Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-skm99 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-29T16:41:49.065Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Transforming Dangerous Nomads into Useful Artisans, Technicians, Agriculturists: Education in the Reza Shah Period

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2022

Rudi Matthee
Rudi Matthee*
Affiliation:
Department of History, University of Delaware
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The Reza Shah period (1921–1941) continues to be one of the most understudied as well as controversial episodes in Iran's modern history. Assessments of the period tend to be politically charged and reflect the widely diverging opinions about the extent and quality of its transformative nature. They rarely involve an appreciation of the effectiveness of the measures taken in this period in relation to stated policy objectives and allowing for the circumstances and conditions of the time—something which is quite common when it comes to evaluating, say, the reforms of Peter the Great in eighteenth-century Russia or those of Muhammad ‘Ali in nineteenth-century Egypt. Instead, they frequently narrow down to a moral verdict that weighs the entire age on a retrospective scale of Iran's historical development since the mid to late nineteenth century.

Type
Articles
Information
Iranian Studies , Volume 26 , Issue 3-4 , Summer Fall 1993 , pp. 313 - 336
Copyright
Copyright © Association For Iranian Studies, Inc 1993

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. For these two conflicting views see Hekmat, ‘Ali Asghar, Sī khāṭereh az ‘aṣr-e farkhondeh-ye Pahlavī (Tehran, 2535 Shah./1976)Google Scholar and Mahrad, Ahmad, Iran unter der Herrschaft Reza Schahs (Frankfurt a/M/New York, 1977), 16Google Scholar.

2. For the first assessment see Katouzian, Homa, The Political Economy of Modern Iran, 1926–1979 (London, 1981), 111CrossRefGoogle Scholar; for the second see Wilhelm Eilers, “Educationand Cultural Development in Iran during the Pahlavi Era,” in Lenczowski, George, ed., Iran under the Pahlavis (Stanford, 1977), 331Google Scholar.

3. Menashri, David, Education and the Making of Modern Iran (Ithaca and London, 1992), 5Google Scholar.

4. Sadiq, ‘Isa, Modern Persia and Her Educational System (New York, 1931), 40Google Scholar.

5. Banani, Amin, The Modernization of Iran, 1921–1941 (Palo Alto, 1961), 108Google Scholar.

6. Sālnāmeh-ye eḥṣā'īyeh (Statistical Yearbook) (Tehran, Ministry of Education, 1304 Sh./1925), 14.

7. Richard, Yann, “La fondation d'une armée nationale en Iran,” in Calmard, Jean, ed., Entre I'Iran et I'Occident: Adaptation et assimilation des idees et techniques occidentales en Iran (Paris, 1989), 54Google Scholar.

8. For the different views and arguments, see Menashri, Education, 116–18.

9. Sadiq, Modern Persia, 57–8Google Scholar.

10. Menashri, Education, 119Google Scholar.

11. Banani, Modernization, 95Google Scholar.

12. Unlike high schools, which charged a small monthly fee, elementary schools were free. See Arasteh, A., Education and Social Awakening in Iran, 1850–1968 (Leiden, 1968), 34, 90Google Scholar.

13. United States National Archives, Washington, D.C. (hereafter NA), M715/14 891.42/8, Murray to State Dept., March 22, 1925.

14. Sadiq, Modern Persia, 63–5Google Scholar.

15. Sadiq, ‘Isa, Tārīkh-e farhang-e Irān āz āghāz tā zamān-e ḥāżer (Tehran, 2d ed., 1338 Sh./1959), 357Google Scholar.

16. Sadiq, ‘Isa, Yādgār-e ‘omr: khāṭerātī az sar-goẕasht, 3 vols. (Tehran, 1340–53 Sh./1961–74), 2:93Google Scholar.

17. Annuaire du ministère de V instruction publique, 1935–36, 84.

18. Szyliowicz, Joseph, Education and Modernization in the Middle East (Ithaca, 1973), 177Google Scholar.

19. Elwell-Sutton, L. P., Modern Iran (London, 1944), 139Google Scholar.

20. Sadiq, Tārīkh-e farhang, 357Google Scholar.

21. Annuaire, 84.

22. Elwell-Sutton, Modern Iran, 141Google Scholar.

23. Mahludji, Mahin “Die Frauenbildung in Iran und ihr Kulturgeschichtlicher Hintergrund” (dissertation. University of Cologne, 1956), 69Google Scholar.

