A Comprehensive Review of the Strategies to Reduce Retinoid-Induced Skin Irritation in Topical Formulation

Currently, retinoids are known for their abundant benefits to skin health, ranging from reducing signs of aging and decreasing hyperpigmentation to treating acne. However, it cannot be denied that there are various side effects associated with the use of retinoids on the skin, one of which is irritation. Several approaches can be employed to minimize the irritation caused by retinoids. This review article discusses topical retinoid formulation technology strategies to reduce skin irritation effects. The methodology used in this study is a literature review of 21 reference journals. The sources used in compiling this review are from PubMed, Scopus, ScienceDirect, and MEDLINE. The findings obtained indicate that the following methods can be used to lessen retinoid-induced irritation in topical formulations: developing drug delivery systems in the formulation, such as encapsulating retinoids, transforming retinoids into nanoparticles, forming complexes (e.g., with cyclodextrin), and binding retinoids with carriers (e.g., polymers, NLC, SLN), adding ingredients with anti-irritation activity, skin barrier improvement, and increased skin hydration to retinoid formulations (e.g., combinations of glucosamine, trehalose, ectoine, sucralfate, omega-9, and 4-t-butylcyclohexanol, addition of ethanolic bark extract of Alstonia scholaris R. Br).


Introduction
Retinoids are compounds that have been used topically and systemically since the 1940s to address acne problems [1].Over the past few decades, topical retinoids have seen increasing development in their usage.Among various treatments, topical retinoids are among the most commonly used active ingredients and have been clinically tested [2].Retinoids have been shown to successfully improve several dermatological conditions, including photoaging/rhytides, psoriasis, and acne vulgaris.Tey are also used of-label for conditions, such as hyperpigmentation and keratosis pilaris [3].
While retinoids ofer advantages in treating several skin conditions, they can also have drawbacks, including retinoid dermatitis, characterized by redness, peeling, burning, and itching [4].Te side efects that occur are typically dosedependent [5].Te concentration of retinoids that can cause skin irritation can vary depending on several factors, including the specifc retinoid compound, the individual's skin sensitivity, and the frequency and duration of use.Generally, higher concentrations of retinoids tend to cause more skin irritation [6,7].
Studies on the mechanism of irritation have shown that retinoid-induced irritation can be mediated by various pathways.Te mechanism of retinol irritation generates broad and chronic infammation defned by immune cell infltration and cytokine release, as well as breakdown of the skin barrier caused by a genetic imbalance of components linked with the cornifed envelope (CE) [8].A study conducted by Kim et al. [9] demonstrated that retinoids can generate a range of proteins associated with skin irritation, such as MCP-1 and IL-8.However, the observations made so far have not provided a comprehensive explanation for the process behind retinoid-induced irritation, and as a result, defnitive conclusions have yet to be established.
Tere are many ways to reduce skin irritation caused by retinoid products.Te way a product is made afects how it works on the skin.Research is ongoing to create products that work well without causing irritation [3].Diferent methods, like liposomes and solid lipid nanoparticles, are being studied to reduce irritation [10].Tis review aims to explore these methods to lessen skin irritation from using retinoid products.

Method
Tis review was conducted following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, utilizing a search of articles from the PubMed, Scopus, ScienceDirect, and MEDLINE databases.Te search strategy employed Boolean operators, using the syntax "Retinoid AND Irritation AND Formulation."To enhance the comprehensiveness of the review, no restrictions were placed on the publication year during the literature search.Te retrieved articles were then collated and evaluated for duplicates.Subsequently, screening of titles and abstracts of the obtained articles was performed.Further screening involved analyzing full-text articles to assess their eligibility.Te eligibility of articles was determined based on inclusion criteria, including studies published in English, studies involving the use of retinoids as an active ingredient in the formulations used, and studies conducting irritation testing either in vitro, in vivo, or clinically.Te exclusion criteria for this review encompassed articles, such as reviews, notes, book chapters, conference papers, short surveys, editorials, and letters.Te fow of article selection leading to the identifcation of eligible articles is depicted in Figure 1.

Topical Formulation of Retinoid
Retinoids have been shown to successfully treat several dermatological conditions, including reducing signs of aging (wrinkles, photoaging, rhytides), decreasing hyperpigmentation, and treating acne, as well as other dermatological illnesses, such as Kaposi's sarcoma, psoriasis, and T-cell lymphoma.

Reducing Signs of Aging (Wrinkle, Photoaging, and Rhytides).
Vitamin A and its derivatives, particularly retinol, have demonstrated notable efcacy as pharmaceutical agents for slowing down the aging process.Te efcacy of topically administered formulations containing retinoids in reducing wrinkles can be attributed to several mechanisms.Tese mechanisms include the stimulation of keratinocyte proliferation and collagen synthesis, enhancement of the epidermal barrier function (EGFR), prevention of collagen breakdown, reduction of transdermal water loss (TEWL), and suppression of metalloproteinase activity.Hence, the objective of this literature review is to provide a comprehensive overview of several approaches applied to mitigate the occurrence of skin irritation as an adverse efect resulting from the application of topical retinoids [11,12].Retinoids are thought to exert their efects at the molecular level by interacting with nuclear retinoic acid receptors, which act as transcription factors in the regulation of gene expression [13].Retinol improves skin suppleness by eliminating damaged elastin fbers, activating fbroblasts to produce collagen fbers, increasing fbroblast number, and stimulating angiogenesis.Collagen production declines with age, leading to wrinkles and fne lines.Retinoids stimulate collagen formation, which improves skin frmness and reduces the depth of wrinkles [14,15].

Decrease Hyperpigmentation.
Retinoids can be used to improve melanin distribution in the skin, reducing skin discoloration and pigmentation by up to 60%.Tey are employed to treat pigmentation disorders, such as melasma and postinfammatory hyperpigmentation.Retinoids work by inhibiting tyrosinase and dispersing epidermal melanin.Additionally, they may cause the epidermis to shed faster, interfering with pigment transfer to keratinocytes and accelerating pigment loss.Tey also inhibit the activity of active melanocytes and prevent melanin transfer to epidermal cells.Long-term use of retinoids decreases melanin levels while increasing the stratum corneum thickness [15,16].

