Development of a microarray for simultaneous detection and differentiation of different tospoviruses that are serologically related to Tomato spotted wilt virus

Background Tospoviruses, the plant-infecting genus in the family Bunyaviridae, are thrips borne and cause severe agricultural losses worldwide. Based on the serological relationships of the structural nucleocapsid protein (NP), the current tospoviruses are divided into six serogroups. The use of NP-antisera is convenient for virus detection, but it is insufficient to identify virus species grouped in a serogroup due to the serological cross-reaction. Alternatively, virus species can be identified by the N gene amplification using specific primers. Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) is the type species of the genus Tospovirus and one of the most destructive plant viruses. Eight known tospoviruses, Alstroemeria necrotic streak virus (ANSV), Chrysanthemum stem necrosis virus (CSNV), Groundnut ringspot virus (GRSV), Impatiens necrotic spot virus (INSV), Melon severe mosaic virus (MeSMV), Pepper necrotic spot virus (PNSV), Tomato chlorotic spot virus (TCSV) and Zucchini lethal chlorosis virus (ZLCV), sharing serological relatedness with TSWV in NP, are grouped in the TSWV serogroup. Most of the TSWV-serogroup viruses prevail in Europe and America. An efficient diagnostic method is necessary for inspecting these tospoviruses in Asia, including Taiwan. Methods A microarray platform was developed for simultaneous detection and identification of TSWV-serogroup tospoviruses. Total RNAs extracted from Chenopodium quinoa leaves separately inoculated with ANSV, CSNV, GRSV, INSV, TCSV and TSWV were used for testing purposes. The 5’-biotinylated degenerate forward and reverse primers were designed from the consensus sequences of N genes of TSWV-serogroup tospoviruses for reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) amplification. Virus-specific oligonucleotide probes were spotted on the surface of polyvinyl chloride (PVC) chips to hybridize with PCR products. The hybridization signals were visualized by hydrolysis of NBT/BCIP with streptavidine-conjugated alkaline phosphatase. The microarray was further applied to diagnose virus infection in field crop samples. Results Amplicons of approximately 0.46 kb were amplified from all tested TSWV-serogroup tospoviruses by RT-PCR using the degenerate primer pair Pr-dTS-f/Pr-dTS-r. Virus species were identified on chips by hybridization of PCR products with respective virus-specific probes. The microarray was successfully used to diagnose TSWV infection in field pepper samples. Conclusions In this study, a rapid, sensitive and precise microarray method has been developed to simultaneously detect and identify six TSWV-serogroup tospoviruses. The microarray platform provides a great potential to explore tospoviruses that can help researchers and quarantine staff to prevent invasions of tospoviruses. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12985-016-0669-1) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.


