Research Article


DOI :10.26650/TurkJHist.2019.19009   IUP :10.26650/TurkJHist.2019.19009    Full Text (PDF)

A MENGUJEKID TURKMEN BEG: FAKHR AL-DÎN BAHRÂMSHÂH AND HIS NEWLY DISCOVERED GOLD COINS

Ali Mıynat

Although he was the malik of the Mengüjekid Principality (the branch of Erzincan and Kemah) from the mid-12th century to the end of the first quarter of the 13th century, the primary sources were not very generous in the years of the sovereignty of Bahrâmshâh (560-622 / 1165-1225). Apart from mentioning his active roles in only a few political cases, these sources share records emphasizing his wealth and generosity. In this article, besides the information given in the primary sources, there will be two different types of gold coins struck by the Mengüjekid melik which will make an important contribution to the years of the Mengüjekid Principality and the regnal years of Bahrâmshâh. These unique dinars, which were put up for sale in some auctions in Europe, have never been involved in any coin catalogues or academic studies. These numismatic findings are undoubtedly important in order to complete the limited information in other written sources. It should be remembered that no gold coins belonging to the first period of Turkish principalities in Anatolia had been found until recently. In this respect, the gold coins we will share in this article will allow us to bring a new interpretation to the history of the Anatolian Turkish numismatic. Cite this article as: Mıynat, Ali, “Bir Mengücekli Türkmen Beyi: Fahreddîn Behrâmşâh ve Yeni Keşfedilen Altın Sikkeleri”, Turk J Hist sayı 70 (2019), s.19-36.
DOI :10.26650/TurkJHist.2019.19009   IUP :10.26650/TurkJHist.2019.19009    Full Text (PDF)

BİR MENGÜCEKLİ TÜRKMEN BEYİ: FAHREDDÎN BEHRÂMŞÂH VE YENİ KEŞFEDİLEN ALTIN SİKKELERİ

Ali Mıynat

12. yüzyılın ortalarından, 13. yüzyılın ilk çeyreğinin sonuna kadar Mengücekoğulları Beyliği’nin Erzincan ve Kemah kolunun melikliğini yapmasına rağmen, Behrâmşâh’ın (560-622/1165-1225) hâkimiyet yıllarına dair kaynaklar pek de cömert davranmazlar. Bu kaynaklar, sadece birkaç siyasî olaydaki etkin rolünden bahsetmenin dışında, onun zenginliği ve cömertliğine vurgu yapan kayıtlar paylaşırlar. Bu makalede birinci el kaynaklarda verilen bilgilerin yanında, gerek Mengücekoğulları Beyliği tarihi, gerekse Behrâmşâh’ın iktidar yıllarına önemli katkı sunacağını düşündüğümüz söz konusu melik tarafından darp ettirilmiş iki farklı tipte altın sikkeye yer verilecektir. Avrupa’daki bazı müzayedelerde satışa çıkarılan bu eşsiz dinarlar, daha önce hiçbir sikke kataloğunda ya da akademik çalışmada yer almamıştır. Diğer yazılı kaynaklardaki kısıtlı bilgileri tamamlaması açısından bu nümismatik bulguları hiç şüphesiz çok önemlidir. Hatırlatmak gerekir ki Anadolu’da kurulmuş ilk dönem Türk beyliklerine ait yakın zamana değin herhangi bir altın sikkeye rastlanılamamıştı. Bu yönüyle de makalede paylaşılacak altın sikkeler Anadolu Türk nümizmatik tarihine yeni bir yorum getirmemize müsaade edecektir. Cite this article as: Mıynat, Ali, “Bir Mengücekli Türkmen Beyi: Fahreddîn Behrâmşâh ve Yeni Keşfedilen Altın Sikkeleri”, Turk J Hist sayı 70 (2019), s.19-36.

EXTENDED ABSTRACT


One of the most important Turkmen principalities founded in Anatolia right after the Manzikert (Malazgirt) Victory (1071) is undoubtedly the Mengüjekids. Information from written sources about this principality, which played a very active role in the Turkization and Islamization of Anatolia, is not sufficient. It is known that this principality, which was founded in Erzincan, was divided into two branches in 536/1142, between two brothers after the death of Mengüjekid malik Ishaq. While the younger brother, Suleiman, took over the rule of Divriği, Davud ascended to the throne in Erzincan. Fakhr al-Dîn Bahrâmshâh, who came to the throne in Erzincan after the death of Davud, is one of the most famous and important figures of this principality. Although he succeeded in retaining his rule over Erzincan and its vicinity for more than sixty years and some primary sources pointed out his wealth, in general medieval historical sources were not very generous about his political life. In fact, they have particularly focused on his active roles in two political incidents. One of them is the tension and strife between the Seljuk sultan Kilidj Arslan II (550-588 / 1155- 1192) and his son, Kutb al-Dîn Melikshâh, who ruled in Sivas on behalf of his father; the other is the superior heroism of Bahrâmshâh in the military expedition of Georgia (599/1202-3), commanded by Rukn al-Dîn Suleimanshâh II. The attitude that he took in these cases gives us clues that Mengüjekid malik was not a passive character indeed in his time. In the first case, he undertook the role of mediator between the Seljuk sultan and his son. In this incident, the acceptance of his demand for the transfer of the famous Seljuk vizier Ikhtiyar al-Dîn Hasan to Erzincan for the purpose of arresting him, who Bahrâmshâh considered responsible for the tension between the sultan and the prince, shows that Mengüjekid malik had prestige in the Seljuk dynasty. Primary sources state that the Mengüjekid malik was the son-in-law of the Seljuk sultan Kilidj Arslan II, and also he had strengthened his political ties with the Seljuk court by marrying his daughters to members of the Seljuk dynasty. These marital ties and the moderate policy against the Seljuk dynasty must have allowed him to continue his rule for so long. In the second case, Behrâmşâh, who unconditionally joined the military expedition of Georgia, was captured by the Georgians. His heroism in this war and his devotion to the Seljuk dynasty took place in the sources.

Apart from these political events, in the al-Avamir al-’ala’iyya fi’l-umuri’l-’ala’iyya penned by the famous Rûm Seljuk historian Ibn Bîbî, and in the Mahzan al-asrâr, personally presented by the Azerbaijani poet Nizâmî Ganjavî to the Mengüjekid malik, there are very striking anecdotes about the richness and generosity of Fakhr al-Dîn Bahrâmshâh. Nizâmî praises him with pompous sentences and uses expressions about him such as the courageous, the hero, the mighty, the wise, the generous, the dignified, the victorious and the supreme. The records of Ibn Bîbî also confirm the words of the Iranian poet. He emphasizes his kindness, mercy, morality, justice, compassion and generosity, and shows that he was sensitive to participating in weddings and mournings in the capital city Erzincan. If he could not attend these occasions, he sent food from his court’s kitchen. Even a dress to the groom from camehâne-i saltana (the imperial dresshouse) and a wedding dress to the bride from the Harem, were presented as a gift during his rule.

Ibn Bîbî also mentions the jaiza (gift for a poem of praise) presented to Nizâmî by Mengüjekid malik for his book Mahzan al-asrâr. According to the author, when the book was presented, the poet was given five thousand gold dinars and five esters (rahvan mules), five horses with harnesses, a precious hilat, precious dresses, rare ornaments, engraved jewelery. This amount is, of course, very high for a person who is the ruler of a branch of a small principality.

Two different types of newly discovered gold coins struck by Bahrâmshâh add extra value to this study. In the light of available numismatic findings, these gold dinars show that the Mengüjekid malik Fakhr al-Dîn Bahrâmshâh was the earliest Turkish ruler who struck gold coins in Anatolia, apart from the Seljuk sultans. In other words, until recently, any gold coin minted by the Artuqid, Saltukid and Danishmendid Turkmen begs has not been found. These unique dinars, which were put up for sale in some auctions in the USA and Europe, have never been involved in any coin catalogues or academic studies. The first of these types of coins was imitated from the gold coins of Fatimid caliph al-Mustansir-Billâh (429-487 / 1038- 1094) which were minted in Misr, Sûr, Tripoli and Damascus in 439/1047-8. On the obverse, the name, title and generation (nasab) of Mengüjekid malik are clearly seen. As for the reverse, it is almost identical to its original one.

The second type of coin was produced from the gold dinars of Salâh al-Dîn Ayyûbî (567-589 / 1171-1193), which were minted in Cairo and Alexandria between the years of 576-579 / 1180-1183. The obverse is the same as the previous gold coin of the malik, and the inscription on the reverse is not touched. There is no date or mint name on both coins. However, considering that the originals of the second type of coins began to be minted by Salâh al-Dîn since 576/1180, it is clear that at least this type of Mengüjekid dinars were struck after this date. As for the mint place, it should be the capital of Erzincan. In fact, it is possible to find the mint names of ‘Erzincan’ and ‘madinat-i Erzincan’ on copper coins struck also by Bahrâmshâh.

It is unclear how the dinars, which were inspired by the Mengüjekid malik, passed into his hands. However, at least his contemporary Salâh al-Dîn’s dinars traveled far from their production site in the course of trade. It may also be thought that the coins of al-Mustansir-Billâh were still in circulation in the local markets, even though they were produced over a century ago. It is very difficult to make some inferences on the socio-economic structure of the principality, since we do not know where, how  and what amounts of these coins, which have reached Europe by smuggling, were found. But at least they are very useful to confirm the records that emphasize the richness, generosity and power of Fakhr al-Dîn Bahrâmshâh in the primary sources.