Treating Acne.
Topical retinoids are used for the treatment of both noninfammatory and infammatory acne.Currently, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has approved three topical retinoids: adapalene, tazarotene, and tretinoin [17].Topical retinoids play a signifcant role in acne treatment due to their proven efcacy in reducing visible lesions and suppressing the development of microcomedones and new lesions [18].Tey function by inhibiting keratinocyte growth and promoting cellular diferentiation, thereby regulating the process of desquamation [18].In addition to their primary efects, topical retinoids have been found to inhibit the migration of leukocytes, hinder the AP-1 pathway, and disrupt various other crucial infammatory mechanisms triggered during the development of acne [19,20].Furthermore, topical retinoids have been shown to improve the penetration of additional topical acne medications and facilitate the healing of postinfammatory hyperpigmentation resulting from acne [21].

Kaposi's Sarcoma.
In the case of Kaposi's sarcoma (KSC), retinoids have been observed to indirectly inhibit its initial growth.Te antiproliferative efects of retinoids can occur due to the modulation of cytokines or receptors, leading to changes in their expression.For example, retinoids can inhibit the production of oncostatin M through the autocrine IL-6 pathway, thereby exerting antiproliferative efects.Additionally, retinoids can upregulate 2 Dermatology Research and Practice the expression of TGF-β, which hinders the normal proliferation of endothelial cells.Furthermore, retinoids can infuence the expression of TGF-β receptors, contributing to their antiproliferative properties [19,20,22,23].

Psoriasis.
Retinoids are involved in the physiological process of skin cell formation and possess a chemical composition that bears resemblance to vitamin A. Te mechanism of action of retinoids involves the inhibition of keratinization, which refers to the process by which skin cells thicken due to the deposition of protein within them.Additionally, retinoids suppress excessive cell proliferation, both of which are characteristic features observed in individuals with psoriasis [11,24].Te sole prescribed treatment for psoriasis is the topical retinoid known as tazarotene.Tazarotene undergoes hydrolysis in the tissues, resulting in the formation of tazarotenic acid.Subsequently, tazarotenic acid binds to the retinoic acid receptors.Te interaction between the receptor and ligand is responsible for controlling the expression of retinoid-responsive genes, which play a role in cell proliferation and infammation.Psoriasis, a condition characterized by increased epidermal proliferation, is distinguished by the presence of cell proliferation and infammation as prominent symptoms [25].

T-Cell Lymphoma.
Retinoids, as a collective class, share a common mode of action.However, it is important to note that individual retinoids possess unique structural characteristics and exhibit specifc binding afnities to receptors.Tis molecular variability accounts for the diverse indications and results associated with diferent retinoids.For instance, bexarotene, a retinoid compound with specifcity for the retinoid X receptor (RXR), is indicated as a suggested therapeutic option for managing cutaneous T-cell lymphoma [26].Bexarotene binds to and activates the RXR nuclear receptors, resulting in the inhibition of the G1, G2, Dermatology Research and Practice and M phases of the cell cycle.Tis leads to a reduction in cell proliferation and an increase in programmed cell death, known as apoptosis [27].

Skin Irritation.
While retinoids have proven benefcial in dermatology, they can also cause skin irritation, with the severity often corresponding to the dosage administered.Symptoms of irritation may include erythema, pruritus, a sensation of burning, xerosis, desquamation, or the development of a condition known as "retinoid dermatitis" at the application site of the retinoid [7,28].Retinoids have been found to enhance the proliferation of cells in the stratum corneum and basal layer of the epidermis, promoting epidermal turnover.Consequently, the process of shedding old and damaged skin cells is accelerated.Te thinning of the stratum corneum due to increased cell turnover can diminish the skin's ability to act as a protective barrier, contributing to heightened irritation and sensitivity.
Research conducted in vivo and clinical settings has demonstrated that the application of topical retinoids often leads to dry skin.However, there is no empirical evidence to support the notion that sebum production is diminished as a result of this treatment.Dry skin, characterized by faky skin, is believed to arise from the normalization of keratinocyte diferentiation, proliferation, and desmosome weakening, leading to a reduction in cell adhesion [29].
Although topical retinoids have the ability to bind to retinoid receptors on sebocytes, resulting in decreased sebum production, current research does not convincingly show that topical retinoids have a sebosuppressive efect [30].Te administration of retinoids could interfere with lipid production, essential for maintaining the integrity of the skin barrier.Reduced lipid production levels diminish the capacity of lipid envelopes to function as a barrier, potentially leading to decreased defense against external irritants and increased transepidermal water loss.Tis heightened sensitivity may disrupt the integrity of the skin's natural barriers, increasing susceptibility to skin damage [31].

