Evaluating the impacts of education and digitalization on renewable energy demand behaviour: new evidence from Japan

Abstract Increasing renewable energy consumption is considered the panacea to tackle the issue of global warming and energy security. The digitalization of society can provide smart solutions for energy and environmental-related issues. Similarly, education can bring environmental awareness and encourage individuals and firms to rely more on renewable energy sources. We have tried to investigate the impact of education and digitalization on the renewable energy demand in Japan by applying the Quantile ARDL model. In the short and long run, the estimates attached to education are significantly positive almost all quantiles, which confirms that the higher the level of education in Japan, the higher the renewable energy demand. Likewise, the estimated coefficients of ICT, in both the short and long run, are positive and significant, confirming that increased digitalization help facilitate the renewable energy demand in Japan. Moreover, when we observe the Wald test, the asymmetric impact of education and digitalization are confirmed on the renewable energy demand in the short and long run.


Introduction
The survival of human society is largely dependent on energy consumption, which has a long-lasting effect on the stability and affluence of the nations (Brown et al., 1987;X. Guo et al., 2022).However, fossil fuel-based energy consumption has given rise to energy security problems, natural capital exhaustion, and environmental setbacks (Umar et al., 2022;Usman et al., 2022;Yousaf et al., 2022).The literature agrees that carbon emissions from burning fossil fuels are the primary reason behind global warming and climate change (W.Li & Ullah, 2022;Su et al., 2022).The UN agenda and (Paris Agreement 2015) have demanded that the world community reduce CO2 emissions to achieve a better environment (Lei et al., 2021).Empirics and environmentalists have presented several options to control CO2 emissions, but the most attractive solution is to increase renewable energy consumption (Akintande et al., 2020;Khribich et al., 2021).Despite all these efforts to improve the environmental quality through increasing renewable energy consumption, the actual deployment of renewable energy is still far from the target set during the Paris agreement (Su et al., 2022;Umar et al., 2021).Therefore, nations must increase renewable energy consumption as an essential part of sustainable development goals (Churchill et al., 2021;Ielasi et al., 2018;X. Ji et al., 2021).
Over the last two decades, the global energy market has witnessed a process of energy transition (Sohail et al., 2021;Yan et al., 2022), whereby many countries are trying to increase the generation of renewable energy (Y.Guo et al., 2021;Liang et al., 2022).Irrespective of the type of solar energy, such as solar, wind, and biomass, all are considered important strategic choices aimed at accomplishing sustainable economic development (Burke & Stephens, 2018;Cai & Menegaki, 2019;Khribich et al., 2021).Due to considerable policy support from all around the globe and a decline in related costs, renewable energy production is increasing globally with every passing year (Q.Ji & Zhang, 2019).Since the consumption of renewable is on the rise, the empirics have shifted their focus to investigating the factors of renewable energy (J.Wang et al., 2021).The most significant factors mentioned in the literature are macroeconomic factors such as economic growth and environmental factors (Naqvi et al., 2021;Uzar, 2020).For instance, (R. Li & Leung, 2021) have observed that renewable energy consumption is positively impacted by economic growth in the long run.However, (Usman et al., 2022) have given another view regarding it and tied the positive impact of economic growth on renewable energy demand when the economic activities are supported by renewable energy.Similarly, the erstwhile studies on the impact of environmental quality on renewable energy consumption did not provide conclusive results.Some past analyses have confirmed the positive impact of environmental degradation on renewable energy consumption (Nguyen & Kakinaka, 2019); conversely, some others confirmed the negative impact (Khan et al., 2020).
In addition, some empirics have also pointed out the significance of social factors in affecting renewable energy demand.In this regard, (Khribich et al., 2021 andZhang et al., 2021) observed that social development promotes renewable energy.Similarly, the positive role of institutional quality is validated by (Dorfleitner & Grebler, 2022;Hmaittane et al., 2019;Uzar, 2020), whereas the negative role of income inequality is confirmed by (Churchill et al., 2021).Human capital is another important factor that can facilitate the generation of renewable energy consumption (Bansal & Kumar, 2021;Yao et al., 2019).Moreover, the literature suggests that raising awareness about environmental degradation is also crucial in increasing renewable energy production, and (Akerlof, 2017) provided three reasons behind such consciousness.Firstly, intervention is required through policy instruments to modify the personal behavior policy.Secondly, the institutions that drive the policies must follow democratic nor ms.Thirdly, education can directly influence environmental awareness (Hasnaoui et al., 2021).Environmental education is an important factor that can help improve environmental quality (W.Li & Ullah, 2022).The current literature also supports that raising environmental awareness has a strong role in shaping energy policies that protect the environment (Jian et al., 2021).The main cause of low renewable energy production in developing economies include low investment in research and development activities and a lack of environmental awareness and education (Berger, 2022;Ferrat et al., 2021;Gao et al., 2021).The research and development activities are directly linked to the level of formal education (Yarovaya et al., 2021).Hence, a low education level means low research and development activities which slow down the production of renewable energy and deteriorate the environmental quality (W.Li & Ullah, 2022).
The issue of climate change has become the most daunting challenge among all goals of sustainable development in the developed and developing world (Mirza et al., 2020;Wei et al., 2022).The last two decades have been impressive for expanding information and communication technologies (ICT) in emerging economies (IEA, 2020).This has led the economies toward the path of digitalization and dematerialization.Digitalization and dematerialization are critical in helping the economies to install innovative solutions as technologies that are slowly but surely becoming part and parcel of the socio-economic structure of such economies (Chen et al., 2022;Lobato et al., 2021).In the past, some empirics observed that ICT could promote energy efficiency and help the sectors like real estate, manufacturing, and transportation reduce their reliance on primary energy consumption by providing smart solutions (Usman et al., 2021).This is an era of digitalization where ICT is used to enhance energy efficiency with the help of data propagation, observing and administration of power grids, devolution of energy generation by assimilating clean energy projects, dispersed trading, and dematerialization.
From the above discussions, we conclude that renewable energy is a panacea to environmental degradation and depleting fossil fuel resources.Education and ICT are crucial factors in promoting renewable energy consumption.However, the empirics in the past have ignored the nexus between education, digitalization, and renewable energy consumption, particularly in the context of Japan.The top pollution emitters of the world are the USA, India, China, Russia, and Japan.Japan is determined to cut GHGs emissions from 26% to 46% from 2013 to 2030.Thus, Japan has adopted a renewable energy strategy to achieve this target by 2030 as the Japanese government aims to solve its climate change problem and wants to become a carbon-neutral economy by 2050.Renewable energy consumption is increasing rapidly in Japan as an alternative energy source to fossil fuel.
Against this background, our study determines to answer the following questions.Do education and digitalization help in enhancing the renewable energy demand in Japan?Therefore, our primary objective is to estimate digitalization and education's impact on Japan's renewable energy demand.The association between digitalization and education on renewable consumption in the literature is estimated through other approaches.But in this study, we have applied the latest and extended version of the ARDL model known as the Quantile ARDL model, which can estimate the short and long-run results across various quantiles.Additionally, this is the first-ever study in Japan that considers the impact of digitalization and education at different intensities of renewable energy demand.The study's findings are valuable for policymakers, government, and educationists in understanding and evaluating how education and digitalization influence renewable energy consumption in both ways, i.e. negatively and positively.

