World Kidney ForumOrgan Trafficking: Global Solutions for a Global Problem
Section snippets
Background
With an increase in cardiometabolic diseases and aging populations worldwide, the burden of kidney disease also is increasing, posing unique social and ethical challenges in a rapidly globalizing world.7, 8, 9, 10 The number of patients with ESKF, ie, those requiring maintenance dialysis therapy or transplant, in the United States nearly doubled during the 1990s, increasing from 196,000 in 1991 to 382,000 in 2000. A recent US Renal Data System projection of the growth of the ESKF population
Legislation and Regulations
Major steps toward establishing a sound and ethical system of availability of organs were initiated by enactment of the Uniform Anatomical Gift Act in 1968 in the United States.24 This law details the rights of individuals to designate their organs for donation after their death and also the conditions under which living donor transplant is permissible. Further advances were made in 1984 by the National Organ Transplant Act, which established the nationwide computer registry operated by the
Unregulated Kidney Trade and Transplant Tourism
Based on a survey of 98 countries that represent more than 5.4 billion people (82% of the world's population), the WHO estimated that 10% of all global kidney transplants in 2004 were in patients from developed countries who traveled to economically challenged nations to buy organs (Fig 2).40
The ease of access to such services advertised in package deals of $15,000-$150,000 has been particularly attractive, and countries such as Pakistan, India, and Turkey have acquired the unsavory reputation
Regulated Compensated Kidney Transplantation
To address the concern of the short supply of kidneys to meet the national demand of patients with ESKF, a regulated system of living unrelated paid donor kidney transplantation was legally adopted in Iran in 1988.57 In this system, all potential donors are registered by the government and undergo a rigorous process of informed consent and donor evaluation. No brokers are involved in the state-run program, which offers a fixed amount of US $1,200 to the donor, along with posttransplant care.
Efforts to Curb Transplant Tourism
Because of deep concerns with the gross exploitation of the vulnerable associated with profit-driven organ trade, the World Health Assembly issued a resolution in 2004 for all WHO member states to prohibit transplant tourism.71 It also called for international cooperation in the formulation of organ procurement guidelines on suitability, safety, and ethics and the establishment of national oversight committees to ensure implementation.
Although countries have attempted to adhere to the
Declaration of Istanbul on Organ Trafficking and Transplant Tourism
The most recent Declaration of Istanbul on Organ Trafficking and Transplant Tourism strictly condemns all forms of organ trade that exploit the poor, regardless of whether from within their own countries or abroad.81 This declaration, which builds on the principles of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, was passed in April 2008 at the Summit in Istanbul, Turkey, convened by the Transplantation Society and International Society of Nephrology. The declaration states that all forms of
Other Successful Efforts to Enhance the Kidney Donor Pool
The nexus that supports kidney trade is powerful, fueled by the lure created by the limited supply of kidneys in the face of increasing demands in rich countries. Therefore, measures to enhance the donor pool in well-resourced countries to meet their own needs will act as a strong deterrent to the proliferation of unregulated transplant enterprise in impoverished nations. Results of initiatives to increase the legal donor pool, such as the Organ Donation Breakthrough Collaborative, which
The Way Forward
It is obvious that in addition to guidelines and declarations, multipronged concerted efforts are needed at the national, regional, and global levels to address illegal kidney trade and transplant tourism within and across borders. For a global approach, there are lessons to be learned from countries that have shown success with innovative models and initiatives of regulated cadaveric and living donations. The following efforts are likely to yield fruitful results.
Acknowledgements
I would like to thank my distinguished colleagues who encouraged me to write on the subject and shared their valuable thoughts on it with me.
Financial Disclosure: None.
References (92)
- et al.
Chronic kidney disease as a global public health problem: approaches and initiatives—a position statement from Kidney Disease: Improving Global Outcomes
Kidney Int.
(2007) - et al.
Effect of waiting time on renal transplant outcome
Kidney Int.
(2000) - et al.
Current arrangement and activity of organ transplantation after new organ transplant legislation in Japan
Transplant Proc.
(2000) Keeping an eye on the global traffic in human organs
Lancet
(2003)- et al.
Living paid organ transplantation results in unacceptably high recipient morbidity and mortality
Transplant Proc.
(2005) - et al.
Psychosocial health of living kidney donors: a systematic review
Am J Transplant.
