http://orcid.org/0000-0001-6753-0928
Figures
Abstract
Introduction
The objective of this study was to determine the growth patterns, rates of malnutrition, and factors associated with malnutrition in children born to HIV-infected mothers in western Kenya using data from an electronic medical record system.
Methods
This study was a retrospective chart review of HIV-infected (HIV+) and–exposed (HEU) children (<5 years) using data collected prospectively in the course of routine clinical care and stored in the electronic medical record system in western Kenya between January 2011 and August 2016. Demographics and anthropometrics were described, with Chi-square testing to compare proportions. Multiple variable logistic regression analysis was used to identify correlates of children being stunted, underweight, and wasted. We also examined growth curves, using a resampling method to compare the areas under the fitted growth curves to compare males/females and HIV+/HEU.
Results
Data from 15,428 children were analyzed. The children were 51.6% (n = 7,955) female, 5.2% (n = 809) orphans, 83.3% (n = 12,851) were HEU, and 16.7% (n = 2,577) were HIV+. For HIV+ children assessed at 24 months, 50.9% (n = 217) were stunted, 26.5% (n = 145) were underweight, and 13.6% (n = 58) were wasted, while 45.0% (n = 577) of HEU children were stunted, 14.8% (n = 255) were underweight, and 5.1% (n = 65) were wasted. When comparing mean z-scores, HIV+ children tended to have larger and earlier dips in z-scores compared to HIV-exposed children, with significant differences found between the two groups (p<0.001). Factors associated with an increased risk of malnutrition included being male, HIV+, and attending an urban clinic. Maternal antiretroviral treatment during pregnancy and mixed feeding at 3 months of age decreased the risk of malnutrition.
Citation: McHenry MS, Apondi E, Ayaya SO, Yang Z, Li W, Tu W, et al. (2019) Growth of young HIV-infected and HIV-exposed children in western Kenya: A retrospective chart review. PLoS ONE 14(12): e0224295. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0224295
Editor: Sphiwe Madiba, Sefako Makgatho Health Sciences University, SOUTH AFRICA
Received: May 13, 2019; Accepted: October 9, 2019; Published: December 4, 2019
Copyright: © 2019 McHenry et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: This study was in part by a training grant entitled “Training in STIs and Other Infections of Global Health Significance” (T32AI007637, PI: Dr. Wools Kaloustian) from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, Bethesda, MD, USA and the Indiana University Morris Green Physician Scientist Program, both awarded to M.S.M. during her time as a fellow. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
Malnutrition contributes to nearly 50% of the deaths in children under 5 years of age worldwide, which translates into 3 million deaths per year [1]. Children with malnutrition are caught in a vicious cycle–their poor nutritional state puts them at increased risk of infection, then acute or chronic illness further depletes their valuable nutrients and their risk of infection increases even more [2]. Moreover, stunted growth is associated with impaired cognitive ability and reduced school and work performance [2–5]. In many African countries, like Kenya, over a third of children have moderate-to-severe stunting [6].
Compounding the issue of malnutrition in these settings is the prevalence of HIV. Children born to HIV-infected (HIV+) mothers are more likely to be malnourished [7–9]. Poor growth in HIV+ children contributes to immune dysfunction and is associated with disease progression and decreased survival [10, 11]. Even those who are HIV-uninfected but were born to mothers with HIV have increased risks of mortality and morbidity compared to their HIV-unexposed counterparts. In a study performed in Zimbabwe, nearly 80% of children infected with HIV+ in utero and 35% of HEU children were stunted at 24 months [8]. These increased risks are thought to be related to in utero and early life exposures, increased risk of prematurity, and reduced care due to parental illness or death [12–15].
Increased implementation of strong electronic medical records (EMR) systems in resource-limited settings provides the opportunity to obtain real-world clinical data on a large number of children more easily than in decades past [16, 17]. While our current knowledge of the nutritional status of HIV+ and HIV–exposed but uninfected (HEU) children is informed by prospective studies, these studies are resource-intense, challenging to replicate, and only represent a subset of the population [8, 9, 14, 18]. Utilizing EMR systems to obtain real-time data for specific variables, such as rates of malnutrition, enable healthcare systems to identify issues most negatively impacting their patients.
In this study, we used a large retrospective data set from a healthcare system in western Kenya to examine the growth data for young children born to HIV+ mothers to determine the growth patterns, rates of malnutrition, and factors associated with malnutrition in children born to HIV+ mothers.
Methods
Study design and setting
This is a retrospective study using data collected prospectively in the course of routine clinical care and stored in the electronic medical record (EMR) system. Data were pulled for all children who were <5 years of age between January 2011- August 2016 and enrolled in a large HIV clinical care system in Kenya, the Academic Model Providing Access to Healthcare (AMPATH). Born from a 20-year partnership between Indiana University School of Medicine (IUSM), Moi University School of Medicine (MUSM), and the Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital in Eldoret, Kenya, the AMPATH HIV care program has enrolled over 160,000 patients and currently provides care for approximately 15,000 HIV+ and HEU children in 65 clinics in western Kenya [19]. During this period, AMPATH clinical data were captured on standardized paper encounter forms and then entered into the AMPATH Medical Records System (AMRS), a resource for both patient care and research evaluations. AMRS was sub-Saharan Africa’s first comprehensive EMR for HIV care, pioneering the effective use of EMRs in such settings [20, 21]. Outcomes of HIV+ children in this large cohort have previously been reported for retention in care, therapy, and HIV transmission rates [22–24].
This study was approved by the IUSM Institutional Review Board and the United States’ Office of Human Research Protections-approved MUSM Institutional Research and Ethics Committee. The requirement for informed consent was waived by both ethical governing bodies. The data for this study were handled and stored within Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996-compliant secured servers.
Study participants
Participants were eligible if they were seen in any of the AMPATH clinics between January 2011 and August 2016, were <5 years of age when enrolling in care during that time period, were born to HIV+ mothers, and had at least one anthropometric measurement recorded. In this setting, HIV-exposed children receive confirmatory HIV testing at 18 months of life. Because this dataset encompassed data from a specific range of time, there are individuals who were monitored by AMPATH but had not yet reached 18 months of age prior to completion of data collection. This group was termed “HIV-indeterminate” for this study. Also included in this group were the individuals who were lost-to-follow-up prior to 18 months of age. HIV-indeterminate children (n = 1,576) were removed from the dataset. All children who were exposed to HIV but had negative confirmatory testing during the data collection period are referred to as being HEU. HEU children were eligible to receive free follow-up care with well-child visits in the AMPATH system until 5 years of age. No HIV-unexposed children are included in this cohort.
Per AMPATH and Kenya’s Ministry of Health protocols, during the period of data collection, pregnant mothers with HIV were expected to be on an antiretroviral treatment (ART) regimen of tenofovir, lamivudine, and efavirenz as the first-line combination (Option B+) which would continue for life. Exclusive breastfeeding was recommended for all HIV-exposed children for the first 6 months of life and to continue breastfeeding with appropriate complementary feeding introduced thereafter [25]. Nevirapine prophylaxis was given for 6 weeks to all infants attending the AMPATH clinics and co-trimoxazole was given from 6 weeks of age until the time of confirmatory testing at 18 months of age [25]. If a child was found to be HIV+ at any time, they would be switched to either a regimen of zidovudine/lamivudine/nevirapine or abacavir/lamivudine/nevirapine as first-line treatment. In late 2013, the first-line regimen for children was changed to abacavir/lamivudine/lopinavir/ritonavir, in accordance with changes in the World Health Organization (WHO) guidelines [26]. Per AMPATH standard operating procedures, from 2010- December 2015 all children included in this study were recommended to attend monthly follow-up visits until 5 years of age [27]. In 2016, this was changed to be in line with the national policy of monthly visits until 18 month and then every 6 months until 5 years of age [25].
Data collection
The variables included within this study were collected from clinic visit forms completed by a clinical officer (a mid-level provider), medical officer, or pediatrician and entered into the AMRS system. These variables included age at enrollment, sex, clinic location/type, person accompanying child, orphan status, visit height/weights, caregiver-reported feeding method, clinician-reported maternal or child ART, HIV+ sibling, mean CD4 for HIV+ children, and final HIV testing result. There were also places where a clinician could indicate whether they believed a child was considered developmentally delayed or failure to thrive, although no standard operating procedures or guidelines were available outlining the definitions of those terms. Patient identifiers, including name, address, and contact information, were removed during data extraction. All analyzed data were handled and transferred using password protected, encrypted methodologies compliant with the United States’ Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act standards.
For this study, z-scores and standardized WHO definitions were used for presentation and analysis of anthropometric data, with z-scores calculated using the modeling defined by the WHO [28]. Z-scores are expressed anthropometric values as several standard deviations below or above the reference mean or median values, that are helpful for grouping growth data by age and sex [29]. To characterize malnutrition, the following categories were evaluated: stunting, underweight, and wasting. In these analyses, “stunting” refers to moderate-to-severe stunting, (height-for-age (HFA) z-scores of ≤-2). “Underweight” refers to moderate-to-severe underweight status (weight-for-age (WFA) z-scores of ≤-2). “Wasting” refers to moderate-to-severe wasting (weight-for-height (WFH) z-scores of ≤-2). The WHO defines “moderate-severe malnutrition” based on these three variables.
Statistical analysis
To minimize the influences of recording errors and data irregularity, we conducted a due-diligence examination of the height and weight growth data: We restricted the weight change to no more than +/-3 kg per month, the height change to less than 10cm per month. We excluded height measures that were shorter than previously recorded heights, and z-scores (WFA, HFA, WFH) that changed more than +/-2 units per month. These thresholds were determined upon review of World Health Organization growth charts, review of the current dataset, and by using clinical judgement.
Participant characteristics at study entry were summarized in a tabular form. Frequencies and percentages were calculated for categorical variables. Any visits occurring at a certain age point included a +/- 1 month window. For example, children who came to clinic between the ages of 11 and 13 months were marked as having a 12 month visit. In the event that multiple visits occurred within that window, only the first visit’s data was included. Mean and standard deviation were calculated for continuous variables. Descriptive statistics for participant characteristics were evaluated for the full sample and for the subsamples defined by the HIV status. Comparisons between HIV+ and HEU children of characteristics presented as proportions were analyzed using Chi-squared test, while comparisons of means between the two groups were analyzed using independent t-tests.
We also compared the proportions of stunting, underweight, and wasting among HIV+ and HEU children, using chi-square tests. We then performed a visit-level analysis, assessing WFA, HFA, and WFH at multiple points of observations. A random effects logistic regression model was used to accommodate within-subject correlations over time to assess the effects of factors that were associated with the risks of stunting, underweight, and wasting. Two authors (M.S.M. and R.C.V) reviewed all available variables and selected those which may be potential confounders using clinical judgement and knowledge of the literature. Univariate analysis was then performed with each of these variables, and those found to reach statistical significance (α set at 0.05) were included in the multiple variable logistical regression models. Estimated adjusted odds ratios and related confidence intervals were reported. Finally, we comparatively examined the mean HFA, WFA, and WFH curves among the two HIV subgroups, over the entire age range. Comparisons of the curves were made using a resampling-based test [30].
All analyses were implemented in SAS 9.4 (SAS Institute, Cary NC) and R 3.4.0. P values less than 0.05 were considered statistically significant.
Results
Participant characteristics
During the time period of interest, 15,428 children met the inclusion criteria, with 150,815 clinic visits included among them (Fig 1). Fifty-two percent (n = 7,955) of children were female, 16.7% (n = 2,577) were HIV+, and 83.3% (n = 12,851) were HEU. The mean age of enrollment was 2.1 ± 1.5 years for HIV+ children and 0.2 ± 0.3 years for HEU children. Nearly 15% (n = 372) of HIV+ children had at least one deceased parent compared to 3.5% (n = 437) of HEU children. Only 1% (n = 151) of all children were identified as failure to thrive by the clinician and 1.2% (n = 189) of all children were indicated to have a developmental disability by the clinician assessing them (Table 1). Baseline characteristics between HIV+ and HEU were significantly different from one another (most with p <0.001), with the exception of sex and specific clinic locations. For those HIV+ children with CD4 counts (n = 700), the mean and standard deviation was 798.5 and 471.5, respectively.
Rates of malnutrition
When compared to HEU children, the HIV+ children had higher rates of stunting, underweight status, and wasting at multiple time points. This difference was most significant for stunting at the 12 months visit (p<0.001); 24 month visit (p = 0.035); 36 month visit (p<0.001); and 48 month visit (p = 0.002). This difference was also statistically significant when comparing underweight status at the 12 month visit (p<0.001); 24 month visit (p<0.001); and 36 month visit (p = 0.004) and for wasting at 12 months (p<0.001) and 24 months (p<0.001) (Table 2). The numbers of HEU children coming in for visits decreased over time, with the largest decreases in attendance after the 12 and 24 month visits.
Trends of growth over time
Growth trends over time are illustrated by HIV status (Fig 2) and further subdivided by sex (Fig 3).
Solid line with shading indicates mean z-score for HIV-infected children. Dotted lines indicates mean z-score HIV-exposed but uninfected children. Shaded areas and dotted lines indicate 95% confidence interval of the estimated mean. (A) Weight-for-age (WFA) z-scores over age, in years; (B) Height-for-age (HFA) z-scores over age, in years; (C) Weight-for-height (WFH) z-scores over age, in years.
Solid line with shading indicates mean Z-score for HIV-infected children. Dotted lines indicates mean Z-score HIV-exposed but uninfected children. Shaded areas and dotted lines indicate 95% confidence interval of the estimated mean. (A) Weight-for-age (WFA) z-scores over age, males only; (B) WFA z-scores over age, females only; (C) Height-for-age (HFA) z-scores over age, males only; (D) HFA z-scores over age, females only; (E) Weight-for-height (WFH) z-scores over age, males only; (F) WFH z-scores over age, females only.
Underweight.
HIV+ children had a sharp decrease in WFA z-scores during the first year of their life (Fig 2A), and this was most prominent among the HIV+ males with a low estimated mean of -0.534 at 11 months of age (Fig 3A). This decrease in WFA z-scores gradually improved over time, and by 20 months, HIV+ children, both male and female, had a higher mean WFA z-score compared to HEU children. Overall, the growth curves of the HIV+ and HEU WFA z-scores were significantly different from each other, with HEU generally having lower z-scores (p <0.001).
Stunting.
The decline in the HFA z-scores started after birth for HIV+ children and around 6 months of age for HEU, reaching a low of -0.380 at 18 months for HIV+ children and -0.417 at 24 months for HEU children. Catch-up growth occurred for both HIV+ and HEU children, although the HEU caught up at a slower rate (Fig 2B). When comparing male and female HFA z-scores over time, their trends were similar (Fig 3C and 3D). Overall, there was a significant difference between HIV+ and HEU HFA z-score growth curves (p <0.001).
Wasting.
WFH z-scores followed a similar pattern to that of WFA z-scores. HIV+ children had a sharp decrease in WFH z-scores early in life, reaching an estimated mean low of -0.403 at 12.7 months of age (Fig 2C); however, the sharp decline seen among HIV+ males, a mean low of -0.497 at 13.3 months, likely influenced the severity of this drop (Fig 3E). This decrease gradually improved, and by 24 months, HIV+ children had a higher mean WFA z-scores compared to HEU. Overall, there was a significant difference between the HIV+ and HEU WFA growth curves, with HEU having lower z-scores (p <0.001).
Factors associated with malnutrition
Children living in rural settings were less likely to be stunted (OR:0.45; 95%CI:0.41 to 0.50) compared to those living in urban settings. The odds of being stunted when attending a rural health clinic or county/sub-county hospital were much higher compared to those for children attending the referral hospital, (county/sub-county: (OR:3.88;95%CI:3.53 to 4.27); rural health clinic: (OR:5.06; 95%CI:4.42 to 5.80)).
Children accompanied to clinic by grandparents were more likely to be underweight (OR:1.49; 95%CI:1.25 to 1.77) and wasted (OR:1.45; 95%CI:1.11 to 1.79). For every year of age older a child was enrolled in clinic, there was a higher odds of being stunted (OR:1.17; 95%CI:1.11 to 1.23) and underweight (OR:1.25; 95%CI:1.18 to 1.32). Females and those with ART exposure in-utero were less likely to be stunted, underweight, or wasted, while children who were HIV+ were more likely to be malnourished. Children for whom families reported mixed feedings at 3 months of age were less likely to be malnourished (Table 3).
Discussion
We found that, while the mean estimated z-scores for growth were generally above the cut-off for malnutrition, there were still a large proportion of children coming in each year who were malnourished. Some of the factors associated with malnourished status in children included living in urban settings, having a grandparent bring the child to clinic, and being HIV+. Females, those with in-utero ART exposure, and those who started mixed feeding by 3 months were less likely to be malnourished.
Malnutrition in the context of HIV is likely to have a ripple effect in increasing morbidities and mortalities in young children thus decreasing the gains made in reduction of under-five mortality globally over the last decade. Our results support prior findings of worse nutritional status in HIV+ children compared to HEU. In this cohort, HIV+ children were much more likely to be stunted, wasted, and underweight compared to HEU children. Even more concerning were the high proportion of both HIV+ and HEU children with moderate-to-severe stunting, underweight status, and wasting at each visit age. While our study did not include any HIV-unexposed children, national survey data from Kenya provides a comparative estimate of the general population’s nutritional status. According to the 2014 Kenya Demographic and Health Survey (KDHS), there was moderate-to-severe stunting in 35% of Kenyan children aged 12–17 months and 44% of Kenyan children aged 24–35 months [31]. Our study found rates of moderate-to-severe stunting 49% for HIV+ children at 12 months and 51% at 24 months. HEU children had similar rates of malnutrition compared to that reported in the KDHS survey. Similarly, there was a discrepancy between underweight and wasted status as reported within the KDHS compared to the HIV+ children within this clinical cohort [31]. Within the KDHS, the rates of malnutrition in the geographical regions where AMPATH operates did not differ substantially from the overall survey results, making it less likely that the difference found was primarily due to the regional rates of malnutrition. This leaves other factors, such as HIV infection, as being a potential contributor to worse nutritional status, as seen in other studies [8, 9, 18].
Our data have shown that HIV+ children are particularly vulnerable to malnutrition. Despite early initiation of ART, other studies from sub-Saharan Africa have also shown that HIV+ children have lower HFAZ compared to population norms [32, 33]. The etiology of this vulnerability is multifactorial, but certainly comorbidities such as increased prevalence of premature birth, diarrheal infection, pneumonia, tuberculosis infection, all contribute to the worse growth outcomes of HIV+ children [34–36]. While many of these comorbidities are also hold true for HEU children[13, 37], our study did not find differences in the proportion of children with malnutrition compared to national survey data. Growth data in other HEU populations within sub-Saharan Africa is mixed and it is unclear at this time whether there is a link between HIV exposure and malnutrition [18, 38, 39]. A meta-analysis is underway to determine across studies whether HEU children are also at higher risk for malnutrition [40]. Other social determinants of health, such as educational level and poverty, are also key variables that contribute to malnutrition, although they were not captured within this data set. We hypothesize these comorbidities play a role in malnutrition in our study population.
Our study also has the added advantage of tracking mean z-scores for children over time between the ages of 0–5 years. While there were decreases in mean z-scores around ages 1–2 years for both HIV+ and HEU children, the decrease in HIV+ typically occurred earlier. The etiology of this finding is unclear. However, we do know that failure to maintain adequate nutritional status during critical periods in brain development has lifelong effects on a child, and the first 1000 days of a child’s life are particularly important [41]. Thus, it is imperative that nutritional status is monitored from birth to ensure that interventions can be implemented prior to significant growth faltering.
The differences between the HIV+ and HEU children were clear early in analysis. Nearly all baseline characteristics differed significantly between the two groups. During comparisons of their rates of malnutrition and estimate mean scores, these differences remained. Due to the circumstances that allowed for the child to become HIV-infected, inherent differences exist between the groups including the age at enrollment and length of follow-up. For example, HIV+ children typically enrolled at an older age, likely due to the lack of maternal HIV diagnosis during pregnancy and hence, lack of ART exposure to prevent perinatal infection. Additionally, HEU children had better anthropometric outcomes compared to HIV+ children until approximately 18–24 months of age, at which time their estimated mean Z scores decreased. HIV+ and HEU children had similar rates of wasting above the age of 24 months and of stunting above the age of 36 months, with rates of wasted and stunted HEU children even exceeded that of HIV+ children in some cases. This suggests that HEU children remaining in care after 24 months of age may be inherently different than those lost-to-follow-up. We hypothesize that this is due to the confirmatory HIV testing which occurs at 18 months, and the large number of HEU children who stopped coming to clinic because, presumably, they were otherwise in generally good health. Those HEU children who remained to be seen within the clinic may have been sicker in general with poorer nutritional status, which is reflected in our results. These differences should be considered in any clinical setting that cares for both HIV+ and HEU children, to ensure appropriate resources are available at critical periods of need.
One area of concern that arose from this study was the discrepancy between the numbers of children identified as having failure-to-thrive by clinicians with the number of moderately-to-severely malnourished children. In settings with few providers trained in pediatrics, clinician assessments of growth, failure-to-thrive, and developmental delays might be very limited or absent. Even in well-resourced settings, failure-to-thrive in children is often overlooked [42]. However, in countries with minimal primary care services, healthcare systems that interact with children, either for acute conditions or specific disease processes, must educate their clinicians to identify and refer when issues are found to ensure optimal growth, health, and development of young children.
Other findings from this study provide new insights which warrant further exploration. In our study, females were less likely to be malnourished in stunting, underweight status, and wasting. The KDHS also indicated sex differences in regards to growth, with females faring better, and a meta-analysis found less stunting in girls in sub-Saharan Africa compared to boys [31, 43]. In other countries, such as India and Pakistan, studies have found the opposite to be true, with females being at greater risk for malnutrition [44, 45]. At this time, it is unclear what cultural or economic factors might account for these differences. However, it is important for countries to explore these differences to determine how to best improve the health of their children.
This study also found that children who started solid foods at 3 months were less likely to be malnourished. In this cohort, 1 in 6 HEU and 1 in 5 HIV+ children were started on solid foods at 3 months. The WHO and UNICEF recommend exclusive breastfeeding for the first 6 months of life to prevent undernutrition [46]. Some studies show exclusive breastfeeding for the first 6 months improves rates of stunting and underweight status [47]. However, other studies, such as a recent systematic review, did not find a difference in growth between feeding regimens, but it did show an improvement in the rate of iron deficiency anemia in breastfed infants when solid foods were introduced early [48]. For children born to HIV+ mothers, early mixed feeding is often discouraged due to the increased risk of HIV transmission and other infectious diseases [49, 50]. However, many HIV+ mothers start mixed feeding early, even in the first few weeks of an infant’s life [51]. While our results may suggest that early introduction to solid foods or mixed feedings benefits nutritional status, it is also possible that these children were introduced to solid foods earlier because their caregivers perceived that they were not gaining enough weight. More research is needed to clearly understand this issue before any definitive conclusions can be made.
Our study found that children were more likely to be malnourished when living in urban settings. This finding is in contrast with the KDHS data and other studies, which show that rural populations have increased rates of malnutrition compared to urban [31, 52]. However, these data often do not delineate individuals of lower socioeconomic status living in those urban settings, who often have much higher rates of malnutrition than other populations [53]. A study in Kenya showed that there is high prevalence of stunting (46%) in children living in urban poor settings [54]. We hypothesize that poverty in urban settings is a contributing factor to the outcomes of this study. Additionally, individuals living in rural areas may have the capabilities and resources to perform subsistence farming for some food items, whereas those living in urban settings would not. Healthcare systems must be aware of the disparities existing within urban populations to better identify children who are at risk for malnutrition and support them with nutritional services when warranted.
In this study, there were mixed results in terms of the nutritional status of children who were orphaned by either losing a single parent or both parents. Those children who had lost both parents tended to be less likely to have malnutrition than those who had both parents alive. One potential hypothesis for this finding may be that these children received additional resources through the healthcare system or government programs due to their vulnerable status. One limitation of this study is that we do not have data regarding nutritional referrals or receipt of food supplementation associated with each individual participant. Thus, we are only able to speculate on the results. While orphans are vulnerable to malnutrition, studies have found mixed results on this topic, and it appears the adverse effects of a parental loss may be mitigated if the appropriate resources and support are provided for the child [23, 55]. Child outcomes may also depend on who is ultimately responsible for the orphan’s care [56]. In our study, children brought to clinic by grandparents are more likely to be underweight and wasted, whereas no significant differences in nutritional status were noted when another family member brought the child to clinic. Further analyses would be necessary to delineate the potential heterogeneity among orphans in terms of their care provision and available resources. Other factors that may decrease the risk of malnutrition within our cohort should be explored.
With the nature of a retrospective chart review, there are limitations to the findings of this research. We relied on the data obtained at each clinic visit among 65 different clinics in western Kenya. While there are standard operating procedures for weighing and measuring the height of children during each visit, the methods and measurement instruments were not standardized throughout the data collection period as they would have been in a prospective trial. This may have introduced error into our data set. We attempted to mitigate that error by creating rules to remove data entries that fell out of the typical ranges of growth, but this would not have corrected for small variations in measurements. Another limitation to this study is that there was no HIV-unexposed group for comparison. During the time of data collection, only children exposed to HIV were seen within these clinics and data were subsequently entered into the EMR. The availability of the KDHS enables us to have a reference point of malnutrition rates in children of a similar age, living in the same regions as our AMPATH cohort, during the time range of our study’s data collection period. While the methods of collecting those data may differ slightly, this provides us with a representative population with whom we may compare our results. Additionally, due to the inherent differences between the HIV+ and HEU groups, these retrospective data reported may not be representative of the general characteristics of these populations as a whole. HIV+ children enrolled in clinic at an older age than HEU. As such, the characteristics of HIV+ children enrolling prior to 12 months of age may be different from those diagnosed later. Additionally, since a large number of HEU children no longer attended clinic after 18 months of age, the remaining cohort may not be representative of HEU between the ages of 24–60 months and may overestimate the proportion of children with malnutrition in those age groups. Finally, this study was also limited by the lack of differentiation among the HIV-indeterminate group, which was excluded from analysis. Because some members of that group may have been lost-to-follow-up prior to 18 months, their exclusion may lead to selection bias.
Conclusions
This study demonstrated higher rates of stunting, underweight status, and wasting for children born to HIV+ mothers compared to external data from the general Kenyan population and identified factors associated with malnutrition in this healthcare system. Additionally, HIV+ infected children had higher rates of malnutrition at an earlier age compared to HEU children. To our knowledge, this is the first large retrospective study performed on malnutrition using an EMR system in a resource-limited setting. While the use of EMR data had its limitations, the knowledge obtained from the analysis of a large, clinical cohort of children is uniquely valuable and informs next steps needed to better understand and address malnutrition in this setting.
Supporting information
S1 Table. De-identified AMPATH data set used for analysis.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0224295.s001
(XLSX)
References
- 1.
UNICEF. Malnutrition- UNICEF Data: UNICEF; 2018 [updated Jan 2018; cited 2018 March 6]. Available from: https://data.unicef.org/topic/nutrition/malnutrition/.
- 2.
Caulfield L, Richard S, Rivera J, Musgrove P, and Black R. Stunting, Wasting, and Micronutrient Deficiency Disorders. In: Jamison DT BJ, Measham AR, et al, editor. Disease Control Priorities in Developing Countries. 2 ed. Washington (DC): World Bank; 2006.
- 3.
Fishman S, Caulfield L, de Onis M, Blossner M, Hyder A, Mullany L, et al. Comparative quantification of health risks: global and regional burden of disease attributable to selected major risk factors. 2004; World Health Organization. [cited 2018 March 6]. Available from: https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/42770
- 4. Alderman H, Hoddinott J, and Kinsey B. Long term consequences of early childhood malnutrition. 2003. [cited 2018 March 6] Available from: https://ageconsearch.umn.edu/record/16436/files/fc040168.pdf
- 5. Gashu D, Stoecker BJ, Bougma K, Adish A, Haki GD, Marquis GS. Stunting, selenium deficiency and anemia are associated with poor cognitive performance in preschool children from rural Ethiopia. Nutrition Journal. 2016;15(1):38. pmid:27067274
- 6.
UNICEF. Statistics: Kenya: UNICEF; 2013 [cited 2018 March 6]. Available from: https://www.unicef.org/infobycountry/kenya_statistics.html.
- 7. McDonald CM, Kupka R, Manji KP, Okuma J, Bosch RJ, Aboud S, et al. Predictors of stunting, wasting and underweight among Tanzanian children born to HIV-infected women. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition. 2012;66(11):1265–76. pmid:23031850
- 8. Omoni AO, Ntozini R, Evans C, Prendergast AJ, Moulton LH, Christian PS, et al. Child growth according to maternal and child HIV status in Zimbabwe. The Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal. 2017;36(9):869–76. Epub 2017/02/16. pmid:28198792; PubMed Central PMCID: PMC5571879.
- 9. McGrath CJ, Nduati R, Richardson BA, Kristal AR, Mbori-Ngacha D, Farquhar C, et al. The prevalence of stunting is high in HIV-1-exposed uninfected infants in Kenya. The Journal of Nutrition. 2012;142(4):757–63. Epub 2012/03/02. pmid:22378334; PubMed Central PMCID: PMC3301992.
- 10. Fergusson P, Chinkhumba J, Grijalva-Eternod C, Banda T, Mkangama C, Tomkins A. Nutritional recovery in HIV-infected and HIV-uninfected children with severe acute malnutrition. Archives of Disease in Childhood. 2009;94(7):512. pmid:18977785
- 11. Isanaka S, Duggan C, Fawzi WW. Patterns of postnatal growth in HIV-infected and HIV-exposed children. Nutrition Reviews. 2009;67(6):343–59. PMC2771338. pmid:19519675
- 12. Filteau S. The HIV-exposed, uninfected African child. Tropical Medicine & International Health: TM & IH. 2009;14(3):276–87. Epub 2009/01/28. pmid:19171011.
- 13. Ramokolo V, Goga AE, Lombard C, Doherty T, Jackson DJ, Engebretsen IM. In utero ART exposure and birth and early growth outcomes among HIV-exposed uninfected infants attending immunization services: results from national PMTCT surveillance, South Africa. Open Forum Infect Dis. 2017;4(4):ofx187–ofx. pmid:29062860.
- 14. Slogrove A, Reikie B, Naidoo S, De Beer C, Ho K, Cotton M, et al. HIV-exposed uninfected infants are at increased risk for severe infections in the first year of life. Journal of Tropical Pediatrics. 2012;58(6):505–8. Epub 2012/05/05. pmid:22555385; PubMed Central PMCID: PMC3612013.
- 15. McHenry MS, McAteer CI, Oyungu E, McDonald BC, Bosma CB, Mpofu PB, et al. Neurodevelopment in young children born to HIV-infected mothers: a meta-analysis. Pediatrics. 2018;141(2). Epub 2018/01/28. pmid:29374109; PubMed Central PMCID: PMC5810606 conflicts of interest to disclose.
- 16. Akanbi MO, Ocheke AN, Agaba PA, Daniyam CA, Agaba EI, Okeke EN, et al. Use of electronic health records in sub-Saharan Africa: progress and challenges. Journal of Medicine in the Tropics. 2012;14(1):1–6. PMC4167769. pmid:25243111
- 17. Jawhari B, Ludwick D, Keenan L, Zakus D, Hayward R. Benefits and challenges of EMR implementations in low resource settings: a state-of-the-art review. BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making. 2016;16:116. Epub 2016/09/08. pmid:27600269; PubMed Central PMCID: PMC5011989.
- 18. Rosala-Hallas A, Bartlett JW, Filteau S. Growth of HIV-exposed uninfected, compared with HIV-unexposed, Zambian children: a longitudinal analysis from infancy to school age. BMC Pediatrics. 2017;17(1):80. Epub 2017/03/18. pmid:28302082; PubMed Central PMCID: PMC5356250.
- 19. Einterz RM, Kelley CR, Mamlin JJ, Van Reken DE. Partnerships in international health. The Indiana University-Moi University experience. Infect Dis Clin North Am. 1995;9(2):453–5. pmid:7673682.
- 20. Siika AM, Rotich JK, Simiyu CJ, Kigotho EM, Smith FE, Sidle JE, et al. An electronic medical record system for ambulatory care of HIV-infected patients in Kenya. Int J Med Inform. 2005;74(5):345–55. pmid:15893257.
- 21. Mamlin BW, Biondich PG, Wolfe BA, Fraser H, Jazayeri D, Allen C, et al. Cooking up an open source EMR for developing countries: OpenMRS—a recipe for successful collaboration. AMIA Annu Symp Proc. 2006:529–33. Epub 2007/01/24. 86578 [pii]. pmid:17238397.
- 22. Braitstein P, Katshcke A, Shen C, Sang E, Nyandiko W, Ochieng VO, et al. Retention of HIV-infected and HIV-exposed children in a comprehensive HIV clinical care programme in Western Kenya. Tropical Medicine and International Health. 2010;15(7):833–41. pmid:20487430
- 23. Nyandiko WM, Ayaya S, Nabakwe E, Tenge C, Sidle JE, Yiannoutsos CT, et al. Outcomes of HIV-infected orphaned and non-orphaned children on antiretroviral therapy in western Kenya. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes (1999). 2006;43(4):418–25. Epub 2006/11/14. pmid:17099313.
- 24. Nyandiko WM, Otieno-Nyunya B, Musick B, Bucher-Yiannoutsos S, Akhaabi P, Lane K, et al. Outcomes of HIV-exposed children in Western Kenya: Efficacy of prevention of mother to child transmission in a resource-constrained setting. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes. 2010;54(1):42–50. pmid:20224420
- 25.
Kenya Ministry of Health. Guidelines for Prevention of Mother to Child Transmission (PMTCT) of HIV/AIDS in Kenya. National AIDS & STI Control Programme. 4th ed. Nairobi, Kenya: Republic of Kenya, Minstry of Health; 2012. p. 82.
- 26.
World Health Organization. Consolidated Guidelines on The Use of Antiretroviral Drugs and Treating and Preventing HIV Infection: Recommendations for a public health approach. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization; 2013. p. 272.
- 27.
Apondi E. "AMPATH Standard Operating Procedures: Maternal-Child Health Clinic Follow up for HIV-exposed Infant. [Personal Communications with McHenry M) 1 August 2019.
- 28.
World Health Organization. Global Database on Child Growth and Malnutrition Geneva: World Health Organization,; [cited 2016 January]. Available from: http://www.who.int/nutgrowthdb/software/en/.
- 29. Mei Z, Grummer-Strawn LM. Standard deviation of anthropometric Z-scores as a data quality assessment tool using the 2006 WHO growth standards: a cross country analysis. Bull World Health Organ. 2007;85(6):441–8. pmid:17639241.
- 30. Young SG, Bowman AW. Non-Parametric Analysis of Covariance. Biometrics. 1995;51(3):920–31.
- 31.
Kenya National Bureau of Statistics. Kenya Demographic and Health Survey. Nairobi, Kenya: Repubic of Kenya; 2015. [cited 2018 March 7]. Available from: https://dhsprogram.com/pubs/pdf/fr308/fr308.pdf
- 32. Shiau S, Arpadi S, Strehlau R, Martens L, Patel F, Coovadia A, et al. Initiation of antiretroviral therapy before 6 months of age is associated with faster growth recovery in South African children perinatally infected with human immunodeficiency virus. The Journal of Pediatrics. 2013;162(6):1138–45, 45.e1-2. Epub 2013/01/15. pmid:23312691; PubMed Central PMCID: PMC3640753.
- 33. Jesson J, Dahourou DL, Amorissani Folquet M, Malateste K, Yonaba C, N'Gbeche MS, et al. Malnutrition, growth response and metabolic changes within the first 24 months after ART initiation in HIV-infected children treated before the age of 2 years in west Africa. The Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal. 2018;37(8):781–7. Epub 2018/02/07. pmid:29406463.
- 34. Sewale Y, Hailu G, Sintayehu M, Moges NA, Alebel A. Magnitude of malnutrition and associated factors among HIV infected children attending HIV-care in three public hospitals in East and West Gojjam Zones, Amhara, Northwest, Ethiopia, 2017: a cross-sectional study. BMC Research Notes. 2018;11(1):788. pmid:30390693
- 35. Martin R, Boyer P, Hammill H, Peavy H, Platzker A, Settlage R, et al. Incidence of premature birth and neonatal respiratory disease in infants of HIV-positive mothers. The Journal of Pediatrics. 1997;131(6):851–6. pmid:9427889
- 36. Nyandiko WM, Mwangi A, Ayaya SO, Nabakwe EC, Tenge CN, Gisore PM, et al. Characteristics of HIV-infected children seen in western Kenya. East African Medical Journal. 2009;86(8):364–73. Epub 2010/06/26. pmid:20575310.
