Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-xtgtn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-24T18:50:09.643Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Transposing the Merton Thesis: Apostolic Spirituality and the Establishment of the Jesuit Scientific Tradition

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 September 2008

Steven J. Harris
Steven J. Harris
Affiliation:
Department of the History of ScienceHarvard University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Despite more than fifty years of debate on the Merton thesis, there have been few attempts to substantiate Merton's argument through empirically based comparative studies. This study of the Jesuit scientific tradition is intended to serve as a test of some of Merton's central claims.

Jesuit science is remarkable for its scope and longevity, and is distinguished by its markedly empirical and utilitarian orientation. In this paper I examine the ideological structure of the Society of Jesus and find at its core an “apostolic spirituality” that explains the legitimation of these forms of science within the Society. The values of apostolic spirituality (diligence, practicality, learning, etc.) strongly encouraged an activist mentality among Jesuits, which in turn led to the formation of apostolates in education, at court, and in the overseas missions. The values associated with apostolic spirituality led to the initial acceptance of active-empirical sciences within the Society, which became established as traditions because they were useful in fulfilling the goals of the Society's apostolates.

This study, by providing a qualified confirmation of Merton's central claims, suggests the importance of a supra-confessional sanctification of labor and learning in the growth of active-empirical sciences.

Type
Article
Information
Science in Context , Volume 3 , Issue 1 , Spring 1989 , pp. 29 - 65
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1989

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abraham, Gary A., 1983. “Misunderstanding the Merton Thesis” Isis 74:368–87.Google Scholar
Ashworth, William, 1986. “Catholicism and Early Modern Science,” in God and Nature: Historical Essays on the Encounter between Christianity and Science, ed. Lindberg, David C. and Numbers, Ronald L., 136–66. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Bangert, William J., S. J., , 1972. A History of the Society of Jesus. St. Louis: The Institute of Jesuit Sources.Google Scholar
Bangert, William J., S. J., , 1972. A History of the Society of Jesus. St. Louis: The Institute of Jesuit Sources.Google Scholar
Bell, Daniel, 1960. The End of ideology. New York: The Free Press.Google Scholar
Bell, Daniel, 1960. The End of ideology. New York: The Free Press.Google Scholar
Bernoulli, Johann, 1771. Lettres astronomiques où l'on donne une idée de l'état actuel de l'astronomie pratique dans plusieurs villes de l'Europe. Berlin.Google Scholar
Bernoulli, Johann, 1771. Lettres astronomiques où l'on donne une idée de l'état actuel de l'astronomie pratique dans plusieurs villes de l'Europe. Berlin.Google Scholar
Bretschneider, E., 1880. “Early European Researches into the Flora of China” Journal of the North China Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society, 1–195.Google Scholar
Chrisman, Miriam Usher, 1982. Lay Culture, Learned Culture: Books and Social Change in Strasbourg. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Chrisman, Miriam Usher, 1982. Lay Culture, Learned Culture: Books and Social Change in Strasbourg. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Cohen, I. Bernard, forthcoming. Puritanism and the Rise of Modern Science. New Brunswick, N. J.: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar
Cohen, I. Bernard, forthcoming. Puritanism and the Rise of Modern Science. New Brunswick, N. J.: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar
Dear, Peter, 1987. “Jesuit Mathematical Science and the Reconstruction of Experience in the Early Seventeenth Century” Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science 18:133–75.Google Scholar
Dear, Peter, 1988. Mersenne and the Learning of the Schools. Ithaca, N.Y. and London: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Dear, Peter, 1988. Mersenne and the Learning of the Schools. Ithaca, N.Y. and London: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Dehergne, Joseph S. J., 1973. Répertoire des jésuites de Chine de 1552 à 1800. Rome: Institutum Historicum S.I.; Paris: Letouzey and Ane.Google Scholar
Dehergne, Joseph S. J., 1973. Répertoire des jésuites de Chine de 1552 à 1800. Rome: Institutum Historicum S.I.; Paris: Letouzey and Ane.Google Scholar
D'Elia, Pasquale M., 1960. Galileo in China: Relations through the Roman College between Galileo and the Jesuit Scientist-Missionaries (1610–1640), trans. Rafus Suter and Matheu Sciascia. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
D'Elia, Pasquale M., 1960. Galileo in China: Relations through the Roman College between Galileo and the Jesuit Scientist-Missionaries (1610–1640), trans. Rafus Suter and Matheu Sciascia. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Elkana, Yehuda, 1981. “A Programmatic Attempt at an Anthropology of Knowledge,” in Science and Cultures, ed. Mendelsohn, Everett and Elkana, Yehuda, 1–76. Dordrecht: Reidel.Google Scholar
Elkana, Yehuda, forthcoming. “The Scientific Revolution as a Revolution in Reflexivity.”Google Scholar
Evennett, H. Outram, 1968. The Spirit of the Counter-Reformation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Evennett, H. Outram, 1968. The Spirit of the Counter-Reformation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Feldhay, Rivka, 1985. “The Jesuits' Educational Ideology: From ‘officium docendi’ to ‘ministerium’” (typescript).Google Scholar
Feldhay, Rivka, 1987. “Knowledge and Salvation in Jesuit Culture” Science in Context 1(2):195–213.Google Scholar
Fischer, Karl Adolf Franz, 1978. “Jesuiten-Mathematiker in der deutschen Assistenz bis 1773” Archivum Historicum Societatis Iesu 47:159–224.Google Scholar
Fischer, Karl Adolf Franz, 1980. “Jesuiten in Breslau: Quellen zur Geschichte der Breslauer Jesuitenakademie und Jesuitenuniversität, 1640–1755“ Archivu für Schlesische Kirchengeschichte 38:121–74.Google Scholar
Fischer, Karl Adolf Franz, 1983a. “Jesuiten-Mathematiker in der Französischen und Italienischen Assistenz bis 1762 bzw. 1773” Archivum Historicum Societatis lesu 52:52–92.Google Scholar
Fischer, Karl Adolf Franz, 1983b. “Die Astronomie und Naturwissenschaften in Mähren” Bohemia 24(1):19–103.Google Scholar
Fischer, Karl Adolf Franz, and Hibst, Peter, 1983. “Die Astronomie an den Hochschulen in Brünn” Bohemia 24(2):295–98.Google Scholar
Fülöp-Miller, René, 1930. The Power and Secret of the Jesuits, trans. Flint, F. S. and Tait, D. F.. New York: Viking Press.Google Scholar
Ganss, George S.J., 1954. St. Ignatius: The Idea of a Jesuit University: A Study in the History of Catholic Education. Milwaukee: Marquette University Press.Google Scholar
Ganss, George S.J., 1954. St. Ignatius: The Idea of a Jesuit University: A Study in the History of Catholic Education. Milwaukee: Marquette University Press.Google Scholar
Geertz, Clifford, 1964. “Ideology as a Cultural System,” in Ideology and Discontent, ed. Apters, David E., 47–76.New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
Gicklhorn, Joseph, and Gicklhorn, Renée, 1954. Georg Joseph Kamel, S. J. (1661–1706): Apotheker, Botaniker, Artz und Naturforscher der Philipineninseln. Eutin: Holstein.Google Scholar
Gicklhorn, Joseph, and Gicklhorn, Renée, 1954. Georg Joseph Kamel, S. J. (1661–1706): Apotheker, Botaniker, Artz und Naturforscher der Philipineninseln. Eutin: Holstein.Google Scholar
Gickihorn, Renée, 1973. Missionapotheker: Deutsche Pharmazeuten in Latinamerika des 17. und 18. Jahrhunderts. Stuttgart: Wissenschaftliche Verlagsgesellschaft.Google Scholar
Gickihorn, Renée, 1973. Missionapotheker: Deutsche Pharmazeuten in Latinamerika des 17. und 18. Jahrhunderts. Stuttgart: Wissenschaftliche Verlagsgesellschaft.Google Scholar
Gieryn, Thomas F., 1988. “Distancing Science from Religion in Seventeenth-Century England” Isis 79:582–93.Google Scholar
Gillispie, Charles Coulston, ed., 1970. Dictionary of Scientific Biography, 16. vols New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.Google Scholar
Grant, Edward, 1984. “In Defense of the Earth's Centrality and Immobility: Scholastic Reaction to Copernicanism in the Seventeenth Century” Transactions of the American Philosophical Society 74(4): 1–69.Google Scholar
Hall, A. Rupert, 1963. “Merton Revisited, or Science and Society in the Seventeenth Century” History of Science 2:1–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harney, P., Martin, S. J., 1941. The Jesuits in History: The Society of Jesus Through Four Centuries. New York: The American Press.Google Scholar
Harney, P., Martin, S. J., 1941. The Jesuits in History: The Society of Jesus Through Four Centuries. New York: The American Press.Google Scholar
Heilbron, John, 1979. Electricity in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Heilbron, John, 1979. Electricity in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Hill, Christopher, 1965. The Intellectual Origins of the English Revolution. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Hill, Christopher, 1965. The Intellectual Origins of the English Revolution. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Hill, Christopher, 1974. “Puritanism, Capitalism and the Scientific Revolution,” in The Intellectual Revolution of the Seventeenth Century, ed. Webster, Charles, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. 243–253.Google Scholar
Huard, P., 1953. “La diffusion de l'anatomie européenne dans quelques secteurs de l'Asie” Archives Internationales d'Histoire des Sciences 6:266–78.Google Scholar
Huonder, , Anton Von, S. J., 1899. “Deutsche Jesuitenmisionäre des 17. und 18. Jahrhunderts: Em Beitrag zur Missionsgeschichte und zur deutschen Biographie” Ergänzungsheft zu den Stimmen aus Maria-Laach, vol. 74. Frieburg in Briesgau.Google Scholar
Huonder, , Anton Von, S. J., 1899. “Deutsche Jesuitenmisionäre des 17. und 18. Jahrhunderts: Em Beitrag zur Missionsgeschichte und zur deutschen Biographie” Ergänzungsheft zu den Stimmen aus Maria-Laach, vol. 74. Frieburg in Briesgau.Google Scholar
Ignatius of Loyola, 1955. The “Spiritual Exercises” of Saint Ignatius of Loyola and the “Directorium in Exercita,” ed. Longridge, W. H.. London: A. R. Mowbray & Co.Google Scholar
Ignatius of Loyola, 1970. The Constitutions of the Society of Jesus, ed. George Ganss, S. J. St. Louis: Institute for Jesuit Sources.Google Scholar
Jardine, Nicholas, 1979. “The Forging of Modern Realism: Clavius and Kepler against the Sceptics” Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science 10:141–73.Google Scholar
Kelley, Donald R., 1981. The Beginning of Ideology: Consciousness and Society in the French Reformation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Kelley, Donald R., 1981. The Beginning of Ideology: Consciousness and Society in the French Reformation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Knowles, , David, O. S. B., 1966. From Pachomius to Ignatius: A Study in the Constitutional History of the Religious Orders. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Knowles, , David, O. S. B., 1966. From Pachomius to Ignatius: A Study in the Constitutional History of the Religious Orders. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Koch, , Ludwig, S. J., 1934. Jesuiten-Lexikon; die Gesellschaft Jesu einst und jetzt. Paderborn: Bonifacius-Druckerei.Google Scholar
Koch, , Ludwig, S. J., 1934. Jesuiten-Lexikon; die Gesellschaft Jesu einst und jetzt. Paderborn: Bonifacius-Druckerei.Google Scholar
Koyré, Alexandre, 1955. “A Documentary History of the Problem of Free-Fall from Kepler to Newton” Transactions of the American Philosophical Society 45:329–95.Google Scholar
Kuhn, Thomas S., 1977. “Mathematical versus Experimental Traditions in the Development of Physical Science,” in his The Essential Tension, 31–65. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Kuhn, Thomas S., 1977. “Mathematical versus Experimental Traditions in the Development of Physical Science,” in his The Essential Tension, 31–65. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Lalande, M. de., [1792] 1794. Astronomie, 2. vols Paris: Desaint and Gaillant.Google Scholar
Lalande, M. de., [1792] 1794. Astronomie, 2. vols Paris: Desaint and Gaillant.Google Scholar
Lohr, , Charles, S. J., 1976. “Jesuit Aristotelianism and Sixteenth-Century Metaphysics” Paradosis 32:203–20.Google Scholar
Lohr, Charles S. J., 1988. Latin Aristotle Commentaries: Renaissance Authors. Florence: Olschki.Google Scholar
Lohr, Charles S. J., 1988. Latin Aristotle Commentaries: Renaissance Authors. Florence: Olschki.Google Scholar
Martin, A. Lynn, 1988. The Jesuit Mind: The Mentality of an Elite in Early Modern France. Ithaca, N.Y. and London: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Martin, A. Lynn, 1988. The Jesuit Mind: The Mentality of an Elite in Early Modern France. Ithaca, N.Y. and London: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Merton, Robert K., 1936. “The Unanticipated Consequences of Purposive Social Action” American Sociological Review 1:894–904.Google Scholar
Merton, Robert K., [1938] 1970. Science, Technology and. Society in Seventeenth-Century England. New York: Howard Fertig. Originally published in Osiris 4:360–632.Google Scholar
Merton, Robert K., 1970. “Preface: 1970,” in Merton [1938] 1970, vii–xxix.Google Scholar
Morgan, John, 1979. “Puritans and Science: A Reinterpretation” The Historical Journal 22:535–60.Google Scholar
Morgan, John, 1986. Godly Learning: Puritan Attitudes Toward Reason, Learning and Education, 1560–1640. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Morgan, John, 1986. Godly Learning: Puritan Attitudes Toward Reason, Learning and Education, 1560–1640. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Noti, S., 1906. “Joseph Tieffenthaler: A Forgotten Geographer of India” East and West (Bombay) 5:400–413.Google Scholar
Pfister, , Louis, S. J., 1932. Notices biographiques et bibliographiques sur les Jésuites de l'ancienne mission de Chine, 1552–1773. Shanghai.Google Scholar
Pfister, , Louis, S. J., 1932. Notices biographiques et bibliographiques sur les Jésuites de l'ancienne mission de Chine, 1552–1773. Shanghai.Google Scholar
Poggendorff, J. C., 1863. Biographisch-Literarisches Handwörterbuch zur Geschichte der Exacten Wissenschaften. Leipzig: Johann Ambrosius Barth.Google Scholar
Popkin, R., 1979. The History of Scepticism from Erasmus to Spinoza. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Popkin, R., 1979. The History of Scepticism from Erasmus to Spinoza. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Pyenson, Lewis, 1977. “‘Who the guys were’: Prosopography in the History of Science” History of Science 15:155–88.Google Scholar
Renaldo, John J., 1976. “Bacon's Empiricism, Boyle's Science, and the Jesuit Response in Italy” Journal for the History of Ideas 37:689–95.Google Scholar
Robertson, H. M., 1935. The Rise of Economic Individualism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Robertson, H. M., 1935. The Rise of Economic Individualism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Rowbotham, Arnold Horrex, 1942. Missionary and Mandarin: The Jesuits at the Peking Court of China. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Rowbotham, Arnold Horrex, 1942. Missionary and Mandarin: The Jesuits at the Peking Court of China. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Shapin, Steven, 1988. “Understanding the Merton Thesis” Isis 79:594–605.Google Scholar
