A comparative note on the ethnomedicinal plants used by the Kattunaikka and Paniya tribes of Nilambur forest, Malappuram district, Kerala, (India)

. A comparative note on the ethnomedicinal


Ethnobotanical data collection
Several field visits were conducted between 2010 and 2016 in the study areas among the Kattunaika and Paniya tribes to collect information on medicinal plants used by them using a questionnaire survey, interviews with key informants (knowledgeable elders, religious leaders and other individuals) and field observations.Interviews and discussions were conducted in Malayalam (the local language) using a checklist of topics.At the beginning of each interview the aim of the interview was explained to invoke clear and objective responses and then informants were asked for their consent.A range of ethnobotanical information including local names, habit and habitat, uses, parts used and mode of utilization of the plant were covered.Vegetation surveys and field observations were also conducted to substantiate these results.Vegetation surveys were carried out both in homesteads, in the wild and road sides to assess the distribution of the most frequently reported plant species.The collected specimens were cross-checked for their local names with the help of key informants and development agents.Botanical names were established by comparing specimens with those at the herbarium of Centre for Medicinal Plants Research (CMPR) and final identification was done after detailed laboratory studies, using stereomicroscopes and light microscopes or after consulting relevant floristic literature and their uses was carefully recorded in the field data book, Figure 1.The specimens are preserved in the CMPR herbarium.Medicinally important parts of some plants were collected and preserved in Formalin Acetic Acid (FAA) solution for further reference.Each species was checked for its Ayurvedic uses with the help of available literature like Ayurvedic pharmacopoeia of India and other books and similarity and dissimilarity in uses were analysed [6].

INTRODUCTION
The Indian subcontinent represents one of the greatest treasures of ethnobotanical knowledge.Kerala state of India, at the southernmost boundary of the Malabar coast, has Western Ghats on the east and Arabian Sea on the west and has a land area of 38,863 Km 2 .Malappuram district lies in northern Kerala and is bounded on the north by Wayanad and Kozhikkode districts, on the northeast by Tamil Nadu state, on the southeast and south by Palakkad district, on the southwest by Thrissur district, on the west by the Arabian Sea and on the northwest by Kozhikode district.Nilambur, a municipality and a taluk in the Malappuram district, is situated close to the Nilgiris range of the Western Ghats on the banks of the Chaliyar river.Nilambur is inhabited by indigenous tribal groups.The scheduled tribes of Nilambur area are about 0.56% of the total population and it comes to 22,990 people.As per the 2011 census, the Kattunaikkan population was estimated at 1629 individuals, spread over 452 households.Out of the 35 scheduled tribes notified in the state, Paniyan is the most populous tribe with a population of 81,940, forming 22.5 percent of the total tribal population of the state [1].

Study area
The study was conducted in the Nilambur taluk of Malappuram district,

Level of knowledge about plant resources among the informants
The study revealed that the level of knowledge differs in extent among the two tribes, gender and age groups.Though not much difference was recorded between the two tribes in the number of plant species used and the number/nature of ailments mentioned by them, Paniya tribe possessed comparatively higher knowledge about ethno-botanically useful plants than the Kattunaikka in terms of number of species used for a particular ailment/condition (details on differences are mentioned under the section ethnobotanical uses).Similarly, male informants had more knowledge than women.Among the men, elders were more aware than the younger members of the community.The lack of availability of elderly informants was experienced during the study.Narayanan et al., [7] has conducted ethnobotanical studies in the Wayanadu district, Kerala and documented information on 165 edible plants used by Kattunaikka, Paniya and Kuruma tribes.They report that the Paniya tribal community possesses knowledge regarding 136 taxa of wild edible plants, with Kattunaikkas coming next with knowledge of 97 taxa and Kurumas are at the bottom of the knowledgeladder with knowledge of 42 taxa of wild edible plants.The study supports our view that Paniya community of Nilambur area is rich in their knowledge on medicinal value of plants.