PDF View

References

  • Ahmed Eflâkî, Ariflerin Menkıbeleri, çev. Tahsin Yazıcı, MEB Yayınevi, İstanbul 1995. google scholar
  • Balog, Paul - Yvon, Jacques, “Monnaies à légendes arabes de l’Orient latin”, Revue numismatique, 6e série - Tome 1, 1958, s. 133-168. google scholar
  • Berchem, Max Van – Josef Strzygowski, Amida, Hiedelberg 1910. google scholar
  • Clavjo Gonzales de Ruy, Timur Devrinde Kadis’ten Semerkant’a Seyahat, çev. Ömer Rıza Doğrul, Kesit Yayınları, İstanbul 2007. google scholar
  • el-Hamevî, Şihâbeddîn Ebû Abdullâh Yakut, Mucemü’l-Büldân, I, Dâr-ı Sadr, Beyrut 1988. google scholar
  • İbn Battûta, İbn Battûta Seyahatnamesi, çev. A. Sait Aykut, c. I, Yapı Kredi Yayınları, İstanbul 2004. google scholar
  • İbn Bibi (el-Hüseyin b. Muhammed b. Ali el-Ca’feri er-Rugadi), el-Evamirü’l-Ala’iye fi’l-Umuri’l-Ala’iye (Selçuk Name), I, çev. Mürsel Öztürk, T.C. Kültür Bakanlığı Yayınları, Ankara 1996. google scholar
  • İbni Bîbî, Selçuknâme, çev. Mükrimin Halil Yinanç, haz. Refet Yinanç ve Ömer Özkan, Kitabevi Yayınları, İstanbul 2017. google scholar
  • İbnü’l-Esîr, el-Kâmil fi’t-Târih, İslâm Tarihi, çev. Abdülkerim Özaydın, Hikmet Neşriyat, C. 10, İstanbul 2008. google scholar
  • Josaphat Barbaro, Anadolu’ya ve İran’a Seyahat, çev. Tufan Gündüz, Yeditepe Yayınları, İstanbul 2005. google scholar
  • Gregory Abû’l-Farac (Bar Hebraeus), Abû’l-Farac Tarihi, C. II, Süryanice’den İngilizce’ye çev. Ernest A. Wallis Budge, Türkçeye çev. Ömer Rıza Doğrul, Türk Tarih Kurumu, Ankara 1999. google scholar
  • Kayalan, Ferruh, “Geçmişte Erzincan Şehrinin Sosyo-Ekonomik ve Kültürel Yapısı (M.Ö. II. Yüzyıl – M.S. XVII. Yüzyıl)”, Cappadocia Journal of History and Social Sciences, Vol. 9, October 2017, s. 152-174. google scholar
  • Lane-Poole, Stanley, Catalogue of the Collection of Arabic Coins preserved in the Khedivial Library at Cairo, London 1897. google scholar
  • Müneccimbaşı Ahmed bin Lütfullah, Câmiu’d-Düvel, Selçuklular Tarihi II (Anadolu Selçukluları ve Beylikler), haz. Ali Öngül, Akademi Kitabevi, İzmir 2001. google scholar
  • Nizamî Gencevî, Mahzen-i Esrar, çev. M. Nuri Gençosman, Ataç Yayınları, İstanbul 2014. google scholar
  • Özme, Adil, “Mengücek Beyliği Sikkeleri”, Sanat Tarihi Dergisi, sayı 13/1 (Nisan 2004), s. 95-105. google scholar
  • Ravendî, Râhatü’s-Sudûr ve Âyetü’s-Sürûr, I, çev. Ahmed Ateş, Türk Tarih Kurumu, Ankara 1999. google scholar
  • Répertoire chronologique d’épigraphie arabe, X (1939), s. 30-31, no. 3643. google scholar
  • Sakaoğlu, Necdet, Türk Anadolu’da Megücekoğulları, Millyet Yayınları, İstanbul 1971. google scholar
  • Sakaoğlu, Necdet, Yitik Bir Anadolu Beyliği, Mengücekoğulları, Alfa Yayınları, İstanbul 2017. google scholar
  • Sümer, Faruk, “Mengücüklüler”, DİA, C. 29, 2004, s. 138-142. google scholar
  • Süryani Mihail, Chronique de Michel le Syrien, Patriarche Jacobite d’Antiche (1166-1199), ed. ve Fransızca çev. J-P. Chabot, III, Ernest Leroux, Paris 1905. google scholar
  • Süryani Mihail, Vekâyinâme, Türkçe çev. Hrant Andreasyan, Türk Tarih Kurumu Kütüphanesi (Basılmamış Nüsha). google scholar
  • Turan, Osman, Doğu Anadolu Türk Devletleri Tarihi, Boğaziçi Yayınları, İstanbul 1993. google scholar
  • Whelan, Estelle J., “A Contribution to Danishmendid History: The Figured Copper Coins”, American Numismatic Society Magazine (ANSM), 25 (1980), s. 133-166. google scholar
  • William Von Rubruk, Moğolların Büyük Hanına Seyahat (1253-1255), çev. Ergin Ayan, Ayışığı Kitapları, İstanbul 2001. google scholar
  • Yazıcı, Tahsin - Cemal Kurnaz, “Hamse”, DİA, C. 15, 1997, s. 499-500. google scholar