Strategies
Te strategy of formulating topical retinoid technology to minimize skin irritation can be achieved through encapsulation or complex formation techniques in the drug delivery process [32,33].Tere are several methods (Table 1) for encapsulating nanoparticles.One popular strategy involves encapsulating nanoparticles with a protective layer or shell, which can be formed from polymer materials, lipid layers, or inorganic substances [52][53][54].Several studies have shown that colloidal carriers such as solid lipid nanoparticles (SLN), nanostructured lipid carriers (NLC), polymer particles, liposomes, niosomes, cyclodextrins, and microemulsions can reduce retinoid irritation.Additionally, alternative methods to reduce irritation efects include the inclusion of anti-irritation substances.In this paper, we provide a comprehensive review of several studies focusing on technological advancements in topical retinoid formulations aimed at mitigating skin irritant efects.
4.1.Liposome.Te frst generation of new drug delivery vehicles, liposomes, has undergone substantial research [55].Liposomes, consisting of bilayers referred to as unilamellar or multilamellar liposomes, are employed as carriers in various applications.Tese bilayers consist of concentric layers separated by aqueous compartments, created by amphipathic molecules such as phospholipids that enclose the core aqueous compartments [56].Liposomes have the capacity to encapsulate various types of medication, allowing modifcations of their appearance through lipid modifcation [57].Recognized as highly efcient vehicles for drug delivery, liposomes ofer exceptional biocompatibility and safety attributes.Tey prolong the half-life of drugs, regulate the release of drug molecules, and safeguard the encapsulated material against physiological degradation [58].Moreover, liposomes can selectively target aficted areas through passive and/or active delivery mechanisms, reducing the occurrence of systemic side efects, enhancing the maximum tolerated dose, and ultimately improving therapeutic outcomes [59].Te ability of liposomes to reduce the irritation caused by retinol usage stems from their capacity to protect encapsulated molecules from degradation.Additionally, the formation of liposomes enables controlled and localized release, providing sustained and targeted effects [60].Encapsulating drugs into liposomes for topical administration leads to increased drug concentration at the targeted site of action, enhancing localized benefts and minimizing undesirable systemic side efects [61].
A study conducted by Rahman et al. [44]investigated the process of encapsulating tretinoin into liposomes generated using a modifed ether injection approach.In this study, tretinoin (TRT) at a concentration of 0.025% was incorporated into a gel formulation containing 1% carbopol to evaluate its potential for causing skin irritation.Volunteers received a single application of the product (0.3 g dose) and were monitored for observable changes, namely, erythema (redness), after a 6-hour period.Outcomes were assessed using a scoring framework ranging from 4 to 0: 4 indicates severe erythema, 3 indicates moderate-to-severe erythema, 2 indicates moderate erythema, 1 indicates mild erythema, and 0 indicates the absence of erythema.Te results indicated that the liposome formulation exhibited decreased erythema scores (mean score of 0.2 ± standard deviation of 0.37) compared to both the TRT 0.025% gel formulation (mean score of 1.70 ± standard deviation of 0.751) and the commercially available product (mean score of 1.40 ± standard deviation of 0.534) [41].
In another study conducted by Raza et al., the thin-flm hydration process was employed to manufacture tretinoinloaded liposomes.Te liposome dispersion consisted of tretinoin, phospholipids, butylated hydroxytoluene, and cholesterol dissolved in a chloroform-methanol (2 : 1 v/v) mixture.An in vivo investigation was conducted on female Laca mice, with each group being topically treated with TREliposomal gel, TRE-ethosomal gel, TRE-SLN gel, and TRE-NLC gel, while a ffth group was treated with saline as a control.After 2 weeks of daily treatment (approximately 0.2 g of the formulation), any residual formulation on the skin was rinsed of.Te evaluated skin area was 4 Dermatology Research and Practice In vivo test on rabbits [8] Encapsulation into solid lipid nanoparticles (SLNs) Adapalene Encapsulation in solid lipid nanoparticles (SLNs) using an ion-pairing strategy In vivo testing on female rats [34] Encapsulation and controlled release silicone particle Retinol Encapsulation of retinol with silicone particles In vivo test on humans [35] NLC (nanostructured lipid carriers) Tretinoin NLC (nanostructured lipid carriers) loaded with tretinoin were developed using stearic acid, Span 60, oleic acid, and Tween 80 incorporated into carbopol gel In vivo test on rats [36] Solid lipid nanoparticles (SLN) Vitamin A Dispersion of solid lipid nanoparticles using a highpressure homogenization technique In vivo test on rabbits [37] Nanostructured lipid carriers (NLC) In vivo test on humans [45] Conjugated polymer All-trans-retinoic acid (ATRA) Formation of polymer conjugate by covalently binding all-trans-retinoic acid through ester linkage with polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) In vivo on rats [46] Addition of ingredients Glucosamine, trehalose, ectoine, sucralfate, omega-9, and 4-t-butylcyclohexanol

Retinol Formulation of retinol with ingredients that can genetically inhibit irritation
In vivo test on humans [4] Polyolprepolymer-2

Tretinoin
Combination of tretinoin with polyolprepolymer-2 In vivo testing on guinea pigs [47] Tretinoin Combination of tretinoin with polyolprepolymer-2 In vivo test on humans [48] Addition of cyclodextrin

Retinoic acid Complexation forming cyclodextrin beta complex (β-CD)
In vivo test on humans [49] Isotretinoin Isotretinoin HP-β-CD complex is made using the freeze-drying method In vivo test on rabbits [50] Alstonia scholaris extract All-trans-retinoic acid (ATRA) Addition of 0.1% Alstonia scholaris extract to 2500 IU retinol cream In vivo test on humans [51] Dermatology Research and Practice photographed using a digital camera one hour later, and the outcomes were observed.Skin samples were taken, fxed in 10% formalin solution, stained with hematoxylin and eosin, and examined under a microscope.Images from skin irritancy tests on mice demonstrated that the developed method was well accepted on rat skin compared to other treatments on the market, as there was no visually or microscopically apparent irritation.Tis can be attributed to the small vesicle size and the function of liposomes in protecting the skin from direct contact with the drug trapped within the vesicles.Tretinoin (TRT) can be supplied to the epidermis gradually, reducing erythematous occurrences by being absorbed into vesicles, which also reduces the contact of the TRT carboxylic acid (−COOH) groups with the stratum corneum [38].Te small vesicle size and high TRT incorporation efciency of this proposed mixture could help reduce skin irritation.However, liposomes have several drawbacks, including high production costs, drug/molecule leakage, and fusion.If the temperature during manufacturing and storage is not tightly regulated, drug encapsulation may leak.Phospholipids occasionally undergo reactions resembling oxidation and hydrolysis.Lysophospholipids and peroxides are created when liposomal phospholipids are hydrolyzed and oxidized, increasing the permeability of the bilayer.Additionally, in aqueous suspensions of liposomes, aggregation, particle size increase, and drug leakage may occur at considerable rates.Liposomes are also poorly soluble and have a limited halflife.Some frst-generation liposome products might not be long-term stable at room temperature [62,63].

