The Effect of pBond Screening on the Reaction of s-Tetrazines with 7-Substituted Benzonorbornadienes

Benzonorbornadiene 21, 7-spirocyclopropylbenzonorbornadiene 23, 7,7-dimethylbenzonorbornadiene 25 , and 7-spirocyclopentylbenzonorbornadiene 27 have been reacted with 3,6-di(2-pyridyl)-s-tetrazine (21>23>25=27) to form symmetrical 4,5-hydropyridazines which are stable towards fragmentation but rearrange with varying facility to their 1,4 isomers. The facial selectivity of attack on the p-bond changes from exo-attack for 21 and 23 to endo-attack for 25 and 27. The 7-spirocyclopropylbenzonorbornadiene 23 typically forms a mixture of dihydropyridazines with exo-stereochemistry, which undergo further stereochemical isomerisation to an exo-fused product upon acetylation (acetyl chloride in hot pyridine). Oxidation with DDQ of these dihydro compounds individually or as mixtures gives the corresponding fused 3,6-dipyridylpyridazines. The use of norbornadiene 1 as a transfer reagent for acetylene is well established1 and its reaction with s-tetrazines is representative. This is now an established method for the conversion of s-tetrazines to pyridazines where norbornadiene provides the C4 and C5 atoms of the pyridazine ring.2 The reaction of norbornadiene 1 with 3,6-di(2pyridyl)s-tetrazine 2 is illustrated in Scheme 1 and involves the following Diels-Alder sequence: Diels-Alder addition of 2 onto 1 to form the transient, primary intermediate 3 which instantaneously collapses by retro-Diels-Alder elimination of dinitrogen, to afford the dihydropyridazine 4. A second retro-Diels-Alder reaction of 4 yields cyclopentadiene 5 and the pyridazine 6. The reaction is extremely facile with the diene 4 being formed rapidly at room temperature and complete fragmentation to 5 and 6 can be achieved by gentle heating (50-60 oC) for a few minutes. While the pyridazine 6 is the target in this reaction, it is very often the other fragmentation partner which is the more appealing. Thus, replacement of the 7-methano carbon of norbornadiene with hetero atoms 9 has been used to form substituted furans 10 or pyrroles 11, and replacement with a vinylidene bridge allows access to fulvenes, eg 12.3 This is especially useful for the preparation of 3,4-disustituted derivatives of these ring-systems where the short sequence from the unsubstituted ring 7 to the substituted compounds 10-12 is shown Scheme 1.

In this report, we describe the reaction of s-tetrazine 2 with benzonorbornadiene 21 and some of its derivatives 23, 25 and 27, where the 7-methano bridge of 21 have been modified by alkyl or ring substituents.The other feature of this study was to establish the effect that modification of the 7-substituent would have on the facial selectivity of attack at the norbornene p-bond and to assess this as a geometry-controlling element in the 'lego' block building program.
At the commencement of this program, benzonorbornadiene 21 and the spirocyclopropyl derivative 23 had been reported (Scheme 4).The 7,7-dimethyl-derivative 25 was prepared using similar methodology by reacting 5,5dimethylcyclopentadiene 9 with benzyne and isolated as a liquid.The 1 H n.m.r.spectrum was very simple reflecting the expected Cs-symmetry of 25: singlets at d 0.79, 1.25 for the methyl protons, with the higher-field resonance being ascribed to the methyl group under the shielding influence of the aromatic ring; coupled resonances between the bridgehead protons (d 3.34) and for the vinyl protons (d 6.65) and two sets of finger-like quartets for the aromatic protons at d 6.8-7.2 are entirely in congruence with the assigned structure.

Scheme 4
The spirocyclopentyl derivative 27 was prepared from spiro [4,4]nona-1,3-diene 26 10 and benzyne in a similar fashion and it also was a liquid.The 1 H n.m.r.spectrum was essentialy identical with 25 except that the singlet methyl protons were replaced with a broad multiplet at d 1.1-1.9 for the cyclopentyl methylene protons.

