Download PDF
J Wrist Surg
DOI: 10.1055/s-0043-1768235
Survey or Meta-Analysis

Comparison between Volar Locking Plate and Kirschner Wire Fixation for Unstable Distal Radius Fracture: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials

Muhammad A. Tariq 
1   Department of Surgery, Dow University Hospital, Dow University of Health Sciences, Karachi, Pakistan
,
Uzair Ali
1   Department of Surgery, Dow University Hospital, Dow University of Health Sciences, Karachi, Pakistan
,
Qazi S. Uddin
2   Department of Surgery, Dow Medical College, Dow University of Health Sciences Karachi, Pakistan
,
Zahabia Altaf
2   Department of Surgery, Dow Medical College, Dow University of Health Sciences Karachi, Pakistan
,
Ashar Mohiuddin
1   Department of Surgery, Dow University Hospital, Dow University of Health Sciences, Karachi, Pakistan
› Author Affiliations Funding None.
› Further Information
    Permissions and Reprints

Abstract

Objective This study aims to compare the outcomes of volar locking plating (VLP) versus percutaneous Kirschner wires (K-wire) fixation for surgical management of unstable distal radius fractures.

Methods We systematically searched multiple databases, including MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane Central till January 2022 for randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that met eligibility criteria. Following outcomes were evaluated at 6-week, 3-, 6-, and 12-month follow-up period: Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (DASH) score, Patient Rated Wrist Evaluation (PRWE) score, grip strength, range of motion, and complication incidence. Meta-analysis was performed using random effects models and results presented as risk ratios (RRs) or mean differences (MDs) with 95% confidence interval.

Results Fourteen RCTs with 1,450 participants met the inclusion criteria. DASH scores were significantly better for VLP fixation at 6th week (MD = 19.02; p < 0.001), 3rd (MD = 10.79; p < 0.001), 6th (MD= 7.78; p < 0.001), and 12th month (MD = 2.94; p < 0.001) postoperation. At 3-month follow-up period, VLP treatment exhibited better grip strength (MD = − 10.32; p < 0.001) and PRWE scores (MD = 8.78; p < 0.001). There was a statistically significant early advantage in flexion, extension, pronation, supination, radial deviation, and ulnar deviation in the VLP group at 6-week follow-up, but at 1-year follow-up only significantly better extension was observed. At 1 year, radiographic outcomes were similar except for volar tilt favoring VLP fixation (p < 0.001). Superficial infections were more common in patients treated with K-wire (RR = 2.89; p = 0.001), but there was no difference in total complications or reoperation rates (p > 0.05).

Conclusion This meta-analysis suggests that VLP fixation and K-wire fixation are both effective procedures, but existing literature does not provide sufficient evidence to demonstrate the superiority of either method. Although VLP fixation improves DASH score, extension and volar tilt at 12-month follow-up, the difference is small and unlikely to be noticeable to the patients.

Keywords

distal radius fracture - Kirschner wire - meta-analysis - volar locking plating

Ethics Approval

Ethical approval was not required as this study only contains data extracted from previous studies that are available online.


Consent to Participate

Not applicable for a systematic review.


Consent for Publication

Not applicable for a systematic review.


Availability of data and materials

Not applicable.


Authors' Contributions

M.A.T. and U.A. conceived and designed the study. Q.S.U., Z.A., and U.A. were involved in data collection and data processing. M.A.T. and A.M. performed data analysis. Q.S.U. and A.M. drafted the initial manuscript. M.A.T., U.A., and Z.A. critically revised the manuscript. All of the authors approved the final manuscript.




Publication History

Received: 05 January 2023

Accepted: 06 March 2023

Article published online:
14 April 2023

© 2023. Thieme. All rights reserved.

