Molecular and behavioral profiling of Dbx1-derived neurons in the arcuate, lateral and ventromedial hypothalamic nuclei

Neurons in the hypothalamus function to regulate the state of the animal during both learned and innate behaviors, and alterations in hypothalamic development may contribute to pathological conditions such as anxiety, depression or obesity. Despite many studies of hypothalamic development and function, the link between embryonic development and innate behaviors remains unexplored. Here, focusing on the embryonically expressed homeodomain-containing gene Developing Brain Homeobox 1 (Dbx1), we explored the relationship between embryonic lineage, post-natal neuronal identity and lineage-specific responses to innate cues. We found that Dbx1 is widely expressed across multiple developing hypothalamic subdomains. Using standard and inducible fate-mapping to trace the Dbx1-derived neurons, we identified their contribution to specific neuronal subtypes across hypothalamic nuclei and further mapped their activation patterns in response to a series of well-defined innate behaviors. Dbx1-derived neurons occupy multiple postnatal hypothalamic nuclei including the lateral hypothalamus (LH), arcuate nucleus (Arc) and the ventral medial hypothalamus (VMH). Within these nuclei, Dbx1+ progenitors generate a large proportion of the Pmch-, Nesfatin-, Cart-, Hcrt-, Agrp- and ERα-expressing neuronal populations, and to a lesser extent the Pomc-, TH- and Aromatase-expressing populations. Inducible fate-mapping reveals distinct temporal windows for development of the Dbx1-derived LH and Arc populations, with Agrp+ and Cart+ populations in the Arc arising early (E7.5-E9.5), while Pmch+ and Hcrt+ populations in the LH derived from progenitors expressing Dbx1 later (E9.5-E11.5). Moreover, as revealed by c-Fos labeling, Dbx1-derived cells in male and female LH, Arc and VMH are responsive during mating and aggression. In contrast, Dbx1-lineage cells in the Arc and LH have a broader behavioral tuning, which includes responding to fasting and predator odor cues. We define a novel fate map of the hypothalamus with respect to Dbx1 expression in hypothalamic progenitor zones. We demonstrate that in a temporally regulated manner, Dbx1-derived neurons contribute to molecularly distinct neuronal populations in the LH, Arc and VMH that have been implicated in a variety of hypothalamic-driven behaviors. Consistent with this, Dbx1-derived neurons in the LH, Arc and VMH are activated during stress and other innate behavioral responses, implicating their involvement in these diverse behaviors.


Background
The hypothalamus plays a critical role in a variety of behaviors essential for survival, species propagation and maintenance of homeostasis. These behaviors most prominently include regulation of hunger and body temperature states, mating, aggression and appropriate responses to threatening encounters [1][2][3][4][5]. Proper development of this system is critical for normal function and behavior, and altered trajectories of development may potentially contribute to diseases or disorders such as obesity, depression and anxiety [4,6].
At the anatomical level, the hypothalamus is composed of multiple nuclei each characterized largely by their location in the rostral-caudal plane, molecularly and functionally distinct diversity of neuronal cell types and involvement in different aspects of behaviors. Different nuclei, as well as the constellation of neuronal subtypes, have specific and overlapping roles in coordinating complex animal behaviors. For example, the arcuate nucleus (Arc) is linked mostly to regulating hunger and satiety states [2,7]. The primary role of the lateral hypothalamus (LH) is to create a state of arousal [8,9], and as such is implicated in diverse behaviors such feeding/food seeking, mating, aggression and predator threat responses. Another major nucleus is the ventromedial hypothalamus (VMH), which appears to be involved in, if not critical for, aggressive and reproductive behaviors as well as innate fear responses [1,10,11].
These diverse behaviors appear to be regulated by different molecularly identifiable neuronal subpopulations located within these distinct nuclei [12][13][14][15]. Neuronal identity of mature hypothalamic neurons is presumably endowed during embryonic development through the combinatorial expression of both distinct and overlapping sets of transcription factors [16][17][18]. While the complete developmental blueprint for specification of different hypothalamic neuronal subpopulations remains to be elucidated, some of the key intrinsic and extrinsic factors controlling specification and differentiation have begun to be elucidated [18]. In our recent studies, we revealed that the homeodomain-containing transcription factor encoding gene Dbx1 acts as a putative selector gene for the generation of the pro-melanin-concentrating hormone (Pmch) + , Calbindin + , and orexin/hypocretin (Hcrt) + neurons in the LH and Agouti-related peptide (Agrp)/ Neuropeptide Y (Npy) + neurons in the Arc [19]. At the behavioral level, we further found that Dbx1 is required for hypothalamic-mediated feeding and stress responses in adult animals. However, despite this understanding of Dbx1 gene function, the contribution of Dbx1-derived neurons to different hypothalamic neuronal populations and activation of Dbx1-derived neurons during innate behaviors currently remains unknown.
To determine the contribution of the Dbx1-lineage to distinct neuronal subpopulations within LH, Arc and VMH, by using both standard and inducible fate-mapping techniques we significantly expand upon existing Dbx1 lineage studies conducted by the Allen Institute for Brain Science (Allen Brain Atlas experiment 167643944). We found that within these regions, Dbx1-derived neurons contribute to diverse populations of molecularly identified neuronal subpopulations. Moreover, we characterized the behavioral activation patterns of Dbx1-derived neurons in the LH, Arc and VMH after exposure to a broad array of innate behavioral cues. We found that Dbx1-derived neurons are activated by predator odor, fasting, mating and male aggression, without specific tuning toward one behavior. Therefore, across hypothalamic nuclei Dbx1-derived neurons likely play a critical role in regulation of different innate behaviors.