Scheme 5
The reaction of the s-tetrazine 2 with benzonorbornadiene 21 (Scheme 5) was conducted in chloroform at 30 o C and monitored by 1 H n.m.r.spectroscopy ; three traces are shown in Figure 1.This indicated that significant reaction has occurred after 10 min (Figure 1, trace 1a) to produce a single compound characterised by having singlet resonances at d 3.58 and 3.79 assigned to the methine protons Ha, Hb of the 4,5-dihydropyridazine 28.While conversion of 21 to 28 was complete after 30 min, evidence for the formation of a second product had emerged (Figure 1, trace 1b) and become the almost exclusive product after 2 hours (Figure 1, trace c).This new product has lost the Cs symmetry of its precursor 28 and was assigned the rearranged 1,4-dihydropyridazine structure 29; there is good precedent for this rearrangement. 11It was characterised by the presence of four singlets d 9.27, 4.36, 4.67, 2.67 where the low-field resonance is assigned to the NH proton, the presence of which was already confirmed by i.r.spectroscopy (n max 3350 cm -1 ), and this assignment is supported by exchange with DO-in D 2 O.The resonance at d 2.76 is attributed to the Hb proton of the heterocyclic ring which might be expected to resonate at much lower field as it is doubly allylic, so clearly an upfield component is also operative.The commonality of basic ring-structures in 28 and 29 was confirmed by oxidation of mixtures of these products with dichlorodicyanoquinone (DDQ) to the same Cs-symmetric pyridazine 30.
When the spirocyclopropylbenzonorbornadiene 23 was treated with s-tetrazine 2 (Scheme 6), only slow evolution of nitrogen was observed.The 4,5-dihydropyridazine intermediate 31 was none-the-less the first-formed product as deduced from the time-dependent 1 H n.m.r.study shown in Figure 3.The structure of the fused 4,5-dihydropyridazine 31 was again indicated by the presence of two singlet methine resonances at d 3.21 and 3.67 which confirmed both the Cs symmetry of the product and its exostereochemistry (no 3J-coupling).Furthermore, under normal reaction conditions (56 o C), this intermediate did not fragment further to yield the respective isoindene, but preferentially underwent rearrangement.The fact that rearrangement product 34 retained the benzonorbornanyl ring-structure present in its precursor 31, was established by oxidation with DDQ, 12 where the same pyridazine 33, mass spectrum (M+ m/z 374), was produced from enriched mixtures favouring each product.The 1 H n.m.r. of 33 was consistent with that expected for a structure of high symmetry (Figure 4).
The structure of 1,4-dihydropyridazine 34 was assigned very much by analogy with 29 and in an attempt to form a derivative suitable for characterisation, it was treated with acetyl chloride in pyridine at reflux overnight.The isolated product had the expected mass spectral peak at m/z = 418 for an acetyl derivative and an M-43 peak, corresponding to a loss of -COCH3, the 1H n.m.r.spectrum (Figure 5) indicated that rearrangement had occurred.The fact that there was vicinal coupling between protons Ha and Hb (d 4.0, d 4.1 J = 3.8 Hz) excluded the structure 35 (endo-Hb) and supported the structure 38 (exo-Hb).This assignment was also supported by the increased dispersion of the aromatic resonances, a manifestation of the proximity of the phenyl and one of the pyridyl rings. 13The expected acetate methyl group occurred as a characteristic, sharp singlet (d 2.32).
A clue to the mechanism for inversion of stereochemistry which occurred during the acetylation, is apparent in the deuterium exchange spectrum (Figure 3, trace c and above) of the starting material 35 where Hb was exchanged under the basic conditions as well as the NH proton.This implicated the anion 36, demonstrating the acidity of the methine proton at the bridgehead of the heterocyclic ring.Accordingly, formation of the acetate 35 may well occur but isomerisation to the observed product would ensue since formation of anion 36 would be favoured under the basic conditions of the reaction which is conducted in pyridine at reflux, and protonation from the favoured exo-face would yield the observed product 38.The reaction between benzonorbornadiene 21 and s-tetrazine 2, which was essentially complete after 2 hours at room temperature, occurred at least an order of magnitude faster than that observed for spirocyclopropyl derivative 23.What, then, if the norbornene p-bond was even more screened by the 7-substituents?The time-dependent 1 H n.m.r.study of the reaction of s-tetrazine 2 with the 7,7-dimethylbenzonorbornadiene 25 (Figure 6) confirmed that reaction was even slower, with essentially no change having occurred at room temperature after 12 hours (Figure 5, trace a).Increasing the temperature to 56 o C confirmed that reaction would proceed, but there were differences.First, the reaction yielded the dehydrogenated pyridazine 41 as the major reaction product after 36 hours (Figure 5, trace c).Secondly, the spectral data indicated that initial attack had occurred from the endo-face of 25.There was also evidence to support an apparent equilibrium between symmetric dihydropyridazine 39 and the unsymmetrical isomer 40 being maintained prior to dehydrogenation to the pyridazine 41.The resonance ascribed to exo-protons Hb (annotated in Figure 5) in either dihydropyridazine 39 or 40 showed no evidence for deuterium exchange which reflected their crowded environment as expected if the exo-stereochemical assignment was correctly assigned.
This change from exo-attack on 23 to endo-attack on 25 by s-tetrazine 2 was entirely in keeping with the known ability of syn-substituents on the methano-bridge to screen the p-bond, and has been observed in other systems.Thus, it was not surprising to find that the predicted endo-attack for the reaction of 2 with the spirocyclopentylbenzonorbornadiene 27 was also observed in practice.The slow rate of attack at the p-bond of 27 by 2 was very similar to that for the 7,7-dimethyl derivative 25, but conversion of the intermediate dihydropyridazines 42 and 43 to the pyridazine 44 was even faster.The time-dependent 1 H n.m.r.study (Figure 7) provided evidence for endo-attack of 2 at the p-bond of 27, and was again based on the coupling between Ha and Hb (see annotations for relevant proton assignments).Rearrangement to the 1,4-isomer was accompanied by substantial oxidation to the pyridazine 44 upon raising the temperature to 60 o C, however, oxidation was still incomplete after 36 hours.

