Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-m8qmq Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-23T20:19:52.027Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

General Franco as Military Leader

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 February 2009

Paul Preston
Paul Preston
Affiliation:
The University of Wales College of Cardiff
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

BOTH during his lifetime, and after his death, General Franco was reviled by his enemies on the left and subjected to the most absurd adulation by his admirers on the right. As the victor in a bloody civil war which inflamed passions throughout the world, that is hardly surprising. Leaving aside his personal political success in remaining in power for nearly four decades, his victory in the Spanish Civil War was his greatest and most glorious achievement, something reflected in the judgements of detractors and hagiographers alike. For the left, Franco the general was a slow-witted mediocrity whose battlefield triumphs were owed entirely to the unstinting military assistance of Hitler and Mussolini. For the right, Franco the general was the twentieth-century incarnation of Alexander the Great, of Napoleon and of the great warrior hero of Spanish legend, El Cid.

Type
Research Article
Information
Transactions of the Royal Historical Society , Volume 4 , December 1994 , pp. 21 - 41
Copyright
Copyright © Royal Historical Society 1994

References

1 [Hitler, Adolf], Hitler's Table Talk 1941–1944 (1953), 569Google Scholar.

2 See, for instance, Documents on German Foreign Policy Series D, III (1951), 408–10Google Scholar.

3 Ciano, Galeazzo, Ciano's Diary 1937–1938 (1952), 46Google Scholar.

4 Ciano, , Diary 37–38, 148Google Scholar.

5 Compare Kindelán, Alfredo, Mis cuademos de guerra 1936–1939 (Madrid, n.d. [1945], 86Google Scholar and Mis cuademos de guerra 1936–1939 2a edición (Barcelona, 1982), 9, 127Google Scholar. All subsequent references are to the 2nd edition.

6 Suerodiaz, Jorge Vigon, Cuademos de guerray notas de paz (Oviedo, 1970), 149–50, 212Google Scholar.

7 It is remarkable, for instance, diat Franco is a shadowy figure in the seventeen-volume set of Monogrqfias de la guerra de España produced by the Spanish Army's Servicio Histórico Militar under die direction of Colonel José Manuel Martinez Bande, (Madrid, 1968–1985). See also the critical comments on Franco's generalship to be found throughout Ramón, Generals & Larrazábal, Jesús Salas, Historia general de la guerra de España (Madrid, 1987)Google Scholar.

8 In a conversation with the Minister of War, Manuel Azaña, on 20 July 1931— Azaña, Manuel, Obras completas 4 vols (Mexico D.F., 1966–1968), IV, 35Google Scholar.

9 On the relationship between Franco's personal life and his political ideas, see Preston, Paul, Franco: A Biography (1993), 3–9, 72Google Scholar.

10 On Franco's time at the Toledo Academy, see Preston, , Franco, 8–13Google Scholar.

11 ‘Declaraciones de S.E. a Manuel Aznar’, 31 December 1938, Palabras del Caudillo 19 abril 1937–31 diciembre 1938 (Barcelona, 1939), 314Google Scholar.

12 Blazquez, José Martin, I Helped to Build an Army: Civil War Memoirs of a Spanish Staff Officer (1939), 302Google Scholar; Southworth, Herbert R., Antifalange: estudio critico de < Falange en la guerra de España: la Unificación y Hedilla> de Maximiano Garcia Venero (Paris, 1967), xxxi–xxiiGoogle Scholar; Cabanellas, Guillermo, La guerra de los mil dias, 2 vols, (Buenos Aires, 1973), II, 792Google Scholar.

13 On Franco's time at the Zaragoza Academy, see Escolá, Carlos Blanco, La Academia General Militar de Zaragoza (1928–1931) (Barcelona, 1989)Google Scholarpassim; Preston, , Franco, 56–61Google Scholar.

14 Durán, Diego Hidalgo, Por qué fui lanzado del Ministerio de la Guenra? Diez meses de actuation ministerial (Madrid, 1934), 79–81Google Scholar; Ballbé, Manuel, Orden púbtico y militarismo en la España constitutional (1812–1983) (Madrid, 1983), 371–2Google Scholar; Ochoa, General López,Campaña militar de Asturias en octubre de 1934 (Narratión tático-episóica) (Madrid, 1936), 11–12, 26–9Google Scholar; Robles, Jose Maria Gil, No fue posible la paz (Barcelona, 1968), 140–1Google Scholar; Jalón, César, Memorias politicas: periodista. ministro. presidiario. (Madrid, 1973), 128–31Google Scholar; Vidarte, Juan-Simeón, El bienio negro y la insurrectión de Asturias (Barcelona, 1978), 358–9Google Scholar.

15 Arrarás, Joaquin, Historia de la Cruzada española, 8 vols, 36 tomos, (Madrid, 1939–43, III, 80–2Google Scholar; Salgado-Araujo, Francisco Franco, Mi vida junto a Franco (Barcelona, 1977), 165Google Scholar; Osma, José Antonio Vaca de, Paisajes con Franco al fondo (Barcelona, 1987), 35–6Google Scholar.

16 News Chronicle, 29 July, 1 August 1936.

17 Kindelán's son claimed that the ideas both for the airlift and for a blockade-breaking convoy emanated from his father, ‘Prólogo’, Kindelán, , Mis cuademos, 45Google Scholar.

18 On Franco's role in securing Italian and German aid, see de Felice, Renzo, Mussolini it duce: lo stalo totalitario 1936–1940 (Turin, 1981), 363Google Scholar; Coverdale, John F., Italian Intervention in the Spanish Civil War, (Princeton, 1975), 69–74Google Scholar; Campos, Ismael Saz, Mussolini contra la II República: hostilidad, conspiradmes, interventión (1931–1936) (Valencia, 1986), 181–5Google Scholar; Viñas, Angel, La Alemania nazi y el 18 de julio 2a edition (Madrid, 1977), 264–342Google Scholar.

19 The Times, 26 August 1926; Whitaker, John, ‘Prelude to World War: A Witness from Spain’, Foreign Affairs, XXI, 1, 10 1942, 105–6Google Scholar; de Madariaga, Maria Rosa, ‘Imagen del moro en la memoria colectiva del pueblo español y retorno del moro en la guerra civil de 1936’, Reuista International de Sociologia XLVI, 4, 10–12 1988, 590–6Google Scholar; Koltsov, Mijail, Diario de la guerra de España (Paris, 1963), 88–9Google Scholar.

20 Bande, José Manuel Martinez, La marcha sobre Madrid (Madrid, 1968), 165–70Google Scholar.

21 Bande, José Manuel Martinez, ‘Del alzamiento a la guerra civil verano de 1936: correspondencia Franco/Mola’, Historia y Vida, XCIII, 1975, 22–3Google Scholar.

22 Bande, Martinez, La marcha sobre Madrid, 45–56Google Scholar.

23 Bande, Martinez, La marcha sobre Madrid, 56–71Google Scholar; Garriga, Ramón, El general Juan Yagüe (Barcelona, 1985), 111–12Google Scholar.

24 Documents on German Foreign Policy, D, III, 28.

25 Boaventura, Armando, Madrid-Moscow de ditadura à República e à guerra civil de Espanha (Lisbon, 1937), 212Google Scholar.

26 On the machinations behind the political elevation of Franco, see Preston, , Franco, 174–85Google Scholar.

27 de Osma, José Antonio Vaca, La larga guerra de Francisco Franco (Madrid, 1991), 209Google Scholar.

28 Bande, Martinez, La marcha, 81–95Google Scholar.

29 de Osma, Vaca, La larga guerra, 233—4Google Scholar; Hills, George, Franco: The Man and his Nation (New York, 1967), 263Google Scholar.

30 Rojo, Vicente, Así fue la defensa de Madrid (Mexico D.F., 1967), 55–103Google Scholar; Colodny, Robert F., The Struggle for Madrid (New York, 1958), 52–91Google Scholar; Thomas, Hugh, The Spanish Civil War (3rd ed, 1977), 82Google Scholar.

31 Documents on German Foreign Policy, D, III, 139; Fascistas en España: la intervención italiana en al guerra civil a trovés de los tekgramas de la ‘Missions Militate Italiana in Spagna’ (15 diciembre 1936–31 marzo 1937), Saz, Ismael & Tusell, Javier, eds, (Madrid/Rome, 1981), 25Google Scholar. (Henceforth MMIS.)

32 Documents on German Foreign Policy, D, III, 155.

33 Documents on German Foreign Policy, D, III, 159–62.

34 Bande, José Manuel Martinez, La lucha en torno a Madrid (Madrid, 1968), 37Google Scholar.

35 MMIS, Telegmmas, 79.

36 de Arce, Carlos, Los generates de Franco (Barcelona, 1984) 186Google Scholar; Bande, Martinez, La lucha en torno a Madrid, 51–69Google Scholar.

37 De Felice, , Mussolini il Duce, 389–90Google Scholar.

38 Mussolini, to Roatta, , 18 12 1936, MMIS, Tekgramas, 69Google Scholar.

39 Roatta, to Spagna, Ufficio, 8 02 1937, MMIS, Telegramas, 130Google Scholar.

40 Salgado-Araujo, Franco, Mi vida, 220Google Scholar.

41 Conforti, Olao, Guadalajara: la prima sconfitta del fascismo (Milan, 1967), 30–2Google Scholar; Coverdale, , Italian Intervention, 215Google Scholar.

42 Cantalupo to Ciano, 17 February 1937, Archivio Storico del Ministero degli Affari Esteri, Spagna Fondo di Guerra, b.38, no.287/137.

43 Conforti, , Guadalajara, 33Google Scholar.

44 On the battle of Guadalajara, see Preston, , Franco, 229–37Google Scholar; MMIS, Telegrams, 161–83; Faldella, Emilio, Venti mesi di guerra in Spagna (Florence, 1939), 255–66Google Scholar; Conforti, , Guadalajara, 51–178Google Scholar; Bande, Martinez, La lucha en torno a Madrid, 133–46Google Scholar; Rovighi, Alberto & Stefani, Filippo, La partecipazione italiana alla guerra civile spagnola (1936–1939) 4 vols (Rome, 1993) I, 232–333Google Scholar.

45 Kindelán, , Mis cuademos, 120–3Google Scholar; Vigón, General Jorge, General Mola (el cospirador) (Barcelona, 1957), 303–4Google Scholar; Salgado-Araujo, Franco, Mi vida, 225Google Scholar.

46 Murray, Williamson, German Military Effectiveness (Baltimore, 1992), 104–5Google Scholar.

47 DGFP, D, III, 125–6.

48 Wolfram von Richthofen, ‘Spanien-Tagebuch’, in Maier, Klaus, A.Guernica 26.4.1937. Die deutsche Intervention in Spanien und der ‘Fall Guernica’ (Freiburg, 1975)Google Scholardiary entries for 24, 28 March 1937, on pages 79, 82.

49 Cantalupo to Mussolini, 29 March 1937, ASMAE, SFG, b.38, T.709/345; Cantalupo, Roberto, Fu la Spagna. Ambasciata presso Franco (Milan, 1948), 230–3Google Scholar.

50 On the process of the so-called unification of all right-wing parties under Franco, see Venero, Maxiraiano Garcia, Falange en la guerra de Españo: la Unificatión y Hedilla (Paris, 1967)Google Scholarpassim; Southworth, Antifalange; Preston, , Franco, 248–74Google Scholar.

