Cavity optocapillaries

Droplets, particularly water droplets, are abundant in both natural and artificial systems. Their capillary oscillations are governed by surface tension and are therefore distinguished from acoustic oscillations. These capillary oscillations play a major role in droplet coalescence, for example, and are also an important phenomenon in interface theories. Here, we experimentally and theoretically analyze the capillary oscillation within an optical cavity with walls of water. Our droplet benefits from an optical finesse of 520 that, accordingly, boosts its sensitivity in recording Brownian capillaries with amplitudes of 1 0.025 Å and kilohertz rates in agreement with naturalfrequency calculations. Our hybrid device allows resonantly enhanced interactions between electromagnetic and capillary waves that could potentially lead to optical excitation or the cooling of droplet capillary oscillations. © 2016 Optical

Droplets, particularly water droplets, are abundant in both natural and artificial systems. Their capillary oscillations are governed by surface tension and are therefore distinguished from acoustic oscillations. These capillary oscillations play a major role in droplet coalescence, for example, and are also an important phenomenon in interface theories. Here, we experimentally and theoretically analyze the capillary oscillation within an optical cavity with walls of water. Our droplet benefits from an optical finesse of 520 that, accordingly, boosts its sensitivity in recording Brownian capillaries with amplitudes of 1 0.025 Å and kilohertz rates in agreement with naturalfrequency calculations. Our hybrid device allows resonantly enhanced interactions between electromagnetic and capillary waves that could potentially lead to optical excitation or the cooling of droplet capillary oscillations. Thermal fluctuations imply that droplet interfaces behave like a stormy sea at the sub-nanometer scale. Thermal capillary waves were first suggested by Smoluchowski [1] and have been widely studied since then [2][3][4][5][6][7]. These waves are important in processes such as the spontaneous rupture of liquid films [8,9] and droplet coalescence [10]. Thermal capillaries were measured via deviations in the law of reflection from liquid interfaces. For example, light [2] and x ray [3][4][5][6] scattering techniques from liquid interfaces revealed details on the thermal capillary roughness and dynamics as well as on the reduction of the surface tension in short-length scales [6]. This reduction is significant to the theory of interfaces [11,12]. Recently, thermal capillary waves and droplet coalescence were directly visually observed in a colloidal suspension [7] while exploiting the scaling up of the lengths when going from molecules to mesoscopic colloidal particles (diameter ∼100 nm). These colloids were used for measuring thermal capillaries since the direct tracking of the dynamics of individual atoms is not experimentally feasible. In a droplet, thermal fluctuations were measured by interfering the reflection from its interface with a reference beam [13]. It is important to distinguish our work here, on capillary droplet resonance, from experiments where acoustical droplet resonances were studied [14]. A detailed comparison between capillary waves and sound is given in Table 1.
Generally speaking, extending interference experiments as in [13] to measure interference between many reflections from the liquid interface (instead of one) can provide an interfacedisplacement sensitivity that linearly increases with the number of reflections. In fact, placing two mirrors facing each other to constitute an optical resonator can provide the mirror displacement with a resolution as fine as the optical wavelength divided by the number of round trips [15].
This number of optical round trips is therefore called "finesse": basically, it describes how fine a resolution this cavity can provide. Indeed, optical cavities are commonly used to boost the sensitivity in displacement measurement devices, including gravitational wave detectors [16]. Relevant to our experiment, light can also resonate while circulating on the circumference of a droplet. Continuous research in droplet optical resonators [17][18][19][20][21] has led to the recent demonstration of water droplets with ultrahigh finesse [22]. In this demonstration, photons are confined in a tight, 180 nm region adjacent to the droplet interface [ Fig. 1(a) inset] where the capillaries reside. For this reason, it is natural to ask if droplets with high optical finesse can provide resonantly enhanced access to thermal capillaries. Ideally, a 10 6 -finesse droplet, as reported in [22], can improve the displacement resolution by a factor of a million. Yet for our purposes here, we investigate a 520-finesse system, where a 1% change in optical transmission represents a 0.026 Å droplet deformation.