Niosome.
Niosomes are nonionic surfactant-based colloidal vesicular carriers composed primarily of two types of components: nonionic surfactants and additives.Te vesicular layer's development is facilitated by the nonionic surfactant, while cholesterol and charged molecules serve as additives in niosome formation [64].Cholesterol plays multiple roles in stabilizing vesicular structures, including reducing the transition temperature from the gel phase to the liquid crystal phase and decreasing the overall hydrophilic-lipophilic balance (HLB) value of the surfactant mixture used in niosome preparation [65,66].
In recent years, extensive research has explored the application of niosomes as drug delivery systems.Niosomes ofer controlled and/or sustained release of pharmaceutical substances to targeted areas while demonstrating an extended period of stability [67].Tey can encapsulate large amounts of materials in a small volume, are more efective than conventional oily formulations, and can entrap a diverse range of chemicals due to their unique structure [67][68][69].Properties such as shape, fuidity, and size can be easily adjusted by modifying their structural composition and synthesis technique [70].Previous studies have shown that incorporating niosomes into gel matrices can improve drug absorption and reduce skin irritation due to their particle size, surface composition, and characteristics [71].Niosomes, as second-generation vesicular carriers, have gained attention as suitable replacements for liposomes due to their enhanced chemical stability, superior drug encapsulation capabilities, inherent ability to enhance skin penetration, and cost-efectiveness [72,73].
Rahman et al. investigated the in vivo irritant efects of topical proniosomal formulations containing tretinoin.Proniosomes can be hydrated immediately before use to produce niosomes.Te proposed formula, N8G, consisted of protonosomes synthesized with 0.025% TRT and a 3 : 1 molar ratio of cholesterol to Span 60.Skin irritation tests were performed by comparing it to a commercial product, revealing minor erythema skin irritation test results for the proniosomal TRT gel compared to other treatments [44].
Kim et al. conducted an investigation using the lipid hydration method to generate niosomes.A cohort of 23 healthy individuals received daily administration of a 0.05% RA-N nanoemulsion blend for 4 weeks.Te Visioscan ® method was employed to compute the average desquamation index, which showed a signifcant reduction in desquamation, indicating the potential for skin tolerance without causing irritation [43].
Despite the mentioned advantages, aqueous solutions of niosomes have a short shelf life due to fusion, aggregation, drug leakage, and hydrolysis [74].Stability is afected by factors, such as surfactant type, storage temperature, interfacial polymerization of surfactant monomers, detergents, membrane-spanning lipids, nature of encapsulated drug, and inclusion of charged molecules [3,4].
Niosomes and liposomes have similar applications in drug delivery but difer chemically in their structure units.Niosomes are made of nonionic surfactants, whereas liposomes are made of phospholipids [75].Tey function as amphiphilic vesicles, carrying out similar tasks and sharing morphological traits.Both can be used for targeted and sustained drug delivery systems [76].Studies have shown that niosomes and liposomes both have comparable functions in vivo [77].While having similar characteristics to liposomes, niosomes ofer several advantages, including intrinsic skin penetration-enhancing qualities, increased chemical stability, and lower costs [67].

Solid Lipid Nanoparticle (SLN)
. Solid lipid nanoparticles (SLNs) are lipid-based nanoparticles characterized by a solid core, capable of encapsulating both hydrophilic and hydrophobic pharmaceutical compounds [78].Tey ofer advantages such as enhanced physical stability, controlled release properties, and ease of preparation, making them safer and more cost-efective than polymer nanoparticles [35,79,80].SLNs have shown potential as a drug delivery system for topical applications due to their ability to enhance drug permeation into the skin and reduce potential toxicity and irritation upon dermal application [81,82].
Several studies have demonstrated that SLNs can reduce or even eliminate skin irritation caused by retinoids.Rodrigues et al. used an ion-pairing approach to create SLNs for encapsulating adapalene.In vivo irritation tests on female rats over a 7-day period showed signifcantly lower erythema scores for SLN-SA-AD gel compared to commercially available AD gel (p < 0.05) [34].

6
Dermatology Research and Practice Shields et al. employed high-pressure homogenization to generate dispersions of SLNs, which were incorporated into polymer gels.Skin irritation tests on albino rabbits showed no erythema or edema, indicating that the formulated substances did not induce skin irritation [35].
Ahmad Nasrollahi et al. examined the creation of SLNs using a hot-melt homogenization approach combined with ultrasound emulsifcation.Female rats treated with SLNs containing RA-STE showed signifcantly reduced irritation indices compared to those treated with a commercially available RA cream (p < 0.05) [42].
Despite the advantages of SLNs, such as protection from adverse environmental conditions, ease of large-scale synthesis, biocompatibility, and biodegradability, they also have limitations.Tese include low drug loading efciency, potential drug expulsion due to crystallization during storage, and initial burst release.Te propensity for drugs to expel from SLNs during storage due to crystallization restricts drug loading.To overcome these limitations, nanostructured lipid carriers (NLCs) can be employed to prevent crystallization [83][84][85].

4.4.
Nanostructured Lipid Carriers (NLCs).Nanostructured lipid carriers (NLCs) are lipid-based nanoparticles composed of a mixture of solid and liquid lipids, resulting in an imperfect crystal structure [86].NLCs ofer advantages over SLNs, including higher drug loading capacity, minimized drug expulsion due to lipid crystallization, increased drug solubility in lipid matrix, and more controllable release profles [87,88].Te addition of oil in NLCs prevents lipid recrystallization, resulting in a more thermodynamically stable system with improved release properties [89][90][91].
NLCs are considered an enhanced version of SLNs, featuring optimized core composition, increased drug loading capacity, enhanced stability, and the ability to function at reduced temperatures [87,[91][92][93].Despite being solid at physiological body temperature, NLCs have a lower melting point than SLNs, providing more space for drug dissolution and higher loading capacity [87,88].NLCs are less susceptible to gelation during preparation and storage, facilitating nanoparticle separation from the medium and dosage form preparation for parenteral administration [87,88].
Autoclaving can be employed to sterilize NLC solutions, but this method requires strong dilution of the particle dispersion and elimination of organic solvent residues, posing challenges for industrial application [94].Te use of retinoid active components in NLCs has shown enhanced skin penetration due to the lipid composition of the nanocarrier, reducing the likelihood of skin irritation and photosensitization.Clinical studies have demonstrated the nonirritating nature of NLC formulations containing retinyl palmitate and tretinoin [37][38][39][40].
Castro et al. reported that NLCs prepared using ultrasonic homogenization and high-pressure techniques demonstrated skin tolerance in clinical studies [40].Rahman et al. found that NLCs loaded with retinyl palmitate minimized irritant efects, with in vitro tests showing cell survival above 90% for all NLC formulations [39].Pople and Singh observed no irritation with NLC-based tretinoin gel compared to a commercially available gel, which induced signifcant irritation within three days [37].Raza et al. also demonstrated superior skin tolerance of NLCs compared to a commercially available product in animal studies [38].
4.5.Polymer.Polymer drug delivery systems are defned as formulations or devices that facilitate the entry of therapeutic substances into the body [95].Drug carriers utilizing polymers are available in various forms, including nanoparticles, micelles, dendrimers, and hydrogels.Tese carriers consist of either natural or synthetic polymers, such as poly-D, L-lactide coglycolide (PLGA) or polylactide (PLA) [96,97].Loading drugs into these carriers can be achieved through covalent bonding, surface adsorption, or trapping within the polymer matrix [98].Tese systems can enhance the safety and efectiveness of drugs by controlling the rate, timing, and location of drug release within the body.Additionally, they can protect and facilitate the release of encapsulated drugs by preventing physical and chemical degradation [95].Drug delivery carriers ofer signifcant capabilities, and the use of smart polymers can improve drug transport and reduce the adverse efects associated with these therapeutic agents, thereby enhancing therapeutic efectiveness [99].
Te solubility of poorly water-soluble medicines can be improved by polymers, increasing their bioavailability and therapeutic impacts.Polymers have signifcantly contributed to the advancement of drug delivery technology by enabling cyclic dosage, adjustable release of both hydrophilic and hydrophobic medicines, and regulated release of therapeutic agents in steady doses over extended durations [100,101].Using a polymer as an inert carrier ofers many benefts.For example, polymers can improve the pharmacodynamic and pharmacokinetic properties of biopharmaceuticals by lengthening their plasma half-lives, lowering their immunogenicity, boosting their stability, increasing the solubility of low-molecular-weight drugs, and potentially enabling targeted drug delivery [102].Polymeric nanoparticles are excellent options for drug delivery.However, toxicity and a higher likelihood of particle aggregation are drawbacks of polymeric nanoparticles (NPs).Although polymeric nanocarriers are being tested in several clinical trials, only a small number of polymeric nanomedicines have received FDA approval and are being utilized in clinical settings [103].Te efectiveness of these nanopharmaceuticals is limited by safety issues, toxicity risks, insufcient biocompatibility, and physiological limitations [104].Drawbacks of these nanoparticles include harmful monomer aggregation, residual material attached to them, and toxic disintegration [105].

Dermatology Research and Practice
Niemiec et al. [107] suggested that adding polyolprepolymer-2 to the formulation can hinder the migration of tretinoin into the deeper layers of the epidermis, consequently decreasing irritation.Quigley and Bucks [47] conducted a study where they formulated tretinoin into cream and gel forms using polyolprepolymer-2.Te study demonstrated the efectiveness of polyolprepolymer-2 in minimizing the adverse efects of tretinoin-induced irritation.Tree diferent test substances were used in patch tests on the shaved dorsal skin of guinea pigs: a 0.025% tretinoin gel containing polyolprepolymer-2, a commercially available 0.025% tretinoin gel, and a 0.025% tretinoin gel without polyolprepolymer-2.Preliminary fndings indicated that the formulation with polyolprepolymer-2 resulted in signifcantly less pain compared to the other formulations.While the irritation scores for the 0.025% tretinoin cream with polyolprepolymer-2 suggested reduced irritation risk, no signifcant diference was observed compared to the 0.025% cream [47].
Luckya et al. also investigated the formulation of tretinoin with polyolprepolymer-2.Patch tests were conducted on human skin to evaluate irritation levels.A comparative analysis was performed between a tretinoin gel containing polyolprepolymer-2 at a concentration of 0.025% and an over-the-counter tretinoin gel.Te results showed that tretinoin combined with polyolprepolymer-2 led to a statistically signifcant reduction in facial peeling compared to using the commercially available tretinoin gel [48].

Conjugated Polymer.
Comparing this drug-polymer conjugate to standard small-molecule therapy reveals several signifcant advantages.First, conjugating a drug with a water-soluble polymer can greatly enhance its solubility in aqueous solutions [108].Te drug-polymer conjugate ofers potential for controlled drug delivery, releasing the drug in a controlled manner over a specifc period.Tis allows for precise control of the rate and duration of drug administration to achieve the desired therapeutic concentration efectively [109].Drug-polymer conjugates, composed of polymers, generally exhibit extended half-lives, improved stability, enhanced water solubility, reduced immunogenicity and antigenicity, and increased tissue or cell specifcity [110].Both polymeric and molecular prodrugs use polymers as carriers for proteins, targeting moieties, and imaging agents.Drug-polymer conjugates can be viewed as drug delivery systems that achieve their therapeutic efcacy by gradually releasing small drug molecules from the polymer chain [111].
Research by Castleberry et al. demonstrated that the synthesis of polymer conjugates involves covalently binding the drug to a hydrophilic polymer, polyvinyl alcohol (PVA), through ester bonds.Tis process produces an amphiphilic nanomaterial soluble in water, which can be hydrolytically degraded.Te PVA-bound all-trans-retinoic acid acts as a prodrug, facilitating its accumulation in the skin and enabling controlled and sustained release of active all-transretinoic acid.In vivo irritation experiments were conducted on laboratory animals, specifcally rats.Rats were administered two distinct treatments: PATRA, ATRA, PVA, and PBS, applied to a 1 cm 2 area on their dorsal surface.Irritation assessment involved digital imaging to examine the application areas of ATRA, PATRA, or the control solution for up to fve days postadministration.Infammation was further examined using histological analysis.Each rat received one of the four test chemicals applied at two separate locations.Evaluation of infammation and skin changes following all-trans-retinoic acid (ATRA) application was conducted using digital imaging and hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) histology.Te in vivo assessment of irritation caused by the PVA-ATRA polymer-drug combination, PATRA, demonstrated a signifcant reduction in infammation and irritation [46].4.6.Cyclodextrins.Cyclodextrins (CDs) are cyclic oligosaccharides composed of at least six, seven, or eight glucose units connected by α-1,4 glycosidic linkages.Cyclodextrin glycosyltransferase (CGT) is an enzyme commonly found in Bacillus macerans, Klebsiella pneumoniae, and Alkalophilic bacteria strain number 38.Tis enzyme primarily facilitates starch hydrolysis, leading to the production of cyclodextrins [49].Complexation of a substance with cyclodextrin can improve its delivery characteristics without afecting its activity, as complexation is a rapid, reversible, and dynamic process [112].Te formation of inclusion complexes between drugs and cyclodextrin enhances the physicochemical and biological properties of poorly soluble drugs and encapsulates lipophilic drugs within the cyclodextrin cavity [113].CDs can modulate the rheological properties of creams and gels and reduce skin irritation caused by active ingredients [114].CDs and their derivatives ofer signifcant advantages in transdermal drug delivery, including enhanced drug solubility and stability, improved transdermal absorption, sustained drug release, reduced side efects, and facilitation of both local and systemic administration [115,116].
CDs have been shown to improve the stability, tolerance, apparent solubility, and organoleptic properties of active substances, as well as their controlled release in the skin [114].While CDs are too large to permeate the stratum corneum (SC), they can act as skin permeation enhancers by increasing the perceived solubility of active substances and providing an in situ reservoir efect [117].Using CDs as skin carriers can increase the stability of active ingredients in the formulation and at the target site, reduce irritation caused by active ingredients, and allow for controlled release [118].CDs can enhance the bioavailability of complex compounds by improving their solubility, stability, penetration, and retention, and they exhibit superior biocompatibility, which limits toxicity associated with active ingredients [119].
A study by Anadolu et al. found that beta-cyclodextrin (−CD) complexes reduced itching caused by retinoids.Tis study compared the efects of various topical applications on acne vulgaris patients, including a cyclodextrin complex hydrogel formulation (0.025%), cyclodextrin complex in a moisturizer base (0.025%), hydrogel base, moisturizer base, and a commercial retinoic acid gel (0.05%), through in vivo 8 Dermatology Research and Practice irritation testing.Only one patient discontinued treatment due to signifcant irritation, and none of the patients treated with the cyclodextrin complex experienced substantial local irritation compared to currently available retinoic acid formulations [49].
Another study by Kaur et al. focused on evaluating the irritating efects of isotretinoin solid inclusion complexes produced through freeze-drying.Rabbits were used as experimental subjects, and their dorsal fur was removed 24 hours prior to the experiment.Te results showed that the isotretinoin elastic liposomal formulation exhibited significantly reduced skin irritation potency compared to the unencapsulated medication [50].
Despite the advantages of topical formulations, there are also limitations [120].Cyclodextrins can only improve the topical delivery of drugs in the presence of water.In aqueous vehicle systems, cyclodextrins solubilize lipophilic, waterinsoluble drugs and deliver them to the barrier surface.Drug molecules then partition from the cyclodextrin cavity into the lipophilic barrier at the surface.As a result, drug administration from aqueous cyclodextrin solutions is both difusion and membrane-regulated.Only trace amounts of hydrated cyclodextrin molecules and drug/cyclodextrin complexes can pass through intact skin [121].In some cases, the complexation efciency is low, requiring relatively large volumes of cyclodextrin to complex modest amounts of a particular medication.
Te availability of products containing CDs is also limited by high implementation costs for practically all CD formulations and issues with the quality and legal status of derivatives.CDs cannot permeate biological membranes during topical administration under normal conditions, but they can signifcantly alter drug bioavailability.Unfortunately, CDs can interact with formulation components and produce physicochemical stability issues; selecting the correct carrier appears to be a challenge.Tus, it is easier to create solutions or suspensions than to formulate complex semisolid carriers, and this tendency is refected in the number of products available.Despite these challenges, a few complex formulations with properties modifed by CD addition exist, such as liposomes, fabrics, hydrogels, microspheres, and emulsions.While these are promising forms, their practical application will likely be limited to a select few items in the future [122].

