Abstract
Recent years have seen a renewed debate over the importance of groupselection, especially as it relates to the evolution of altruism. Onefeature of this debate has been disagreement over which kinds ofprocesses should be described in terms of selection at multiple levels,within and between groups. Adapting some earlier discussions, we presenta mathematical framework that can be used to explore the exactrelationships between evolutionary models that do, and those that donot, explicitly recognize biological groups as fitness-bearing entities.We show a fundamental set of mathematical equivalences between these twokinds of models, one of which applies a form of multi-level selectiontheory and the other being a form of ``individualism.'' However, we alsoargue that each type of model can have heuristic advantages over theother. Indeed, it can be positively useful to engage in a kind ofback-and-forth switching between two different perspectives on theevolutionary role of groups. So the position we defend is a``gestalt-switching pluralism.''
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alexander, R.D. and Borgia, G.: 1978, 'Group Selection, Altruism, and the Levels of Organization of Life', Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 9, 449-474.
Axelrod, R.: 1984. The Evolution of Cooperation, Basic Books.
Axelrod, R. and Hamilton, W.D.: 1981, 'The Evolution of Cooperation', Science 211, 1390-1396.
Barrett, M. and Godfrey-Smith, P.: 2002, 'Group Selection, Pluralism, and the Evolution of Altruism: A Review of Unto Others', Philosophical and Phenomenological Research.
Buss, L.: 1987, The Evolution of Individuality, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Charnov, E.L. and Krebs, J.R.: 1975, 'The Evolution of Alarm Calls: Altruism or Manipulation?', American Naturalist 109, 107-112.
Cohen, D. and Eshel, I.: 1976, 'On the Founder Effect and the Evolution of Altruistic Traits', Theoretical Population Biology 10, 276-302.
Dawkins, R.: 1982, The Extended Phenotype, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Dugatkin, L.A. and Reeve, H.K.: 1994, 'Behavioral Ecology and Levels of Selection: Dissolving the Group Selection Controversy', Advances in the Study of Behavior 23, 101-133.
Eshel, I.: 1972, 'On the Neighbor Effect and the Evolution of Altruistic Traits', Theoretical Population Biology 3, 258-277.
Godfrey-Smith, P. and Lewontin, R.: 1993, 'The Dimensions of Selection', Philosophy of Science 60, 373-395.
Grafen, A.: 1984, 'Natural Selection, Kin Selection, and Group Selection', in J.R. Krebs and N.B. Davies (eds.), Behavioral Ecology: An Evolutionary Approach, Sinauer, Sunderland, pp. 62-84.
Hamilton, W.D.: 1975, 'Innate Social Aptitudes in Man: An Approach from Evolutionary Genetics', in R. Fox (ed.), Biosocial Anthropology, Wiley, New York, pp. 133-155.
Karlin, S. and Matessi, C.: 1983, 'Kin Selection and Altruism', Proceedings of the Royal Society, London B 219, 327-353.
Keller E.F. and Lloyd, E.A.: 1992, Keywords in Evolutionary Biology, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
Lewontin, R.C.: 1969, 'The Meaning of Stability', Diversity and Stability in Ecological Systems, Brookhaven Symposia in Biology 22, 13-24.
Lloyd, E.A.: 1988, The Structure and Confirmation of Evolutionary Theory, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Matessi, C. and Jayakar, S.D.: 1976, 'Conditions for the Evolution of Altruism under Darwinian Selection', Theoretical Population Biology 9, 360-387.
Matessi, C. and Karlin, S.: 1984, 'On the Evolution of Altruism by Kin Selection', Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, U.S.A. 81, 1754-1758.
Maynard Smith, J.: 1964, 'Group Selection and Kin Selection', Nature 201, 1145-1147.
Maynard Smith, J.: 1976, 'Group Selection', The Quarterly Review of Biology 51, 277-283.
Maynard Smith, J.: 1982, Evolution and the Theory of Games, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Maynard Smith, J.: 1987, 'How to Model Evolution', in J. Dupre (ed.), The Latest on the Best: Essays on Evolution and Optimality, MIT Press, Cambridge, pp. 119-131.
Maynard Smith, J. and Szathmáry, E.: 1995, The Major Transitions in Evolution, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Michod, R.E.: 1999, Darwinian Dynamics: Evolutionary Transitions in Fitness and Individuality, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Nunney, L.: 1985, 'Group Selection, Altruism, and Structured-deme Models', American Naturalist 126(4), 212-230.
Price, G.R.: 1970, 'Selection and Covariance', Nature 227, 520-521.
Price, G.R.: 1972, 'Extension of Covariance Selection Mathematics', Annals of Human Genetics 35, 485-490.
Skyrms, B.: 1994, 'Darwin Meets The Logic of Decision: Correlation in Evolutionary Game Theory', Philosophy of Science 61, 503-528.
Sober, E.: 1984, The Nature of Selection: Evolutionary Theory in Philosophical Focus, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Sober, E.: 1992, 'The Evolution of Altruism: Correlation, Cost, and Benefit', Biology and Philosophy 7, 177-187.
Sober, E.: 1998, 'Three Differences Between Evolution and Deliberation', in P. Danielson (ed.), Modeling Rationality, Morality and Evolution, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 408-422.
Sober, E. and Lewontin, R.C.: 1982, 'Artifact, Cause and Genic Selection', Philosophy of Science 49, 157-180.
Sober, E. and Wilson, D.S.: 1998, Unto Others: The Evolution and Psychology of Unselfish Behavior, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
Sterelny, K. and Kitcher, P.: 1988, 'The Return of the Gene', Journal of Philosophy 85, 339-361.
Sterelny, K.: 1996, 'The Return of the Group', Philosophy of Science 63, 562-584.
Uyenoyama, M.K. and Feldman, M.W.: 1980, 'Theories of Kin and Group Selection: A Population Genetics Perspective', Theoretical Population Biology 17(5), 380-414.
Uyenoyama M.K. and Feldman, M.W.: 1992, 'Altruism: Some Theoretical Ambiguities', in E. Fox Keller and E.A. Lloyd (eds.), Keywords in Evolutionary Biology, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, pp. 34-40.
Wade, M.J.: 1978, 'A Critical Review of the Models of Group Selection', The Quarterly Review of Biology 53(2), 101-114.
Wade, M.J.: 1985, 'Soft Selection, Hard Selection, Kin Selection and Group Selection', American Naturalist 125(1), 61-73.
Waters, C.K.: 1991, 'Tempered Realism About the Force of Selection', Philosophy of Science 58, 553-573.
Williams, G.C.: 1966, Adaptation and Natural Selection, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Williams, G.C. and Williams, D.C.: 1957, 'Natural Selection of Individually Harmful Social Adaptations Among Sibs with Special Reference to Social Insects', Evolution 11, 32-39.
Wilson, D.S.: 1975, 'A Theory of Group Selection', Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, U.S.A. 72(1): 143-146.
Wilson, D.S.: 1977, 'Structured Demes and the Evolution of Group-Advantageous Traits', American Naturalist 111, 157-185.
Wilson, D.S.: 1980, The Natural Selection of Populations and Communities, Benjamin/Cummings, Menlo Park.
Wilson, D.S.: 1983, 'The Group Selection Controversy: History and Current Status', Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 14, 159-187.
Wilson, D.S.: 1990, 'Weak Altruism, Strong Group Selection', Oikos 59(1), 135-140.
Wilson, D.S.: 1997, 'Altruism and Organism: Disentangling the Themes of Multilelvel Selection Theory', American Naturalist 150, S122-S134.
Wilson, D.S. and Sober, E.: 1989, 'Reviving the Superorganism', Journal of Theoretical Biology 136, 337-356.
Wright, S.: 1945, 'Tempo and Mode in Evolution: A Critical Review', Ecology 26(6), 415-419.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kerr, B., Godfrey-Smith, P. Individualist and Multi-level Perspectives on Selection in Structured Populations. Biology & Philosophy 17, 477–517 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1020504900646
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1020504900646