An optimized swine dysentery murine model to characterize shedding and clinical disease associated with “Brachyspira hampsonii” infection

Background The development of a mouse model as an in vivo pathogenicity screening tool for Brachyspira spp. has advanced the study of these economically important pathogens in recent years. However, none of the murine models published to date have been used to characterize the clinical signs of disease in mice, instead focusing on pathology following oral inoculation with various Brachyspira spp. The experiments described herein explore modifications of published models to characterize faecal consistency, faecal shedding and pathology in mice challenged with “Brachyspira hampsonii” clade II (Bhamp). Methods and results In Experiment 1, 24 CF-1 mice were randomly allocated to one of three inoculation groups: sham (Ctrl), Bhamp, or B. hyodysenteriae (Bhyo; positive control). Half of each group was fed normal mouse chow (RMH) while the other received a low-zinc diet (TD85420). In Experiment 2, eight CF-1 mice and nine C3H/HeN mice were divided into Ctrl or Bhamp inoculation groups, and all fed TD85420. In Experiment 1, mice fed TD85420 demonstrated more severe mucoid faeces (P = 0.001; Kruskal Wallis) and faecal shedding for a significantly greater number of days (P = 0.005; Kruskal Wallis). Mean faecal scores of Bhamp inoculated mice trended higher than Ctrl (P = 0.06; Wilcoxon rank-sum) as did those of Bhyo mice (P = 0.0; Wilcoxon rank-sum). In Experiment 2, mean faecal scores of inoculated CF-1 mice were significantly greater than in C3H mice (P = 0.049; Kruskal Wallis) but no group differences in faecal shedding were observed. In both experiments, mice clustered based on the severity of colonic and caecal histopathology but high lesion scores were not always concurrent with high fecal scores. Conclusion In our laboratory, CF-1 mice and the lower-zinc TD85420 diet provide a superior murine challenge model of “Brachyspira hampsonii” clade II. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12917-017-1166-5) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.


Background
In 2009, a new species of Brachyspira associated with disease resembling SD was discovered on a Western Canadian pig farm [1] and was subsequently shown to experimentally reproduce mucohaemorrhagic diarrhoea and typhlocolitis in orally inoculated pigs [2,3]. Initially called Brachyspira sp. Sask30446, the species has now been provisionally named as "Brachyspira hampsonii" [4,5]. Strains 30,599 and 30,446 are Canadian reference strains of clade I and II, respectively. The discovery of a new, pathogenic species affecting the swine industry necessitates continued study with a focus on better understanding disease pathogenesis and control including vaccine development.
Several Brachyspira spp. that are pathogenic in pigs, are known to exploit rodents and waterfowl species as natural reservoirs [6][7][8][9]. The ability of Brachyspira spp. to colonize rodents has led to the development of mouse models of SD. The first published model used CF-1 mice fed a standard rodent chow diet to determine whether it was possible to experimentally infect mice with Treponema hyodysenteriae [10,11]. Not only did the mice in this study become infected, they also developed caecal lesions typical of SD in pigs. The model was subsequently modified by using various strains of C3H mice and a defined diet (TD85420; Harlan Laboratories, Indianapolis, IN) to obtain more consistent caecal lesions following oral inoculation with various isolates of Brachyspira spp. [12][13][14]. Because mice have a small caecum, a swine dysentery challenge model using 24 h chicks was developed in the mid-1980s [15,16], and has since been used to study a number of pathogenic and nonpathogenic Brachyspira spp. [17,18]. Chicks have two large caeca and develop mild to moderate typhlitis following B. hyodysenteriae infection [15], however, subtle changes in faecal consistency are less easily judged due to the nature of their droppings. In spite of being a relevant, non-invasive indicator of virulence and disease severity, changes in faecal consistency have not yet been documented in infection models using chicks or mice, including the most recent and only mouse challenge assessing the pathogenicity of "B. hampsonii" [19].
The overarching objective of the two pilot experiments reported herein was to optimize a pre-existing Brachyspira mouse model of swine dysentery for "B. hampsonii" clade II (strain 30,446), with emphasis on the assessment of clinical signs of disease following oral challenge to ensure it is suited for use evaluating oral and parenteral vaccine prototypes. The primary objectives of Experiment 1 were to determine if CF-1 mice are susceptible to infection with "B. hampsonii" strain 30,446, and to determine if the low zinc TD85420 diet affected the severity of clinical disease. A B. hyodysenteriae infected group was included as positive control, and enabled a secondary objective of comparing disease severity between two Brachyspira species, albeit with low experimental power. The primary objective of Experiment 2 was to compare disease severity in CF-1 and C3H mice following "B. hampsonii" challenge to determine if there are differences in susceptibility between the two mouse strains.

Experiment 1 Mice
Twenty-four, 4-week old, specific pathogen free, female CF-1 mice (Charles River Laboratories, Kingston, NY were obtained from a commercial supplier and randomly assigned to one of three inoculation groups: sham (Ctrl; n = 8), "Brachyspira hampsonii" clade II strain 30,446 (Bhamp; n = 8), or positive control B. hyodysenteriae (Bhyo; n = 8). Each inoculation group was divided into two plastic cages (6 cages total, n = 4 per cage). One cage per group was fed normal rodent chow, RMH 3000 (RMH; Federated Co-Operatives Limited, Saskatoon, SK, Canada), and the other was fed a defined low zinc, Teklad diet TD85420 (TD) for the duration of the experiment. Each mouse was assigned a unique identity by tail-mark and was allowed to acclimate for 7 days prior to inoculation. Mice were housed in ventilated, biocontainment level 2 cage racks with aspen shavings, which were changed once per week. Mouse houses and crinkle bedding were provided in each cage for enrichment.

Bacterial strains and culture
The "B. hampsonii" strain 30,446 and B. hyodysenteriae strain G44 (generously provided by Boehringer Ingelheim Vet Medica, St Joseph, MO) used for inoculation were cultured in JBS broth (BHI plus 0.5% (v/v) sheep blood and 0.5% (v/v) glucose) [2]. To detect Brachyspira in samples from mice, faecal samples and terminal caecal content swabs were cultured on BJ agar [20] at 42°C using an anaerobic gas pack (Oxoid Anaerogen™, Thermo Fisher Scientific, Waltham, MA) for a total of 4 days, with readings taken at 48 and 96 h post-plating. Appearance of zones of strong β-haemolysis on selective BJ agar was considered a presumptive positive culture result.

Molecular identification and quantification of Brachyspira
Total DNA was purified from 1 mL samples of broth cultures using a commercial kit (DNeasy Blood and Tissue Kit, Qiagen, Mississauga, ON) and the concentration of "B. hampsonii" 30,446 or B. hyodysenteriae in inoculum preparations was determined using cladeor species-specific SYBR green quantitative real-time PCR with primers as previously described [2]. Results were expressed as logarithm base 10 genome equivalents (GE) per mL.
For confirmation of species identity from culturepositive faecal or terminal caecal samples, zones of strong β-haemolysis were sampled with a sterile toothpick and subjected to genus-specific Brachyspira PCR using previously published primers targeting the NADH oxidase (nox) gene [21]. PCR products were purified and sequenced using the amplification primers. Raw sequence data was assembled and edited using Pregap4 and Gap4 [22] and the resulting sequences compared to published nox sequences for identification.

Inoculation procedure
The mice underwent a 7-day acclimatization period, during which they were fed exclusively the appropriate diet for their experimental group. Water and food were provided ad libitum throughout the experiment. For each of two daily inoculations (2:00 p.m.), mice were restrained using the double handed manual technique, then held vertically by the scruff and inoculated intragastrically using a straight, 20 gauge blunt-ended feeding needle. The inocula was 0.2 mL of a 24 h old broth culture of the relevant Brachyspira species on day 0 (Bhyo = 1.6 × 10 8 , Bhamp = 1.2 × 10 9 GE per 200 μL dose) and one (Bhyo = 1.0 × 10 8 , Bhamp = 1.56 × 10 9 GE per 200 μL dose) day post-inoculation (dpi). The negative control (Ctrl) mice were sham inoculated with sterile broth in the same manner. The mice were then allowed to recover in their original cages. No sedation was used.

Clinical assessments
Mice were monitored by research personnel twice daily (8:30 a.m. and 3:00 p.m.) to assess signs of illness based on physical appearance and faecal consistency. At each observation, mice were held by the tail and placed on the examiner's palm to facilitate simultaneous defecation. Faeces were observed for the presence of mucus and/or blood, and graded using a scoring system modified from previous pig challenge experiments conducted in our laboratory [2,23](Additional file 1): Score 0 = formed faecal pellet, 1 = formed pellet with a trace mucous tail, 2 = soft, mucoid faeces, 3 = faeces with blood (+/− mucus). From each mouse, faecal pellets were collected at −2 and 0 dpi for culture and nox PCR to confirm that mice were Brachyspira-free prior to inoculation. Faecal samples were also collected from individual mice after inoculation at 5, 7, 9, and 12 dpi to monitor Brachyspira shedding.

Pathological assessments
The experiment was terminated at 15 dpi. At this time, mice were euthanized by way of anaesthetic overdose (isoflurane gas inhalation; AErrane™ Baxter Corporation, Mississauga, ON, Canada) followed by exsanguination. A necropsy was performed immediately thereafter with focus on the gastrointestinal tract. Fresh samples of caecum and colon were collected for culture and nox PCR. The carcass was placed in 10% neutral buffered formalin for 24 h. and samples of ileum, colon, caecum, heart, lung, salivary gland, rectum, liver, spleen, kidney and stomach were processed routinely for histological analysis of 5 μm haematoxylin and eosin stained (H and E) sections by a board certified veterinary pathologist blinded to treatment group. For Experiment 1, the presence or absence of catarrhal inflammation and epithelial regeneration in the colon and caecum were recorded.

Fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH)
To better visualize the interaction of Brachyspira organisms on the colonic mucosae and crypts, 2 cases from each Brachyspira group, selected on the basis of high fecal consistency score, lesion severity and Brachyspira DNA concentration in colon, along with 1 control case were selected for FISH targeting a Brachyspira generic probe. The staining protocol was adapted from previous work [24,25]. Paraffin embedded colonic tissue sections were cut at 4 μm and mounted on histology slide (FisherBrand Superfrost plus, Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc., MA., USA). Tissue sections were deparaffinized by baking in a rotary oven (BK200 Roto-Dry Slide Dryer, Mopec, MI, USA) for one hour at 65°C, followed by three 10 min. Xylene serial passages. Tissues were dehydrated by passage through 100% ethanol (2 passages, 10 min. Each), 95% ethanol (5 min.), and 70% ethanol (5 min.), and allowed to air dry at room temperature. A previously described [24], a custom fluorophore-labelled DNA probe, SER1410 (Alexa 546-5′-GTCATTCCATCGAAACATA-3′) designed for Brachyspira spp. was obtained from a commercial source (Invitrogen Corporation, CA, USA) and reconstituted using nuclease free-water to a working concentration of 5 ng/μl in hybridization buffer ( The slides were visualized using a wide-band epifluorescence microscope (Olympus IX83, Olympus Corporation, Tokyo, Japan) under 100× objective lens (Olympus UPlan-SApo 100×, 1.40, oil, Olympus Corporation, Tokyo, Japan). Filters corresponding to GFP/Green (LED excitation -460 nm, emission -ET525/50) and RFP/Red (LED excitation -565 nm; emission -ET630/75) were used for multicolour imaging. Images were captured using Andor Zyla sCOMS camera (Andor Technologies, Belfast, UK) and an imaging software (Olympus cellSens imaging software, Olympus Corporation, Richmond Hill, ON, Canada).

Experiment 2
Procedures for Experiment 2 were similar to above with a few exceptions described below.

Inoculation procedure
Because the mice were 1 week older at inoculation than those used in Experiment 1, the inoculum dose was increased to 0.3 mL per mouse of "B. hampsonii" broth culture containing 2.31 × 10 8 , 2.22 × 10 8 , 1.33 × 10 8 GE per 300 μL dose, on D0, D1, D2, respectively. The mice also underwent a 6-h fasting period prior to each of three intra-gastric inoculations to decrease gastric transit time. Inoculation procedures were identical to Experiment 1.

Molecular identification and quantification of Brachyspira
To confirm the detection of "B. hampsonii" 30,446 in pre-mortem faecal samples and terminal caecal samples, zones of strong β-haemolysis were sampled with sterile toothpicks and subjected to clade-specific conventional PCR using the same primers employed in the quantitative PCR assay used in Experiment 1 [2]. PCR reactions

Clinical assessments
Clinical assessments were performed twice daily as previously described for Experiment 1. The faecal scoring system was refined to distinguish "mild" from "severe" soft, mucoid faeces. Slightly soft and mucoid faeces were scored as 2.0, whereas very soft and mucoid faeces were scored 2.5 (Additional file 1). Faecal samples were collected from each mouse at −2 and 0 dpi for culture and nox PCR to confirm that the mice were Brachyspira-free prior to inoculation.

Pathological assessments
The experiment was terminated at 14 dpi. The entire colon was linearized and five sections throughout its length were preserved in Carnoy's solution, instead of 10% neutral buffered formalin, to allow for better preservation of the mucous layer and structural integrity of intestinal tissue [26]. Alternating sections were collected for histopathology, Brachyspira culture and PCR. The depth of crypts was assessed in H and E stained sections of colon by measuring the distance between the bottom and top of intact crypts using an eyepiece reticle. Measurements were performed by an observer blinded to treatment group on the available colonic sections (range 9-16) for each mouse, with 5 measurements per section. The following histological changes in the colon and caecum were semi-quantitatively graded from 0 to 3 (Additional files 2, 3, 4 and 5): catarrhal inflammation, epithelial regeneration, degree of mucus accumulation and neutrophilic infiltration.

Statistical analyses
All statistical analyses were performed using Stata v14 (StataCorp, College Station, TX). Group differences were deemed statistically different if P < 0.05, and a trend towards significance if 0.05 ≤ P < 0.1 a priori.

Experiment 1
A mean faecal score per mouse was calculated by averaging the twice daily scores from 3 dpi to termination. Fecal consistency scores from 0 to 2 dpi were not considered in this calculation because the intra-gastric infusion of liquid media (200-300 μl) periodically results in a loose pellets. Mean faecal scores and the number of days that the inoculated Brachyspira (Bhyo or Bhamp) was cultured from faeces (total shedding days) were compared between diet and Brachyspira spp. using a Kruskal Wallis test and post-hoc Wilcoxon rank-sum test where needed. The incubation period was defined as the number of days required for a mouse to develop consistent soft mucoid faeces (score 2) during the postinoculation period. Mice that did not develop soft mucoid faeces were assigned a value of 15 d (i.e. censored at termination). The incubation period was compared between Brachyspira spp. and diet using a Kaplan Meier survival curve followed by Wilcoxon and log-rank tests for equality of survivor functions. Finally, the relationship of histopathologic lesions (catarrhal inflammation, epithelial regeneration) in caecum and colon to Brachyspira group, diet and clinical outcome was assessed using cluster analysis (Ward's linkage; Matched Similarity Measure). The appropriate number of clusters were determined using the post-hoc Calinski-Harabasz pseudo-F index and Duda-Hart Je (2)/Je (1) index stopping rules.

Experiment 2
Similar analyses was undertaken to determine potential differences between mouse strains following "B. hampsonii" challenge. In addition, separate multilevel, linear regression models (XTMIXED) were used to investigate differences in crypt depth between mouse strains and inoculation status. For these, mouse identification was included as a random intercept. The relationship of histopathologic lesions (catarrhal inflammation, neutrophil infiltration, mucus accumulation, mucus epithelial regeneration) in caecum and colon to Brachyspira spp., mouse strain and clinical outcome was assessed using cluster analysis (Ward's linkage; Euclidean Dissimilarity Measure). Because the histopathology data was ordinal, cluster analysis was performed on scaled-ranks as described by Kaufman and Rousseeuw [27].

Results
All pre-inoculation faecal samples were culture-negative for Brachyspira, indicating no Brachyspira infection was present prior to experimental inoculation, or if present, was below the detection limit of selective culture.

Experiment 1 Clinical signs
Both Bhamp and Bhyo inoculation groups exhibited mucoid faeces following inoculation (Additional file 6). From 3 dpi onwards, mean faecal scores across both dietary groups in Bhyo were significantly higher than in sham-inoculated Ctrl (P = 0.007; Kruskal Wallis, post hoc Wilcoxon rank-sum), whereas Bhamp inoculated mice similarly trended (P = 0.06; Wilcoxon rank-sum). Increased mean faecal scores were particularly apparent in mice fed TD85420. Soft, mucoid faeces were observed after inoculation in 100% of mice from the Bhamp and Bhyo groups fed TD85420, compared to only half of the Bhyo and none of the Bhamp mice fed RMH chow. Overall, mean faecal consistency scores were higher in the TD85420 compared to the RMH group, and this result was consistent in both Brachyspira groups as well as Ctrl (P = 0.02 for Bhyo and Bhamp; P = 0.04 for Ctrl; Kruskal Wallis with post-hoc Wilcoxon rank-sum). The severity of clinical disease, however, did not differ between Bhyo and Bhamp groups (Table 1).
Faecal shedding (total shedding days) was also elevated in mice fed TD85420 (P = 0.005; Kruskal Wallis), but did not differ between the Bhyo and Bhamp infected groups. All culture-positive plates from terminal caecum samples were confirmed to be the inoculated strain via nox PCR and sequencing.
The incubation period was significantly shorter in TD85420 fed mice (P = 0.01; Kaplan Meier with posthoc log-rank and Breslow tests) (Additional file 7a), which resulted from more rapid onset and more prevalent soft, mucoid faeces.

Pathology
The most prevalent lesion in infected mice was catarrhal inflammation of the colon, characterized by sloughing of superficial epithelial cells, which were frequently degenerated and mixed with mucus (Fig. 1a). Still, only 25% of Bhamp-TD and 50% of Bhyo-TD mice had catarrhal lesions (Table 1). Epithelial regeneration, characterized by crypt hyperplasia, increased cytoplasmic basophilia, and increased mitotic activity (Fig. 1b) was less commonly observed, and only noted in 50% of Bhamp-TD mice (Table 1). Brachyspira organisms were seen in FISH-stained colonic tissue of mice inoculated with Bhyo and Bhamp, whereas samples from control mice did not reveal any positive signals. In infected mice, Brachyspira spirochaetes were observed in the luminal mucus as well as in crypts in close proximity to epithelial and goblet cells (Fig. 2). Mice clustered into three discrete clusters based on the presence or absence of histopathological lesions present in their colon and caecum (Fig. 3). The largest cluster (#3) included mice with no lesions. With one exception, clusters 1 and 2 were based on the presence of lesions in colon only (#2) versus colon and caecum (#1). Unexpectedly, the clustering of histopathology was unrelated to Brachyspira species, diet and clinical outcome.
No mouse demonstrated any evidence of other systemic or intestinal diseases, based on gross and histopathologic examination.

Experiment 2
Clinical signs CF-1 mice exhibited more severe clinical disease, with 3 of 4 Bhamp inoculated mice developing score 2.0 faeces compared to only 1 of 5 inoculated C3H mice (Additional file 8). The mean faecal scores of CF-1 mice were significantly greater than C3H mice (P = 0.049; Kruskal Wallis; Table 2). Although faecal Brachyspira shedding did not differ by mouse strain, there was a trend toward a shorter incubation time in CF-1 versus C3H mice (P = 0.08 Kaplan Meier with post-hoc log-rank and Breslow tests) (Additional file 7b).

Pathology
Similar histological changes described in Experiment 1 were noted (Table 2). In addition, neutrophilic infiltration in the lamina propria and submucosa were evident in small numbers of mice (Fig. 1c). The mice formed discrete clusters based on the severity of histopathological lesions (Fig. 4). In this experiment, five clusters of varying size were evident. Increased mucous exudate in colon and caecum (Fig. 1d) was observed similarly across all clusters. Cluster 1 and 2 included mice observed with a mild and moderate catarrhal inflammation in caecum and colon. Cluster 3 to 5 featured only Bhamp-inoculated mice with evidence of more severe lesions, including catarrhal and neutrophilic inflammation, and epithelial regeneration. Cluster 3 and 4 comprised of only one mouse each, but had the most severe clinical signs and lesions, compared to all other clusters.
Across all mice, crypt depth averaged 161 ± 49 μm. There was a trend towards C3H mice having lower crypt  depth than CF-1 (P = 0.08; XTMIXED), but the C3H mice were 3.5 g lighter than CF-1 at termination which may explain this result. Crypt depth did not differ between inoculated and control mice at termination.
Based on gross and histopathological examination, none of the mice demonstrated any evidence of other systemic or intestinal diseases.

Discussion
The two mouse inoculation experiments outlined here indicate that it is possible to consistently induce soft, mucoid faeces following experimental challenge with "Brachyspira hampsonii" clade II in mice under ideal conditions. From the results of Experiment 1, it is clear that TD85420 enhances Brachyspira-associated disease severity in mice. This finding is consistent with previous pathological assessments in which caecal lesions were found to be most severe in mice fed TD85420 [13,19]. The mechanism by which this is achieved is not fully understood, but could be attributed to the low zinc levels of TD85420. Zinc supplementation was previously shown to have a prophylactic effect against B. hyodysenteriae challenge in mice [28], which may be associated with reduced biosynthesis of haemolysin toxin rather than inhibition of pre-formed haemolysin [29]. Zinc supplementation may also decrease Brachyspira colonization in the gut as zinc (supplied as zinc oxide, ZnO) is commonly used as a supplement in swine production diets to promote weight gain [30] and maintain stability of intestinal microbiota post-weaning [31,32]. The TD85420 diet also includes an elevated fat content, which may contribute to its effects [33].
The CF-1 mouse strain was more severely affected than C3H mice in terms of faecal consistency. However, faecal shedding of Brachyspira spp. was not different between CF-1 and C3H mice. This indicates that although both mouse strains became colonized by "B. hampsonii" clade II to similar extents, this level of infection resulted in more severe disease in CF-1 mice. The reason for this apparent difference is difficult to ascertain without further study, but may be attributed to genetics. The inbred C3H strains were first selected for this type of experiment because of their varying degrees of responsiveness (determined by the lps locus) to lipopolysaccharide (LPS), a component of the outer membrane of Gramnegative bacteria. Although it was proposed that LPS   hypo-responsive mouse strains would be less susceptible to lesion development following Serpula hyodysenteriae challenge than those mouse strains with greater responsiveness, the study found that other inherent properties are also likely to be involved in determining susceptibility to S. hyodysenteriae infection and expression of disease [14].
Assessing faecal consistency was a very valuable measure of clinical disease in these experiments, with inoculated mice exhibiting more frequent soft, mucoid faeces than controls. The scoring system developed herein to assess faecal consistency in mice was modified from those used in pig inoculation studies [2,23]. During Experiment 1, it became clear that our initial faecal consistency categories were too simplistic to cover the wide range in soft mucoid faeces observed during the experiment. For this reason, the faecal scoring system was modified for Experiment 2 by adding scoring category of 2.5 to record faeces that were very soft and mucoid (Additional file 1). Twice daily assessment of faecal consistency was important because morning and afternoon faecal scores often differed, and mice occasionally did not defecate during one of the daily faecal scoring periods. Faecal consistency assessments are noninvasive, require minimal staff training to implement, and provide valuable, relevant and inexpensive clinical  data table for Experiment 2 showing clustering of histopathology. Five clusters (Ward's linkage of rank-scaled scores, Euclidean dissimilarity measure) are evident; unrelated to mouse strain, but associated with clinical outcome. Values in lesion columns represent the lesion severity score of colonic and caecal tissue sections, with more intense grey scale indicating mice with more prevalent lesions. The single mice in cluster 3 (blue) and 4 (orange) had the highest mean faecal scores and most severe colonic and caecal lesions. One inoculated mouse in cluster 2 (red) also had severe intestinal pathology and high faecal score. Cluster 5 (purple) included mice with severe pathology but both had low mean faecal scores. Mice with the least severe clinical disease and pathology were grouped in cluster 1 (green). Clusters R = regeneration of epithelium; NI = neutrophilic inflammation; IM = increased mucoid exudate; CI = catarrhal inflammation; CF1 = CF-1 mouse strain; C3H = C3H mouse strain; Spp. = Brachyspira species used for inoculation; hamp = "B. hampsonii"; ctrl = non-inoculated control; ID = mouse identification; + = soft mucoid faeces present; − = soft mucoid faeces absent data. The data collected in these experiments helps to demonstrate that mice are capable of developing clinical enteric disease and emphasizes the suitability of mice for Brachyspira studies.
Faecal shedding followed a similar pattern to faecal consistency in Experiment 1, but may be influenced by differences in faecal consistency between mice. Softer faecal samples were much easier to plate for culture compared to solid faecal pellets and thus the amount of faeces deposited on each plate was difficult to control. This added a source of variation in the culture procedure used to assess shedding. Measuring Brachyspira DNA concentration in weighed samples by quantitative PCR would partially overcome this issue, although the results could still be influenced by faecal moisture content to some extent. Measuring faecal content in mouse droppings should also be considered.
The two mouse strains differed greatly in weight at arrival and this may have potentially biased the evaluation of assessment of intestinal crypt depth in Experiment 2. Although crypt depth measurement has been used in pig challenge studies as an indicator of disease [34,35] it appears to have limited utility in mice.
Unexpectedly, the pathologic results in these experiments were not completely consistent with what has been reported in previous studies of Brachyspira challenged mice [13,14,19,36]. The catarrhal changes noted in the current experiments were not reported previously, and the neutrophilic infiltration reported in previous studies was only evident in Experiment 2. The reasons for the discrepancies are not known. It may be that the previous studies mostly focused on the cellular infiltrates in the lamina propria, thus the catarrhal changes were not recorded. The lack of neutrophilic infiltration in Experiment 1 may be the effect of differences in challenge dose and protocol. This may be supported by the fact that, in Experiment 2, where inoculation dose was larger, there were higher rates of neutrophilic infiltration. Mouse origin can also affect susceptibility to infection with Brachyspira spp. since the intestinal and caecal microbiota can differ widely based on the conditions under which the mice are initially raised [11]. However, both mouse strains examined here were from the same source and showed similar faecal shedding patterns, suggesting that they are equally susceptible to infection. To further complicate the interpretation, some control mice (most evident in Experiment 2), developed catarrhal inflammation in the large intestines. While feeding TD85420 diet may increase the probably of developing this lesion, it was also observed a non-inoculated control mouse in Experiment 1 fed RMH diet. In any case, the severity of pathological lesions, particularly the presence of epithelial regeneration and neutrophilic inflammation in Experiment 2 were poorly associated with clinical signs.
Conclusions are more susceptible than C3H mice to developing soft, mucoid faeces following "B. hampsonii" challenge. (TIFF 1522 kb) Additional file 8: Heat map displaying clinical signs and faecal shedding in Experiment 2 during the post-inoculation period. Culture positive results are represented by "+" on 5, 7, 9 and 12 dpi, and termination (all samples were strongly β-haemolytic). Colour of square (grey scale) represents the faecal consistency score on the given day. Culture and PCR performed on the last faecal sample and colonic tissue collected at termination to confirm "Brachyspira hampsonii" are indicated by *. (TIFF 1522 kb)