Animals
Mice were housed in the temperature-and light-controlled Children's National Medical Center animal care facility and given food and water ad libitum, unless otherwise stated. All animal procedures were approved by Children's National Medical Center's Institutional Animal Care and Utilization Committee (IACUC) and conformed to NIH Guidelines for animal use.
Tissue processing, in situ hybridization (ISH) and immunohistochemisty (IHC) For ISH, embryos were dissected and fixed in 4 % paraformaldehyde overnight and then cryoprotected in 30 % sucrose. Embryonic brains were sectioned on a cryostat at 20 μm. Every tenth section was collected in a set, for a total of ten sets of sections representing the entire brain. One probe was run on one set of sections; 10 probes were run on serial sections from the same brains. RNA in situ hybridization was performed as previously described [19]. cDNA plasmids were obtained from Drs. Seth Blackshaw (Pmch and Hcrt), Paul Gray (Agrp and Pomc), Yasushi Nakagawa (Lhx9), Chen-Ming Fan (Sim1), Kenneth Campbell (Dbx1), and Kazue Hashimoto-Torii (Nr5a1 and Fezf1). Images were taken on an Olympus BX51 at 4x and 10x.
Analysis of double labeled IHC stained sections was performed on every sixth section of the brain containing the region of interest. LH, Arc and VMH were defined from Bregma -1.06 to -1.94, -1.22 to -2.06 and -1.34 to -1.70, respectively, using the Paxinos and Watson anatomical atlas. DAPI (DAPI Fluoromount-G, SouthernBiotech #0100-20) was used as a nuclear counterstain to aid the definition of hypothalamic nuclei. Quantification of c-Fos and colabeled cells in LH, Arc and VMH were analyzed across 3, 2 and 1 sections, encompassing each nuclei, per animal, respectively. The average total number of YFP + cells counted per animal was 1027, 546, and 1055 in the LH, Arc, and VMH, respectively. Cell counts were expressed as the number of neurons/mm 2 for each animal. Animals within a group were then averaged.

Behavioral paradigms
Unless otherwise stated, all animals were group-housed by sex after weaning and then singly housed and habituated to the behavioral assay 1 week prior to experiment, which took place >1 h after the beginning of the dark cycle. Mating, aggression, predator avoidance and fasting assays were performed in adult mice (P40-50) as previously reported [19]. Animals were sacrificed 1 h after the start of the behavioral paradigm and brains processed for c-Fos and YFP IHC.

Statistical evaluation
Quantitation of data was performed blind to relevant variables. Using GraphPad Prism 6 statistical software, a One-way ANOVA followed by Tukey-Kramer multiple comparison test was used for analysis of experiments involving three groups with one comparison (Figs. 6 and 7, comparing cell counts at 3 different labeling periods: TME7. 5, 9.5, and 11.5), and an unpaired t-test with Welch's correction was used for analysis of experiments involving two groups.

Regional fate of Dbx1-derived neurons
Previous studies by us and others revealed that Dbx1 is expressed in the ventricular zone (VZ) of the ventral diencephalon, the primordium of the hypothalamus, during early to mid-neurogenesis, with downregulation of expression as precursors transit out of the VZ [19,[23][24][25][26]. Using criteria previously established for emerging hypothalamic domains [27,28], we observed that Dbx1 was expressed across the preoptic, anterior, tuberal and mammillary regions ( Fig. 1A.i-F.i). Because Dbx1 expression is downregulated as cells as cells become postmitotic, we examined the hypothalamic fate of Dbx1-derived neurons by crossing previously generated Dbx1 Cre knockin mice [20] to Rosa26 lox-STOP-lox-YFP reporter mice. This mouse faithfully recapitulates the pattern of Dbx1 expression across the neuraxis and thus provides a validated tool to study the Dbx1-lineage (Additional file 1: Figure S1 and [19][20][21]). Here, we show that Dbx1-derived neurons contributed to multiple developing hypothalamic nuclei including the primordial LH, Arc, VMH, preoptic area, anterior hypothalamus, paraventricular nucleus and mammillary nuclei (Fig. 1A.ii-F.ii). To correlate location of recombined cells with emerging hypothalamic nuclei, we carried out in situ hybridization for specific markers (Pomc, Bsx, Fezf1, Nr5a1, Pmch, Lhx9, and Sim1; Additional file 2: Figure S2) that define either specific cell populations or individual nuclei. These analyses revealed that Dbx1-derived cells contributed to multiple emerging hypothalamic nuclei/subdomains.
To investigate the spatial residence of Dbx1-derived cells in the postnatal hypothalamus, we analyzed coronal and sagittal tissue sections from P21 fatemapped mice. Dbx1-derived cells in the hypothalamus appeared to be primarily neurons, with an estimated <10 % differentiating into glia based on morphological criteria (data not shown). Consistent with the embryonic expression pattern, Dbx1-derived cells occupied all domains of the P21 hypothalamus including the preoptic, anterior, tuberal, and mammillary domains, with the greatest apparent number of fate-mapped cells residing in the preoptic, tuberal and mammillary domains (Fig. 2), patterns which were similarly ii-F.ii) and E15.5 (G.i-J.i). Dbx1 Cre ;Rosa26YFP embryos, Dbx1-derived cells emerge from progenitor domains and coalesce in multiple emerging hypothalamic nuclei. Abbreviations: ah (embryonic anterior hypothalamus); arc (embryonic arcuate nucleus); lh (embryonic lateral hypothalamus); mn (embryonic mammillary nucleus); poa (embryonic postnatal preoptic area); pvn (embryonic paraventricular nucleus); vmh (embryonic ventral medial hypothalamus). The scale bar represents 500 μm for coronal (a-f) and sagittal (g-j) sections observed in the P40-50 hypothalamus (data not shown and Fig. 8). Large numbers of Dbx1-derived cells were specifically observed in the following anterior to posterior located nuclei: Arc, LH, preoptic area, paraventricular nucleus, zona incerta (which may be derived from the prethalamus [22]), dorsomedial hypothalamus, medial tuberal nucleus, posterior hypothalamus, pre-mammillary and mammillary nuclei. Dbx1-derived cells were also present in large numbers in the VMH, although with relatively lower intensity of YFP expression. The anterior hypothalamus had very few Dbx1-derived cells.

Identity of Dbx1-derived neurons
Our previous studies revealed that Dbx1 acts as a putative selector gene to specify the Hcrt + and Pmch + neurons of the LH and Agrp + /Npy + neurons of the Arc, without altering select markers in the VMH [19]. Hcrt + and Pmch + neurons control arousal states associated with sleep/wake, stress and feeding [29][30][31]. In the Arc, feeding is controlled in part by the opposing actions of Agrp-and Pro-opiomelanocortin-(Pomc) expressing neurons [2,32,33]. To examine the specific contributions of Dbx1-derived hypothalamic neurons to these critical LH, Arc and VMH populations, we conducted co-expression analyses of YFP and markers of LH and Arc neuronal subtypes (Figs. 3, 4, and 5). Details of the findings are described below.