Methodology and data
Following the standard literature of (Khan et al., 2020) and (Lv et al., 2022), we assume that the leading factors of renewable energy demand are education, the internet, GDP, and CO2.The QARDL method is used in this investigation.The QARDL approach seems more important and outperforms linear regression approaches (Cho et al., 2015).This study investigates the long-term relationship between renewable energy demand, education, internet, GDP, and CO2 across the quantile variations of the conditional distribution of various quantiles through the QARDL cointegration techniques (Shahbaz et al., 2018).Depending on these solid pieces of data, the QARDL approach is shown to be the best for explaining the nonlinear linkage between renewable energy demand, education, internet, GDP, and CO2.The simplest form looks like this: In the above Eq.( 1) e t represents the error term which is described through RED t -E [REDt/Ft À 1], where Ft À 1 is the smallest r-field prepared by (RED t-1 , Edu t , Internet t , GDP t , CO2 t , RED t-1 , Edu t-1 , Internet t-1 , GDP t-1 , CO2 t-1 }, and p and n1 … .n4signifies the lag orders of variables respectively.Moreover, from Eq. ( 1), we confer that education, Internet, GDP, and CO2. are represented by Edu t , Internet t , GDP t , CO2 t , respectively, while RED t represents renewable energy demand.Subsequent (Cho et al., 2015) studies have been presented in the format of QARDL as revealed below: Where et(s) ¼ REDt À QREDt(s/Ft À1) and QREDt(s/Ft À 1) and 0 > s < 1 denote quantile.To avoid autocorrelation, we have rewritten Eq. ( 2) into generalized form: With the help of Eq. ( 3), we can state that the possibility of a correlation between e t and DEdu t , DInternet t , DGDP t , and DCO2 t increase.Next, we have prolonged the Eq. ( 3) into the QARDL-ECM form, and revised model is revised as follows: Eq. ( 4) can derive the cumulative short-run effects through b Ã P pÀ1 j¼1 b j : Similarly, the cumulative short-run effects of Edu t , Internet t , GDP t , and CO2 t are represented by b Ã P n1À1 j¼1 b j , b Ã P n2À1 j¼1 b j , b Ã P n3À1 j¼1 b j , and b Ã P n4À1 j¼1 b j , respectively.The cointegration among the long-run variables of education, Internet, GDP, and CO2 are described with the help of a p , correspondingly.The delta technique helps measure the various parameters, such as current and previous parameters and quantile cointegrating parameters (Chao et al., 2022).Finally, the nonlinear impact of education, the Internet, GDP, and CO2 on renewable energy demand can be measured by applying the wald test.
To evaluate the effects of education and digitalization on renewable energy demand, the present study adopts four variables, i.e. renewable energy consumption (REC), education (Edu), internet users, CO2 emissions, and GDP per capita.The data handling process is based on two steps.The annual data for all variables are collected in the first step over the period 1995 to 2020 for Japan.REC is measured as % of total final energy consumption.To assemble education data series, the study adopted secondary school enrolment.Digitalization is measured from the internet users as % of the total population.The data for CO2 emissions is gathered in terms of kilotons.Finally, GDP per capita is taken at 2015 constant US$.Data series for all these variables are collected from the WDI published by the World Bank.In the second step, the annual data series are transformed into quarterly data series using the match-sum method.The technique transforms the low-frequency to high-frequency data series.

