Inkjet printing of transparent sol-gel computer generated holograms

In this paper we report for the first time a method for the production of transparent computer generated holograms by desktop inkjet printing. Here we demonstrate a methodology suitable for the development of a practical approach towards fabrication of diffraction patterns using a desktop inkjet printer and nonocrystalline sol-gel ink. In particular, the reported inkjet printing method can be used to generate transparent diffraction structures on supports such as those widely applied in security technologies. Transparent highly refractive layers were deposited with a high precision via a wet-to-dry printing method based on the sol-gel transition phenomenon. With this approach we were able to print a diffraction pattern by TiO2 xerogel, with which a transparent computer generated hologram was created. We argue that this new technology can form the foundation for a new generation of commercial protective coating technologies applied by industrial inkjet printing. c © 2016 Optical Society of America OCIS codes: (090.1760) Computer holography; (160.4236) Nanomaterials; (160.4670) Optical materials. References and links 1. T. Serra, J. Planell, and M. Navarro, “High-resolution PLA-based composite scaffolds via 3-d printing technology,” Acta Biomater. 9, 5521–5530 (2013). 2. H. Sirringhaus, T. Kawase, R. Friend, T. Shimoda, M. Inbasekaran, W. Wu, and E. Woo, “High-resolution inkjet printing of all-polymer transistor circuits,” Science 290, 2123–2126 (2000). 3. M. Singh, H. M. Haverinen, P. Dhagat, and G. E. Jabbour, “Inkjet printing process and its applications,” Adv. Mater. 22, 673–685 (2010). 4. P. Calvert, “Inkjet printing for materials and devices,” Chem. Mater. 13, 3299–3305 (2001). 5. E. Palmer, M. Hutley, A. Franks, J. Verrill, and B. Gale, “Diffraction gratings (manufacture),” Rep. Prog. Phys. 38, 975 (1975). 6. P. Calverta, “Inkjet printing for materials and devices,” Chem. Mater. 13, 3299–3305 (2001). 7. M. Singh, H. M. Haverinen, P. Dhagat, and G. E. Jabbour, “Inkjet printing process and its applications,” Adv. Mater. 22, 673–685 (2010). 8. A. V. Yakovlev, V. A. Milichko, V. V. Vinogradov, and A. V. Vinogradov, “Inkjet color printing by interference nanostructures,” ACS Nano 10, 3078–3086 (2016). PMID: 26805775. 9. T. R. Hebner, C. C. Wu, D. Marcy, M. H. Lu, and J. C. Sturm, “Ink-jet printing of doped polymers for organic light emitting devices,” Appl. Phys. Lett. 72, 519–521 (1998). 10. S. Zhang, “Fabrication of novel biomaterials through molecular self-assembly,” Nat. Biotechnol. 21, 1171–1178 (2003). 11. D. Angmo, T. T. Larsen-Olsen, M. Jørgensen, R. R. Søndergaard, and F. C. Krebs, “Roll-to-Roll inkjet printing and photonic sintering of electrodes for ITO free polymer solar cell modules and facile product integration,” Adv. Energy Mater. 3, 172–175 (2013). 12. M. Jung, J. Kim, J. Noh, N. Lim, C. Lim, G. Lee, J. Kim, H. Kang, K. Jung, A. D. Leonard, J. M. Tour, and G. Cho, “All-printed and roll-to-roll-printable 13.56-MHz-operated 1-bit RF tag on plastic foils,” IEEE Trans. Electron Devices 57, 571–580 (2010). 13. X. Lin, H. Subbaraman, Z. Pan, A. Hosseini, C. Longe, K. Kubena, P. Schleicher, P. Foster, S. Brickey, and R. T. Chen, “Towards realizing high-throughput, roll-to-roll manufacturing of flexible electronic systems,” Electron. 3, 624–635 (2014). 14. C. Zhang, H. Subbaraman, Q. Li, Z. Pan, J. G. Ok, T. Ling, C.