Taxonomic and ethanobotanical information
The present study documented taxonomical status and ethnobotanical usages of 79 plant species belonging to 76 genera and 45 families, used by the two tribes along with botanical name, family, vernacular name, plant parts used and mode of use (Tables 1-3).According to their life form, the greatest proportion of useful plants recorded at the locality included shrubs (32%), trees (29%), herbs (28%) and climbers (11%).The four most important families in terms of their number of taxa were Fabaceae with nine, Apocynaceae with seven, Asteraceae with five and Lamiaceae with four taxa.Two families were represented by three taxa each and nine families were represented by two taxa each.Rest of the 30 families consisted of only one taxa each.Use of plants for medicinal purpose by the two tribes from a wide variety of families was a point of interest.

List of plant species used by Kattunaikka and Paniya tribes in combined form for various ailments/conditions
One point of interest is that there was not even a single species commonly used by the two tribes as single plant remedy for a similar condition or ailment.It was observed that for similar conditions, both the tribes used different plant species.The knowledge and information revealed by Paniya tribes were rich in terms of usage of species for various ailments/conditions compared to Kattunaikkans.In the Paniya community, the number of plants used for a similar condition/ailment was more compared to Kattunaikkan community.For example, for curing skin problems, Paniya tribes revealed use of five species, whereas the Kattunaikka tribes revealed the use of only two.In other words, Kattunaikkans described only twenty-one species for ten ailments, in place of the thirty-five species described by Paniya tribes for same number of ailments (Table 5).The case of using one species for many conditions/ailments was also rarely recorded within the Paniya tribes.For example, Paniyars use Holostemma ada-kodien for postpartum vigor and eye diseases and Indigofera tinctoria for skin diseases, against jaundice and also as a hair tonic.For about ten conditions/ailments such as diabetes, epilepsy and diarrhea, Kattunaikka tribes alone described certain remedies and for certain other conditions/ailments like piles, leprosy, jaundice and joint pain only Paniya tribes described remedies (Table 6).

Ethnomedicinal uses
Kattunaikka and Paniya tribes revealed their knowledge on the use of 79 medicinal plants and about 38 ailments/conditions.Paniya tribes revealed information about the use of 41 species, whereas Kattunaikkans about 43 species which are used as either single or combined forms of medicines.Five species recorded were commonly used by both the tribes.The Paniya tribes revealed information about 24 species which are used as single plant remedies, whereas Kattunaikkans described 28 species (Tables 1 and 2).Information collected from both the tribes on some combined forms of preparations for various conditions is given in Tables 3 and 4.Among the 18 species used by Paniya tribes in combined form of preparations, only one species (Rotula aquatica) was used as the single plant remedy also.In the case of Kattunaikka tribes, out of the 15 species used in combination form, one species (Desmodium gangeticum) is mentioned as single plant remedy also.Out of the five species used commonly either in single or compound form, only two species, i.e., Trigonella foenum-graceum and Curcuma longa, were commonly used by the two tribes in combination remedies (Tables 3 and 4).The species were suggested for various diseases like bronchial asthma, cardiac disorders, diabetes, diarrhoea, epilepsy, gynecological disorders, kidney stone, rheumatism, snake bite, body pain and fever.

Mode of administration Tribes
Cough, cold and fever

Ricinus communnis -
Infantile fever Plectranthus ambonicus - [14] records that a number of the plants used by the clan healer have similar uses in Ayurveda, but differ considerably in their therapeutic uses from that reported for other tribes in Bangladesh.
According to some researcher's traditional medicine and biomedicine may be incompatible and the use of biomedicine and biomedical concepts often displaces the use of traditional medicine and medical beliefs.In contrast, other scholars have found that traditional medicine and biomedicine can co-exist, complement and blend with each other.Giovannini et al., [15] use an econometric model and quantitative data to test the association between individual knowledge of pharmaceuticals and individual knowledge of medicinal plants in a rural indigenous community at Mexico.The results suggest that, in the study site, individual knowledge of medicinal plants and individual knowledge of pharmaceuticals co-exist in a way which might be interpreted as complementary.They conclude that social organization involves in the use of medicines from both traditional medicine and biomedicine is of particular significance and the use of pharmaceuticals alone is not associated with a decline in knowledge/use of medicinal plants.

