Abstract
The paper concerns the struggle between different interest groups to control or significantly influence the objectives, institutional arrangements and processes of French accounting standardisation. Its particular focus of interest is the state agency established to deal with standardisation, namely the National Accounting Council, the Conseil National de la Comptabilité (CNC), and its predecessors. The period addressed spans from 1941 to the present, marked by the first attempt to implement a national accounting code, adoption of the initial post-war code in 1947 and subsequent revisions.
The paper identifies and examines the role played by the French state in establishing an institutional structure for accounting standardisation and in seeking to influence operation of that structure as a means to achieve a concertation of diverse social and economic interest groups with an interest in accounting standards. The objective for the process from the viewpoint of the state has been seen as the intended dominance of certain interests of state over other interests, whether public sector or otherwise. In the course of time, the dominant interests of the state have changed in the face of changing expectations about the role of financial accounting and reporting in the financial life of France. The role of the state is seen to have come under increasing pressure from private sector interests in France and externally. Particular attention is given to the 1996–8 major reforms to the CNC and associated new regulatory structure.
The possibility is assessed of whether and under what terms the French approach to accounting standardisation can be sustained, grounded as it is in a profound attachment by the state to the values of the Etat colbertiste.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Albert, M.: 1991, Capitalisme contre capitalisme (Paris: Seuil).
Asselain, J-C.: 1995, Histoire économique du XXème siècle: la réouverture des économies nationales (1939 aux années 1980) (Paris: Presses de Sciences Po et Dalloz).
Barreau, J. (ed.): 1990, L'Etat Entrepreneur: Nationalisations, gestion du secteur public concurrentiel, construction européenne (1982–1993) (Paris: L'Harmattan).
Bauchet, P.: 1962, La Planification française (Paris: Seuil).
Bendix, R.: 1978, Kings or People: Power and the Mandate to Rule (Berkeley: University of California Press).
Bérard, V. and Y. Lemarchand: 1994, Le Miroir du Marchand (Paris: Editions Comptables Malesherbes).
Bernard, Y. and J-C. Colli: 1984, Dictionnaire économique et financier (Paris: Seuil).
Bourgeois, L.: 1896, La Solidarité.
Brunet, A.: 1947, Rapport général, présenté au nom de la Commission de Normalisation des Comptabilités (Paris: Imprimerie Nationale).
Brunet, A.: 1951, La Normalisation comptable au service de l'entreprise, de la science et de la nation (Paris: Dunod).
Centrale de bilans: Service de l'information: 1980, Les ratios de la Centrale de Bilans de la Banque de France (Note d'information no 43).
Cohen, E.: 1996, La Tentation hexagonale: la souveraineté à l'épreuve de la mondialisation (Paris: Fayard).
Conseil national de la comptabilité: 1965, Plan comptable général [1957 PCG] (Paris: Conseil national de la comptabilité).
Conseil national de la comptabilité: 1986, Plan comptable général (Paris: Conseil national de la comptabilité).
Dupont, J.: 1981, “Sens et portée d'une révision”, Analyse financière (1er trimestre): 3–8.
Ehrmann, H.: 1959, La politique du patronat français 1936–1955 (Paris: Armand Colin).
Forrester, V.: 1996, L'Horreur économique (Paris: Fayard).
Fourastié, J.: 1943, La Comptabilité (Paris: Presses Universitaires de France).
Fourastié, J.: 1945, Comptabilité générale conforme au Plan comptable général (Paris: Librairie Générale de Droit et de Jurisprudence).
Fourastié, J.: 1979, Les Trente glorieuses (Paris: Arthème Fayard).
Fourquet, F.: 1980, Les Comptes de la Puissance (Paris: Encres).
Fukuyama, F.: 1995, Trust: The Social Virtues and the Creation of Prosperity (London: Hamish Hamilton).
Garnier, P.: 1947, La Comptabilité: Algèbre du droit & méthode d'observation des sciences économiques (Paris: Dunod).
Hayward, J.: 1961, “The Official Philosophy of the French Third Republic: Léon Bourgeois and Solidarism”, International Review of Social History (6): 22–25.
Hoffman, S.: 1974, Decline or Renewal? France Since the 1930s (New York: Viking Press).
Jönsson S.: 1991, “Role Making for Accounting While the State is Watching”, Accounting, Organizations and Society (16/5–6): 521–546.
Kerviler de, I.: 1986, Droit comptable (Entreprises) (Paris: Economica).
Kerviler de, I. and P. Standish: 1992, “French Accounting Law: Origins, Development and Scope”, in M. Bromwich and A. Hopwood (eds.), Accounting and the Law (London: Prentice Hall in association with The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales), pp. 130–158.
Lauzel, P.: 1949, Propositions du Conseil Supérieur de la Comptabilité relatives à un éventuel projet de loi comptable (Paris: Ministère des Finances et des Affaires Economiques).
Lutfalla, G.: 1950, “Rapport présenté au nom du Conseil économique”, in Conseil économique, Mise en application du Plan comptable (Paris: Presses Universitaires de France).
Maily, J.: 1946, La Normalisation (Paris: Dunod).
Massé, P.: 1967, Le Plan ou l'anti-hasard (Paris: Gallimard).
Méline, J.: 1905, Le Retour à la terre et la surproduction industrielle.
Miller, P.: 1990, “On the Interrelations Between Accounting and the State”, Accounting, Organizations and Society (15/4): 315–338.
Pérochon, C.: 1981, “Présentation générale du nouveau plan comptable”, Analyse financière (1er trimestre): 9–26.
Pérochon, C.: 1983, Présentation du Plan comptable français (Paris: Foucher).
Raffegeau, J., P. Dufils, C. Lopater and F. Arfoui: 1996, Comptable 1997 (Paris: Editions Francis Lefebvre).
Richard, J.: 1996, Comptabilités et pratiques comptables (Paris: Dalloz).
Sautel, G.: 1982, Histoire des institutions publiques depuis la Révolution Française (Paris: Dalloz).
Schama, S.: 1989, Citizens: A Chronicle of the French Revolution (London: Viking).
Standish, P.: 1990, “Origins of the Plan Comptable général: A Study in Cultural Intrusion and Reaction”, Accounting and Business Research (Autumn): 337–351.
Standish, P.: 1997, The French Plan Comptable (Paris: Ordre des Experts Comptables, in conjunction with The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales).
Ternisien, M.: 1992, Lire et Interpréter les Comptes de l'Entreprise (Paris: Dunod).
Tilly, C.: 1984, Big Structures, Large Processes, Huge Comparisons (New York: Russell Sage).
Young, J.: 1994, “Outlining Regulatory Space: Agenda Issues and the FASB”, Accounting, Organizations and Society (19/1): 83–109.
Zeldin, T.: 1979, France 1848–1945: Ambition and Love (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Colasse, B., Standish, P. State versus Market: Contending Interests in the Struggle to Control French Accounting Standardisation. Journal of Management & Governance 2, 107–147 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009933418444
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009933418444