Abstract
Theorists such as Gumport (2000) suggest thatdifferent conceptions of higher education mayhave important consequences for students andsociety. We explore this possibility byconsidering a specific research question: Dostudents who attend for-profit post-secondaryschools show lower levels of civic engagementthan students who attend non-profit communitycolleges, either at the beginning of theirstudy or two years later?
Using longitudinal data from the U.S. NationalCenter for Education Statistics (NCES)National Post-secondary Student Aid Survey(NPSAS90) and Beginning Post-secondary Survey(BPS), we test the hypothesis that students whoattend for-profit, post-secondary vocationalschools will show lower levels of civicengagement on several measures than similarstudents in community colleges. Studentsattending the two types of schools are alike intheir levels of civic engagement at thebeginning of their post-secondary education,but different four years later. We considerwhether observed differences in civic behaviorare due to variations in who attends thedifferent types of schools or to identifiableexperiences students may have in theirprograms, such as interactions with faculty orother students.
The effect of proprietary school attendance onseven out of the ten different types of civicengagement measured here appears to be direct,rather than being mediated by measurableeducational experiences. We reflect further onprocesses that might explain the differencesand consider the policy implications of thesefindings for educational decision-makers.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Apling, R.N. (1993). 'Proprietary schools and their students', Journal of Higher Education 64(4), 379–416.
Arendt, H. (1959). The Human Condition. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday.
Astin, A.W. (1993). What Matters in College: Four Critical Years Revisited. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Baer, D., Curtis, J. and Graab, E. (2000). 'Has voluntary association activity declined? A cross-national perspective'. Presented at the American Sociological Association annual meeting, Washington, DC, August.
Buer, J. (1995). 'Pedagogical freedom, professional satisfaction, and job-related stress-Analysis of everyday instructional behavior of teachers at commercial schools in the New Laender', Zeitschrift fur Padagogik 41(4), 555–577.
Brint, S. and Karabel, J. (1989). The Diverted Dream: Community Colleges and the Promise of Educational Opportunity in America, 1900-1985. New York: Oxford University Press.
Deth, J.W.V. (ed.) (1997). Private Groups and Public Life: Social Participation, Voluntary Associations and Political Involvement in Representative Democracies. London: Routledge.
Dey, E.L. (1997). 'Undergraduate political attitudes: Peer influences in changing social contexts', Journal of Higher Education 68(4), 398–413.
Dey, E.L. (1996). 'Undergraduate political attitudes: An examination of peer, faculty, and social influences', Research in Higher Education 37(5), 535–554.
Eberly, D.E. (1998). America's Promise: Civil Society and the Renewal of American Culture. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield.
Ehrlich, T. (1997). 'Civic learning: 'Democracy and Education' revisited', Educational Record 78, 56–65.
Eyler, J. and Giles, Jr., D.E. (1998). Where's the Learning in Service Learning. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Feldman, K.A. and Newcomb, T.M. (1969). The Impact of College on Students. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Fitzsimons, P. (1997). 'The conditions of teachers in private training establishments in New Zealand', Journal of Education and Work 10(2), 169–186.
Fukuyama, F. (1995). Trust: The Social Virtues and the Creation of Prosperity. New York: Free Press.
Grubb, W.N. (1993a). 'The long run effects of proprietary schools on wages and earnings: Implications for federal policy', Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis 15, 17–33.
Grubb, W.N. (1993b). 'The varied economic returns to postsecondary education: New evidence from the class of 1972', The Journal of Human Resources XXVII (2), 365–382.
Grubb, W.N. and Tuma, J. (1991). 'Who gets student aid? Variations in access to aid', The Review of Higher Education 14(3), 358–382.
Gumport, P.J. (2000). 'Academic restructuring: Organizational change and institutional imperatives', Higher Education: The International Journal of Higher Education and Educational Planning 39, 67–91.
Gumport, P.J. and Pusser, B. (1999). 'University restructuring: The role of economic and political contexts', in Smart, J. (ed.), Higher Education: Handbook of Theory and Research, Volume XIV. Bronx, NY: Agathon Press, pp. 146–200.
