THE AVIAN SONG OVER TIME: VARIABILITY AND STABILITY

Cover Page

Cite item

Full Text

Open Access Open Access
Restricted Access Access granted
Restricted Access Subscription Access

Abstract

Information is reviewed on the dynamics of bird singing over time, analyzing the rate of change in individual and population repertoires, and considering the factors affecting the rate of such changes. The available data indicate very significant periods of persistence of vocal patterns (song types) in songbird populations. The rate of change in population and individual repertoires is higher in species with an unlimited period of imprinting a song compared to species with a fixed period. The population repertoire of song types in numerous populations inhabiting vast and continuous habitats is more stable than in small and isolated populations occupying structurally fragmented habitats. The most common vocal patterns are the most conserved from year to year, while rare variants often disappear from the population repertoire over time. Abnormal climatic phenomena that cause significant changes in the age composition of populations contribute to rapid changes of dialects. The cases of rapid synchronous changes in vocal repertoires in individuals in local populations, as well as in populations separated from each other by a great distance, are considered in detail. The causes that give rise to this need further research. The most likely reasons may be an exchange of vocal models at wintering grounds or the simultaneous introduction of a large number of migrants into the study populations, which in species with an open training period may cause changes in the repertoire of local individuals also borrowing new vocal models.

About the authors

V. V. Ivanitskii

Faculty of Biology, Lomonosov Moscow State University

Author for correspondence.
Email: vladivanit@yandex.ru
Russia, 119991, Moscow

I. M. Marova

Faculty of Biology, Lomonosov Moscow State University

Email: vladivanit@yandex.ru
Russia, 119991, Moscow

References

  1. Иваницкий В.В., Марова И.М., 2022. Слитная и раздельная песни в акустической коммуникации птиц и других животных // Зоологический журнал. Т. 101. С. 791–804.
  2. Кисляков И.В., Иваницкий В.В., 2017. Изменчивость и пространственная дифференциация песни зяблика (Fringilla coelebs) в городе Москве // Зоологический журнал. Т. 96. С. 960–972.
  3. Комарова И.А., 2015. Массовое размножение короеда-типографа в 2010–2014 гг. и защита еловых насаждений // Охрана и защита лесов. Т. 3. С. 22–32.
  4. Марова И.М., Антипов В.А., Иваницкий В.В., 2015. Аномальные погодные явления и горизонтальный перенос вокальных моделей у восточного соловья (Luscinia luscinia) // Доклады Академии Наук. Т. 463. С. 120–123.
  5. Соколов Л.В., 1986. Филопатрия и дисперсия птиц // Труды Зоологического институт АН СССР. Т. 230. 232 с.
  6. Яблоновская-Грищенко Е.Д., Грищенко В.Н., 2007. Диалекты песни зяблика на территории Лесной и Лесостепной зон Украины и региона Украинских Карпат // Беркут. Т. 16. С. 111–122.
  7. Aplin L.M., 2019. Culture and cultural evolution in birds: a review of the evidence // Animal Behavior. V. 147. P. 179–187.
  8. Avery M., Oring L., 1977. Song dialects in the bobolink (Dolichonyx oryzivorus) // Condor. V. 79. P. 113–118.
  9. Beecher M.D., 2017. Birdsong learning as a social process // Animal Behavior. V. 124. P. 233–246.
  10. Böhner J., Wistel-Wozniak A., 1995. Chaffinch Fringilla coelebs song in western and southern Poland: song types, repertoire sizes, and the terminal element “kit” // Acta Ornithologica. V. 30. P. 107–115.
  11. Browne S.J., 2004. Some aspects of chaffinch Fringilla coelebs biology, based on an analysis of individuals ringed during 1991 to 2003 in Norfolk, England // Ringing & Migration. V. 22. P. 75–82.
  12. Byers B.E., Belinsky K.L., Bentley R.A., 2010. Independent cultural evolution of two song traditions in the chestnut-sided warbler // American Naturalist. V. 176. P. 476–489.
  13. Catchpole C.K., Slater P.J.B., 2008. Bird song: biological themes and variations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 335 p.
  14. Cerchio S., Jacobsen J.K., Norris Th., 2001.Temporal and geographical variation in songs of humpback whales, Megaptera novaeangliae: synchronous change in Hawaiian and Mexican breeding assemblages // Animal Behavior. V. 62. P. 313–329.
  15. Conrads K., 1986. Stabilität und Veränderungen eines Gesangsdialektes des Buchfinken (Fringilla coelebs) im Zeitraum von 1964/66 bis 1982/83 in Ostwestfalen // Bericht des Naturwissenschaftlichen Vereins für Bielefeld und Umgegend. Bd. 28. S. 191–212.
  16. Cooper J.E.J., 2020. On the evolution of vocal development in island chaffinch populations. PhD Thesis. Queen Mary University of London. 229 p.