Thieme Medical Publishers, Inc.
333 Seventh Avenue, 18th Floor, New York, NY 10001, USA

 

  • References

  • 1 Meena S, Sharma P, Sambharia AK, Dawar A. Fractures of distal radius: an overview. J Family Med Prim Care 2014; 3 (04) 325-332
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 2 Olech J, Ciszewski M, Morasiewicz P. Epidemiology of distal radius fractures in children and adults during the COVID-19 pandemic - a two-center study. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 2021; 22 (01) 306
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 3 Nellans KW, Kowalski E, Chung KC. The epidemiology of distal radius fractures. Hand Clin 2012; 28 (02) 113-125
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 4 Dario P, Matteo G, Carolina C. et al. Is it really necessary to restore radial anatomic parameters after distal radius fractures?. Injury 2014; 45 (Suppl 6): S21-S26
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 5 Diaz-Garcia RJ, Oda T, Shauver MJ, Chung KC. A systematic review of outcomes and complications of treating unstable distal radius fractures in the elderly. J Hand Surg Am 2011; 36 (05) 824-35 .e2
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 6 Bohl DD, Lese AB, Patterson JT, Grauer JN, Dodds SD. Routine imaging after operatively repaired distal radius and scaphoid fractures: a survey of hand surgeons. J Wrist Surg 2014; 3 (04) 239-244
    Article in Thieme ConnectPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 7 Arora R, Gabl M, Erhart S, Schmidle G, Dallapozza C, Lutz M. Aspects of current management of distal radius fractures in the elderly individuals. Geriatr Orthop Surg Rehabil 2011; 2 (5-6): 187-194
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 8 Armstrong KA, von Schroeder HP, Baxter NN, Zhong T, Huang A, McCabe SJ. Stable rates of operative treatment of distal radius fractures in Ontario, Canada: a population-based retrospective cohort study (2004–2013). Can J Surg 2019; 62 (06) 386-392
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 9 Wilcke MK, Hammarberg H, Adolphson PY. Epidemiology and changed surgical treatment methods for fractures of the distal radius: a registry analysis of 42,583 patients in Stockholm County, Sweden, 2004–2010. Acta Orthop 2013; 84 (03) 292-296
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 10 Fanuele J, Koval KJ, Lurie J, Zhou W, Tosteson A, Ring D. Distal radial fracture treatment: what you get may depend on your age and address. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2009; 91 (06) 1313-1319
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 11 Gottschalk MB, Wagner ER. Kirschner wire fixation of distal radius fractures, indication, technique and outcomes. Hand Clin 2021; 37 (02) 247-258
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 12 Wilson J, Viner JJ, Johal KS, Woodruff MJ. Volar locking plate fixations for displaced distal radius fractures: an evaluation of complications and radiographic outcomes. Hand (N Y) 2018; 13 (04) 466-472
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 13 Stahl S, Schwartz O. Complications of K-wire fixation of fractures and dislocations in the hand and wrist. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 2001; 121 (09) 527-530
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 14 Egol K, Walsh M, Tejwani N, McLaurin T, Wynn C, Paksima N. Bridging external fixation and supplementary Kirschner-wire fixation versus volar locked plating for unstable fractures of the distal radius: a randomised, prospective trial. J Bone Joint Surg Br 2008; 90 (09) 1214-1221
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 15 Wei DH, Raizman NM, Bottino CJ, Jobin CM, Strauch RJ, Rosenwasser MP. Unstable distal radial fractures treated with external fixation, a radial column plate, or a volar plate. A prospective randomized trial. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2009; 91 (07) 1568-1577
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 16 Rozental TD, Blazar PE, Franko OI, Chacko AT, Earp BE, Day CS. Functional outcomes for unstable distal radial fractures treated with open reduction and internal fixation or closed reduction and percutaneous fixation. A prospective randomized trial. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2009; 91 (08) 1837-1846
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 17 Peng F, Liu YX, Wan ZY. Percutaneous pinning versus volar locking plate internal fixation for unstable distal radius fractures: a meta-analysis. J Hand Surg Eur Vol 2018; 43 (02) 158-167
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 18 Zong SL, Kan SL, Su LX, Wang B. Meta-analysis for dorsally displaced distal radius fracture fixation: volar locking plate versus percutaneous Kirschner wires. J Orthop Surg Res 2015; 10: 108
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 19 Chaudhry H, Kleinlugtenbelt YV, Mundi R, Ristevski B, Goslings JC, Bhandari M. Are volar locking plates superior to percutaneous K-wires for distal radius fractures? A meta-analysis. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2015; 473 (09) 3017-3027
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 20 Youlden DJ, Sundaraj K, Smithers C. Volar locking plating versus percutaneous Kirschner wires for distal radius fractures in an adult population: a meta-analysis. ANZ J Surg 2019; 89 (7-8): 821-826
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 21 Kamal RN, Shapiro LM. Practical application of the 2020 Distal Radius Fracture AAOS/ASSH Clinical Practice Guideline: a clinical case. J Am Acad Orthop Surg 2022; 30 (09) e714-e720
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 22 Page MJ, McKenzie JE, Bossuyt PM. et al. The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ 2021; 372 (71) n71
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 23 Higgins JP, Altman DG, Gøtzsche PC. et al; Cochrane Bias Methods Group, ; Cochrane Statistical Methods Group. The Cochrane collaboration's tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials. BMJ 2011; 343: d5928
    Google Scholar
  • 24 McGrath S, Zhao X, Steele R, Thombs BD, Benedetti A. DEPRESsion Screening Data (DEPRESSD) Collaboration. Estimating the sample mean and standard deviation from commonly reported quantiles in meta-analysis. Stat Methods Med Res 2020; 29 (09) 2520-2537
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 25 Brown HK, Kempton RA. The application of REML in clinical trials. Stat Med 1994; 13 (16) 1601-1617
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 26 Marcheix PS, Dotzis A, Benkö PE, Siegler J, Arnaud JP, Charissoux JL. Extension fractures of the distal radius in patients older than 50: a prospective randomized study comparing fixation using mixed pins or a palmar fixed-angle plate. J Hand Surg Eur Vol 2010; 35 (08) 646-651
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 27 Hollevoet N, Vanhoutie T, Vanhove W, Verdonk R. Percutaneous K-wire fixation versus palmar plating with locking screws for Colles' fractures. Acta Orthop Belg 2011; 77 (02) 180-187
    PubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 28 McFadyen I, Field J, McCann P, Ward J, Nicol S, Curwen C. Should unstable extra-articular distal radial fractures be treated with fixed-angle volar-locked plates or percutaneous Kirschner wires? A prospective randomised controlled trial. Injury 2011; 42 (02) 162-166
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 29 Karantana A, Downing ND, Forward DP. et al. Surgical treatment of distal radial fractures with a volar locking plate versus conventional percutaneous methods: a randomized controlled trial. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2013; 95 (19) 1737-1744
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 30 Bahari-Kashani M, Taraz-Jamshidy MH, Rahimi H. et al. Outcomes of pin and plaster versus locking plate in distal radius intraarticular fractures. Trauma Mon 2013; 17 (04) 380-385
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 31 Costa ML, Achten J, Parsons NR. et al; DRAFFT Study Group. Percutaneous fixation with Kirschner wires versus volar locking plate fixation in adults with dorsally displaced fracture of distal radius: randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2014; 349: g4807
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 32 Goehre F, Otto W, Schwan S, Mendel T, Vergroesen PP, Lindemann-Sperfeld L. Comparison of palmar fixed-angle plate fixation with K-wire fixation of distal radius fractures (AO A2, A3, C1) in elderly patients. J Hand Surg Eur Vol 2014; 39 (03) 249-257
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 33 Manrique J, Mosquera SA, Huérfano E, Rodríguez CA, Ford E, García LA. Fijación percutánea frente a fijación interna con placa bloqueada: resultados postoperatorios de fracturas conminutas de la metáfisis distal del radio. Experimento clínico de distribución aleatoria y controlado. Rev Colomb Ortop Traumatol 2017; 31 (03) 114-119
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 34 Chung KC, Malay S, Shauver MJ, Kim HM. WRIST Group. Assessment of distal radius fracture complications among adults 60 years or older: a secondary analysis of the WRIST randomized clinical trial. JAMA Netw Open 2019; 2 (01) e187053