Conclusion:
The attack of s-tetrazine 2 on the p-bond of benzonorbornedienes is markedly influenced by the substituents at the 7position.Exo-attack occurred with the parent system 21, and a similar facial selectivity was observed with the spirocyclobenzonorbornadiene 23, however the reaction was much slower.Introduction of the spirocyclopentyl at the 7-position screened the exo-face from attack and forced endo-facial attack to occur; a similar result was obtained with the gem-dimethyl derivative 25.The initially-formed 1,3-dihydropyridazines were unstable and were, in all cases, transformed by prototropic isomerisation to their 1,4-isomers, which dehydrogenated to the related pyridazine under the reaction conditions in compounds with the endo-precursors, or by specific dehydrogenation (DDQ) in the case of the exo-products.

Experimental
All melting points were determined on a Reichert hot-stage microscope, and are uncorrected.Microanalyses were performed by the Australian National University Microanalytical Service.Ultraviolet spectra were recorded on a Unicam SP800 spectrophotometer, using matched 5 mm or 10 mm silica cells.Infrared spectra were recorded on either a Unicam SP200G spectrophotometer or a Perkin-Elmer 283 spectrophotometer.Unless otherwise specified, infrared spectra were obtained using a Nujol mull between sodium chloride discs.Where spectra were recorded on solutions, they were obtained using 1 mm sodium chloride cavity cells.The intensities of i.r.absorptions are reported as s (strong, > 50% intensity of maximum absorption), m (medium, 25-50% max.) or w (weak, 12-25% max.). 1 H n.m.r.spectra were recorded on a Varian CFT20 (80 MHz, Fourier mode), a Jeol JNM-MH-100 (100 MHz, continuous wave), or a Brucker HFX-270 (270 MHz, Fourier mode). 13C n.m.r.spectra were recorded on a Jeol JNM-FX-60 (15.04 MHz), a Varian CFT-20 (20.00 MHz) or a Brucker HFX-270 (67.89 MHz) n.m.r.spectrometer. 1H and 13 C n.m.r.spectra were obtained using solutions in 5 mm and 10 mm tubes respectively, with tetramethylsilane (TMS) as internal standard.All chemical shifts are expressed in parts per million (ppm) downfield from TMS (d scale).Coupling constants (J) are given in Hertz, with multiplicity patterns designated as s (singlet), d (doublet), t (triplet), q (quartet), m (multiplet) and br (broad).Simulated spectra were calculated using the NTCSIM or ITRCAL procedures, available as part of the Nicolet 1180 Fourier Package.Low resolution mass spectra were recorded on either a Varian MAT CH7 or an A.E.I.MS902 mass spectrometer.The latter instrument was used for high resolution mass measurements.Unless otherwise stated, all peaks greater than 5% of the intensity of the base peak are reported.Combined GC-MS was carried out using a Varian MAT 111 (0.125 inch column, 2% OV-17) system.Gas chromatographic analyses, and preparative separations were performed on either a Hewlet-Packard Model 5754B (12 ft x 0.25 inch metal column, 10% SE 30 on 60-100 mesh Embacel) or a Packard 7400 Series (2 m x 1 cm glass column, 10% SE 30 on 44-60 mesh Embacel) instrument.A Waters Associates Series 6000 system was used for analytical HPLC.Preparative thinlayer chromatography was carried out on 20 x 100 cm glass plates using silica gel (Merck HP254 as absorbent, or on 20 x 20 cm Merck precoated (2 mm, 60 F254) PLC plates.Either Spence Type H activated alumina or May and Baker chromatography silica gel was employed in column chromatography.

Figure 3 1
Figure 3 1 H nmr spectra (80 MHz; CDCl 3 ) of products resulting from the reaction between s-tetrazine 2 and 7-spirocyclopropylbenzonorbornadiene 23 after a) 30 min at 30 o C b) 120 min at 30 o C c) 24 hours at 60 o C