  17. Derryberry E.P., 2007. Evolution of bird song affects signal efficacy: an experimental test using historical and current signals // Evolution. V. 61. P. 1938–1945.
  18. Derryberry E.P., 2011. Male response to historical and geographical variation in bird song // Biology Letters. V. 7. P. 57–59.
  19. García N.C., Arrieta R.S., Kopuchian C., Tubaro P.L., 2015. Stability and change through time in the dialects of a Neotropical songbird, the rufous–collared sparrow // Emu. V. 115. P. 309–316.
  20. Garland E.C., Goldizen A.W., Rekdahl M.L., Constantine R., Garrigue C., Daeschler N., Hauser N.D., Poole M.M., Robbins J., Noad M.J., 2011. Dynamic horizontal cultural transmission of humpback whale song at the ocean basin scale // Current Biology. V. 21. P. 687–691.
  21. Garland E.C., McGregor P.K., 2020. Cultural transmission, evolution, and revolution in vocal displays: insights from bird and whale song // Frontiers in Psychology 11: | https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.544929
  22. Goodale E., Podos J., 2010. Persistence of song types in Darwin’s finches, Geospiza fortis, over four decades // Biology Letters. V. 6. P. 589–592.
  23. Harbison H., Nelson D., Hahn T., 1999. Long–term persistence of song dialects in the mountain white–crowned sparrow // Condor. V. 101. P. 133–148.
  24. Holland J., McGregor P.K., Rowe C.L., 1996. Changes in microgeographic song variation of the corn bunting Miliaria calandra // Journal of Avian Biology. V. 27. P. 47–55.
  25. Ince S.A., Slater P.J.B., Weismann C., 1980. Changes with time in the songs of a population of chaffinches // Condor. V. 82. P. 285–290.
  26. Ivanitskii V., Marova I., Antipov V.A., 2022. Parallel cultural change in thrush nightingale song in distant populations // Journal of Ornithology. V. 164. P. 407–415.
  27. Ivanitskii V., Marova I., Samsonova I., Volodin I., Volodina E., 2023. Four decades later: the highly conserved repertoire of song types in chaffinch // Behavioral Processes. V. 205 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.beproc.2023.104821
  28. Jäckel D., Mortega K.G., Brockmeyer U., Gerlind U.C., Lehmann G.U.C., Silke L., Voigt-Heucke S.L., 2022. Unravelling the stability of nightingale song over time and space using open, citizen science and shared data // Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution. V. 10. https://doi.org/10.3389/fevo.2022.778610
  29. Janes S.W., Ryker L., 2013. Rapid changes in a Type 1 song dialect of hermit warbler (Setophaga occidentalis) // Auk. V. 130. P. 30−35.
  30. Ju C., Frances C., Geller F.C., Mundinger P.C., Lahti D.C., 2019. Four decades of cultural evolution in house finch songs // Auk. V. 136. P. 1–18.
  31. Koetz A.H., Westcottand D.A., Congdon B.C., 2007. Geographical variation in song frequency and structure: The effects of vicariant isolation, habitat type and body size // Animal Behaviour. V. 74. P. 1573–1583.
  32. Kopuchian C., Lijtmaer D.A., Tubaro P.L., Handford P., 2004. Temporal stability and change in a microgeographical pattern of song variation in the rufous–collared sparrow // Animal Behavior. V. 68. P. 551–559.
  33. Krebs J.R., Kroodsma D.E., 1980. Repertoires and geographical variation in bird song // Advanced in the Study of Behavior. V. 11. P. 143–177.
  34. Kroodsma D., 2004. The diversity and plasticity of birdsong // In Nature’s Music. The Science of Birdsong. London: Elsevier Academic Press. (eds P. Marler and H. Slabbecoorn). P. 108–131.
  35. Lachlan R.F., Ratmann O., Nowicki S., 2018. Cultural conformity generates extremely stable traditions in bird song // Nature Communications. V. 9. 2417.
  36. Lachlan R.F., Slater P.J.B., 2003. Song learning by chaffinches: how accurate, and from where? // Animal Behavior. V. 65. P. 957–969.
  37. Lachlan R.F., Verzijden M.N., Bernard C.S., Jonker P.-P., Koese B., Jaarsma S., Spoor W., Slater P.J.B., ten Cate C., 2013. The progressive loss of syntactical structure in bird song along an island colonization chain // Current Biology. V. 23. P. 1896–1901.
  38. Lynch A., Baker A.J., 1993. A population memetics approach to cultural evolution in chaffinch song: meme diversity within populations // American Naturalist. V. 141. P. 597–620.
  39. Lynch A., Baker A.J., 1994. A population memetics approach to cultural evolution in chaffinch song: differentiation among populations // Evolution. V. 48. P. 351–359.
  40. Luther D.A., Baptista L., 2010. Urban noise and the cultural evolution of bird songs // Proceeding of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences. V. 277. P. 469–473.