Lateral hypothalamus
Pmch-expressing neurons are one of the two major output populations of the LH and respond to high concentrations of blood glucose [30]. Pmch + neurons are defined by their co-expression with Nesfatin (Nfn)-and Cocaine and amphetamine regulated transcript (Cart) [34][35][36]. Our previous Dbx1 loss-of-function studies revealed that Pmch neurons are specified by Dbx1dependent mechanisms [19]. Here we show that the majority of Pmch-, Nfn-and Cart-expressing neurons were Dbx1-derived (Fig. 3B-D.iv). This finding combined with our previous loss-of-function studies is consistent with the hypothesis that Dbx1 acts cell autonomously to specify the fate of Pmch-, Nfn-and Cart-expressing neurons in the LH. Interestingly, the contribution of Dbx1-derived neurons to the Cart + and Hcrt + populations differed between males and females, revealing sexually dimorphic contributions of the Dbx1-lineage within the LH.
The other major neuronal output population of the LH is defined by expression of Hcrt, which, in contrast to the Pmch + population, is activated in the presence of low glucose [30]. Hcrt + neuron specification, differentiation and number appear to require Lhx9 and histamine expression [37,38]. Here, we reveal that the Hcrt- In the LH, a high percentage of Dbx1-derived neurons (green) express markers (red) Pmch (B-B.iv), Nesfatin (Nfn; C-C.iv), Cart (D-D.iv) or Hcrt (E-E.iv). The Dbx1-lineage contribution to the Cart (D.iv) and Hcrt (E.iv) populations is sexually dimorphic. Mean ± SEM; n = 3-6 mice per sex; *, p < 0.05. The scale bar represents 50 μm for low mag panels (b, c, d, and e) and 10 μm for high mag panels (i-iii) expressing population was at least partially Dbx1-derived, and also differed between males and females ( Fig. 3E-E.iv).

Arcuate nucleus
In the Arc, three major neuronal populations are distinguished by their expression of Agrp, Pomc/Cart or tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) [39][40][41]. The expression of Bsx drives immature neurons towards a mature appetitestimulating (orexigenic) Agrp + fate, but not other Arc cell types such as the appetite-inhibiting (anorexigenic) Pomc neurons [42]. Our previous studies in Dbx1 lossof-function mice demonstrated an approximately 50 % reduction in Bsx and Agrp expression, with no changes in Pomc or TH expression [19]. Our analysis here revealed that Dbx1-derived neurons contributed to all three populations, although at varying levels (Fig. 4). Dbx1-derived neurons contributed to 29-42 % of the Agrp + population in males and females ( Fig. 4B-B.iv). The Pomc-, TH-and Cart-expressing populations were 24-44 % Dbx1-derived, with the exception of the Pomc population in females, which was 52 % ± 6 % Dbx1-derived (mean ± SEM; Fig. 4C-E.iv). Of these Arc populations, the contribution of the Dbx1-derived lineage to the Pomc population was sexually dimorphic, with a greater contribution to Pomc + neurons in females compared to males. Thus, the three major populations in the Arc are also derived from Dbx1-expressing progenitors.

Ventromedial hypothalamus
Subsets of neuronal populations in the VMH can be defined by their expression of the sex steroid pathway markers Estrogen Receptor alpha (ERα) and Aromatase (Arom), which are known to function in mating and aggressive behaviors in mice [14,[43][44][45]. The majority of ERα neurons were Dbx1-derived (mean ± SEM; male: 66 % ± 7 %, female: 87 % ± 4 %; Fig. 5B-B.iv). In contrast, more variable results were observed with the Arom + population, which depended on the sex of the animal. While the majority of the Arom + population in females was Dbx1-derived, there was an apparently less, albeit more variable contribution of the Dbx1-lineage in males (male: 23 % ± 23 %, female: 78 % ± 14 %; Fig. 5C-C.iv). Overall, although varying by sex, these results show significant contribution of the Dbx1-lineage to the VMH ERα-and Arom-expressing populations.