Nanoemulsion.
Nanoemulsions are transparent systems typically composed of particles ranging from 20 to 500 nm in diameter [123].Te Brownian motion of nanoemulsion droplets provides sufcient force to counteract physical destabilization processes, such as gravitational separation, focculation, and coalescence due to their small droplet size [124].Nanoemulsions are multiphase colloidal dispersions that do not form spontaneously [125].According to Kale et al., a nanoemulsion is a dispersion of water, oil, and surfactant that generates nanoscale particles through mechanical forces, forming a stable isotropic and thermodynamic system with a distributed droplet diameter [126].Te small droplet size of nanoemulsions allows for uniform deposition and penetration of active compounds across the skin's surface [127].Te increased efectiveness of nanoemulsions in facilitating material penetration can be attributed to their large surface area and lower interfacial tension within the emulsion system, requiring a surfactant concentration of approximately 3-10% during production [128].Nanoemulsions are recognized as superior nanocarriers compared to other emulsion systems due to their stability against temperature fuctuations and dilution [129].Teir long-term stability and ability to prevent drug degradation make them an optimal drug delivery system [130].Nanoemulsions are efcient carriers with a higher surface area and free energy, are nontoxic and nonirritating, and can be easily applied to mucous membranes and skin in various formulations, such as creams, liquids, foams, and sprays [131].Tey have been shown to be excellent carriers for the optimal dispersion of active substances in specifc skin layers or cells [132].Using high-energy machinery to produce nanoemulsions can help avoid the incorporation of potentially irritating surfactants or active substances [133].
A study by Prasad et al. demonstrated that a nanoemulsion formulation containing 0.1% w/w adapalene and 1% w/w clindamycin phosphate exhibited reduced irritant properties.A comparative analysis evaluated the efcacy of a gel formulation containing a combination of 0.1% adapalene and 1% clindamycin versus a standard gel formulation in individuals with facial acne vulgaris.Te results indicated a signifcant decrease in the occurrence and severity of adverse efects, such as local irritation (4.2% vs. 19.8%;P < 0.05) and erythema (0.8% vs. 9.9%; P < 0.05), when comparing the nanoemulsion-containing formulation to the one without [45].
Despite their benefts, nanoemulsions have drawbacks.High concentrations of surfactant and cosurfactant are required to stabilize the nanodroplets during emulsion formation, as well as high concentrations of emulsifers.Tey typically have limited ability to solubilize highly melting compounds, and their stability is afected by temperature and pH, making them less stable under certain conditions [134].
4.8.Glucosamine, Trehalose, Ectoine, Sucralfate, Omega-9, and 4-t-Butyl Cyclohexanol Addition.To reduce the risk of irritation, it is essential to take preventative measures.Kang et al. conducted a study to examine the efcacy of a product called AF (anti-irritant formula) in reducing retinol-induced irritation.Te formulation consists of sucralose, trehalose, ectoine, glucosamine, omega-9, and 4-t-butyl cyclohexanol combined with retinol.After a genetic analysis aimed at identifying factors linked to retinol-induced irritation, retinol synthesis was performed using chemical compounds capable of regulating the molecular mechanisms behind retinol-induced pathogenesis in vitro [4].
Previous studies have shown that retinoids can alter both the structure and function of the skin barrier.Applying retinoic acid to skin tissue, in both ex vivo and in vivo settings, led to an apparent increase in transepidermal water loss (TEWL), a known manifestation of compromised skin Dermatology Research and Practice barrier function.Te efcacy of sucralfate, glucosamine, and trehalose in mitigating retinol-induced disruptions to the epidermal barrier was demonstrated by their modulation of COL6A2, AQP3, and FLG gene expression.Additionally, glucosamine and ectoine administration resulted in a decrease in IL-4R overexpression generated by mast cell activation.Te exact impact of ectoine, a compound found in certain halophilic bacteria, on IL-4R upregulation remains unclear.However, previous studies have shown its ability to modulate several cytokines and chemokines during infammatory conditions.TRPV1 activation has been associated with retinol-induced irritation in an in vitro model.Inhibiting TRPV1 with 4-t-butyl cyclohexanol and omega-9 oleic acid reduced neurogenic infammation.Te research demonstrated that retinoic acid and retinol facilitate the activation of the EGFR pathway, a crucial component in the functioning of the epidermal barrier.Additionally, excessive AQP3 production induced by retinol can be reduced with trehalose [4,135,136].Te use of trehalose in topical formulations can reduce side efects, such as skin irritation [137].
Further investigations have substantiated the efcacy of AF components in reducing skin irritation.As reported by Bissett et al., glucosamine enhances hyaluronic acid production, accelerates wound healing, improves skin hydration, and reduces the appearance of creases.Ectoine, a cyclic amino acid produced by extremophilic bacteria, improves cell membrane hydration by retaining water on the surface, thereby reducing TEWL.Omega-9 also aids in reducing TEWL, rebuilding the damaged epidermal lipid barrier, and stabilizing skin metabolism [138][139][140][141][142][143][144].Kang et al. conducted an in vivo irritation test on seven participants (three men and four women), comparing a control cream (retinol 5000 IU) with an AF-based cream with retinol 5000 IU.After three days of treatment, participants discontinued product use for four days before measuring TEWL and skin redness.Te combination of ingredients signifcantly reduced retinol-induced irritation in the human trials.Te study successfully demonstrated AF's efcacy in reducing retinol-induced irritation, specifically reducing desquamation by 66.67%, burning sensation by 68.42%, and stinging sensation by 68.97%, compared to the control retinol cream [4].
4.9.Plant Extract Addition.Te increasing popularity of plant-derived natural medicines can be attributed to their reduced incidence of adverse efects, improved patient tolerance, and cost-efectiveness.Additionally, herbal medicines ofer viable solutions for various disorders that often lack efective conventional treatments and long-term solutions [145].Several studies have investigated the impact of botanical extracts on skin health, including improving hydration, strengthening the skin barrier, and reducing irritation.
A study by Lee et al. explored the potential of the ethanol extract of Alstonia scholaris R. Br. bark in treating cutaneous irritation induced by retinoids [51].Te study demonstrated the inhibitory efects of the ethanol extract on infammation induced by all-trans-retinoic acid in human keratinocyte cells (HaCat).Te extract, known as ASE, contains a diverse range of alkaloids, favonoids, and terpenoids, including alstonidine, alstonine, chlorogenic acid, ditain, echitamine, and echitenin [146,147].Two signifcant ASE compounds known for their anti-infammatory properties are echitamine and loganin [148].Te study aimed to evaluate the efcacy of Alstonia scholaris extract in alleviating cutaneous irritation through cumulative irritation experiments on human participants.Te results showed that the emulsion containing Alstonia scholaris extract had a lower irritation score (1.95) compared to the emulsion without the extract (5.33) [9].Tis suggests that the extract, particularly echitamine and loganin, has potential as a counterirritant agent in reducing negative skin reactions caused by retinoid therapy.
Skin hydration is crucial for maintaining skin homeostasis.Alterations in hydration levels can signifcantly impact the skin's features and functions [149].Dry skin is associated with increased irritation, fakiness, mechanical failure, and other issues.Maintaining adequate moisture levels is challenging, especially in individuals with sensitive skin [150].Compromised barrier function leads to increased transepidermal water loss (TEWL), which can result in various dermatological conditions, including dry skin (xerosis), acne vulgaris, atopic dermatitis, retinoid-induced dermatitis, rosacea, and psoriasis [151].
A study by Ratz-Lyko et al. demonstrated the signifcant impact of a Centella asiatica extract-based emulsion on skin hydration and epidermal barrier function, particularly in terms of tightness [152].Te presence of carbohydrates and naturally occurring antioxidants, such as saponins, favonoids, and phenolic compounds, is believed to contribute to these efects [153].Te emulsion containing a 5% concentration of Centella asiatica extract showed signifcant improvements in skin hydration and epidermal barrier function in in vivo experiments [154].Based on these fndings, Centella asiatica may warrant further research for its role in reducing retinoid-induced skin irritation.

Encapsulation and Controlled Release Silicone
Particle.Te study conducted by Shields et al. focused on the development of silicone particles designed to encapsulate, protect, and control the release of retinol and other hydrophobic chemicals.Te particles were synthesized through the sol-gel polymerization process using silane monomers capable of efciently encapsulating retinol (>85%), providing protection against degradation.Tis encapsulation led to a signifcantly prolonged half-life of retinol, approximately nine times longer than that of nonencapsulated retinol.Additionally, the encapsulated retinol was released gradually over several hours.To assess the efcacy of the developed system in reducing retinoidinduced irritation, an in vivo experiment was conducted.Tis experiment involved applying 0.2 mL of the test formulation to an occlusive hypoallergenic patch, which was then placed on the infrascapular region of the test subject's back.Te patch was removed within a 24-hour period, 10 Dermatology Research and Practice followed by a comprehensive assessment of the skin's response.Te results from the irritation test indicated that the formulation using silicone particles exhibited lower irritation levels than the formulation incorporating microsponge particles, despite both formulations having an equivalent concentration of retinol.Specifcally, the formulation with 0.2% loaded retinol using silicone particles had a cumulative irritation score of 296.0 ± 37.6, while the microsponge particles with 2% retinol generated a cumulative score of 383.0 ± 29.55.Tese fndings suggest that a reduced rate of retinol release is associated with decreased skin irritation in human subjects [35].4.10.4.Film-Forming Sprays.Film-forming spray (FFS) is a drug delivery system that, when sprayed, forms a flm upon reaching the target therapeutic site, using polymers as a matrix for flm formation [159][160][161].FFS ofers signifcant advantages over traditional topical preparations.It provides consistent medication distribution and dosage, enhanced bioavailability, reduced incidence of irritation, sustained drug release, and accelerated wound healing through moisture control [162].After application to the skin, the composition of the flm-producing system undergoes signifcant changes due to the evaporation of volatile components, resulting in a residual flm on the skin surface.Tis process increases the drug concentration, potentially leading to supersaturation levels on the skin's surface.Supersaturation enhances drug fux through the skin by increasing the formulation's thermodynamic activity without altering the skin barrier, thereby minimizing side efects or irritation [163,164].Lu et al. investigated a metered dosage transdermal spray (MDTS) formulation for dexketoprofen (DE) transdermal administration using rats as an animal model to study skin irritability.Te fndings suggest that MDTS could be a promising and innovative therapeutic technology for transdermal drug administration, reducing skin irritation.Based on the current research with this animal model, it appears that the application does not irritate the skin.Initial skin irritation tests with the optimized formulations on rat skin did not show any redness or swelling.Furthermore, primary skin irritation studies of the improved formulations on rats revealed no evident erythema or edema [165].4.10.5.Ionto-Sonophoresis.Iontophoresis is a physical technique that uses a low-intensity electrical current to transport molecules through the skin [166].Tis technique has various biomedical applications, particularly in facilitating the delivery of drugs, including hydrophilic and/or large-sized molecules, to targeted areas [167].While iontophoresis ofers several advantages, its use can be limited by the potential for skin irritation.However, employing various enhancement strategies may reduce the need for highintensity currents to achieve therapeutically efective delivery volumes, thereby mitigating skin irritation concerns [166].
Several studies have indicated that the combination of sonophoresis and iontophoresis does not induce skin irritation [168][169][170].Using a Franz difusion cell, the synergistic efect of these techniques in the transdermal delivery of various cosmeceutical drugs has been demonstrated.Tis combined approach is benefcial as it reduces energy density and, consequently, skin irritation [168].Long Le et al. demonstrated how sonophoresis and iontophoresis could enhance heparin's transdermal penetration.When these two techniques are combined, a lower voltage or current sufces to achieve the desired transdermal enhancement, thereby reducing skin irritation [171].One proposed hypothesis suggests that the enhanced efect is primarily due to increased molecule difusivity from sonophoresis in the stratum corneum, coupled with the electro-osmotic fow of water induced by iontophoresis [172].Tis highlights the potential of iontophoresis and sonophoresis in minimizing skin irritation associated with retinoid administration.Dermatology Research and Practice 4.10.6.Hydrophase Base.Sawleshwarkar et al. investigated the efcacy and tolerability of 4% benzoyl peroxide cream formulated in a hydrophase base (Brevoxyl) for treating acne vulgaris.Te study assessed the efectiveness and acceptability of Brevoxyl ® , a 4% BP (benzoyl peroxide) cream in a hydrophase base previously available exclusively by prescription, over a six-week clinical trial.Te results indicated that the 4% BP cream was efective and well-tolerated.Only 11.6% of participants reported moderate-to-severe discomfort, and clinicians identifed side efects in 53.8% of all patients.Specifcally, 53.8% of patients reported no irritation, 41.4% reported some irritation, and only 4.8% experienced bothersome irritation.Most patients showed a very satisfactory response after six weeks and expressed eagerness to continue the treatment.A satisfactory response was observed as early as two weeks, supporting the hypothesis that the hydrophase formulation of Brevoxyl helps improve efcacy and reduce irritation associated with benzoyl peroxide use [173].
In another study, Weinberg et al. indicated that benzoyl peroxide formulated in hydrophase bases (Brevoxyl Creamy Washes and Gels) exhibits signifcant efcacy in acne treatment with less irritancy compared to other benzoyl peroxide preparations.It is believed that this product's reduced irritancy stems from its unique delivery vehicle, which includes dimethyl isosorbide that dissolves benzoyl peroxide crystals upon application to the skin [173].