Background
Tospoviruses, classified in the family Bunyaviridae, are destructive plant viruses with a very broad host range, infecting more than 1090 plant species, causing lethal necrotic lesions, wilting and dieback of infected plants [1][2][3]. Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) is the first tospovirus found in Australia in 1915 [4,5]. To date, it is still the most important tospovirus causing severe damage of economically important crops, including tobacco, tomatoes, pepper, cucurbits, lettuce, groundnuts and potatoes throughout Africa, America, Asia, Australasia and Europe [3].
Virions of tospoviruses are enveloped quasi-spherical particles measuring 80-120 nm in diameter, possessing a tripartite segmented ssRNA genome, named large (L), medium (M) and small (S). The L RNA is of negative sense, whereas the M and S RNAs are ambisense [6]. L RNA contains a large open reading frame (ORF) in the viral complementary (vc) strand for encoding an RNAdependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) [7,8]. Each of the M RNA and S RNA contains two ORFs separated by an A-U-rich intergenic region (IGR). The M RNA encodes a movement protein NSm from the viral (v) strand [9][10][11][12] and the enveloped Gn and Gc glycoproteins from the vc strand [13,14]. The S RNA encodes an RNA-silencing suppressor NSs protein from the v strand [15,16] and the RNA-associated nucleocapsid protein (NP) from the vc strand [17].
NP is abundant in infected plant cells [17]. The identity and serology of NP are the most important criteria for identification of tospoviruses. A threshold of 90% amino acid (aa) identity of the NP is proposed to classify tospoviruses at the species level [6,18]. Currently, 29 tospovirus species are identified based on the sequence determination of the N gene or S RNA [3,[19][20][21][22][23][24]. In addition, most of the known tospoviruses are clustered into three major serogroups, which are assigned by the TSWV, Watermelon silver mottle virus (WSMoV) and Iris yellow spot virus (IYSV) due to the serological relatedness of their NPs [25]. The members of the TSWV serogroup principally occur in America and Europe. Alternatively, the tospoviruses belonging to the WSMoV and IYSV serogroups are prevalent in Asian countries [3]. The tospoviruses Alstroemeria necrotic streak virus (ANSV), Chrysanthemum stem necrosis virus (CSNV), Groundnut ringspot virus (GRSV), Impatiens necrotic spot virus (INSV), Melon severe mosaic virus (MeSMV), Pepper necrotic spot virus (PNSV), Tomato chlorotic spot virus (TCSV) and Zucchini lethal chlorosis virus (ZLCV) were grouped in the TSWV serogroup [26][27][28], and they are quarantine viruses in Taiwan and other Asian countries.
Prompt and accurate methods for detection and identification of tospoviruses are crucial for preventing epidemics of domestic and invading species. The serological enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) is the most convenient method for virus detection. Antisera against the NPs of tospoviruses are commonly used to detect tospoviruses. Due to the cross reactions of different species in the same serogroup, the use of NP antisera for virus identification could be limited [28,29]. The nucleic acid-based reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) using N gene-specific primers can be conducted to identify tospovirus species. However, a single species-specific primer pair for diagnosis of tospoviruses in a farm is insufficient due to the complex virus categories which occurred in a crop or area. Degenerate primers designed from the conserved regions of genomic sequences simplify detection of tospoviruses in one tubebased RT-PCR, but they are inconvenient to identify virus species [30,31]. The microarray is an efficient method for simultaneous detection and identification of various plant viruses in one assay to solve these problems [32].
In this study, an oligonucleotide-based microarray method was developed for detection and identification of tospoviruses, which are serologically indistinguishable with TSWV. The degenerate primer pair Pr-dTS-f/Pr-dTS-r was designed from the consensus sequences of N genes of TSWV-serogroup tospoviruses and successfully used to amplify a certain cDNA fragment from the total RNAs of Chenopodium quinoa leaves separately inoculated with ANSV, CSNV, GRSV, INSV, TCSV and TSWV in RT-PCR. Virus species were further identified by hybridization of the PCR products with the virusspecific oligonucleotide probes that were pre-spotted on the surface of polyvinyl chloride (PVC) microchips. The signals were visualized by hydrolysis of NBT/BCIP with streptavidine-conjugated alkaline phosphatase. Furthermore, the microarray was used to diagnose TSWV infections in field pepper samples. The developed microarray has a great potential to prompt the diagnosis of TSWVserogroup tospoviruses.

Virus sources
The NY isolate of TSWV was collected from tomato in New York, the United States [30]. The original isolate of GRSV-BR was collected from tomato in Brazil [33]. The BR-03 isolate of TCSV was isolated from tomato in Brazil [34]. INSV-M was isolated from impatiens in the United States [35]. The TcCh07A isolate of CSNV was collected from chrysanthemum in Tochigi Prefecture, Japan [36]. The original isolate of ANSV was collected from Alstroemeria sp. in Colombia [27]. All virus cultures were maintained in the local lesion host Chenopodium quinoa Willd. by mechanical transmission in an isolated temperature-controlled (25-28°C) greenhouse according to quarantine regulations. A buffer consisting of 0.01 M potassium phosphate (pH 7.0) and 0.01 M sodium sulfite was used for inoculation.