Temporal labeling of Dbx1-derived neurons
To investigate the correlation between timing of Dbx1 expression in relation to the spatial localization of Dbx1derived neurons across the hypothalamus, we delivered tamoxifen to pregnant Dbx1 CreERT2 ;Rosa26 lox-STOP-lox-YFP mice at early (TME7.5), middle (TME9.5) and later (TME11.5) stages of gestation. CreER has been shown to be translocated into the nucleus within 6 h of tamoxifen administration and is sustained for 24 to 36 h [46,47]. We observed that fate-mapped cells derived from the progenitors expressing Dbx1 at early stages (TME7.5) populate medial Arc and periventricular regions, while progenitors expressing Dbx1 at mid stages (TME9.5) occupy dorsal-lateral regions, with the ventral-lateral and paraventricular regions settled by neurons marked at later stages (TME11.5) (Fig. 6a-d). This timing of development is reminiscent of findings from a previous temporal fate mapping study of Shh-expressing progenitors [48], and is likely reflective of the dynamic changes in Dbx1 expression over this developmental window.
Having established that different temporal waves of Dbx1-expressing progenitors occupy different post-natal medial to lateral hypothalamic domains, we next focused on development of subpopulations within the LH and Arc, two major nuclei with Dbx1-lineage contributions. Previous BrdU labeling studies in rats revealed that Pmch + neurons are born in three major waves, with the early born neurons taking residence in the most lateral regions adjacent to the cerebral peduncle. Cells born later occupy progressively more medial portions of the tuberal mantle. The majority of Pmch + neurons are born during mid stages thus occupying the majority of the zona incerta and LH regions surrounding the fornix [49]. To investigate whether Dbx1-derived neurons develop in a similar pattern, we again used inducible fatemapping and performed double immunohistochemistry. We observed proportionately more double-labeled neurons (Pmch + and YFP + ) at mid and later stages (TME9.5 and TME11.5; Fig. 6e-h). Thus, development of the Pmch + Dbx1-derived population follows the same overall pattern of Pmch + development, with the greatest contribution occurring between~E10.5-E13.0. Unlike the Pmch + population, less is known about the timing of development of the Hcrt + population. Here, we observed a marked increase in co-labeling of YFP and Hcrt at TME11.5, with little to no co-labeling at earlier stages ( Fig. 6i-l). This suggests that the Dbx1-derived Hcrt + population observed in Fig. 3E-E.iv most likely arises from a later wave of Dbx1 + progenitors.
Compared to the LH, a population of Dbx1-derived neurons in the Arc is generated during an earlier wave (Fig. 7a-c). Cart expression defines the Pomc + population in the Arc [40,41]. The Dbx1-lineage contribution to both the non-overlapping Cart-and Agrpexpressing neurons occurs at earlier stages of Dbx1 expression ( Fig. 7e-l). Together these observations demonstrate the temporal contribution of early and late Dbx1expressing progenitors to Arc and LH neuronal populations, with the generation of Arc Dbx1-derived populations commencing earlier than LH Dbx1-derived populations.

Activation of Dbx1-derived neurons during innate behaviors
Different hypothalamic nuclei are engaged during processing of a variety of innate behaviors such as feeding, mating, aggression and predator odor avoidance [31,[50][51][52][53][54]. Specifically, c-Fos translation occurs in cells of the LH, Arc and VMH in response to fasting, predator odor, conspecific aggression and mating situations [19,[55][56][57][58]. Our previous studies revealed that Dbx1 functions in the specification of the LH and Arc neurons required for physiological and behavioral responses to innate stressors such as stress feeding and predator odor exposure [19]. To investigate the putative involvement of Dbx1-derived neurons in different innate behaviors (predator odor, fasting, mating or aggression) we assessed the activation patterns of Dbx1-derived neurons in male and female Dbx1 Cre ; Rosa26 lox-STOP-lox-YFP mice using expression of the immediate early gene c-Fos as a proxy for neuronal activation [59,60]. We focused our analyses on the LH, Arc and VMH, three major nuclei involved in these select innate behaviors.