24. Szyliowicz, Education and Modernization, app. B, 466Google Scholar.

25. Ibid., 238–9.

26. In NA, M1202/9 891.42/64, report Engert, December 17, 1937.

27. NA, M1202/9 891.42/71, Moore to State Dept., September 24, 1938.

28. Mahludji, “Frauenbildung,” 23Google Scholar.

29. Genevieve L. Coy, “Education of Girls in Teheran: An American Woman's Impression of Persian Methods,” in The Baghdad Times, 21 Dec. 1923.

30. Mahludji, “Frauenbildung,” 50.

31. See Sālnāmeh-ye Pārs, 1929.

32. Nakhosteen, Mehdi, “The Development of Persian Education and Learning” (Ph.D. thesis, Cornell University, 1933), 373Google Scholar.

33. Journal de Téhéran, 11 January 1938.

34. Hekmat, Sī khāṭereh, 102Google Scholar.

35. Ibid.

36. Chatelet, A., “La mission lazariste en Perse,” Revue d'Histoire des Missions 13 (1936): 501Google Scholar.

37. Archives du Ministère des Affaires Etrangères, Paris (hereafter AE), Asie, Perse 65, 2.

38. Public Record Office, London (hereafter FO) 371/11485 E/560/134/34 report Loraine, December 31, 1925, pp. 211–14.

39. NA, M715/14 891.42/17, report Ferrin, March 9, 1929.

40. Ardakani, Hosayn Mahbubi, Tārīkh-e taḥavvol-e dāneshgāh-e Tehrān va mo’ assasāt-e ‘ālī-ye āmūieshī-ye Irān dar ‘aṣr-e khojasleh-ye Pahlavī (Tehran, 1350 Sh./1971), 55–6Google Scholar

41. Hekmat, Sī khāṭereh, 360Google Scholar.

42. Rāhnamā-ye dāneshgāh-e Tehrān, 1314–1315.

43. Arasteh, Education and Social Awakening, 37Google Scholar; Banani, Modernization, 100Google Scholar.

44. Elwell-Sutton, Modern Iran, 141–2Google Scholar.

45. Banani, Modernization, 99Google Scholar.

46. The term “revolution from above” derives from Trimberger, K., Revolution from Above: Military Bureaucrats and Developments in Japan, Turkey, Egypt and Peru (New Jersey, 1978)Google Scholar. The role played by political considerations in educational policy is noted by Williamson, Bill, Education and Social Change in Egypt and Turkey: A Study in Historical Sociology (London, 1987), 5CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

47. Abrahamian, Ervand, Iran between Two Revolutions (Princeton, 1982), 153Google Scholar.

48. FO 371/11504 E/5049/5049/34, report Nicholson, August 9, 1925, pp. 74–7; Sadiq, Modern Persia, 60Google Scholar.

49. Sālnāmeh-ye eḥṣā'iyeh, 1311–12 Sh./1932–33, p. 93.

50. Reza Shah's obsession with control and uniformity in educational matters is vividly illustrated in an anecdote told by Solayman Behbudi, the ruler's personal assistant. Reza Shah was so used to the tolling of the bells of the Tarbiat school, located next to the ruler's palace, that when one day he failed to hear the sound, he inquired about the reason. Being informed that the school had closed on account of the death of one of its employees, the shah angrily summoned ‘Ali Asghar Hekmat, the minister of education, and scolded him for failing to uphold a standard of uniformity by allowing one particular school to suspend its classes. See Reżā Shāh: khāṭerāt-e Solaymān Behbūdī, Shams-e Pahlavī.'Alī Izadī, ed. Gholamhosayn Mirza Saleh (Tehran, 1372 Sh./1993), 336–7.

51. NA, M1202/9 891.42/56, Honnibrook to State Dept., April 23, 1935.

52. NA, M1202/9 891.42/20, Hart to State Dept., March 6, 1931.

53. Akhavi, Shahrough, Religion and Politics in Contemporary Iran: Clergy-State Relations in the Pahlavi Period (Albany, 1980), 36Google Scholar.

54. Ibid., 51–4.

55. Sadiq, Modern Persia, 62Google Scholar.

56. Akhavi, Religion and Politics, 187Google Scholar.

57. Wilber, Donald, Reza Shah Pahlavi: The Resurrection and Reconstruction of Iran (New York, 1975), 164–5Google Scholar. For the architectural development of Tehran in this period, see Marefat, Mina, “The Protagonists Who Shaped Modern Tehran,” in Adle, C. and Hourcade, B., eds., Téhéran, capitate bicentenaire (Paris-Tehran, 1992), 95–126Google Scholar.

58. Sālnāmeh-ye Pārs, 1308 Sh./1929–30.

59. For boy-scouting in Iran, see Pazargad, B., Pīshāhangī dar Irān (Tehran, 1315 Sh./1936)Google Scholar.

60. Banani, Modernization, 106–7Google Scholar; and Hekmat, Sī khāṭereh, 83–5Google Scholar.

61. Banani, Modernization, 98Google Scholar.

62. Ibid, 89.

63. Etteḥād-e Eslām, June 30, 1924; Tabrīz, March 8, 1925.

64. FO, 371/16067 E4645/78/34, report Hoare, August 26, 1932, pp. 71–2.

65. Mahrad, Ahmad, Die Deutsch-persische Beziehungen von 1918–1933 (Frankfurt a/M, 2d ed., 1979), 447–57Google Scholar.

66. American College of Tehran Catalogue, 1931.

67. NA, Corr. Persia, 1925, vol. 136, file 360; text in Shafaq-e sorkh, 18 June 1925.

68. Sadiq, Yādgār 11:93Google Scholar.

69. See, for example, AE, Perse 63, “La Perse qui parle français,” Dr. René Roland, September 1, 1923, 89–111; ibid., M. Dayet to Poincaré, February 12, 1925, 112; ibid., letter A. Wilden, May 31, 1925, 139–40; NA, Corr. Persia, 1929, vol. 179, file 360, Treat to State Dept., January 4, 1929.

70. Sālnāmeh-ye eḥṣā'īyeh, 1304 Sh./1925, p. 29.

71. Mahrad, Iran unter der Herrschaft, 118Google Scholar.

72. Mahrad, Deutsch-persische Beziehungen, 460–62Google Scholar.

73. Sadiq, Yādgār 11:136Google Scholar.

74. NA, Persia Corr., vol. 129, letter 794, Murray, December 14, 1924; and NA, M716 711.91/7, January 6, 1925, containing an interview with Hosayn Khan ‘Ala in Shafaq-e sorkh, 21, 23, 25 December 1924.

75. See NA, Persia Corr., vol. 133, 1924, “Imbrie Records.“

76. AE, Asie, Perse, 68.

77. Sadiq, Modern Persia, 78Google Scholar.

78. FO, 371/13069; AE, Asie, Perse 68.

79. Eṭṭelā'āt, 28 September 1933.

80. NA, M1202/9 891.42/37, Hart to State Dept., April 21, 1932.

81. FO, 395/521 P2964/105, report Hoare, September 26, 1934, pp. 440–59. For similar figures for 1932, see Catrice, P., “L'lnfluence occidentale dans l'lran contemporaine,” Vie Intellectuelle 11 (1939): 260–78Google Scholar.

82. See Mahrad, Ahmad, “Lag Berlin in Persien? Iranische Oppositionelle in der Weimarer Republik,” in Kurt Greussing and Jan-Heeren Grevemeyer, eds., Revolution in Iran and Afghanistan (Frankfurt a/M, 1980), 77–121Google Scholar.

83. NA, M1202, appended to #1203.

84. Elwell-Sutton, Modem Iran, 138Google Scholar.

85. Menashri, Education, 135Google Scholar.

86. NA M1202/9 891.42/65, report Engert, January 5, 1938, end. “Progress of Education in Iran.“

87. Sadiq, Yādgār 11:95Google Scholar.

88. Szyliowicz, Education and Modernization, 239Google Scholar. Arasteh, Education and Social Awakening, 93Google Scholar, gives the figures of 25,410 for 1940–41.

89. Arasteh, Education and Social Awakening, 93Google Scholar.

90. Mahludji, “Frauenbildung,” 50Google Scholar.

91. Ibid., 66.

92. Journal de Téhéran, 25 January 1938.

93. Menashri, Education, 91Google Scholar.

94. Szyliowicz, Education and Modernization, 240, 250–52Google Scholar.

95. Ibid., 252.