- 37. Brennan AT, Bonawitz R, Gill CJ, Thea DM, Kleinman M, Long L, et al. A meta-analysis assessing diarrhea and pneumonia in HIV-exposed uninfected compared with HIV-unexposed uninfected infants and children. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes (1999). 2019;82(1):1–8. Epub 2019/08/14. pmid:31408450.
- 38. Bailey RC, Kamenga MC, Nsuami MJ, Nieburg P, St Louis ME. Growth of children according to maternal and child HIV, immunological and disease characteristics: a prospective cohort study in Kinshasa, Democratic Republic of Congo. International Journal of Epidemiology. 1999;28(3):532–40. Epub 1999/07/16. pmid:10405861.
- 39. Makasa M, Kasonka L, Chisenga M, Sinkala M, Chintu C, Tomkins A, et al. Early growth of infants of HIV-infected and uninfected Zambian women. Tropical Medicine & International Health. 2007;12(5):594–602. Epub 2007/04/21. pmid:17445127.
- 40. Ekali GL, Jesson J, Enok PB, Leroy V. Effect of in utero exposure to HIV and antiretroviral drugs on growth in HIV-exposed uninfected children: a systematic review and meta-analysis protocol. BMJ Open. 2019;9(6):e023937. Epub 2019/06/24. pmid:31229997; PubMed Central PMCID: PMC6596996.
- 41. Schwarzenberg SJ, Georgieff MK. Advocacy for Improving Nutrition in the First 1000 Days to Support Childhood Development and Adult Health. Pediatrics. 2018;141(2). pmid:29358479
- 42. Spencer NJ. Failure to think about failure to thrive. Archives of Disease in Childhood. 2007;92(2):95–7. PMC2083320. pmid:17264277
- 43. Wamani H, Åstrøm AN, Peterson S, Tumwine JK, Tylleskär T. Boys are more stunted than girls in sub-Saharan Africa: a meta-analysis of 16 demographic and health surveys. BMC pediatrics. 2007;7(1):17. pmid:17425787
- 44. Kshatriya GK, Acharya SK. Gender disparities in the prevalence of undernutrition and the higher risk among the young women of Indian tribes. PLoS ONE. 2016;11(7):e0158308. pmid:27379521.
- 45. Nuruddin R, Hadden WC. Are pre-school girls more likely to be under-nourished in rural Thatta, Pakistan?-a cross-sectional study. International Journal for Equity in Health. 2015;14:151. pmid:26689821.
- 46.
World Health Organization. Infant and young child feeding: WHO; 2017 [updated July 2017; cited 2018 7 March]. Available from: http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs342/en/.
- 47. Kuchenbecker J, Jordan I, Reinbott A, Herrmann J, Jeremias T, Kennedy G, et al. Exclusive breastfeeding and its effect on growth of Malawian infants: results from a cross-sectional study. Paediatrics and International Child Health. 2015;35(1):14–23. pmid:25005815
- 48. Qasem W, Fenton T, Friel J. Age of introduction of first complementary feeding for infants: a systematic review. BMC Pediatrics. 2015;15:107. PMC4557230. pmid:26328549
- 49. Effect of breastfeeding on infant and child mortality due to infectious diseases in less developed countries: a pooled analysis. WHO Collaborative Study Team on the Role of Breastfeeding on the Prevention of Infant Mortality. Lancet (London, England). 2000;355(9202):451–5. Epub 2000/06/07. pmid:10841125.
- 50. Coutsoudis A, Pillay K, Kuhn L, Spooner E, Tsai WY, Coovadia HM. Method of feeding and transmission of HIV-1 from mothers to children by 15 months of age: prospective cohort study from Durban, South Africa. AIDS (London, England). 2001;15(3):379–87. Epub 2001/03/29. pmid:11273218.
- 51. Kiarie JN, Richardson BA, Mbori-Ngacha D, Nduati RW, John-Stewart GC. Infant feeding practices of women in a perinatal HIV-1 prevention study in Nairobi, Kenya. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes (1999). 2004;35(1):75–81. PMC3380107.
- 52. Smith LC, Ruel MT, Ndiaye A. Why is child malnutrition lower in urban than in rural areas? Evidence from 36 developing countries. World Development. 2005;33(8):1285–305.
- 53. Van de Poel E, O’Donnell O, Van Doorslaer E. Are urban children really healthier? Evidence from 47 developing countries. Social Science & Medicine. 2007;65(10):1986–2003. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socscimed.2007.06.032.
- 54. Kimani-Murage EW, Muthuri SK, Oti SO, Mutua MK, van de Vijver S, Kyobutungi C. Evidence of a double burden of malnutrition in urban poor settings in Nairobi, Kenya. PLoS One. 2015;10(6):e0129943. Epub 2015/06/23. pmid:26098561; PubMed Central PMCID: PMC4476587.
- 55. Finlay JE, Fink G, McCoy DC, Tavarez LC, Chai J, Danaei G, et al. Stunting risk of orphans by caregiver and living arrangement in low-income and middle-income countries. Journal of epidemiology and community health. 2016;70(8):784–90. Epub 2016/01/31. pmid:26826211.
- 56. Ayaya SO, Esamai FO, Rotich J, Olwambula AR. Socio-economic factors predisposing under five-year-old children to severe protein energy malnutrition at the Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital, Eldoret, Kenya. East African Medical Journal. 2004;81(8):415–21. Epub 2004/12/30. pmid:15622936.