CONCLUSION
The study revealed that Paniya and Kattunaikka tribes of Nilambur forest use many plants or plant parts for both internal and external applications for the treatment of various ailments in their daily life.The difference in usage of plants by same tribes occupying different localities and different tribes of the same or nearby localities was observed.The similarity and difference observed between tribal and Ayurvedic system also requires more investigation.The use of plants among these tribes reflects their interest in ethnomedicine and further investigation on unexplored species may led to the discovery of novel pharmaceutical products.[10] records the plants used by the Paniya and Kattunaikka tribes for the treatment of digestive system disorders in Wayanad district, Kerala and they mention certain similarities in the usage of plants among these two tribes.Only two species, Aegle marmelos and Aristolochia tagala, used by the Kattunaikka tribes of Nilambur forests for diabetes and snake bite respectively, reported in our study are used by both the tribes of Wayanad district for digestive system disorders.Amuthavalluvan [11] documents the traditional ethno-medicinal practices of Kattunayakan of southern northern Arcot district, Tamil Nadu and nearly ten medicinal species utilize by them in traditional healing system is found to be common in our report for same or different conditions.They also report the use of two or more remedies for the same disease indicating that one is superior to the other and such observation has been recorded in our study also.Out of the 32 plant species reported by Naseef et al., [12] against gynaecological problems by the Paniya tribes of Nellivayal of Wayanad district, Kerala, only one species, Holostemm ada-kodien was found commonly used by the Paniya tribes of Nilambur forest for same condition.

Ayurvedic use of ethnobotanical plants
Ayurveda, which also relies on medicinal plants for treatment, is possibly the oldest traditional medicinal system in the Indian sub-continent dating back to nearly five thousand years ago.Of the 79 species recorded in this study, 64 species (81%) were found to be used in the Ayurvedic system of medicine and 65% for similar conditions.Nearly 79% of the plants used as single plant remedies by the Paniya tribes are recorded to be used in the Ayurvedic system of medicine for treating similar (73.7%) or different (26.3%) conditions (Table 1).In the case of Kattunaikka tribes 78.6% of the plants used as single plant remedies are recorded to be used in the Ayurvedic system of medicine for treating similar (77%) or different (23%) conditions (Table 2).Among the 32 plants used in the combined form of drugs, 87.5% are being used in Ayurveda and similarity in use was recorded in 53.6% cases (Table 3).The Ayurvedic system of medicine has been the major medicinal system practiced in Kerala since time immemorial.The traditional medicinal practice of the tribal communities typically involves simple use of plant parts of single plants or combination of 3 or 4 items, whereas Ayurvedic formulations mostly contains combination of many medicinal plants.The observation by Rahmatullah et al., [13] knowledge and returning it to local communities.Several wild medicinal plants are declining in number due to the destruction and unscientific collection of plants from forests.Except for the documentation of the ethnobotanical knowledge in the Malappuram district by Thomas et al., [2-5] not much work is being done in this area.There is a very limited and scattered scientific record of the traditional medicines, used by the Kattunaikka and Paniya tribes of Malappuram district.The aim of this study was (1): To document the knowledge on ethnomedicines of Kattunaikka and Paniya tribes of Nilambur forest and (2): To find out whether traditional usages of medicinal plants by these tribals for treatment of various ailments has similarity with the uses in Ayurvedic medicine or the tribal medicinal plants were totally distinctive from Ayurveda.
Decoction made up of dry Zingiber officinale+Piper longum+Ocimum sanctum+Allium sativum+Piper nigram+Trigonella foenum-graecum is taken internally Kattunaikka Cough and stomach pain Ripe fruits of Gmelina arborea+Psidium guajava are taken internally once a day for 2 weeks Kattunaikka Hair fall Lawsonia inermis (dried leaves)+Eclipta alba (whole plant)+Sida cordifolia (root)+Phyllanthus emblica (dried) all are crushed and heated with coconut oil and applied on hair once daily Paniya Kidney stone and abdominal disorders Trigonella foenum-graecum+whole plant paste of Rotula aquatica+Cuminum cyminum is taken internally in empty stomach once daily for man and twice daily for women Paniya Lactation Cocunut milk (Cocos nucifera)+4 or 5 earthworms+Cuminum cyminum is made in to a paste and mixed in half glass of cow milk only one time Paniya Postpartum vigor A decoction made up of Phyllanthus emblica+Desmodium gangentium+Pseudarthria viscida+Asparagus racemosus is taken internally three months Kattunaikka Seeds of Coix lacryma jobi+Curcuma longa applied on stomach Paniya Rheumatism Alpinia galanga rhizome paste+Cassia fistula is applied externally Paniya Justicia jerandurossa whole plant mixed with Azadirachta indica Paniya Snake bite Bark of Strychnos nux-vomica (small amount)+Momordica charantia (4 or 5 leaves) are crushed and take internally on early morning and evening.Bitted portion is recommended to tie with a hair to avoid spreading Paniya Rauvolfia serpentina root paste+Curcuma longa is applied to affected portion Kattunaikka Cassia fistula tender root+Curcuma longa external application for 7 days.That person is recommended to avoid sleep and also salt, chilly and oil Paniya Aristolochia tagala whole plant+Curcuma longa external application for 7 days Kattunaikka Tuberculosis A decoction made up of root tuber of Holostemma ada-kodien+Catharanthus roseus+Ocimum sanctum is taken internally twice a day for one month.Kattunaikka Wounds Ageratum conyzoides plant paste+Curcuma longa are applied externally for seven days Paniya External application of Sapindus trifoliatus fruits+Solanum melongena leaf for wounds on head Paniya that use of medicinal plants in the traditional medicine practiced by Chakma tribes in Bangladesh is having resemblance to their use in Ayurveda, supports our view.Of the 73 total plants used by Chakma tribe, the medicinal uses of 33 plants are similar to Ayurvedic uses, as reported for various Ayurvedic preparations.While documenting the tribal medicinal practices of the Deb-barma clan of the Tripura tribe, residing in Dolusora Tripura Palli of Moulvibazar district of Bangladesh, Kabir et al.,