Construction of N genes
The sequences of the N genes or S RNAs of tospoviruses were obtained from the GenBank of National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov) ( Table 1) for design of N gene-specific primer pairs ( Table 2). One hundred milligram of plant leaf tissues inoculated with ANSV, CSNV-TcCh07A, GRSV-BR, INSV-M and TCSV-BR-03 were ground to fine powder in liquid nitrogen and placed in microcentrifuge tubes for isolation of total RNAs using the Plant Total RNA Miniprep Kit (GeneMark, GMbiolab Co., Ltd., Taichung, Taiwan) following the manufacturer's instructions. The complete N gene sequences of tospoviruses were amplified from the aforementioned total RNAs with individual primer pairs (Table 2) using the One-Step RT-PCR Kit (GeneMark). Ten microgram of total RNA, 200 nM individual primers, 25 U One-Step RT-PCR enzyme mix, 1/5 volume of reaction buffer and 1/5 volume of enhancer buffer (GeneMark) were mixed for amplification. Synthesis of cDNAs was conducted at 50°C for 30 min, and inactivation at 94°C for 2 min. PCR was performed by 35 cycles of strand separation at 94°C for 1 min, annealing at 58°C for 30 s and synthesis at 72°C for 1 min; and a final reaction at 72°C for 7 min. The amplicons were ligated with the TOPO TA cloning vector pCR2.1-TOPO (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA), and then transferred into the DH5α competent cells following the manufacturer's instructions. The resultant plasmids named pTOPO-ANSV-N for ANSV, pTOPO-CSNV-N for CSNV-TcCh07A, pTOPO-GRSV-N for GRSV-BR, pTOPO-INSV-N for INSV-M and pTOPO-TCSV-N for TCSV-BR-03 were obtained by the Plasmid Miniprep Purification Kit (GeneMark) following the standard protocols. The nucleotide sequences of all cloned N genes were verified by sequencing using ABI3730 XL DNA Analyzer (Perkin-Elmer Applied Biosysterms, Foster City, CA), performed by Mission Biotech Company (Taipei, Taiwan). The plasmid pTOPO-TSWV-N for TSWV-NY was constructed in the previous study [28].

Design of degenerate primers and virus-specific probes
The Lasergene 7 software package (DNASTAR, Madison, WI, USA) was used to analyze sequences. Multiple alignments of nucleotide sequences of N genes listed in Table 1 were conducted by the MegAlin program. The conserved regions of N genes were used to design degenerate primers, and the virus-specific probes were designed from the variable regions of N genes.

Microarray preparation and assay
Twenty micromolar of each probe were spotted on the surface of PVC microchips with an automatic spotting machine (DR. Chip Biotechnology Inc., Miaoli, Taiwan) and immobilized by an ultraviolet crosslinker (UV Light Enterprise Co., Taichung, Taiwan) with 1.2 J for 5 min following the previous report [37]. In addition to the spots for specific tospoviruses, 100 μM of the commercial probe Anti-VP1 (Dr. Chip) was spotted for positive control of hybridization. Chip). After discarding the liquid, 4 μl of DR. NBT/BCIP™ (nitro blue tetrazolium/5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl phosphate, Dr. Chip) was mixed with 196 μl of detection buffer, and the mixture was added to the hybridization chamber. The colorimetric development was allowed to react in the dark for 10 min at room temperature, and then the detection liquid was discarded. The chip was rinsed with deionized water twice, and the developed patterns were recorded by DR. Scanning Reader (Dr. Chip).

Establishment of the detection platform of the microarray
The PCR product amplified from pTOPO-TSWV-N [28] using the designed primers was serially diluted for testing the detection sensitivity of the microarray. Total RNAs extracted from TSWV-infected pepper samples were used for testing the virus identification by microarray. The protocols of the microarray were described above.
Indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) Indirect ELISA was conducted to detect TSWV in diseased plant samples according to the previous report [38]. The crude extracts of plant samples at a 1/20 dilution with coating buffer (0.05 M sodium carbonate, pH 9.6, containing 0.01% sodium azide) were used for assays. The monoclonal antibody against the NSs protein