-J. Chung, X. Zhang, X. Lin, R. T. Chen, L. Jay Guo, “Printed photonic elements: nanoimprinting and beyond,” J. Mater. Chem. C 4, 5133–5153 (2016). Vol. 6, No. 12 | 1 Dec 2016 | OPTICAL MATERIALS EXPRESS 3794 #275184 http://dx.doi.org/10.1364/OME.6.003794 Journal © 2016 Received 6 Sep 2016; revised 28 Oct 2016; accepted 31 Oct 2016; published 10 Nov 2016 15. B. MacCraith, C. McDonagh, G. O’Keeffe, A. McEvoy, T. Butler, and F. Sheridan, “Sol-gel coatings for optical chemical sensors and biosensors,” Sens. Actuators, B 29, 51–57 (1995). 16. C. Brinker, K. Keefer, D. Schaefer, and C. Ashley, “Sol-gel transition in simple silicates,” J. Non-Cryst. Solids 48, 47–64 (1982). 17. L. C. Klein, Sol-gel optics: processing and applications, vol. 259 (Springer Science & Business Media, 2013). 18. D. Chen, “Anti-reflection (AR) coatings made by sol–gel processes: a review,” Sol. Energy Mater. Sol. Cells 68, 313–336 (2001). 19. J. Stringer and B. Derby, “Formation and stability of lines produced by inkjet printing,” Langmuir 26, 10365–10372 (2010). 20. B. E. Yoldas, “Design of sol-gel coating media for ink-jet printing,” J. Sol-Gel Sci. Technol. 13, 147–152 (1998). 21. C. Brinker, G. Frye, A. Hurd, and C. Ashley, “Fundamentals of sol-gel dip coating,” Thin Solid Films 201, 97–108 (1991). 22. A. V. Yakovlev, V. A. Milichko, V. V. Vinogradov, and A. V. Vinogradov, “Sol-gel assisted inkjet hologram patterning,” Adv. Func. Mater. 25, 7375–7380 (2015). 23. Y. Han, C. Wei, and J. Dong, “Super-resolution electrohydrodynamic (EHD) 3d printing of micro-structures using phase-change inks,” Manuf. Lett. 2, 96 – 99 (2014). 24. J.-U. Park, M. Hardy, S. J. Kang, K. Barton, K. Adair, D. kishore Mukhopadhyay, C. Y. Lee, M. S. Strano, A. G. Alleyne, J. G. Georgiadis, Placid M. Ferreira, John A. Rogers, “High-resolution electrohydrodynamic jet printing,” Nat. Mater. 6, 782–789 (2007). 25. M. S. Onses, E. Sutanto, P. M. Ferreira, A. G. Alleyne, and J. A. Rogers, “Mechanisms, capabilities, and applications of high-resolution electrohydrodynamic jet printing,” Small 11, 4237–4266 (2015). 26. C. Lv, Z. Jia, Y. Liu, J. Mo, P. Li, and X. Lv, “Angle-resolved diffraction grating biosensor based on porous silicon,” J. Appl. Phys. 119, 094502 (2016). 27. H. H. Solak, C. David, J. Gobrecht, V. Golovkina, F. Cerrina, S. Kim, and P. Nealey, “Sub-50 nm period patterns with EUV interference lithography,” Microelectron. Eng. 67, 56–62 (2003). 28. Y. Xie, Z. Lu, and F. Li, “Lithographic fabrication of large curved hologram by laser writer,” Opt. Express 12, 1810–1814 (2004). 29. J. Wu, “Computer generated hologram,” Ph.D. thesis (2007). 30. I. Hołowacz, H. Podbielska, J. Bauer, and A. Ulatowska-Jarża, “Viscosity, surface tension and refractive index of tetraethylorthosilicate-based sol-gel materials depending on ethanol content,” Opt. Appl. 35, 691–699 (2005). 31. H. Dong, W. W. Carr, D. G. Bucknall, and J. F. Morris, “Temporally-resolved inkjet drop impaction on surfaces,” AIChE J. 53, 2606–2617 (2007). 32. D. Jang, D. Kim, and J. Moon, “Influence of fluid physical properties on ink-jet printability,” Langmuir 25, 2629–2635 (2009). PMID: 19196020. 33. I. Botten, M. Craig, R. McPhedran, J. Adams, and J. Andrewartha, “The dielectric lamellar diffraction grating,” J. Mod. Opt. 28, 413–428 (1981). 34. J. R. Marciante, N. O. Farmiga, J. I. Hirsh, M. S. Evans, and H. T. Ta, “Optical measurement of depth and duty cycle for binary diffraction gratings with subwavelength features,” Appl. Opt. 42, 3234–3240 (2003). 35. F. L. McCrackin, E. Passaglia, R. R. Stromberg, and H. L. Steinberg, “Measurement of the thickness and refractive index of very thin films and the optical properties of surfaces by ellipsometry,” J. Res. Nat. Bur. Sec. A 67 (1963).