  41. Martens J. 1996. Vocalizations and speciation in Palearctic birds. In Ecology and evolution of acoustic communication in birds. Eds D.E. Kroodsma, E.H. Miller. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University PressP. 221–240.
  42. McGregor P.K., Holland J., Shepherd M., 1995. The ecology of corn bunting Miliaria calandra song dialects and their potential use in conservation. The ecology and conservation of corn bunting Miliaria calandra // Proceedings of a conference held at Fordingbridge, Hampshire, 2–3 March 1995. Eds P.F. Donald, N.J. Aebischer. P. 76–87.
  43. Mikkonen A., 1983. Breeding site tenacity of the chaffinch Fringilla coelebs and the brambling F. montifringilla in Northern Finland // Ornis Scandinavica. V. 14. P. 36–47.
  44. Mundinger P.C., 1982. Microgeographic and macro–geographic variation in the acquired vocalizations in birds. In: Kroodsma D.E., Miller E.H. (Eds). Acoustic Communication in Birds. V. 2. New York: Plenum Press. P. 147–208.
  45. Nelson D.A., Hallberg K.I., Soha J.A., 2004. Cultural evolution of puget sound white–crowned sparrow song dialects // Ethology. V. 110. P. 879–908.
  46. Noad M., Cato D.H., Bryden M.M., Jenner M., Jenner K.C.S., 2000. Cultural revolution in whale songs // Nature. V. 408. P. 537.
  47. Otter K.A., Mckenna A., LaZerte S.E., Ramsay S.M., 2020. Continent–wide shifts in song dialects of white–throated sparrows // Current Biology. V. 30. P. 3231–3235.
  48. O’Loghlen A.L., Ellis V.A., Zaratziar D., Merril L., Rothstein S.I., 2013. Fidelity of song imitation and stability of dialect songs in brown–headed cowbirds // Condor. V. 115. P. 677–686.
  49. Parker T.H., Sousa B., Leu S.T., Edmondson S., Foo C., Strauss A.V., Kahl H., Ballinger K., Ross E., Große Ruse M., Sandsten M., Verheijen B.H.F., Jensen W., 2022. Cultural conformity and persistence in dickcissel song are higher in locations in which males show high site fidelity // Ornithology. V. 139. ukab061. https://doi.org/10.1093/ornithology/ukab061
  50. Payne R.B., 1985. Behavioral continuity and change in local song populations of village indigobirds Vidua chalybeate // Zeitschrift für Tierpsychologie. V. 70. P. 1–44.
  51. Payne R.B., Payne L.L., Doechlert S.M., 1988. Biological and cultural success of song memes in indigo buntings // Ecology. V. 69. P. 104–117.
  52. Payne R.B., Thompson W.L., Fiala K.L., Sweany L.L., 1981. Local song traditions in indigo buntings: cultural transmission of behavior patterns across generations // Behaviour. V. 77. P. 199–221.
  53. Podos J., Peters S., Rudnicky T., Marler P., Nowicki S., 1992. The organization of song repertoires in song sparrows: themes and variations // Ethology. V. 90. P. 89–106.
  54. Podos J., Warren P.S., 2007. The evolution of geographic variation in birdsong // Advances in the Study of Behavior. V. 37. P. 403–458.
  55. Slater P.J.B., Clements F.A., Goodfellow D.J., 1984. Local and regional variations in chaffinch song and the question of dialects // Behaviour. V. 88. P. 76–97.
  56. Slater P.J.B., Ince S.A., Colgan P., 1980. Chaffinch song types: their frequencies in the population and distribution between repertoires of different individuals // Behaviour. V. 75. P. 207–218.
  57. Sorjonen J., 1987. Temporal and spatial differences in traditions and repertoires in the song of the thrush nightingale (Luscinia luscinia) birds // Behaviour. V. 102. P. 196–212.
  58. Thorpe W.H., 1958. The learning of song patterns by birds, with especial reference of the song of the chaffinch Fringilla coelebs // Ibis. V. 100. P. 535–570.
  59. Trainer J.M., 1983. Changes in song dialect distributions and microgeographic variation in song of white–crowned sparrows (Zonotrichia leucophrys nuttallz) // Auk. V. 100. P. 568–582.
  60. Trainer J.M., 1989. Cultural evolution in song dialects of yellow-rumped caciques in Panama // Ethology. V. 80. P. 190–204.
  61. Tyarks S.C., Aniceto A.S., Ahonen H., Pedersen G., Lindstrøm U., 2022. Changes in humpback whale song structure and complexity reveal a rapid evolution on a feeding ground in Northern Norway // Frontiers Marine Sciences. V. 9. https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2022.862794
  62. Williams H., 2021. Mechanisms of cultural evolution in the songs of wild bird populations // Frontiers in Psychology. V. 12. 643343. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.643343
  63. Williams H., Levin I.I., Norris D.R., Newman A.E., Wheelwright N.T., 2013. Three decades of cultural evolution in savannah sparrow songs // Animal Behavior. V. 85. P. 213–223.

Supplementary files

Supplementary Files
Action
1. JATS XML
Download
2.

Download (1MB)
Indexing metadata

Copyright (c) 2023 В.В. Иваницкий, И.М. Марова

This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies