Abstract
Objective. This study compared psychiatric diagnoses ascertained by independent clinicians with structured research interviews of homeless psychiatric patients assessed in a mental health clinic and in the community. Problems of both over-diagnosis and underdiagnosis in structured research interviews compared to clinician assessment were predicted. Method. Over a period of a year, 97 patients referred to a mental health clinic for homeless people were assessed with the Diagnostic Interview Schedule (DIS) administered by a clinical social worker who then completed a full clinical psychiatric social work assessment. These same patients received a thorough and systematic clinical psychiatric evaluation by a psychiatrist or psychologist, both experienced with this population. These clinicians gathered data from multiple sources, often with extended observation over time. The DIS and clinician diagnoses were made blind to one another and then compared; the clinician was often made aware of some of the symptoms that the social worker had elicited, but not whether the elicited material was from the DIS or from the clinical assessment. Diagnoses of 33 clinic patients previously assessed by trained nonclinician DIS interviews in an epidemiologic study of the homeless population in the community were also compared to clinician diagnoses, and no information from these patients' survey DIS interviews was made available to the clinicians. Results. Compared to clinician assessment, structured interviews under-diagnosed antisocial personality disorder (ASPD) and overdiagnosed major depression. Alcohol use disorder and schizophrenia showed only small discrepancies by assessment method. Drug use disorder revealed no bias according to method of ascertainment, but showed very discrepant kappa levels comparing DIS to clinician assessment in the two different comparison contexts. Conclusions. If structured research methods assessing the homeless population actually overestimate depression, underestimate ASPD, and misclassify drug abuse, then policies stemming from structured interview research recommendations may call for levels and types of services not optimally suited to the reality of this population's needs. Because mental illness and substance abuse are thought to be critical factors in the generation and perpetuation of homelessness, the issue of accurate diagnosis is tantamount to understanding and providing workable solutions to the problem of homelessness. Further research is needed to untangle potential confounders of the homeless situation to psychiatric diagnosis.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Bassuk, E.L., Rubin, L., & Lauriat, A.S. (1986). Characteristics of sheltered homeless families. American Journal of Public Health, 76(9), 1097-1101.
Breakey, W.R., Fischer, P.J., Kramer, M., Nestadt, G., Romanoski, A.J., Ross, A., Royall, R.M., & Stine, O.C. (1989). Health and mental health problems of homeless men and women in Baltimore. The Journal of the American Medical Association, 262(10), 1352-1357.
Drake, R.E., Alterman, A.I., & Rosenberg, S.R. (1993). Detection of substance use disorders in severely mentally ill patients. Community Mental Health Journal, 29, 175-192.
Drake, R.E., Osher, F.C., & Wallach, M.A. (1991). Homelessness and dual diagnosis. American Psychologist, 46(11), 1149-1158.
Fischer, P.J. (1989). Estimating the prevalence of alcohol, drug and mental health problems in the contemporary homeless population: A review of the literature. Contemporary Drug Problems, 16(3), 333-390.
Fischer, P.J., Drake, R.E., & Breakey, W.R. (1992). Mental health problems among homeless persons: A review of epidemiological research from 1980 to 1990. In H.R. Lamb, L.L. Bachrach, & F.I. Kass (Eds.), Treating the Homeless Mentally Ill: A Report of the Task Force on the Homeless Mentally Ill. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association. (pp. 75-93).
Fischer, P.J., Shapiro, S., Breakey, W.R., Anthony, J.C., & Kramer, M. (1986). Mental health and social characteristics of the homeless: A survey of mission users. American Journal of Public Health, 76(5), 519-524.
Fleiss, J. (1981). Statistics for rates of proportions. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Herrman, H., McGorry, P., Bennett, P., van Riel, R., & Singh, B. (1989). Prevalence of severe mental disorders in disaffiliated and homeless people in inner Melbourne. American Journal of Psychiatry, 146, 1179-1184.
Koegel, P., & Burnam, A. (1988). Alcoholism among homeless adults in the inner city of Los Angeles. Archives of General Psychiatry, 45, 1011-1018.
Koegel, P., Burnam, A., & Farr, R.K. (1988). The prevalence of specific psychiatric disorders among homeless individuals in the inner city of Los Angeles. Archives of General Psychiatry, 45, 1085-1092.
Koegel, P., & Burnam, M.A. (1992). Problems in the assessment of mental illness among the homeless: An empirical approach. In M.J. Robertson & M. Greenblatt (Eds.), Homelessness: A National Perspective. New York: Plenum. (pp. 77-99).
Lipton, F.R., Sabatini, A., & Katz, S.E. (1983). Down and out in the city: The homeless mentally ill. Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 34, 817-821.
North, C.S. (1995). Homelessness: Psychiatric and Cultural Dimensions. American Psychiatric Association presentation in Miami, Florida.
North, C.S., Smith, E.M., & Spitznagel, E.L. (1993). Is antisocial personality a valid diagnosis among the homeless? American Journal of Psychiatry, 150, 578-583.
North, C.S., Smith, E.M., & Spitznagel, E.L. (1994). Violence and the homeless: an epidemiologic study of victimization and aggression. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 7(1), 95-110.
Robins, L.N., Helzer, J.E., Croughan, J., Williams, J.B.W., & Spitzer, R.L. (1981). NIMH Diagnostic Interview Schedule: Version III (May 1981). National Institute of Mental Health.
Smith, E.M., North, C.S., & Spitznagel, E.L. (1991). Are hard-to-interview street dwellers needed in assessing psychiatric disorders in homeless men? International J of Methods in Psychiatric Res. 1, 69-78.
Smith, E.M., North, C.S., & Spitznagel, E.L. (1992). A systematic study of mental illness, substance abuse, and treatment in 600 homeless men. Annals of Clinical Psychiatry, 4(2), 111-120.
Smith, E.M., North, C.S., & Spitznagel, E.L. (1993). Alcohol, drugs, and psychiatric comorbidity among homeless women: An epidemiologic study. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry,54, 82-87.
Spitznagel, E.L., & Helzer, J.E. (1985). A proposed solution to the base rate problem in the kappa statistic. Archives of General Psychiatry, 42, 725-728.
Susser, E., Conover, S., & Struening, E.L. (1989). Problems of epidemiologic method in assessing the type and extent of mental illness among homeless adults. Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 40, 261-265.
Susser, E., Struening, E.L., & Conover, S. (1989). Psychiatric problems in homeless men. Archives of General Psychiatry, 46, 845-850.
Susser, E.S., & Struening, E.L. (1990). Diagnosis and screening for psychotic disorders in a study of the homeless. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 16, 133-145.
Torrey, E.F. (1986). Forced medication is part of the cure. The New Physician, December, 34-37.
Yule, G.U. (1912). On the methods of measuring association between two attributes. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, 75, 581-642.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
North, C.S., Pollio, D.E., Thompson, S.J. et al. A Comparison of Clinical and Structured Interview Diagnoses in a Homeless Mental Health Clinic. Community Ment Health J 33, 531–543 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1025052720325
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1025052720325