Introduction
The development of additive technologies and materials for security printing holds a great promise for a wide range of industrial applications well beyond the modern printing industry. Despite the great success of modern three-dimensional (3D) printing methods and their growing widespread utilization in different applications, these methods still cannot be routinely used to achieve a resolution below 5 microns [1]. Nevertheless, more advanced approaches based on the layering of materials have recently extended the capabilities of such techniques to the diffraction limit of about 1 micron. Interestingly, this limitation can be in principle overcome by using technologies based on a much more established 1D printing technology. Inkjet printing represents the leading technology among such 1D printing methods [2]. This method is based on the use of liquid ink, which upon contacting with the substrate dries either naturally or with the help of different drying methods (based on infrared (IR), ultraviolet (UV), etc. irradiation) to produce a print [3]. Besides the well-known household and print-industry applications, the inkjet printing method is a well-established technique for the nanofabrication of various structures attracting therefore a great attention from different technological areas including for example the production biosensors [4]. The advantage of this technology is the high accuracy of positioning of the printed structures along with the clear economic advantages associated among others with the intrinsically low consumption of expensive reagents.
Another advantage of inkjet printing is the possibility of locally applying a strictly predetermined amount of a liquid ink at a high printing speed, up to 244 m/min (for HP industrial printing systems) on a single printhead. Taking into account that considering that the deposition of a printed material does not require additional drying and can be carried out in a single step, such a high printing speed represents one of the key advantages of such technologies compared to those employing photoresists requiring multistage production [5]. Previously inkjet printing has been applied for producing various coatings ranging from conductive transparent films to optical coatings [6]. The development of nanoparticle-based inks allowed expanding [7] the applicability of inkjet printing to fabrication of micro and nanostructured solid objects with a resolution of up to 20 nm along the z-axis [8]. This technological advancement was the result of the unique properties of nanoparticles related to both their small dimensions and specific physico-chemical characteristics, which allow producing uniform layers [9] and induce self-assembly of materials [10] and specific packing on the surface of substrates giving rise to important properties of the resulting materials including new optical characteristics inaccessible to the respective bulk materials.
The utilization of inkjet printing for the production of optical coatings and optical devices is still an underdeveloped technological area. This is primarily due to the intrinsic limitations of the classical method. The principle possibility to obtain optical devices by a controlled deposition of a matter using an inkjet printer would give rise in a near future to a complete new technical field that would enable a roll-to-roll printing [11][12][13][14] of optical elements for flexible electronics based on polymer substrates. To utilize inkjet printing for optical applications a number of crucial requirements has to be satisfied, of which the most important are (i) the availability of the inks which can form optically homogeneous structures, (ii) a high ink drying rate to allow the fabrication of three-dimensional microscale structures, and (iii) the specific optical and structural characteristics of the resulting print such as refractive index, low porosity and optical transparency.
Most of these requirements are met by inks made of inorganic compounds that undergo a transition from a sol state in the ink to a solid xerogel state upon drying on a substrate [15]. The use of small nanoparticles in the ink makes it possible to create xerogels having porosity close to that in the bulk materials [16]. When gradually deposited in the form of thin layers, such materials may produce optically uniform surfaces behaving towards light waves as homogeneous layers. Most of the established technologies requiring inks, which can rapidly undergo a liquid-to-solid transition, are based on polymeric substances [4]. However, the utilization of such approaches to the production of optical coatings on polymer substrates is hampered by the high hydrophobicity of the common materials giving to the so-called coffee-ring effects in the prints and, accordingly, to the disruption of optical homogeneity [17]. Furthermore, polymeric inks usually show a low adhesion to films unless additional processing is implemented [18]. Therefore, the development of alternative ink compositions to overcome these crucial limitations represent an important challenge in the field.