Detection test of the designed degenerate primers and virus-specific probes in the microarray
Two conserved regions located at the first 20 nucleotides and middle portion of N genes of the TSWV-serogroup tospoviruses were used to design the forward primer Pr-dTS-f and reverse primer Pr-dTS-r, respectively (Fig. 1a).
Both primers were synthesized with a 5'-biotinylation ( Table 3). The primer pair Pr-dTS-f/Pr-dTS-r was able to amplify a DNA fragment of approximately 0.46 kb from all tested plasmids carrying the N genes of ANSV, CSNV, GRSV, INSV, TCSV or TSWV in PCR (Fig. 1b). The virusspecific probes designed from the N genes of ANSV, CSNV, GRSV, INSV, TCSV and TSWV were synthesized with an addition of 20 thymidine deoxynucleosides (T 20 ) at the 5' terminus for fixing on microchips ( Table 3). The spotted positions of individual probes in the microarray are indicated in Fig. 2a and b. The PCR products amplified from different plasmids were incubated with the microarray for hybridization. Colorization of the specific spots indicated that the virus species can be identified by the microarray (Fig. 2c).

Sensitivity assay of microarray
The PCR product amplified from the plasmid pTOPO-TSWV-N was serially diluted, initiating from 250 to 0.1 ng, to determine the sensitivity of microarray detection. EtBr staining in agarose gel electrophoresis was performed for comparison. The results showed that the microarray was able to detect a lesser amount of 0.1 ng of the PCR product that is more sensitive than EtBr staining with a detection limitation of 0.2 ng of the PCR product (Fig. 3).

Microarray in virus detection
RT-PCR was performed to amplify the DNA fragment of 0.46 kb from the individual total RNAs of C. quinoa leaves separately inoculated with ANSV, CSNV, GRSV, INSV, TCSV or TSWV as well as the plasmid results shown in Fig. 1b. The amplicons were incubated with probe-spotted microchips mentioned in Fig. 2b, and all tested tospoviruses could be singly detected by the microarray (Fig. 4a). Furthermore, the total RNAs of different virus infections were mixed in 2-6 combinations for microarray assays, and individual tospovirus species could be identified (Fig. 4b). Our results demonstrated that the degenerate primer pair is sufficient for detection of the members of the TSWV serogroup and that the microarray is efficient in virus identification.

Application of microarray for virus diagnosis in crop samples
The diseased pepper samples (SY-1 to 6), exhibiting chlorotic spots or ringspots on leaves and fruits, were collected from Sinyi Township, Nantou County, Taiwan in December 2015 for detecting tospovirus infection by indirect ELISA using the monoclonal antibody against the TSWV NSs protein [39]. SY-1 and 3 exhibited an ELISA-positive (Fig. 5a). These samples were also used for assay in the microarray, and the identical result as well as indirect ELISA was obtained (Fig. 5b).