Empirical results
The descriptive statistics for all concerned variables, i.e.REC, EDU, Internet, GDP, and CO2, are given in Table 1.The descriptive analysis confirms that all the mean values are positive.The mean score for REC is 4.850, with a maximum score of 7.824 and a minimum score of 3.487.The mean EDU score is 4.639, with maximum and ECONOMIC RESEARCH-EKONOMSKA ISTRAŽIVANJA minimum scores of 4.688 and 4.595, respectively.The average internet score is 3.820, and the maximum and minimum range is 4.536 and 0.029.The mean score for GDP is 10.40, with a maximum score of 10.50 and a minimum score of 10.29.Finally, the mean score for CO2 is found to be 13.98, with maximum and minimum scores of 14. 05 and 13.88, respectively.The skewness values are positive for REC, EDU, and GDP and reported negative for the internet and CO2.The coefficients for the JB test are found to be statistically significant for all variables describing that the series is not normally distributed.These results indicate that the QARDL technique is good for this data set.Before processing the QARDL method, the study confirmed the order of data series integration properties using ADF and ZA methods.The results are illustrated in Table 2, which shows that internet and CO2 are I(0) stationary series while REC, EDU, and GDP are I(1) stationary series.Moreover, ZA detected structural breaks in the data series.It can be seen that 2019Q4 is the break period in the REC series, 1999Q1 in the EDU series, 1995Q4 in the internet series, 2010Q3 in the GDP series, and 2007Q1 in the CO2 series.
Table 3 illustrates the findings of the QARDL model, where the coefficients of the constant term, speed of adjustment, and long-run and short-run coefficient estimates are displayed.The coefficient estimates of the constant term are reported to be significant and positive at all quantiles.The coefficient estimates for speed of adjustment are also significant at all quantiles.Moreover, the negative sign associated with the speed of adjustment parameters confirms the possibility of convergence toward longterm stabilization.
The findings of the QARDL model, in the long run, portray a significant role of education and digitalization in tempting renewable energy demand in Japan.It is reported that the coefficients for EDU are found to be significantly positive at all quantiles.It describes that the increase in secondary education level enhances REC at all intensities in Japan.The studies support our finding by (Z.Wang et al., 2022), who reported a similar positive nexus between education and renewable energy demand.Findings confirm that education can help increase the renewable energy demand.The result is not surprising at all because it is clearly mentioned in the available literature that education has an important role in improving environmental quality.Education, on one side, provides a strong base for the progress of human capital; on the other, it promotes awareness about the issues of energy supply and environmental degradation.In light of the available literature, we infer that people who are not highly educated may rely more on non-renewable energy sources because they are unaware of the adverse impact of burning fossil fuels (X.Li et al., 2022;Z. Wang et al., 2022).On the other side, people with higher education levels are much more  aware of the issues related to environmental degradation and energy supply and, therefore, are inclined toward the demand for renewable energy, an environmentally friendly and sustainable energy source (Yang et al., 2017).Moreover, the long-run coefficient estimates of the internet exhibit a positive association between digitalization and renewable energy demand, as confirmed by the significantly positive estimates of the internet at all quantiles.It reveals that an increase in internet results in increasing REC at all intensities.Indeed, the role of ICT in the green transformation of society cannot be ignored.With the increased popularity of ICT, the digitalization and dematerialization of the economy have also gathered pace (Usman et al., 2021).The digitalization of the economy has significantly improved energy efficiency in many sectors and thus decreased the reliance on primary energy resources (Lv et al., 2022).Moreover, ICT penetration can speed up the process of innovations in the energy sector due to the convenience provided by the ICT in storing, process, and diffusing data and scientific knowledge.Such activities may promote the progress of clean energy technologies through research and development activities, thus positively influencing the energy demand.
The coefficient of GDP is positively related to renewable energy consumption at all intensities except 0.05 and 0.10.The results show that GDP positively impacts REC (Zhao et al., 2020), providing a similar nexus between GDP and energy demand.The study justifies this relationship as the improvement in GDP per capita over time improves the lifestyle and people, and thus their renewable energy demand increases.The result also shows that the coefficient of CO2 has a significant positive effect on REC at all quantiles.It portrays that an upsurge in CO2 emissions plays a crucial role in enhancing renewable energy demand in Japan.
In the short-run, findings portray that EDU's impact on REC is significant and positive at all quantiles except 0.05.Internet variable reports significant and positive intensification in REC at all intensities except quantiles 0.05 and 0.10.The impact of GDP on REC is found to be significantly positive at all intensities.Likewise, the impact of CO2 on REC is observed significantly positive at all intensities.In the end, in order to confirm the nonlinearity of the concerned variables on REC in Japan, the Wald test is used.The outcomes of the Wald test are given in Table 4.The findings of the Wald test infer that the null hypothesis is negated for speed of adjustment and linearity parameter, so the asymmetries of coefficients are confirmed.The Wald test findings also confirm the long-run nonlinear association among EDU, Internet, GDP, CO2, and REC; conversely, the null hypothesis is accepted for all short-run parameters except EDU.Hence, reject the asymmetric association among variables in the short-run except EDU.