Potentially, methods involving the application of a wet hydrophilic layer on a hydrophobic substrate surface enable to cross-link droplets and to decrease their x-y dimension upon increasing the thickness of the layer [19]. Applying solid coatings, even in small sizes, on a wet surface may result in chaotic discontinuities in the dried droplets [20]. In the case of sol-gel systems, there is a gradual increase in viscosity simultaneously with a contraction of a drop or a layer from its edges to the center as the increased viscosity prevents the wet layer from the formation of discontinuities [21]. This approach allows one to obtain objects with a very high resolution of up to 1 micron (in z direction) and, at the same time, to maintain the high performance and scalability [3]. The resolution in the x-y direction is determined solely by the hardware capabilities of the printer. A sub-micron resolution was demonstrated in the recent studying employing the advanced EHD Printing method [23][24][25]. This renders a soft lithography of one-dimensional (1D) optical structures a very promising approach for the application in the inkjet technology. We have recently demonstrated the utility of this concept by developing the first interference printing technique [8,22].
The simplest optical element is diffraction grating from which more complex elements of optical systems can be constructed [26]. Diffraction grating [27] used in monochromators and spectrometers are usually prepared by photolithographic methods. Such elements have high line density and can produce color separation in transmission or reflection mode. This principle is widely used in computer-generated holography [28]. From a pattern of diffraction gratings one can develop an optical device that allows recreating an image in its projection [29] under the influence of, for example, a laser irradiation. A transparent holographic film that recreates an image at a certain angle is the most sought-after approach in the field of holography. Such holograms are widely used in manufacturing security features in banknotes, passports, and other important documents. The production methods involve an embossing process, which implies the application of highly refractive lacquers producing a holographic micro-relief on the substrate [22]. In this study, we for the first time employed this approach for inkjet printing of sol-gel titania inks with high refractive index to produce a transparent computer generated hologram.

Synthesis of a TiO 2 ink
To produce a sol, two solutions were prepared. For the first solution, 16 mL of titanium isopropoxide and 12 mL of 2-propanol were taken. For the preparation of the second solution, 0.7 mL of nitric acid (70%, AR grade) was added to 100 mL of water, and the mixture was heated to 70 • C, after which the first solution was slowly added to the second one under stirring. The resulting mixture was maintained for 1 hour at 70 • C, then hermetically covered by a film and kept for 4 days at room temperature and under stirring. For the preparation of ink, the initial sol was concentrated 5 times by rotary evaporatoration at 50 • C. Resulting concentrated sol was diluted with ethanol in a ratio of 1 : 3 and used for 10 hours after dilution.

Inkjet printing
To produce diffraction gratings and holographic patterns, a modified inkjet printer Canon IP2840 with the capability of printing on glass slides was used. Standard printing cartridges were employed, which were filled with the titania-based ink. To print diffraction structures, ITO float glass plates were utilized. Indium tin oxide coated glass slide, rectangular with sheet resistance 15 − 25 Ω/sq, slide (Aldrich). Substrates were sonicated in ultrasonic irradiation (USI) bath, rinsed with isopropanol, and dried in a flow of air.

Results and discussion
To produce basic optical components by inkjet printing, we use titania-based inks [8]. A distinctive feature of most sol-gel inks is the ability to adjust viscosity and surface tension by diluting with alcohols [30]. Upon addition of alcohol, viscosity increases due to the destruction of the electrical double layer of the particles and an increase in the coagulation contact forces, which results in the controlled gelation of ink without the formation of aggregates and leads to the decrease in the surface tension of colloids. The current titania inks were characterized by the nanoparticle size of 11.9 nm (dynamic light scattering (DLS) meashurments) and ζ-potential of +32 mV. After complete drying, such inks form a thick xerogel containing no organic phases, which in contrast to the methods involving the use of surfactants and thickeners for adjusting rheological properties allows maintaining high optical density and transparency of the coatings. This advantage of sol-gel inks makes them unique for the direct fabrication of the finished products, where one has to produce elements and coatings without the need of further surface treatment. However, the generation of such surface structures is practically impossible when using a commercially-available dispersions of titanium dioxide. In this case, the main problem is the lack of gelation of such structures on the substrate surface and, accordingly, the impossibility to form formation of defined optical structures.