Lateral hypothalamus
The neurons in the LH have various functions during stress, arousal and feeding [29][30][31]. We placed female and/or male fate-mapped mice in four different behavioral paradigms (predator, fasting, mating and male . e-l Proportionately more Pmch (e-h) and Hcrt (i-l) co-labeled with YFP when tamoxifen was given during later stages of development (E9.5-E11.5). Mean ± SEM; E7.5 n = 4 mice (2 males, 2 females); E9.5 n = 3 mice (0 males, 3 females); and E11.5 n = 9 mice (2 males, 7 females). The scale bar represents 250 μm for panels (a-c), 50 μm for low mag and 10 μm images in panels (e-k). Abbreviations: mt, mammillothalamic tract; f, fimbria; VMH, ventromedial hypothalamic nucleus; mLH, medial portion of the lateral hypothalamus; lLH, lateral portion of the lateral hypothalamus; DMH, dorsomedial hypothalamic nucleus aggression) and observed a significant increase in c-Fos + cells in the LH in all four behaviors, with the exception of predator odor in males (Fig. 8, Additional file 3: Figure S3A-D.i). We then analyzed the number of c-Fos + neurons that co-labeled with YFP. In all behaviors tested, with the exception of male predator odor, there was a significant increase in the number of co-labeled cells (YFP + and c-Fos + ; Fig. 8a-d, A.ii-D.ii) as well as the percentage of Dbx1-derived cells that co-labeled with c-Fos (YFP + and c-Fos + /total YFP + ; Fig. 8a-d, A.iii-D.iii). This revealed that the Dbx1-derived neurons in the LH are active during predator exposure (female), fasting (both sexes), mating (both sexes) and male aggression.

Arcuate nucleus
The Arc is primarily known for its function during feeding [2,32,33], but has also been implicated in mating and stress [19,50]. Similar to the LH, the Arc displayed a significant increase in the number of c-Fos + cells in response to most behaviors tested ( Fig. 9; Additional file 3: Figure  S3E-H.i). Significant increases in co-labeled cells (YFP + and c-Fos + ; Fig. 9a-d, A.ii-D.ii) as well as the percentage of Dbx1-derived cells that co-labeled with c-Fos (YFP + and c-Fos + ;/total YFP + ; Fig. 9a-d, A.iii-D.iii) were observed in the Arc after fasting, mating and male aggression, but not after predator odor exposure. Thus, Dbx1-derived neurons in the Arc are activated during fasting, mating and male aggressive behaviors, but not by predator odor.

Ventromedial hypothalamus
The VMH principally functions during mating, aggression and predator odor avoidance [1,10,11], but also functions in feeding [3,33,47]. As expected the VMH had a significant increase in c-Fos in response to mating and aggression ( Fig. 10a-d, A.i-D.i; Additional file 3: Figure S3I-L.i). Significant increases in co-labeled cells (YFP + and c-Fos + ; Fig. 10a-d, A.ii-D.ii) as well as the percentage of Dbx1-derived cells that co-labeled with c-Fos (YFP + and c-Fos + /total YFP + ; Fig. 10a-d, A.iii-D.iii) were observed in the VMH after mating and male aggression. There were also significant increases in the number of c-Fos + cells and Dbx1-derived cells expressing c-Fos after exposure to rat odor in . e-l Proportionately more Cart (e-h) and Agrp (i-l) co-labeled with YFP when tamoxifen was given during early stages of development (E7.5-E9.5). Mean ± SEM; E7.5 n = 4 mice (2 males, 2 females); E9.5 n = 3 mice (0 males, 3 females); and E11.5 n = 9 mice (2 males, 7 females). The scale bar represents 100 μm for panels (a-c), 50 μm for low mag and 10 μm images in panels (e-k) females ( Fig. 10A.i-ii) and fasting in males (Fig. 10B.ii). This suggests that the primary involvement of Dbx1-derived neurons in the VMH is during mating and male aggressive behaviors, but may also have minor overlapping functions with the LH and Arc during aspects of fasting and predator responses.