Future Perspective
Based on the gathered literature, various strategies been identifed to efectively reduce the adverse efects associated with retinol application.Tese strategies ofer alternative drug release mechanisms, including controlled and sustained release, enabling gradual and regulated drug molecule release over an extended period.Tis controlled release mechanism helps minimize the likelihood of irritation from active substances with known irritant properties, such as retinoids.Additionally, these approaches can enhance the stability of retinoids within formulations and promote improved skin penetration, thereby reducing irritating efects.
Given the benefcial outcomes of advanced retinoid formulations in mitigating retinoid-induced irritation, incorporating these approaches into formulation design appears promising, considering their proven advantages in both in vivo and in vitro settings.Further research is needed to develop novel interventions aimed at reducing skin irritation caused by retinoids, thus expanding the range of available application methods.In this context, we present several methodologies designed to mitigate retinoid-induced irritation, which warrant further investigation and exploration.Numerous studies have demonstrated the efcacy of these interventions in reducing skin irritation resulting from topical and transdermal application of active compounds.
Further investigation is necessary to advance novel interventions aimed at reducing the adverse efects of retinoidinduced skin irritation, thereby expanding the available range of application methods.Based on the preceding discussion, it can be inferred that multiple drug delivery strategies have the potential to mitigate the adverse efects associated with retinoid use.Currently, the predominant technology focus is on transdermal administration rather than topical application.Tis observation may warrant consideration in future investigations related to the irritative consequences associated with retinol use.

Conclusion
Various techniques have been employed in formulation to enhance drug delivery systems, including encapsulation of retinoids, conversion of retinoids into nanoparticles, formation of complexes with cyclodextrin, and binding of retinoids with carriers, such as polymers, NLC, and SLN.Ongoing research is exploring the incorporation of elements that provide anti-irritation properties, strengthen the skin barrier, and enhance skin hydration into retinoid formulations.Tese components include glucosamine, trehalose, ectoine, sucralfate, omega-9, and 4-t-butylcyclohexanol.Additionally, an ethanolic bark extract derived from Alstonia scholaris R. Br. is also included.Te aforementioned methodologies highlight that nonlamellar liquid crystalline (NLC) and solid lipid nanoparticle (SLN) drug delivery technologies are widely employed to mitigate the irritative efects associated with retinoid administration.One could argue that the use of nanoparticle lipid carriers (NLC) ofers more advantages compared to solid lipid nanoparticles (SLN) because NLC represents an enhanced version of SLN.Te development of NLC was prompted by the need to address signifcant defciencies identifed within SLN formulations.

Figure 1 :
Figure 1: Flowchart of the search and selection process based on PRISMA guideline.
Liposomes loaded with TRE were developed using nanostructured lipid carriers (NLC) as the developed using nanoemulsion technology.Combination of adapalene and clindamycin w/w

Table 1 :
Mechanism and skin irritation test method of strategy to reduce retinoid-induced skin irritation.