The inks applied to the surface using an inkjet printer form a single drop pattern on the substrate, which passes to a solid state upon drying. This is evident from the microphographs collected in Fig. 1 showing the formation of a solid xerogel on the surface after the solvent evaporation. The printed droplets on the substrate have dense structure consisting of titanium dioxide nanoparticles. Fig. 1(a) shows that a circular shape of the dried drop having an increased border thickness (relative to the drop center part) when applied to a hydrophobic substrate. Nevertheless, this height inhomogeneity does not affect the formation of a dense layer with a high refractive index. Even single-drop layer thickness is sufficient to produce an interference effect in the thin film. This effect is clearly shown in Fig. 1(b). The inner surface of the drop remains uniform and homogeneous, Fig. 1(c, f), and it is composed of particles with a narrow size distribution and a sharp transition to the border effect, Fig. 1(d, e). The ratio between the heights of the border and the center of the drop does not exceed 2. Fig. 1(d)shows that the border portion of the drop has a more dense structure because the drying on the hydrophobic surface results in a rapid shrinking of the drop in diameter due to the increase in viscosity upon the evaporation of the solvent. This leads to the density increase in coffee-ring effect, caused by constrict forces aimed at drop center. This process enables the production of both droplets and thin lines on hydrophobic surfaces. Formation of different layer height is clearly seen in the Fig. 2. Optical scheme of diffraction measurements. The scheme consists of a light source (laser pointer), the printed grating and the screen on which the image is projected, which is subsequently captured by DSLR camera. (a). b -Modeled data (Gaussian) of green laser (532 nm). The model was used to calculate, given the size of the laser point.; c -model of diffraction grating with 60 µm period and 50% duty ratio; d -Calculated optical model of image on screen at presented conditions; e -Photograph of a laser Gaussian, captured by DSLR; f -a microscopy photograph of inkjet printed lines with 50% duty ratio ≈ 60 µm goal period; g -Diffraction pattern from inkjet printed diffraction grating on a black screen, captured by DSLR cross-section of the sample Fig. 1(e). In addition, it is seen that the formation of small dense xerogel nanoparticles on a glass surface provides a good contact with the glass surface. This ensures that there are no voids between the layer and the substrate and the structure near the surface is similar to that in the bulk layer. This is confirmed by the results of the atomic force microscopy (AFM) Fig. 1(f).
The mechanism by which lines can be created from small droplets implies a delicate adjustment of the drop volume until the distance between droplets becomes critical for coalescence and the droplets merge into a single line. This process occurs simultaneously with the decrease in the line width making it possible to fabricate uniform lines on substrate surface required to achieve diffraction structures. One should note that usually [31] the preservation of the line geometry after drying of the droplets cannot be achieved because of the high concentration of the dispersed phase characterized by the high viscosity and surface tension resulting in the parameter Z beyond the requirements of the inkjet printing conditions [7,32].
To produce a periodic 1D diffraction grating, pixelated pattern of lines was printed by titanium dioxide on the substrate, Fig. 2(f). The dimension of such lines is close in size to the original droplets.
To compare the quality of the printed diffraction grating in the real testing calculations were performed. To this end, as a model of radiation was taken as close as possible in size laser irradiation source (Fig. 2(b)) that radiates to the diffraction grating (Fig. 2(c)) with duty cycle of 50 and eventually calculated diffraction image model (Fig. 2(d)). A more detailed diagram of the calculation and the actual measurements shown in Fig. 2(a).
