aggregates.

Conclusions
MWCNTs can be easily functionalized by covalently introducing pendant amino-groups on their surface. In this paper, we used ethylenediamine (EDA) and tetraethylenepentamine (EPA), which after coupling with carboxylic groups on the exterior walls, led to one and four protonable amino groups for chain, respectively. Under mild acidic conditions, the diacid form of TPPS is able to electrostatically bind to the surface and eventually aggregate. In line with our previous Altogether, the combination of drug carrier ability of MWCNTs with the theranostic properties of porphyrins could allow the development of MWCNTs/TPPS J-aggregates nanohybrids for applications in biomedical field. Unlike from the others families of hybrid carbon nanomaterials [9], the potential applications in biological/pharmaceutical field of carbon based nanomaterials-porphyrins appear still scarcely investigated, especially for J-aggregates self-assemblies as well as their intracellular trafficking, therapeutic and imaging properties. In the literature, it was observed that hybrids nanomaterials based on porphyrinoids [24,63] were prepared at pH different from physiological conditions, and then treated with cells. In this context, future work will be devoted to studying the biocompatibility and cellular uptake of our hybrid MWCNTs/J-aggregates supramolecular systems. With these perspectives in mind, this research could lay the groundwork for the incoming biological assessment of MWCNT-EPA/TPPS J-aggregates.

Conclusions
MWCNTs can be easily functionalized by covalently introducing pendant amino-groups on their surface. In this paper we used ethylenediamine (EDA) and tetraethylenepentamine (EPA), which after coupling with carboxylic groups on the exterior walls, led to one and four protonable amino groups for chain, respectively. Under mild acidic conditions, the diacid form of TPPS is able to electrostatically bind to the surface and eventually aggregate. In line with our previous investigations on the ability of polyamines to trigger the aggregation of TPPS, the presence of only one pendant amino group (EDA) is not enough to induce the formation of TPPS J-aggregates, whatever the mixing protocol. On the other hand, when EPA functionality is present, these species are effective to generate stable MWCNT-EPA/TPPS J-aggregates nanohybrids and their general spectroscopic features are rather independent on the mixing protocol. A similar behavior was observed in solutions mimicking physiological medium (NaCl 0.15 M), whereby stable nanohybrids were also obtained. These systems exhibit remarkable optical features, and in this perspective could be considered for potential applications in phototherapy (by irradiating on extinction bands at 491 nm and/or at 709 nm) and/or bio-imaging (by exploiting the fluorescent emission band at 716 nm). In this respect, this class of amine-modified MWCNTs could be investigated as carriers of J-aggregates in biological environment. All these optical and structural properties make MWCNT-EPA/TPPS J-aggregates appealing for further considerations in theranostic.