Beyond allowing a finesse-scaled boost in resolving capillaries, a resonator cohosting light and capillaries can pave the way for new frontiers. That is, and from a broader-impact point of view, optocapillary cavities can support a controlled energy exchange between light and capillaries. Such an energy exchange is possible, for instance, by operating at the resonance sideband region. As an example, operating at the blue (/red) side of the optical resonance can facilitate optical excitation (/cooling) of capillary oscillations, which we believe will be soon possible with our optocapillary resonator. In the following, we discuss the droplet from a "capillary" point of view. Droplets represent a fundamental structure of self-contained liquid bounded almost completely by free surfaces. Unlike freely propagating capillary waves with a continuous frequency spectrum, droplets host a set of discrete thermal capillary resonances that dominate the droplet spectrum at the relatively low damping (by viscosity) region. The lowest capillary eigenfrequency is near the frequency of a capillary wave whose length is comparable with the droplet size and is known as the cutoff frequency.
To couple between the drop's optical and capillary oscillations, we set our laser wavelength near an optical resonance. As one can see in Fig. 1(b), the transmission fluctuation, ΔT , will scale with the radius fluctuation, Δr, [15] as given by where Q is the optical quality factor of the droplets and r is the radius. A system with an input optical frequency near the steepest region of the Lorentzian-shaped resonance can therefore translate radius fluctuations to changes in the optical transmission through the cavity. This transmission can be easily measured with a photodetector. Relying on this principle, we use the optical mode [17][18][19][20][21][22] as a probe that optically interrogates the drop's thermal capillary oscillations [23,24]. As one can see in Fig. 1(b), a spherical droplet can oscillate in a capillary manner. The eigenfrequency of this shape oscillation [23,24] is where ρ and γ are the liquid density and surface tension at the air-liquid interface. Using this analytical solution, we estimate the spring constant of this system, k, assuming that the effective vibrating mass is half the droplet mass. The thermal capillary fluctuation, Δr, in this droplet is calculated using where T is the temperature and k B is the Boltzmann constant.
Substituting typical values, the thermal capillary motion of an r 10 μm droplet at room temperature is Δr 1.8 Å.
We fabricate our water droplet resonator by dipping one side of a silica stem in a practically unlimited water reservoir [22]. As silica is hydrophilic, water creeps up the stem, forming a droplet at its end [ Fig. 1(a)]. We then use a tapered fiber to evanescently couple light into the water droplet [25]. These tapers are convenient for coupling light in and out of solid and liquid [19,20] resonators since they end with a standard optical fiber at both their input and output sides. Next, we characterize the optical resonance of the droplet by scanning the pump-laser wavelength through a resonance [ Fig. 1(c)]. We calculated an optical quality of 70,000 from the resonance linewidth.
Monitoring the transmission near a resonance, such as in Fig. 1(b), can teach us about a liquid droplet's size fluctuation. This technique was used to similarly interrogate shape oscillations in solid devices [26]. We should note here that the resonance wavelength [ Fig. 1(b)] does not instantly track radius fluctuations; rather, it is delayed by the cavity photon lifetime. Still, as the photon lifetime in our 70,000 Q experiment is 70 ps, we well oversample [27] our ∼100 kHz capillary fluctuations.
We experimentally record the thermal capillaries of our water droplet by tuning our laser wavelength near the resonance [as illustrated in Fig. 1(c)] and then measuring the radius fluctuations by monitoring the transmission. These kHz transmission fluctuations can be heard in Visualization 1. Figure 2 shows the measured drop's fluctuations that reveal, as expected [28], quasi-sinusoidal oscillations in the temporal domain. This type of quasi-sinusoidal oscillation was theoretically predicted [28] to be irregular over a period of time comparable to the ripplon lifetime. As the irregularity period here [ Fig. 2(a)] is longer than the oscillation cycle, we can say that these droplet fluctuations are in the under-damped regime. This claim is in agreement with our calculations using the relatively low viscosity of water [29].
Upon examination of the oscillation in the frequency domain [Figs. 2(b) and 2(c)], we focus our analysis on two peaks that dominate over their vicinity. Performing a finite element calculation (ANSYS Fluent) reveals droplet eigenmodes [Figs. 2(b) and 2(c)] with eigenfrequencies near the rates of the experimentally measured peaks. As expected, the lowest-frequency mode relates to motion along the axial direction, which is the longest in our system. Similarly, the higher-frequency mode [Fig 2(b), right] involves motion along the shorter radial direction.