Citations

Copy and paste a formatted citation or use one of the options to export in your chosen format


EXPORT



APA

Mıynat, A. (2019). A MENGUJEKID TURKMEN BEG: FAKHR AL-DÎN BAHRÂMSHÂH AND HIS NEWLY DISCOVERED GOLD COINS. Turkish Journal of History, 0(70), 19-36. https://doi.org/10.26650/TurkJHist.2019.19009


AMA

Mıynat A. A MENGUJEKID TURKMEN BEG: FAKHR AL-DÎN BAHRÂMSHÂH AND HIS NEWLY DISCOVERED GOLD COINS. Turkish Journal of History. 2019;0(70):19-36. https://doi.org/10.26650/TurkJHist.2019.19009


ABNT

Mıynat, A. A MENGUJEKID TURKMEN BEG: FAKHR AL-DÎN BAHRÂMSHÂH AND HIS NEWLY DISCOVERED GOLD COINS. Turkish Journal of History, [Publisher Location], v. 0, n. 70, p. 19-36, 2019.


Chicago: Author-Date Style

Mıynat, Ali,. 2019. “A MENGUJEKID TURKMEN BEG: FAKHR AL-DÎN BAHRÂMSHÂH AND HIS NEWLY DISCOVERED GOLD COINS.” Turkish Journal of History 0, no. 70: 19-36. https://doi.org/10.26650/TurkJHist.2019.19009


Chicago: Humanities Style

Mıynat, Ali,. A MENGUJEKID TURKMEN BEG: FAKHR AL-DÎN BAHRÂMSHÂH AND HIS NEWLY DISCOVERED GOLD COINS.” Turkish Journal of History 0, no. 70 (Apr. 2024): 19-36. https://doi.org/10.26650/TurkJHist.2019.19009


Harvard: Australian Style

Mıynat, A 2019, 'A MENGUJEKID TURKMEN BEG: FAKHR AL-DÎN BAHRÂMSHÂH AND HIS NEWLY DISCOVERED GOLD COINS', Turkish Journal of History, vol. 0, no. 70, pp. 19-36, viewed 26 Apr. 2024, https://doi.org/10.26650/TurkJHist.2019.19009


Harvard: Author-Date Style

Mıynat, A. (2019) ‘A MENGUJEKID TURKMEN BEG: FAKHR AL-DÎN BAHRÂMSHÂH AND HIS NEWLY DISCOVERED GOLD COINS’, Turkish Journal of History, 0(70), pp. 19-36. https://doi.org/10.26650/TurkJHist.2019.19009 (26 Apr. 2024).


MLA

Mıynat, Ali,. A MENGUJEKID TURKMEN BEG: FAKHR AL-DÎN BAHRÂMSHÂH AND HIS NEWLY DISCOVERED GOLD COINS.” Turkish Journal of History, vol. 0, no. 70, 2019, pp. 19-36. [Database Container], https://doi.org/10.26650/TurkJHist.2019.19009


Vancouver

Mıynat A. A MENGUJEKID TURKMEN BEG: FAKHR AL-DÎN BAHRÂMSHÂH AND HIS NEWLY DISCOVERED GOLD COINS. Turkish Journal of History [Internet]. 26 Apr. 2024 [cited 26 Apr. 2024];0(70):19-36. Available from: https://doi.org/10.26650/TurkJHist.2019.19009 doi: 10.26650/TurkJHist.2019.19009


ISNAD

Mıynat, Ali. A MENGUJEKID TURKMEN BEG: FAKHR AL-DÎN BAHRÂMSHÂH AND HIS NEWLY DISCOVERED GOLD COINS”. Turkish Journal of History 0/70 (Apr. 2024): 19-36. https://doi.org/10.26650/TurkJHist.2019.19009



TIMELINE


Submitted26.03.2019
Accepted14.11.2019

LICENCE


Attribution-NonCommercial (CC BY-NC)

This license lets others remix, tweak, and build upon your work non-commercially, and although their new works must also acknowledge you and be non-commercial, they don’t have to license their derivative works on the same terms.


SHARE




Istanbul University Press aims to contribute to the dissemination of ever growing scientific knowledge through publication of high quality scientific journals and books in accordance with the international publishing standards and ethics. Istanbul University Press follows an open access, non-commercial, scholarly publishing.