(2006) Paid organ procurement: pragmatic and ethical viewpoints
Transplant Proc.
(2004)Notes on the new Israeli organ donation law-2008
Transplant Proc.
(2008)- et al.
Payment for living donor (vendor) kidneys: a cost-effectiveness analysis
Am J Transplant.
(2004) - et al.
Incentive models to increase living kidney donation: encouraging without coercing
Am J Transplant.
(2005)
How to improve organ donation: results of the ISHLT/FACT poll
J Heart Lung Transplant.
China introduces new rules to deter human organ trade
Lancet
Transplants in foreign countries among patients removed from the US transplant waiting list
Am J Transplant.
Checklist: passport, plane ticket, organ transplant
Am J Transplant.
Will transplant tourism erode the surgical skills of transplant surgeons in Israel?
Am J Transplant.
Organ donation and utilization in the United States, 1996-2005
Am J Transplant.
The impact of presumed consent legislation on cadaveric organ donation: a cross-country study
J Health Econ.
What is the system failure?
Kidney Int.
Early detection of kidney disease in community settings: the Kidney Early Evaluation Program (KEEP)
Am J Kidney Dis.
Kidney thefts shocks India
The New York Times
Trends in unrelated-donor kidney transplantation in the developing world
Pediatr Nephrol.
Beijing investigates transplants for tourists
The New York Times
Larry's Kidney
Not just urban legend
Newsweek
Organ transplantsThe gap between supply and demand
The Economist
Chronic kidney disease: the global challenge
Lancet
Prevalence of chronic kidney disease in the United States
JAMA
The growing burden of chronic kidney disease in Pakistan
N Engl J Med.
Projecting the number of patients with end-stage renal disease in the United States to the year 2015
J Am Soc Nephrol.
USRDS 2006 Annual Data Report
End-stage renal disease in the United States: an update from the United States Renal Data System
J Am Soc Nephrol.
Comparison of mortality in all patients on dialysis, patients on dialysis awaiting transplantation, and recipients of a first cadaveric transplant
N Engl J Med.
Survival improvement among patients with end-stage renal disease: trends over time for transplant recipients and wait-listed patients
J Am Soc Nephrol.
The case for a regulated system of living kidney sales
Nat Clin Pract Nephrol.
Long-term outcome of renal transplantation from older donors
N Engl J Med.
USRDS 2008 Annual Data Report
Transplants save lives
Number of UK patients awaiting a transplant reaches record high
BMJ
Presumed consent for organ donation in the United Kingdom
J Intensive Care Soc.
The impact of transplantation on survival with kidney failure
Clin Transpl.
The uniform anatomical gift actA model for reform
JAMA
The United States Revised Uniform Anatomical Gift Act (2006): new challenges to balancing patient rights and physician responsibilities
Philos Ethics Humanit Med.
Uniform Anatomical Gift Act (UAGA)
Social Security Amendments of 1972: summary and legislative history. In-depth research: legislative history, social security online
Cited by (43)
Ethical Decisions in Transplantation
2015, Transplantation of the Liver: Third EditionAssessing the Potential Impact of the Declaration of Istanbul 2008 on Internet Reporting of Human Organ Transplantation-Related Crimes Using Interrupted Time Series Analysis and Meta-Analysis Approaches
2020, Transplantation ProceedingsCitation Excerpt :The kidney waiting list has been eliminated in Iran, 1 of the several nations, including Australia and Singapore, that have instituted some levels of state-sponsored structures for compensating for organ donation [37,38]. The present report and many others [7,8,39–41] have indicated that the current laws and the prevalent system are insufficient to meet the donor organ demand and unable to prevent the illegal and immoral activities related to organ transplantation. Many developing nations may not have the resources to combat transplantation-related crimes [9].
Social network analysis of illicit organ trading networks: The Medicus case
2023, Trends in Organized CrimeGlobal Practices and Policies of Organ Transplantation and Organ Trafficking
2022, Experimental and Clinical TransplantationPaediatric kidney transplantation in under-resourced regions—a panoramic view
2022, Pediatric NephrologyOrgan donation in turkey: The knowledge, approaches and opinions of family physicians
2021, Iranian Journal of Public Health
Originally published online as doi:10.1053/j.ajkd.2009.08.014 on November 2, 2009.