51 Kindelán, , Cuadernos, 131–7Google Scholar.

52 On the battle and its strategic significance, see Faldella, , Venti mesi, 357Google Scholar; Rojo, Vicente, España heroica: diez bocetos de la guerra española 3a editión (Barcelona, 1975) 91–101Google Scholar; Thomas, , The Spanish Civil War, 710–16Google Scholar.

53 Kindelán, , Mis cuadernos, 136–7Google Scholar; Aznar, Manuel, Historia militar de la guerra de Espańa (Madrid, 1940), 460Google Scholar; de Tena, José Ignacio Luca, Mis amigos muertos (Barcelona, 1971), 205–6Google Scholar; de Osma, Vaca, La larga guerra, 294–7Google Scholar.

54 Rojo, , España heroica, 103–15Google Scholar; Militar, Servicio Histórico (Bande, Coronel josé Manuel Martinez),La gran ofensiva sobre Zaragoza (Madrid, 1973), 78–167Google Scholar; Aznar, , História militar, 499–516Google Scholar; Thomas, , Civil War, 722–8Google Scholar; Salgado-Araujo, Franco, Mi vida, 241–2Google Scholar.

55 Bande, José Manuel Martinez, La batalla de Teruel 2a edición (Madrid, 1990), 16–26Google Scholar.

56 Rojo, , España heroica, 117–125Google Scholar; Bande, José Manuel Martinez, La batalla de Teruel (Madrid, 1990), 52–64Google Scholar; Aznar, , Historia militar, 543–54Google Scholar.

57 Martin, Claude, Franco soldado y estadista (Madrid, 1965), 293Google Scholar; Aznar, , Historia militar, 551, 622Google Scholar; Garriga, , Yagüe, 139–40Google Scholar.

58 Ciano, , Diary 37–38, 46Google Scholar.

59 Bande, Martinez, Teruel, 165–209Google Scholar; Lojendio, , Operaciones militares, 380–95Google Scholar; Aznar, , Histaria militar, 569–85Google Scholar; Larrazábal, Salas, Ejército, II, 1672–1704Google Scholar.

60 DGFP, D, IH, 556–7; Howson, Gerald, Aircraft of the Spanish Civil War 1936–1939 (1990), 20–8Google Scholar.

61 The Times, 4 March 1938; DGFP, D, III, 613–14; Suñer, Ramón Serrano, Entre Hendaya y Gibraltar (Madrid, 1947), 60–4Google Scholar.

62 Kindelán, , Mis cuadernos, 157–63Google Scholar; DGFP, D, III, 628.

63 Parrilla, Jaime Martinez, La fuerzas armadas francesas ante la guerra civil española (1936–939) (Madrid, 1987), 184–92Google Scholar; Pike, David Wingeate, Les français et la guerre d'Espagne 1936–1939 (Paris, 1975), 296–7Google Scholar; DGFP, D, III , 620–2.

64 Bande, José Manuel Martinez, La ofensiva sobre Valencia (Madrid, 1977), 16–18Google Scholar; Garriga, , Yagüe, 145–6Google Scholar; Rojo, Vicente, Alerta los pueblos! estudio politico-militar del periodo final de la guerra española 2a editión (Barcelona, 1974), 40, 46–50, 54–5Google Scholar.

65 Bande, Martinez, La ofensiva, 69–96Google Scholar.

66 Salgado-Araujo, Franco, Mi vida, 264Google Scholar; Aznar, , Historia militar, 739–70Google Scholar.

67 Kindelán, , Mis cuadernos, 173Google Scholar.

68 Lacorte, Manuel Tagüeña, Testimonio de dos guerras (México D. F., 1973), 230Google Scholar; Bande, José Manuel Martinez, La batalla del Ebro 2a edition (Madrid, 1988), 168Google Scholar.

69 Preston, Paul, The Politics of Revenge: Fascism and the Military in Twentieth Century Spain (1990), 30–47Google Scholar.