Shils, Edward, 1961. “Ideology: The Concept and Function of Ideology,” in the International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, 7:66–76. New York: MacMillan.Google Scholar
Shils, Edward, 1961. “Ideology: The Concept and Function of Ideology,” in the International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, 7:66–76. New York: MacMillan.Google Scholar
Sommervogel, Carlos S. J., 1890–1910. Bibliothèque de Ia Compagnie de Jésus, 12. vols Brussels: Oscar Schepens; Paris: Alphonse Picard.Google Scholar
Sommervogel, Carlos S. J., 1890–1910. Bibliothèque de Ia Compagnie de Jésus, 12. vols Brussels: Oscar Schepens; Paris: Alphonse Picard.Google Scholar
Stitz, Peter, 1934. “Kalifornische Briefe des P. Eusebio Francisco Kino (Chini) nach der Oberdeutschen Provinz, 1683–1985” Archivum Historicum Societatis lesu 3:108–28.Google Scholar
Stoeckius, Hermann, 1910. Studien über die Pädagogik der GesellschaftJesu im 16. Jahrhundert: Das Prinzip der Trennung in der Ordnung des Verkehrs zwischen den Ordenangehörigen und den Externen, Dissertation der Universität Erlangen. Nördlingen: C. H. Beck.Google Scholar
Stoeckius, Hermann, 1910. Studien über die Pädagogik der GesellschaftJesu im 16. Jahrhundert: Das Prinzip der Trennung in der Ordnung des Verkehrs zwischen den Ordenangehörigen und den Externen, Dissertation der Universität Erlangen. Nördlingen: C. H. Beck.Google Scholar
Stoeckius, Hermann, 1911. Forschungen zur Lebensordnung der Gesellschaft Jesu im 16. Jahrhundert. Munich: C. H. Beck.Google Scholar
Stoeckius, Hermann, 1911. Forschungen zur Lebensordnung der Gesellschaft Jesu im 16. Jahrhundert. Munich: C. H. Beck.Google Scholar
Stoeckius, Hermann, 1912. Die Reiseordnung der Gesellschaft Jesu im 16. Jahrhundert. Heidelberg: Carl Winter's Universitatsbuchhandlung.Google Scholar
Stoeckius, Hermann, 1912. Die Reiseordnung der Gesellschaft Jesu im 16. Jahrhundert. Heidelberg: Carl Winter's Universitatsbuchhandlung.Google Scholar
Stoeckius, Hermann, 1918. Untersuchungen zur Geschichte des Noviziates in der Gesellschaft Jesu, Dissertation der Universität Göttingen. Bonn: Albert Falkenroth Verlag.Google Scholar
Stoeckius, Hermann, 1918. Untersuchungen zur Geschichte des Noviziates in der Gesellschaft Jesu, Dissertation der Universität Göttingen. Bonn: Albert Falkenroth Verlag.Google Scholar
Stoeckius, Hermann, 1925. “Ignatius von Loyola Gedanken über Aufnahme und Bildung von Novizien,” in Pädagogisches Magazin, ed. Mann, Friedrich, Heft 808. Langensalza: Hermann Beyer und Söhne.Google Scholar
Stone, Lawrence, 1971. “Prosopography” Daedalus 100:46–79.Google Scholar
Trevor-Roper, H. R., 1963. “Religion, the Reformation, and Social Change,” in Historical Studies IV, ed. Hayes-McCoy, G. A..London.Google Scholar
Tyacke, Nicholas, 1973. “Puritanism, Arminianism and Counter-Revolution,” in The Origins of the English Civil War, ed. Russel, Conrad, 119–43 London: MacMillan.Google Scholar
Tyacke, Nicholas, 1978. “Science and Religion at Oxford before the Civil War,” in Puritans and Revolutionaries, ed. Pennington, Donald and Thomas, Keith. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Wallace, William A., 1984. Galileo and His Sources: The Heritage of the Collegio Romano in Galileo's Science. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Weber, Max, 1930. The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, trans. Talcott Parsons. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.Google Scholar
Webster, Charles, 1975. The Great Instauration. London: Duckworth.Google Scholar
Wessels, , Cornellius, S. J., 1924. Early Jesuit Travellers in Central Asia 1603–1721. The Hague: Nijhoff.Google Scholar
Whitmore, P., S. J., , 1967. The Order of the Minims in Seventeenth-Century France. The Hague: Nijhoff.Google Scholar