Discussion
An efficient detection method is necessary for inspection of viral diseases in quarantine. The previous studies reported that the tospoviruses ANSV, CSNV, GRSV, INSV, TCSV and TSWV share a serological relationship in their NPs, so that they can be detected, but not be differentiated, by antisera against the NP in serological assays [28,40]. On the other hand, several consensus sequences can be found among tospoviral genomic sequences. Degenerate primers designed from the consensus nucleotide sequences of RdRp and NSm genes have been used to detect tospoviruses at the genus level [30,31].  The virus strains with different genotypes will not be excluded when degenerate primers are used in amplification. By contrast, the N genes of tospoviruses are more diverse, thus it can be the key target for classification of a tospovirus [6]. Consensus nucleotide sequences can also be found within the N genes of tospoviruses belonging to a phylogenetical clade. According to this finding, the degenerate primer pair Pr-dTS-f/Pr-dTS-r were designed from the N genes of all nine TSWV-serogroup tospoviruses, and can successfully detect all six tested viruses, ANSV, CSNV, GRSV, INSV, TCSV and TSWV, in one-step RT-PCR (Fig. 1). Unfortunately, the other three TSWVserogroup viruses, MeSMV, PNSV and ZLCV, can not be obtained for test in the present study. Sequence comparison of the N genes of all members of TSWV serogroup was conducted to reveal that INSV shares the lowest nucleotide identity (59.3-61.7%) with other tospoviruses (Additional file 1: Table S1) and still can be detected by the degenerate primer pair Pr-dTS-f/Pr-dTS-r. Thus, the detection of MeSMV, PNSV and ZLCV using the degenerate primer pair Pr-dTS-f/Pr-dTS-r can be   Here, we first integrated the degenerate primers and specific probes into a microarray system to simultaneously detect and differentiate the TSWV-serogroup tospoviruses that possess twofold higher sensitivity than conventional RT-PCR (Fig. 3). The tospoviruses belonging to other serogroups, including Calla lily chlorotic spot virus (CCSV), Capsicum chlorosis virus (CaCV), Groundnut bud necrosis virus (GBNV), Groundnut chlorotic fan-spot virus (GCFSV), IYSV, Melon yellow spot virus (MYSV), Soybean vein necrosis-associated virus (SVNaV), Tomato necrotic spot-associated virus (TNSaV), Tomato yellow ring virus (TYRV), Tomato zonate spot virus (TZSV), Watermelon bud necrosis virus (WBNV) and WSMoV, were also used to test the developed microarray. No unexpected signals were observed to demonstrate the excellent specificity of the microarray in TSWV serogroup only (data not shown). Using the same approach, microarrays for detecting tospoviruses in other serogroups will be further developed.
The DNA microarray is basically developed as a combination technique of nucleic acid amplification and hybridization for high-throughput assay and has a wide application including use in analyses of gene expression, transcription factor binding and genotyping [41]. It also provides a benefit for simultaneous detection of numerous plant RNA viruses [32]. The reliability and timeand-cost-saving are very important issues in development of detection methods. In this study, we used the PVC biochip-based microarray platform developed by the Dr. Chip Company. Different from the common glass-slide microarray system, the signals on PVC biochips can be directly observed by the naked eye and recorded by an optical scanner or camera after colorization instead of the need of expensive equipment for fluorescent detection. It also provides an advantage of customized probe spotting. The reliability of the PVC biochip has been proven in several applications; e.g., the simultaneous detection and differentiation of seven mastitis-causing pathogens in bovine milk samples [37], Newcastle disease and avian influenza in the poultry industry [42], and Cymbidium mosaic virus, Odontoglossum ringspot virus and CaCV for orchid inspection (Dr. Orchid-3™ Kit, Dr. Chip), and the identification of insect species [43] and the sex of owls [44]. The developed microarray was used to inspect virus infection in the fields of Sinyi Township in central Taiwan, and indirect ELISA using MAb-TNSs-82D3B4 was performed for comparison. MAb-TNSs-82D3B4 reacted with TSWV but not reacted with GRSV, INSV and TCSV was mentioned in our previous report [39], and its serological reactivity with ANSV and CSNV was proven by our laboratory later. Thus, in this case, the ELISA-positive result might be resulted from the infections of ANSV, CSNV and/or TSWV (Fig. 5a). The developed microarray helps to clarify the result of indirect ELISA, indicating that two pepper samples, SY-1 and 3, exhibiting ringspots on leaves and fruits, were infected with TSWV only (Fig. 5b). No other TSWV-serogroup tospoviruses, such as ANSV, CSNV, GRSV and INSV, were found in Taiwan yet. Our results also demonstrated the reliability of the microarray in diagnosis of tospoviral diseases.
Tospoviruses are vectored by thrips for oversea distribution. The identification of the thrips category and the inspection of viruliferous thrips are necessary for preventing an invasion of foreign tospoviruses. The microarray is sufficient for multiplex detections. The identifications of tospoviruses and thrips will be integrated into a biochip to strengthen inspection for quarantine.

Conclusions
In this study, a degenerate primer pair Pr-dTS-f/Pr-dTS-r, designed from the consensus sequences of N genes, was used to amplify a DNA fragment from total RNAs of plant tissues infected by six tested tospoviruses, ANSV, CSNV, GRSV, INSV, TCSV and TSWV. The virus species were further differentiated by hybridization with specific probes spotted on PVC biochips. The microarray platform was used to diagnose TSWV infections in field peppers. Our results showed that the microarray method can be used to simultaneously detect and identify TSWV-serogroup tospoviruses that provides a great applicable potential in inspection of tospoviruses for quarantine.

Additional file
Additional file 1: Table S1. Nucleotide (above diagonal) and amino acid (below diagonal) identities (%) of the N genes among the members of TSWV serogroup. (DOCX 68 kb)