Abstract
In this article we examine the potential effect of market structure on hospital technical efficiency as a measure of performance controlled by ownership and regulation. This study is relevant to provide an evaluation of the potential effects of recommended and initiated deregulation policies in order to promote market reforms in the context of a European National Health Service. Our goal was reached through three main empirical stages. Firstly, using patient origin data from hospitals in the region of Catalonia in 1990, we estimated geographic hospital markets through the Elzinga–Hogarty approach, based on patient flows. Then we measured the market level of concentration using the Herfindahl–Hirschman index. Secondly, technical and scale efficiency scores for each hospital was obtained specifying a Data Envelopment Analysis. According to the data nearly two-thirds of the hospitals operate under the production frontier with an average efficiency score of 0.841. Finally, the determinants of the efficiency scores were investigated using a censored regression model. Special attention was paid to test the hypothesis that there is an efficiency improvement in more competitive markets. The results suggest that the number of competitors in the market contributes positively to technical efficiency and there is some evidence that the differences in efficiency scores are attributed to several environmental factors such as ownership, market structure and regulation effects.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abel-Smith, B., and E. Mossialos (1994) 'Cost Containment in Health Care Reform: A Study of the European Union', Health Policy, 28, 89-132.
Banker, R. D., A. Charnes, and W. W. Cooper (1984) 'Some Models for Estimating Technical and Scale Efficiencies in Data Envelopment Analysis', Management Science, 30, 9.
Bazzoli, G. J., D. Marx, R. J. Arnould, and Larry M. Manheim (1995) 'Federal Antitrust Merger Enforcement Standards: A Good Fit for the Hospital Industry', Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 20(1), 137-169.
Blackstone, E. A., and J. P. Fuhr (1992) 'An Antitrust Analysis of Non-Profit Hospital Mergers', Review of Industrial Organization, 8, 473-490.
Chirikos, T. N., and A. M. Sear (1994) 'Technical Efficiency and the Competitive Behavior of Hospitals', Socio-Economic Planning and Science, 28(4), 219-227.
Crane, S. E., and Patrick J. Welch (1991) 'The Problem of Geographic Market Definition: Geographic Proximity vs. Economic Significance', Atlantic Economic Journal, 19(2), 12-20.
Debreu, G. (1951) 'The Coefficient of Resource Utilization', Econometrica, 19(3), 273-292.
DOJ and FTC (1993) 'Horizontal Merger Guidelines', Review of Industrial Organization, 8, 231-256.
Dranove, D., Mark Shanley, and Carol Simon (1992) 'Is Hospital Competition Wasteful?', RAND Journal of Economics, 23(2), 247-262.
Dranove, D., M. Shanley, and William D. White (1993) 'Price and Concentration in Hospital Markets: The Switch from Patient-Driven to Payer-Driven Competition', Journal of Law and Economics, 36, 179-204.
Eakin, B. K. (1991) 'Allocative Inefficiency in the Production of Hospital Services', Southern Economic Journal, 58, 240-248.
Elzinga, K. G., and Thomas F. Hogarty (1973) 'The Problem of Geographic Market Delineation in Antimerger Suits', The Antitrust Bulletin, 18(1), Spring.
Elzinga, K. G., and Thomas F. Hogarty (1978) 'The Problem of Geographic Market Delineation Revisited: The Case of Coal', The Antitrust Bulletin, 23(1), Spring.
Farrell, M. J. (1957) 'The Measurement of Productive Efficiency', Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A, General, 120, Part 3, pp. 253-81.
Ferguson, B., and Stephen Palmer (1994) 'Markets and the NHSM Guidelines Costs and Prices in the NHS Internal Market', Working Paper #120, Centre for Health Economics, University of York.
Greene, W. H. (1993) Econometric Analysis, 2nd. ed. New York: Macmillan.
Hadley, J., S. Zuckerman, and L. I. Iezzoni (1996) 'Financial Pressure and Competition: Changes in Hospital Efficiency and Cost-Shifting Behavior', Medical Care, 34(3), 205-219.
Hersch, P. (1984) 'Competition and the Performance of Hospital Markets', Review of Industrial Organization, Win, 324-341.
Kooreman, P. (1994) 'Nursing Home Care in the Netherlands: A Nonparametric Efficiency Analysis', Journal of Health Economics, 13, 301-316.
Magleby, J. E. (1996) 'Hospital Mergers and Antitrust Policy: Arguments Against a Modification of Current Antitrust Law', The Antitrust Butlletin, Spring, pp. 137-201.
Maynard, A. (1991) 'Developing the Health Care Market', The Economic Journal, 101, 1277-1286.
Melnick, G. A., and Jack Zwanziger (1988) 'Hospital Behavior under Competition and Cost-Containment Policies: The California Experience, 1980–1985', JAMA, 260, 2669-2675.
Miller, R. A. (1982) 'The Herfindahl-Hirschman Index as a Market Structure Variable: An Exposition for Antitrust Practitioners', The Antitrust Bulletin, Fall.
Morrisey, M. A., F. A. Sloan, and J. Valvona (1988) 'Defining Geographic Markets for Hospital Care', Law and Contemporary Problems, 51(2), 165-194.
Nguyen, X. N., and Frederick W. Derrick (1994) 'Hospital Markets and Competition: Implications for Antitrust Policy', Health Care Management Review, 19(1), 34-43.
Noether, M. (1988) 'Competition Among Hospitals', Journal of Health Economics, 7, 259-275.
OECD (1996) 'La réforme des systèmes de sauté. La volanté de changement', Études de Politique de Santé, 8. Paris.
Propper, C. (1996) 'Market Structure and Prices: The Responses of Hospitals in the U.K. National Health Service to Competition', Journal of Public Economics, 61, 307-335.
Register, C. A., and E. R. Bruning (1987) 'Profit Incentives and Technical Efficiency in the Production of Hospital Care', Southern Economic Journal, 53, 899-914.
Robinson, J. C., and Harold S. Luft (1985) 'The Impact of Hospital Market Structure on Patient Volume, Average Length of Stay, and the Cost of Care', Journal of Health Economics, 4, 333-356.
Scherer, F. M., and David Ross (1990) Industrial Market Structure and Economic Performance. 3rd ed., Boston. Hougthon Mifflin.
Werden, G. J. (1989) 'The Limited Relevance of Patient Migration Data in Market Delineation for Hospital Merger Cases', Journal of Health Economics, 8, 363-376.
Zuckerman, S., J. Hadley, and L. Iezzoni (1994) 'Measuring Hospital Efficiency with Frontier Cost Functions', Journal of Health Economics, 13, 255-280.
Zwanziger, J., G. A. Melnick, and K. M. Eyre (1994) 'Hospitals and Antitrust: Defining Markets, Setting Standards', Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 19(2).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dalmau-Atarrodona, E., Puig-Junoy, J. Market Structure and Hospital Efficiency: Evaluating Potential Effects of Deregulation in a National Health Service. Review of Industrial Organization 13, 447–466 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1007775616593
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1007775616593