초록

Selecting promising technology is becoming more and more difficult due to the increased number and complexity. In this study, we propose hybrid AHP/DEA-AR method and hybrid AHP/DEA-AR-G method to evaluate efficiency of technology alternatives based on ordinal rating data collected through survey to technology experts in a certain field and select efficient technology alternative as promising technology. The proposed method normalizes rating data and uses AHP to derive weights to improve the credibility of analysis, then in order to avoid basic DEA models' problems, use DEA-AR and DEA-AR-G to evaluate efficiency of technology alternatives. In this study, we applied the proposed methods to clean technology and compared with the basic DEA models. According to the result of the comparison, we can find that the both proposed methods are excellent in confirming most efficient technology, and hybrid AHP/DEA-AR method is much easier to use in the process of technology selection.

키워드

data envelopment analysis-assurance region, analytical hierarchy process (AHP), technology selection

참고문헌(42)open

  1. [학술지] Andersen, P / 1993 / A procedure for ranking efficient units in data envelopment analysis / Management Science 39 : 1261 ~ 1264

  2. [학술지] Allen, R. / 1997 / Weights restrictions and value judgements in data envelopment analysis: Evolution, development and future directions / Annals of Opertations Research 73 : 3 ~ 34

  3. [학술지] Abbas, A. / 2010 / Information technology project evaluation: Anintegrated data envelopment analysis and balanced scorecard approach / Expert Systems with Applications 37 : 5931 ~ 5938

  4. [학술지] Bowen, W. M. / 1990 / Subjective judgements and data envelopment analysis in site selection / Computers, Environment and Urban Systems 14 (2) : 133 ~ 144

  5. [학술지] Banker, R.D. / 1984 / Some models for estimating technical and scale inefficiencies in data envelopment analysis / Management science 30 : 1078 ~ 1092

  6. [학술지] Charnes, A. / 1978 / Measuring the efficiency of decision making units / European Journal of Operational Research 2 (6) : 429 ~ 444

  7. [학술지] Chang, S.C. / 2011 / Returns to scale in DEA models for performance evaluations / Technological Forecasting and Social Change 78 : 1389 ~ 1396

  8. [기타] Daddario, E. / 1968 / Technology Assessment, Subcommittee on science, research, and development of the committee on science and astronautics / U.S. Congress

  9. [학술지] Ertay, T. / 2006 / Integrating data envelopment analysis and analytic hierarchy for the facility layout design in manufacturing systems / Information Sciences 176 (3) : 237 ~ 262

  10. [학술지] Hajeeh, M. / 2005 / Application of the analytical hierarchy process in the selection of desalination plants / Desalination 174 (1) : 97 ~ 108

  11. [학술지] Ho, J.C. / 2011 / Technology evaluation in Taiwan's technology industries: strategies, trajectories, and innovations / Technological Forecasting and Social Change 78 : 1379 ~ 1388

  12. [학술지] Hsu, Y.L. / 2010 / The application of Fuzzy Delphi Method and Fuzzy AHP in lubricant regenerative technology selection / Expert System with Applications 37 : 419 ~ 425

  13. [단행본] Hwang, C.L. / 1981 / Multiple attribute decision making: methods and applications / Springer

  14. [학술지] James, F. / 2001 / Technology, the technology complex and the paradox of technological determinism / Technology Analysis and Strategic management 13 (4) : 523 ~ 531

  15. [학술지] Karsak, E.E. / 2005 / Practical common weight multi-criteria decision-making approach with an improved discriminating power for technology selection / International Journal of Production Research 44 : 1537 ~ 1554

  16. [학술지] Kong W.H. / 2012 / Assessing the performance of business colleges in Taiwan using data envelopment analysis and students based value-added performance indicators / Omega 40 : 541 ~ 549

  17. [학술지] Khorramshahgol, R. / 1988 / Delphic hierarchy process (DHP): a methodology for priority setting derived from the Delphi method and analytical hierarchy process / European Journal of Operational Research 37 (3) : 347 ~ 354

  18. [학술지] 김순영 / 2009 / AHP를 이용한 국방연구개발사업 메타평가 지표개발 / 지식경영연구 10 (2) : 65 ~ 84

  19. [학술지] 김관열 / 2011 / 특허맵과 AHP를 활용한 최적의 LCD 저온폴리실리콘 결정화 기술 선정 / 지식경영연구 12 (1) : 39 ~ 52

  20. [학술대회] Lamb, M. / 1997 / Industrial concerns in technology selection / Paper presented at the meeting of the Portland International Conference on Management of Engineering and Technology

  21. [학술지] Lee, S.K / 2011 / Measuring the relative efficiency of hydrogen energy technologies for implementing the hydrogen economy: An integrated fuzzy AHP/DEA approach / International Journal of Hydrogen energy 36 : 12655 ~ 12663

  22. [학술지] 이정숙 / 2009 / DEA와 AHP를 혼용한 소프트웨어공학 지원도구 평가 모형 연구 / 한국IT서비스학회지 8 (2) : 173 ~ 182

  23. [학술지] Moutaz, K. / 1995 / The use of data envelopment analysis for technology selection / Computers and Industrial Engineering 28 (1) : 123 ~ 132

  24. [학술지] Malladi, S. / 2005 / Decision support methods for the selection of internet access technologies in rural communities / Telematics and Informatics 22 (3) : 201 ~ 219

  25. [학술지] Roll, Y. / 1993 / Alternate methods of treating factor weights in DEA / Omega 21 (1) : 99 ~ 109

  26. [학술지] Ryu, J. / 2011 / Technology level evaluation methodology based on the technology growth curve / Technological Forecasting and Social Change 78 : 1049 ~ 1059

  27. [학술지] Raju, U.S. / 1995 / The influence of Development perspectives on the choice of technology / Technological Forecasting and Social Change 48 : 27 ~ 43

  28. [단행본] Saaty, T.L. / 1980 / The analytic hierarchy process / McGraw-Hill

  29. [학술지] Shen, Y.C. / 2010 / A hybrid selection method for emerging technology / Technological Forecasting and Social Change 77 : 151 ~ 166

  30. [학술지] Shang, J. / 1995 / A unified framework for the selection of a Flexible Manufacturing System / European Journal of Operational Research 85 (2) : 297 ~ 315

  31. [학술지] Seifert, L. M. / 1998 / Identifying excesses and deficits in Chinese industrial productivity (1953-1990): A weighted data envelopment analysis approach / Omega 26 (2) : 279 ~ 296

  32. [학술지] Sharon, M.O. / 2008 / Fuzzy logic and evaluation of advanced technologies / Industrial Management and Data Systems 108 (7) : 928 ~ 946

  33. [학술지] Sinuany-Stern, Z. / 2000 / An AHP/DEA methodology for ranking decision making units / International Transactions in Operational Research 7 (2) : 109 ~ 124

  34. [학술지] Saen, R.F. / 2006 / A decision model for technology selection in the existence of both cardinal and ordinal data / Applied Mathematics and Computation 181 : 1600 ~ 1608

  35. [학술지] 성웅현 / 2005 / 중소벤처기업의 기술가치평가를 위한 할인츌 추정에 관한 연구 / 지식경영연구 6 (1) : 19 ~ 32

  36. [학술지] Torkkeli, M. / 2002 / The contribution of technology selection to core competencies / International Journal of Production Economics 77 (3) : 271 ~ 284

  37. [학술지] Thompson, R.G. / 1986 / Comparative site evaluations for locating a high-energy physics lab in Texas / Interfaces 16 : 35 ~ 49

  38. [학술지] Takamura, Y. / 2003 / A comparative site evaluation study for relocating Japanese government agencies out of Tokyo / Socio-Economic Planning Sciences 37 (2) : 85 ~ 102

  39. [학술지] Tran, T.A. / 2008 / A taxonomic review of methods and tools applied in technology assessment / Technological Forecasting and Social Change 75 (9) : 1396 ~ 1405

  40. [학술지] Taylor, W.M. / 1997 / DEA/AR efficiency and profitability of Mexican banks: A total income method / European Journal of Operational Research 98 : 346 ~ 363

  41. [학술지] Winebrake, J.J. / 2003 / The future of hydrogen fueling systems for transportation: an application of perspective-based scenario analysis using the analytic hierarchy process / Technological Forecasting and Social Change 70 (4) : 359 ~ 384

  42. [학술지] Zhang, X.S. / 1991 / A project evaluation system in the state economic information system of China: An operations research practice in public sectors / International Transactions in Operational Research 6 (5) : 441 ~ 452