Gumport, P.J. and Sporn, B. (1999). 'Institutional adaptation: Demands for management reform and university administration', in Smart, J. (ed.), Higher Education: Handbook of Theory and Research, Volume XIV. Bronx, NY: Agathon Press, pp. 103–145.
Harnisch, D.L. (1994). 'Supplemental education in Japan: Juku schooling and its implication', Journal of Curriculum Studies 26(3), 323–334.
Hyman, H.H. and Wright, C.R. (1978). Education's Lasting Influence on Values. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Hyman, H.H., Wright, C.R. and Reed, J.S. (1975). The Enduring Effects of Education. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Jackson, G.A. (1978). 'Financial aid and student enrollment', Journal of Higher Education 49(6), 548–574.
Janoski, T., Musick, M. and Wilson, J. (1998). 'Being volunteered? The impact of social participation and pro-social attitudes on volunteering', Sociological Forum 13(3), 495–519.
Karmokolias, Y. and Maas, J.L. (1997). 'The business of education: A look at Kenya's private education sector'. Report. Washington, DC: International Finance Corp. ERIC document 418464.
Kraatz, M.S. and Zajac, E.J. (1996). 'Exploring the limits of the new institutionalism: The causes and consequences of illegitimate organizational change', American Sociological Review 61 (October), 812–836.
Ladd, E.C. (1999). The Ladd Report: Startling New Research Shows How an Explosion of Voluntary Groups, Activities, and Charitable Donations is Transforming Our Towns and Cities. New York: Free Press.
Lewis, D.R., Hearn, J.C. and Zilbert, E.E. (1993). 'Efficiency and equity effects of vocationally focused postsecondary education', Sociology of Education 66(3), 188–205.
Lundberg, D. (1994). 'Calling the tune. Market responsive vocational education: A discussion paper'. Report. Leabrook, South Australia: National Centre for Vocational Education Research. ERIC document 380541.
Merisotis, J.P., Phipps, R.A. and Harrison, K.V. (n.d.). Unpublished paper, Washington, DC: The Institute for Higher Education Policy.
Mills, V. (1977). 'From school to work: The experience of Bell and Howell schools in matching graduates to careers'. Unpublished paper prepared for a conference on Labor Market Intermediaries sponsored by the National Commission for Manpower Policy, Washington, DC (November).
Moore, R.W. (1986). Private Training and Public Goals: A Study of New York Proprietary Schools. Report. Santa Monica, CA: Training Research Corporation.
Moore, R.W. and Smith, E.J. (1992). Measuring Outcomes: A Follow-up of Minnesota Private Career School Students. Report. Minneapolis, MN: Minnesota Association of Private Proprietary Schools, Training Research Corporation, and the Minnesota Higher Education Coordinating Board. ERIC document 351554.
Moser, R., Kenny, R.A. Jr. and Garrod, A. (1994). Preparing for Citizenship: Teaching Youth to Live Democratically. Westport, CT: Praeger.
National Center for Education Statistics (1992a). Students at Less than 4 Year institutions: Contractor Report. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Education.
National Center for Education Statistics (1992b). Methodology Report for the 1990 National Postsecondary Student Aid Study. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Education.
National Center for Education Statistics (1993a). Profile of Undergraduates in U.S. Postsecondary Education Institutions: 1989-90. Contractor report. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Education.
National Center for Education Statistics (1993b). Financing Undergraduate Education: 1990. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Education.
National Center for Education Statistics (1995). Student Financing of Undergraduate Education: 1992-1993. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Education.
Nie, N.H., Junn, J. and Stehlik-Barry, K. (1996). Education and Democratic Citizenship in America. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Niemi, R.G. and Junn, J. (1998). Civic Education: What Makes Students Learn. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Pascarella, E.T., Ephington, C.A. and Smart, J.C. (1988). 'The influence of college on humanitarian/civic involvement values', Journal of Higher Education 59(4), 412–437.
Pascarella, E.T. and Terenzini, P.T. (1991). How College Affects Students. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Patrick, J.J. (1998). 'Education for constructive engagement of citizens in democratic civil society and constitutional government'. Report. International Conference on Citizenship in Twenty-First Century Democracies, Valley Forge, PA, October 4-9. ERIC Document 428991.