Discussion
The hypothalamus is a complex multi-nucleated structure in which individual nuclei function to direct a variety of behaviors essential for survival, adaptation and species propagation [2,3]. Despite the extensive study of hypothalamic function and anatomy, only recently has iii-D.iii) in male and female mice compared to appropriate behavioral controls. Significant increases in total c-Fos, total co-labeled cells, and the percent of Dbx1-derived cells expressing c-Fos was detected in both males and females after every behavior, except in males after exposure to rat odor (A.i-A.ii, black bars). Mean ± SEM; n = 4-12 mice per subgroup; *, p < 0.05; **, p < 0.01; ***, p < 0.001. The scale bar represents 50 μm for low mag and 10 μm high mag images in panels (a-d) there been a greater understanding of the mechanisms of hypothalamic development, predominantly via a combination of gene expression and lineage tracing studies. Our previous study focusing on the function of the embryonic expressed homeodomain encoding transcription factor, Dbx1 revealed Dbx1 to have a restricted function in the specification of hypothalamic neurons required for innate stress responses but not other innate behaviors [19]. Here, we sought to extend these findings in order to provide deeper insight into the Dbx1-lineage iii-D.iii) in male and female mice compared to appropriate behavioral controls. Significant increases in total c-Fos, total co-labeled cells, and the percent of Dbx1-derived cells expressing c-Fos was detected in both males and females after every behavior, except after exposure to rat odor (A.i-A.ii). After exposure to rat odor, only females had a significant increase in total c-Fos in the Arc (A.i, gray bar) and only males had a significant increase in the total numbers of co-labeled cells (A.ii, black bar). Mean ± SEM; n = 4-12 mice per subgroup; *, p < 0.05; **, p < 0.01; ***, p < 0.001. The scale bar represents 50 μm for low mag and 10 μm high mag images in panels a-d contribution to diverse neuronal hypothalamic populations and to determine if Dbx1-derived neurons are activated by specific innate behaviors. We found a large amount of Dbx1-derived neuronal diversity across hypothalamic nuclei and broad activation of the Dbx1lineage by different innate behaviors. Interestingly, the broad fate and generally non-selective activation of Dbx1-derived neurons to a variety of innate behaviors iii-D.iii) in male and female mice compared to appropriate behavioral controls. After exposure to rat odor, only females had a significant increase in total c-Fos in the Arc (A.i, gray bar) and only males had a significant increase in the total numbers of co-labeled cells (A.ii, black bar). After fasting, only males had a significant increase in total c-Fos and total co-labeled cells in the VMH (B.i and B.ii, black bars). Significant increases in total c-Fos, total co-labeled cells, and the percent of Dbx1-derived cells expressing c-Fos was detected in both males and females after mating and aggression (C.i-D.iii). Mean ± SEM; n = 4-13 mice per subgroup; *, p < 0.05; **, p < 0.01; ***, p < 0.001. The scale bar represents 50 μm for low mag and 10 μm high mag images in panels a-d was not predicted by our previous finding of the restricted function of Dbx1 in specification of neurons solely required for innate stress responses. However, taken together these data are consistent with a model in which there are distinct gene sets expressed during hypothalamic development that, while maybe widespread in their lineage contribution, perform select functional roles in specification of distinct hypothalamic subpopulations.
Previous fate-mapping studies of the hypothalamus have begun to provide a general understanding of the relationship between progenitor domains and mature nuclei [3,16,18,28,61]. These studies have included examination of the lineage of a variety of developmentally defined subpopulations such as those that express the transcription factors Nkx2.1, Dlx, Nr5a1 [62,63] and secreted factors such as Shh [48]. Complementing this fate-mapping work are a series of detailed and highly informative hypothalamic developmental gene expression studies [27,28,64]. Collectively these studies have revealed that: 1) there are gene sets that give rise to neurons and function across hypothalamic nuclei (e.gs Rax, Nkx2.1, Asc1) and complementary gene sets that appear to be restricted in expression and function in specification of specific nuclei (e.gs Bsx, Nr5a1) [18] and 2) consistent with our findings, embryonic gene expression domains appear to be generally predictive of the location of mature nuclei, suggesting a general lack of widespread migration across domains. This is in contrast to the telencephalon where the ventral embryonic ganglionic eminence developmental domains (MGE and CGE) give rise to immature neurons that migrate to distant areas such as the cerebral cortex and hippocampus [65][66][67].
Within this framework, similar to progenitors expressing the developmentally regulated genes Shh and Nkx2.1, we found that Dbx1 + progenitors generate a wide variety of neuronal subtypes across multiple hypothalamic nuclei. Dbx1-derived cells were also present, although to a lesser degree, in the VMH. In contrast, regions of the anterior hypothalamus were devoid of Dbx1-derived neurons. A gradient of Dbx1-derived cells was also observed radiating from the tuberal domain into the anterior domain, a pattern that is more pronounced in medial portions of the ventral diencephalon. This pattern of Dbx1-derived neuronal location was generally shared with the pattern of location of Shh-lineage neurons [48]. This finding perhaps reflects the overlapping embryonic expression domains of Shh and Dbx1 and may further indicate putative positive control of Dbx1 expression by Shh during forebrain development.
The hypothalamus has been thought to develop in an 'outside-in' manner, stemming from studies using traceable thymidine analogs indicating the lateral hypothalamic nuclei are typically born prior to medial nuclei [49,68,69]. More recent fate-mapping studies and analysis of molecularly defined cell types have provided another layer of complexity of development for select cell populations [48,70]. Here, using inducible fate-mapping, we demonstrate that medial Dbx1derived neurons in both LH and Arc are recombined earlier (before E9.5), with lateral populations recombined at later ages (after E9.5). Although our study is limited in that we did not conduct a birth-dating analysis of Dbx1-derived neurons, this observed pattern is consistent with previous Shh fate-mapping studies [48], and is supportive of a more complex pattern of medial-lateral development.
We further found Dbx1-derived neurons contribute to diverse molecularly defined populations in the LH, Arc and VMH. Within the LH, the majority of Pmch + cells, which also express Nfn + , and Cart + , were Dbx1-derived. This finding is predicted by our loss-of-function studies in which the Pmch + population was dramatically reduced [19]. In the Arc, our Dbx1 loss-of-function studies demonstrated a~50 % reduction of Agrp and Cart expression, with no changes in the Pomc + or TH + populations [19]. Here we demonstrate that~50 % of Agrp + and Cart + neurons were Dbx1-derived. Collectively these data are consistent with a cell autonomous function of Dbx1 in generation of LH Pmch + and Arc Agrp + populations. However, surprisingly, a significant proportion of Arc Pomc + and TH + cells were also Dbx1-derived. Thus, while Dbx1 + progenitors generate diverse populations in the Arc, it appears that Dbx1-independent mechanisms are required for specification of the Pomc + and TH + neurons.
At the behavioral level, the number of c-Fos + cells in response to innate behavioral cues was increased in a predictable manner consistent with previous work [19,[55][56][57]. Building upon these results, we assessed the Dbx1-lineage contribution to these patterns of activation. We previously demonstrated that at the behavioral level conditional Dbx1 hypothalamic loss-of-function resulted in a specific defect in innate stress responses, but not other innate behaviors such as mating or aggression [19]. Based on these findings, we anticipated that Dbx1-derived neurons would also be engaged (c-Fos + ) selectively during innate stress behaviors (predator odor and fasting), but not other social behaviors (mating and aggression). In contrast, we found that across hypothalamic nuclei, Dbx1derived neurons were active during multiple innate behavior tasks. Most broadly tuned to many behaviors was the LH, in which the percent of Dbx1-derived neurons expressing c-Fos increased after every behavioral paradigm tested. While this was not predicted by our previous lossof-function studies, as we show here that a large portion the Pmch + and Hcrt + populations were Dbx1-derived, it is perhaps not surprising that the Dbx1-derived populations in the LH are responsive to a variety of innate cues.
These activation patterns, while still encompassing multiple behaviors, were more specific in the Arc and VMH. We observed an increase in the proportion of activated Dbx1-derived neurons after fasting, mating and male aggression in the Arc, and an increase after mating and male aggression in the VMH. In the Arc, while less than 50 % of the feeding neurons (Pomc, Agrp, and Cart) were Dbx1-derived, these neurons were c-Fos + during fasting, likely reflecting their involvement in this major function of the Arc. In contrast, Arc Dbx1-derived neurons were less engaged in responses to predator odor. In the VMH, the Dbx1-derived neurons contributed to large portions of the ERα + and Arom + neuronal subpopulations, which are known to influence mating and aggressive behaviors [14,[43][44][45]71]. This was reflected in the behavioral activation patterns, where the Dbx1-derived neurons were selectively activated during mating and aggression. While further experiments are needed to define the Dbx1-derived circuits that are required for specific hypothalamic-driven behaviors, these studies present novel insight into the link between developmental lineage and behavioral control.

Conclusions
In summary, using a combination of approaches we reveal a widespread and temporally regulated contribution of Dbx1 + progenitors to multiple neuronal populations across hypothalamic nuclei. We further demonstrate a broad innate behavioral tuning of Dbx1-derived cells in the LH, Arc and VMH, implicating their involvement in multiple innate behaviors. Thus, our studies provide new information regarding the link between hypothalamic embryonic gene expression patterns, postnatal neuronal fate, subtype identity and potential contribution to essential hypothalamic-driven behaviors.

Additional files
Additional file 1: Figure S1. Correspondence between Dbx1-driven recombination and Dbx1 expression. Regions of recombination in the tuberal hypothalamus (schematic on left) at the level of the E11.5 lateral hypothalamic primordium and (A-C) and E12.