In contrast to freely propagating capillary waves where all the frequencies are allowed, a droplet cannot host modes with wavelengths larger than the droplet diameter. Indeed and as seen in Fig. 2(a), we observe a reduction in thermal capillaries below the first mode (near 50 kHz), where the density of the capillary states drops. Such a reduction is typically called the cutoff and the eigenfrequency of the lowest state is called the cutoff frequency.
Looking at Fig. 1(b), one expects that the highest detection sensitivity for thermal capillaries is at the steepest slope region of Letter the Lorentzian shape. Contrary to that region, the Lorentzian center exhibits a zero first derivative where sensitivity for detecting thermal capillaries vanishes. To find that optocapillary coupling indeed scales with the first derivative of the Lorentzian representing optical transmission, we measure the transmission oscillation again, but now by scanning our laser frequency through the resonance. We use here an octane droplet submerged in water [30]. This octane-core water-clad droplet is almost perfectly spherical, and its position (with respect to the tapered-fiber coupler) is controlled using optical tweezers, as explained in [30].
As one can see in Fig. 3, we scan our laser frequency through the regions of maximal and minimal optocapillary coupling. Of course, the regions of maximal optocapillary coupling [Figs. 3(a)-3(f ), green background] are interesting from the practical point of view of needing high sensitivity. The region of zero optocapillary coupling (which appears between the green backgrounds) is less practical for sensing capillaries; yet, it depicts the Lorentzian optocapillary transfer function at its singular flat-top region. Capillaries in this region do not affect the cavity optical transmission. We end our experiment here by showing that optocapillary coupling indeed scales with the slope of the optical-resonance transmission [ Fig. 3(f )], as expected from the illustration of optocapillary coupling [ Fig. 1(b)]. The fact that transmission oscillation follows the first derivative of (DC) transmission [ Fig. 3(f )] makes it unlikely that the oscillation originates from oscillation in the coupling strength or the laser power. These are independent of , where the oscillation frequencies that dominate over their vicinity are linked to calculated droplet modes (inset); see Visualization 2 and Visualization 3. The blue arrows lead to a zoomed-in plot where each of the points represents the transmission average over a 125 ns period. The error bar represents the standard deviation for each average. Presenting the capillary spectrum on a (c) log-log scale reveals a drop at high frequencies where the black line represents a Lorentzian fit. The Lorentzian "skirt" dominates at the high frequencies on the right-hand side of (c). The stem holding the droplets has a radius of 5 μm and the droplet radius is 16 μm and the optical wavelength is 980 nm. Deformation in the three-dimensional plots is exaggerated in the graphics. Letter the transmission slope. As for possible oscillation in the laser frequency, we choose a laser with a specified frequency drift (NewFocus Velocity Laser TLB-6700) that is 4500 times smaller than the frequency drifts caused by the droplet capillaries. We experimentally confirm this laser spec by performing a controlgroup experiment to test the laser, as shown in Fig. 1(d), against a solid silica "droplet" (silica stiffness is comparable to that of steel) with an optical quality factor of 300 million [22].
In conclusion, we fabricated an optocapillary resonator, then used its optical resonance to probe thermal capillaries with the resolution enhanced by its 520 finesse. We measure thermal capillary oscillations in a droplet as well as their cutoff with a resolution of 0.03 Å. Our technique is relatively simple as it is relies on regular water, uses standard optical fibers and photodetectors, operates on an individual droplet at room temperature and pressure, and requires no controller or feedback loop.
Energy exchange and interaction between light and sound (optoacoustics) or light and light (nonlinear optics) has been widely studied. Its most important enabler is a resonator with optical modes that overlap the wave they interact with. In contrast, optocapillary resonators are rarely available. Light was therefore thought of as minimally interacting with capillaries. We believe that our optocapillary cavity will serve as a bridge between capillary and optical waves and will facilitate resonantly enhanced optocapillary interactions that might enable optical excitation (/cooling) of capillary droplet modes and the search for capillary rogue waves.