Persell, C.H., Green, A. and Gurevich, L. (2001). 'Civil society, economic distress, and social tolerance', Sociological Forum 16(2), 203–230.
Portland State University (1997). Assessing the Impact of Service Learning: A Workbook of Strategies and Methods. Report. Portland, OR: Portland State University.
Putnam, R.D.(1995a). 'Bowling alone: Democracy in America at the end of the twentieth century'. Nobel Symposium, Uppsala, Sweden, August 27-30, 1994.
Putnam, R.D. (1995b). 'Tuning in, tuning out: The strange disappearance of social capital in America', PS: Political Science & Politics (December), 664-683.
Putnam, R.D. (2000). Bowling Alone. New York: Simon & Schuster.
Robinson, G. and Barnett, L. (1996). 'Service learning and community colleges: Where we are', AACC Survey Report. Washington, DC: American Association of Community Colleges. ERIC Document 394612.
Saguaro Seminar (2001). 'Better together', Vol. 2001: Saguaro Seminar: Civic Engagement in America. http://www.ksg.harvard.edu/saguaro (Last accessed January 2, 2001).
St. John, E.P. (1991). 'The impact of student financial aid: A review of recent research', Journal of Student Financial Aid 21, 18–30.
St. John, E.P. and Noell, J. (1989). 'The impact of student aid on access: Analysis of progress with special consideration of minority access', Research in Higher Education 30(6), 563–581.
St. John, E.P., Starkey, J.B., Paulsen, M.B. and Mbaduagha, L.A. (1995). 'The influence of prices and price subsidies on within-year persistence by students in proprietary schools', Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis 17(2), 149–165.
Salganik, L.H. and Hopper, P.A. (1990). 'Who attends proprietary schools? Findings from NPSAS'. Washington, D.C.: Unpublished manuscript.
Schine, J. and Halsted, A. (1997). 'Alienation or engagement? Service learning may be an answer', in Totten, S. and Pedersen, J.E. (eds.), Social Issues and Service at the Middle School Level. Boston: Allyn and Bacon, pp. 195–210.
Schudson, M. (1998). The Good Citizen: A History of American Civic Life. New York: The Free Press.
Schudson, M. (1996). 'What if civic life didn't die?' American Prospect 25, 17–20.
Skocpol, T. (2000). 'From membership to advocacy: Civic engagement in American democracy'. Keynote address, ninth annual graduate student conference, Sociology Department, New York University, March 25.
Stevens, M. (2003). Personal communication (April 16).
U.S. Department of Education (1992). Information on the FY1990 Default Rate, Enclosure B. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Education.
U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics (1997). Digest of Education Statistics, 1997, NCES 98-015, in Snyder, T.D. (ed.), Hoffman, C.M., Production Manager; Geddes, C.M., Program Analyst. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
Verba, S., Schlozman, K.L. and Brady, H.E. (1997). 'The big tilt: Participatory inequality in America', The American Prospect (May-June), 74-80.
Verba, S., Schlozman, K.L. and Brady, H.E. (1995). Voice and Equality. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Weil, F.D. (1985). 'The variable effects of education on liberal attitudes: A comparative-historical analysis of anti-Semitism using public opinion survey data', American Sociological Review 50, 458–474.
Wellman, J.V. (1999). Contributing to the Civic Good: Assessing and Accounting for the Civic Contributions of Higher Education. Report. Washington, D.C.: The Institute for Higher Education Policy.
Westheimer, J. and Kahne, J. (1998). 'What kind of citizen? The politics of educating for democracy', in Ayers, W. (ed.), Teaching for Social Justice: A Democracy and Education Reader. New York: New Press/Teachers College Press, pp. 1–20.
Wuthnow, R. (1998). 'Inequality and civic involvement'. Presented at the American Sociological Association annual meeting, San Francisco, CA.
Youniss, J. and Yates, M. (1997). Community Service and Social Responsibility in Youth. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Persell, C.H., Wenglinsky, H. For-profit post-secondary education and civic engagement. Higher Education 47, 337–359 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1023/B:HIGH.0000016436.45792.00
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/B:HIGH.0000016436.45792.00