Similar images only for the actual measurements are shown in Fig. 2(c-g). The printed grating period of ≈ 59 microns, which, based on the optical microscopy results, is fully confirmed by calculating the grating order using the diffraction equation (1) [33]: Fig. 3. Captured from real image data ( Fig. 2(g)) of lines intensity and calculation of diffraction maxima and distanced of maximums. Fig. 4. a) A schematic representation of a binary grating; n 1 and n 2 are the refractive indices of the media that share the periodic boundary with a material having a refractive index n 3 ; d is the grating depth and A is the grating period, a/A shows the duty cycle of the material with the refractive index n 3 . b) A photograph of inkjet printed titania lines on an ITO glass with maximum duty cycle 85. c) CAD design in pixels (black squares) for 85 duty cycle d) Stability of mean grating period for different printed lines.
where d is the diffraction grating order, λ is the laser wavelength, m is the diffraction maximum order, L is the distance to the diffraction picture, and D m is the distance between diffraction maxima of the same order (−m; +m).
According to the calculations, a diffraction order of ≈ 58 µm at a wavelength of 535 nm at a distance of 3 m for all three diffraction orders (Fig. 3) was fully consistent with the data obtained.
The reproducibility and stability of the duty ratio are crucial for multiline printing. When using indium tin oxide (ITO) coated glass as a substrate, we were able to achieve a high reproducibility in printed lines showing a reproducibility level lines period (at duty cycle 50) of ca. 59 ± 3µm (Fig. 4(c)). In this example we used drop on demand (DOD) technique on a desktop printer. The obtained values correspond to the duty ratio of 50% ( Fig. 4(a)) and optical efficiency of 0.96 and 0.48 according to T +1 /T 0 and T +1 /T −1 methods, respectively [34].
The possibility of fabrication of diffraction gratings made of high-refractive index material opens avenue towards a practical technology for creating latent security images. The methodology , where n 2 is the refractive index of the film at the same wave-lengths, and n1 and n 3 are the refractive indices for air and fused silica, respectively.
described here is particularly attractive in this respect. The inkjet printed titania is completely transparent in the visible region ( Fig. 5(a)) and when printed on a glass slide is almost invisible on transmittance ( Fig. 5(b)). At the same time, printed lines made of titania have a reflectance color (Fig. 5(c)) and are characterized by a high refractive index (Fig. 5(d)).
Next, aiming at creating a computer generated hologram (CGH) based on the laser beam diffraction, we printed a diffraction pattern with a coded image of a circle, Fig. 6. The highly refractive image print on the ITO glass has a clear pattern Fig. 6(d), Fig. 6(f) yet it is completely transparent to visible light. When illuminating the pattern with a laser at a wavelength of 650 nm, the long ranges (8 m) are characterized by the recovery of the holographic image on the projected plane. After the horizontal movement of the glass substrate from one end to another, the recovery of the coded holographic image is observed as the circle is moved from the center of symmetry of the laser in a horizontal direction. The holograms of this type are widely used to produce security transparent images for example in Canadian dollar banknotes. Fig. 6. Inkjet printing of a computer generated hologram from digital information to holography reconstruction. Source image (circle) was recalculated (Blue line) in the holographic pattern with 600 dpi resolution (g) and printed on an ITO coated glass (d) substrate and hologram has reconstructed by red laser (650 nm) at a distance of 8 m from the substrate (Circle reconstruction at the bottom of the picture). Left, center and right -points of laser illumination on slide in green area of picture (g) printed on slide and corresponding image on projection screen. Ink characterization -a) photograph of used ink with 30 wt.% of sol in ethanol; b) Dynamic light scattering of titania nanoparticle size distribution with mean 11.9 nm particle size and ζ-potencial of +32 mV; c) Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) microphotograph of nanocrystalline titania particles. Printed results -d) SEM microphotograph of inkjet printed pattern on ITO glass; e) Zoom-in part of SEM microphotograph showing the structure of a printed hologram; f) Photograph of transparent glass slide with printed transparent holographic pattern; g) Coded holographic image with part (green) printed on a glass slide.

Conclusion
The principle of the sol-gel transition on the hydrophobic substrate surface is a fundamental approach that can be employed for the production of highly ordered diffraction gratings thanks to the possibility of achieving a manifold reduction of the drop size in wet-to-dry printing technologies. This technique allows to generate transparent diffraction gratings and computer generated holograms using inkjet printing. The full transparency of holograms to the visible light renders copying and reading of the images by other devices very difficult with classical methods. The results presented in this paper are anticipated to create a base for the development of new roll-to-roll industrial printing technologies.