S. no Botanical name, family, local name, part used Tribal use Mode of administration Ayurvedic uses Similar (S)/Dissimilar (D)
24Wrightia tinctoria (Roxb.)R. Br.Apocynaceae, Kutakappala, Bark, seeds Burning sensations Seed oil is applied Skin diseases, hair growth D

TABLE 1 List of plant species used as single plant remedies by Paniya tribes for various ailments/conditions
28Vernonia anthelmintica (L.) Willd, Compositae, Kattujeerakam, seedsInflammation against liceSeed paste is applied to affected portion, used externally to kill lice Cure ulcers, vata, kapha and roundworms D

TABLE 4 Some combined form of preparations used by the Paniya and Kattunaikka tribes for various conditions Paniya tribes of Nilambur forest, Malappuram district, Kerala, (India)
AGBIR Vol.40 No.02 Mar 2024

TABLE 5 Difference in use of plants for similar ailments and conditions by Paniya and Kattunaikka tribes
[9]nobotanical survey in Mundakunnu village of Gudalur taluk, Nilgiri district of Tamil Nadu, (India) reveals that six plant species are commonly used for different ailments by the Paniya tribes from two localities.But, tribes from both places use Hemidesmus indicus as a refreshing drink or coolant[8].Thomas et al., [3] reports ethno-veterinary uses of 30 species from the Paniyar tribes of Malappuram, in which two species, Asparagus racemosus and Elephantopus scaber are found commonly used.They also report that Paniyars have a strong tendency of keeping their traditional knowledge and techniques secret.Ramachandran et al.,[9]studied the wild edible plants used by the Paniyas and Kurumbas of Western Nilgiris, Tamil Nadu and describe nine species which are used as food and also for curing various common ailments.Plant species such as Lantana camara, Momordica charantia, Cyclea peltata, Solanum anguii (Solanum violaceaum) and Phyllanthus emblica which are consumed as wild edible plants by the Paniya and Kurumba tribes of Nilgiris, were found to be used for therapeutic purpose among the Paniya tribes in our study.Prasad et al., 3. Thomas B, RajendranA, Aravindhan V, et al.Ethnoveterinary medicines of tribe Paniyars in Kerala, India.Int J Biol Tech.2011;2(2):72-75.4. Thomas B, Mathews RP, Rajendran A, et al.The wild edible plants and its contribution to the dietary equilibrium of tribe Cholanaikkans of Nilambur forest, Western Ghats of Kerala, India.GTRP Botan Rep. 2012;1(2):8-12.5. Thomas B, Mathews RP, Rajendran A, et al.Ethnobotanical observations on tribe Arnatans of Nilambur forest, Western ghats region of Kerala, India.Res Plant Biol.2013;3(2):12-17.