Conclusion and policy recommendation
Indeed, the issue of global warming has become the most serious challenge for developing and developed economies.According to environmentalists and empirics, the combustion of fossil fuels to support anthropogenic activities all around the globe is the major cause of CO2 emissions, triggering environmental degradation.Moreover, fossil fuels are depleting throughout the world, which may halt the growth process of many economies.Increasing renewable energy consumption is considered the most significant contributor to mitigating the effects of global warming.As a result, the empirics and policymakers have started to find the factors that can promote renewable energy consumption.Digitalization of society through increased reliance on ICT can drive the economy towards dematerialization that provides smart solutions for energy related-issues.Similarly, education can bring environmental awareness and encourage individuals and firms to rely more on renewable energy sources.We have tried to investigate the impact of education and digitalization on the renewable energy demand in Japan.The empirical strategy of the analysis is based on the QARDL model.
In the short and long run, the estimates attached to education are positive almost all quantiles, which confirms that the higher the level of education in Japan, the higher the renewable energy demand.Likewise, the estimated coefficients of ICT, in the short and long run, are positive and significant, confirming that increased digitalization help facilitate the renewable energy demand in Japan.The estimates of the control variables of GDP and CO2 emissions are also positively significant, signifying the beneficial role of these two in increasing renewable energy.Moreover, when we observe the Wald test, the asymmetric impact of education, digitalization, GDP, and CO2 emissions are confirmed on the renewable energy demand in the short and long run.
We have utilized the findings of the study to provide crucial guidelines for the stakeholders.Our analysis confirmed the positive impact of digitalization on increasing renewable energy demand.Therefore, policymakers must try to enhance the role of ICT in every sector, particularly the energy sector.ICT penetration in society can help the economy to shift from physical to information resources, which will speed up the process of storing, processing, and diffusing the data and help promote research and development activities, promoting renewable energy technologies.Moreover, ICT allows people and firms to control the renewable energy system and structure from a distant place through mobiles and laptops, increasing the renewable energy demand.ICT penetration conveniently transfers and propagates the data, making observing and managing power grids very easy, thereby promoting decentralization of energy generation by integrating clean energy projects.Further, the policymakers should pay attention to increasing formal education and encourage programs and workshops related to environmental awareness that can significantly increase the renewable energy demand by making people more conscious about the determinantal impact of the environment.
Though the findings of the study are crucial, yet lack in some areas.For instance, future studies must focus on other factors of renewable energy, such as technology shocks, trade openness, financial development, etc.Moreover, the factors of renewable energy consumption must be explored for other emerging and developed economies.The present study has explored the linear impact of digitalization and education on REC using the QARDL technique.It will be more beneficial if future studies explore these determinants' asymmetric impact on Japan's renewable energy demand.A similar objective can also be tested for other economies of the world.

Disclosure statement
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.

Table 2 .
Unit root results.

Table 4 .
Results of Wald test.