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 35 Khan NU, Khan AQ, Jameel M, Yaqoob HM, Khan Z, Bajwa MA. Functional outcome with Kirschner wire fixation versus volar locking plate fixation for management of patients with dorsally displaced fractures of distal radius. Rawal Med J 2020; 45 (01) 107-110
    PubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 36 Mishra RK, Sharma BP, Kumar A, Sherawat R. A comparative study of variable angle volar plate and bridging external fixator with K-wire augmentation in comminuted distal radius fractures. Chin J Traumatol 2021; 24 (05) 301-305
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 37 Sorensen AA, Howard D, Tan WH, Ketchersid J, Calfee RP. Minimal clinically important differences of 3 patient-rated outcomes instruments. J Hand Surg Am 2013; 38 (04) 641-649
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 38 Angst F, Schwyzer HK, Aeschlimann A, Simmen BR, Goldhahn J. Measures of adult shoulder function: Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand Questionnaire (DASH) and its short version (QuickDASH), Shoulder Pain and Disability Index (SPADI), American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES) Society standardized shoulder assessment form, Constant (Murley) Score (CS), Simple Shoulder Test (SST), Oxford Shoulder Score (OSS), Shoulder Disability Questionnaire (SDQ), and Western Ontario Shoulder Instability Index (WOSI). Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken) 2011; 63 (Suppl 11): S174-S188
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 39 Kim JK, Park MG, Shin SJ. What is the minimum clinically important difference in grip strength?. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2014; 472 (08) 2536-2541
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 40 Jensen J, Rasmussen BS, Duus LA. et al. Distal radius fractures and radiographic assessment: a systematic review of measurement accuracy. Acta Radiol 2019; 60 (11) 1482-1489
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 41 Plant CE, Parsons NR, Costa ML. Do radiological and functional outcomes correlate for fractures of the distal radius?. Bone Joint J 2017; 99-B (03) 376-382
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 42 Levin SM, Nelson CO, Botts JD, Teplitz GA, Kwon Y, Serra-Hsu F. Biomechanical evaluation of volar locking plates for distal radius fractures. Hand (N Y) 2008; 3 (01) 55-60
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 43 Sobky K, Baldini T, Thomas K, Bach J, Williams A, Wolf JM. Biomechanical comparison of different volar fracture fixation plates for distal radius fractures. Hand (N Y) 2008; 3 (02) 96-101
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 44 Quadlbauer S, Pezzei C, Jurkowitsch J. et al. Early rehabilitation of distal radius fractures stabilized by volar locking plate: a prospective randomized pilot study. J Wrist Surg 2017; 6 (02) 102-112
    PubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 45 Brehmer JL, Husband JB. Accelerated rehabilitation compared with a standard protocol after distal radial fractures treated with volar open reduction and internal fixation: a prospective, randomized, controlled study. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2014; 96 (19) 1621-1630
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 46 Tubeuf S, Yu G, Achten J. et al. Cost effectiveness of treatment with percutaneous Kirschner wires versus volar locking plate for adult patients with a dorsally displaced fracture of the distal radius: analysis from the DRAFFT trial. Bone Joint J 2015; 97-B (08) 1082-1089
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 47 Saving J, Heintz E, Pettersson H, Enocson A, Mellstrand Navarro C. Volar locking plate versus external fixation for unstable dorsally displaced distal radius fractures-A 3-year cost-utility analysis. PLoS One 2020; 15 (10) e0240377
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 48 Wilson CD, Probe RA. Shared decision-making in orthopaedic surgery. J Am Acad Orthop Surg 2020; 28 (23) e1032-e1041
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 49 Franceschi F, Franceschetti E, Paciotti M, Cancilleri F, Maffulli N, Denaro V. Volar locking plates versus K-wire/pin fixation for the treatment of distal radial fractures: a systematic review and quantitative synthesis. Br Med Bull 2015; 115 (01) 91-110
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar