We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 April 2010
Although this paper builds on earlier research, let me frankly confess that this is still a preliminary report as it is not based on comprehensive research in the original sources upon which my work on the seventeenth centuryis based. Given the huge amount of sources available for the eighteenth century, to write a truly thorough paper on the Arabian seas in the eighteenth century would take many years – nay, a life-time so voluminous is it. Holden Furber, perhaps the greatest historian of the eighteenth-century Indian Ocean, started to work on this topic in 1936, published a volume on the 1780–1790 period in 1948 and then announced he would write further volumes tracing the story back into the seventeenth century. But Holden Furber spent the rest of his life hunting down further archival material, with new material constantly forcing him to delay further publications for another forty years. Even then he was only able to write a preliminary survey of the eighteenth century, ending with the causing note that, of course, he had not studied the Dutch material as well as he would have liked to.
1 Barendse, R.J., Arabian Seas 1640–1700 (Leiden 1998)Google Scholar. Revised version: Arabian Seas: The Indian Ocean World of the Seventeenth Century (Armonk, N.Y. 2001).
2 Furber, Holden, John Company at Work (Cambridge, Mass. 1948).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
3 Furber, Holden, Rival Empires of Trade in the Orient, 1600–1800 (Minneapolis, Minn. 1976).Google Scholar
4 As Steensgaard, Niels uses the word for example ‘The Indian Ocean Network and the Emerging World-Economy ca. 1500–1700’ in: Chandra, S. ed., The Indian Ocean: Explorations in History, Commerce and Politics (London 1987) 223–235.Google Scholar
5 Kieniewicz, J., ‘Pepper Gardens and Market in Precolonial Malabar’ in: M.N. Pearson, Spices in the Indian Ocean World (Ashgate 1996) 209–244Google Scholar. But note that if accepting Kieniewicz-in my view reliable - figure of 24,000,000 lbs pepper produced by Kerala and Canara around 1760 the total production of pepper had more than doubled compared to the seventeenth century. And this was by and large in response to demand from the Indian internal market and from the Middle East. Proof - if any more was needed - for an overall sharp increase in demand on the subcontinent in the eighteenth century.
6 Todd, J., Travels in Western India (Delhi 1971) 460.Google Scholar
7 Ohlson, D., The Ottoman Siege of Mosul and Ottoman-Persian Relations (Bloomington 1974) 23; General State Archive The Hague (ARA), Archief Verenigde Oost-Indische Compagnie (VOC), 1291, ‘Rapport omtrentde ghelegenheyt van't land Oman in Arabiēn’, 1673.Google Scholar
8 Badger, G.P. ed., Salih Ibn Raziq, History of the Imams and Seyyids of Oman (London 1871) 56.Google Scholar
9 Milburn, J., Oriental Commercel-U (London 1813/Delhi 1999) i, 314–327.Google Scholar
10 Though, as I argued elsewhere in labelling something ‘luxury’ we do not just have to consider the value but their effects on employment and the ‘prestige’ invested in them as well, besides in neither respect textiles were ‘luxury goods’.
11 Note that we know still far too little about West African demand for Indian textiles-and in particular on how it correlated with the indigenous manufacturing there. However, a promising departure to the study of this issue has been made in Roberts, R., ‘West Africa and the Ponducherry Textile Industry’ in: Roy, T. ed., Cloth and Commerce in Colonial India (Walnut Creek 1996) 142–176.Google Scholar
12 See e.g. the excerpts from the Dutch shipping-records of Surat in Furber, John Company, 166, which show one single ship importing treasure to the value of 800,000 rupees - nearly half the estimated imports from Persia in the seventeenth century.
13 Golikova, N.B., Astrakhanskoe vostanije 1706 g. (Moscow 1973) 168–182.Google Scholar
14 ‘Russko-Iranskie torgovl'ie otnosenija v kontse XVII v. nacale XVIII vv.’ Istoriceskie Zapiski 57 (1956) 232–254.Google Scholar
15 Ionissian, A. ed., Armjano-Russkie otnosenija v pervoi tretii XVIII veka (Sbomik, dokumentov) I-II (Erevan 1964) II, 24.Google Scholar
16 Appolova, N.G., Ekonomiceskie i politiceskie svjazi Kazakstana s Rossiei (v XVIII-natsale XIX w.) (Moscow 1960) 229–233.Google Scholar
17 See Steur, J., Herstel of ondergang: de voorstellen tot redres van de V.O.C 1740–1795 (Utrecht 1984) vi.Google Scholar
18 Amin, A. Amir, British Interests in the Persian Gulf (Leiden 1967) 123Google Scholar; ARA, HRB 877, ‘Radicale Beschryvinge van Persien’ by D. van Rheede (1758) and 10.
19 Indeed - the prime case for the seventeenth century crisis in India as I argued in Arabian Seas.
20 See the statistical tables of Astrakhan's in-and exports to Persia in the 1770s and 1780s in Abdulaev, M.G., Politeceskic, ekonomiceskie i socialnogo istorija Azerbaidjana v XVIII v. i vsaim otnosenije ego s Rossiejei (Baku 1967).Google Scholar
21 National Archives of India, Foreign Miscellaneous 55, Report Malabar Commission, fo. 229–231.
22 On the cowrie trade see Hagendoorn, J. and Johnson, M., The Shell-Money of the Slave-Trade (Cambridge 1986).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
23 de Andrade, A.A., Relacoes de Mocambique setlecentista (Lisbon 1955) 220.Google Scholar
24 See my ‘Trade and State in the Arabian Seas: A Survey from the Fifteenth to the Eighteenth Century’, Journal of World History 11 (2) (2000) 221.Google Scholar
25 Lougnon, A., L'île Bourbon pendant la regence: Desbout le Forger, les debuts du caffee (Paris 1956).Google Scholar
26 Matthee, R., ‘Coffee in Safavid Iran: Commerce and Consumption’, Journal of the Economic and Social History of the Orient 37 (1994) 1–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
27 Biblotheca National, Lisbon, Fundo Geral, Códice. 28, fo. 25.
28 For which see Hakima, A.M. Abu, History of Eastern Arabia (Beirut 1965).Google Scholar
29 Griffiths, J., Travels in Europe, Asia Minor and Arabia (London 1805) 389Google Scholar; Kelly, J.B., Britain and the Persian Gulf 1795–1880 (Oxford 1968) 25.Google Scholar
30 See e.g. Knaap, G.'s study of Javanese coastal trade (Shallow Waters, Rising Tide: Shipping and Trade in Java around 1775 (Dordrecht 1996))Google Scholar. This could easily be paralleled by a study of the Cochin boomboekjes from the same period, or for the Goa alfandegas for the waters of the central Konkan were absolutely crawling with small crafts.
31 ARA, HRB 877, ‘Radicale Beschryvinge van Persiēn’ by D. van Rheede (1758) and 11.
32 See the lists of in- and exports from Mozambique in the 1780s (sub tecidos da India) in Lobato, A., Historia do presidio de Lourenco Marques I-II (Lisbon 1960) 328.Google Scholar
33 See Alpers, E.A., ‘Gujarat and the Trade of East Africa’, International Journal of African Historical Studies 9/1 (1976) 368–390Google Scholar (to be used with care since Alpers confuses Parsis, banias and Christian saraswats).
34 Sachdova, V., Policy and Economics of the Punjab in the Late Eighteenth Century (Delhi 1993) 130–165.Google Scholar
35 Ricks, T.M., ‘Slavery in the Persian Gulf in the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Century: An Assessment’ in: Manning, P. ed., Slave Trades 1500–1800: Globalization of Forced Labour (Ashgate 1996) 283.Google Scholar
36 Todd, Travels in Western India, 450.
37 Pankhurst, R. ed., Prutsky's Travels in Ethiopia (London 1991) 61–63.Google Scholar
38 Pankurst, R., An Introduction to the Economic History of Ethiopia (London 1961) 338–356.Google Scholar
39 Milburne, Oriental Commerce I, 89, 326.
40 See the description of the specialist on coastal navigation on the Swahili coast, the late Prins, A.H.J., The Swahili Speaking Peoples of Zanzibar and the East African Coast (London 1961) 65Google Scholar. I have been arguing this contra E.A. Alpers for late seventeenth century Mozambique/Querimba viz. Kilwa.
41 Austen, R., ‘The Nineteenth Century Islamic Slave Trade from East Africa (Swahili and Red Sea Coast): A Tentative Census’ in: Smith, W.G. Clarence ed., The Economics of the Indian Ocean Slave Trade in the Nineteenth Century (London 1989).Google Scholar
42 Toladano, E.R., The Ottoman Slave-Trade and its Suppression: 1840–1890 (Princeton 1989) 142–198.Google Scholar
43 Scarr, D., Slaving and Slavery in the Indian Ocean (London 1998) 20CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Alpers, E.A., Ivory & Slaves in East Africa (London 1975) 127–135.Google Scholar
44 Toussaint, A., Le mirage des lies: Le negoce français aux Mascareignas au XVIIIème siècle (Aix en Provence 1977).Google Scholar
45 See e.g. Deschamps, H., Les pirates à Madagascar au XVII el XVIIIème siècle (Paris 1949 and 1959).Google Scholar
46 Filiot, J.M., La traile des esclaves vers les Mascareignes au XVIIIème siècle (Tanarive 1971)Google Scholar; Daccany, R., L'Île Nossi Bé de Madagascar (Paris 1968).Google Scholar
47 See Carlson, S.'s study on the trade of the Triest Company in Delagoa Bay, Trade and Dependency: Studies in the Expansion of Europe (Upsalla 1984)Google Scholar and Smith, A., ‘Delagoa Bay and the Trade of Southeast Africa’ in: J. Gray and D. Birmingham, Pre-Colonial African Trade Essays on Trade in Central and Eastern Africa before 1900 (London 1970) 267–277.Google Scholar
48 Fauvel, A. ed., Unpublished Documents on the History of the Seychelles Islands Anterior to 1809 (London 1906)Google Scholar; Sainsbury, N. et al. ed., Calendar of State Papers: Colonial Series: America and West-Indies I-XXXXII (London 1860–1969) 1697–1698, 287–289.Google Scholar
49 Polanyi, K., ‘Ports of Trade in Early Civilisation’, Journal of Economic History 23/1 (1963) 30–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
50 Schenk, H., Views on Alleppey: Socio-Historical and Socio-Spatial Perspectives on an Industrial Port-Town in Kerala (South India) (Amsterdam 1986).Google Scholar
51 Issawi, C., The Economic History of Iran (Chicago 1971) 88.Google Scholar
52 Chimnaji and Parasnis, Selections, 160.
53 Thus e.g. in Vengurla - by 1704 a very small port indeed -(VOC 1708, Cochin to Batavia, 30 April 1705,227).
54 The Maria Teresia Thaler is a coin which badly needs closer research - constituting (as it did) a kind of ‘Euro’ for an ‘Islamic common market’ in the early nineteenth century stretching from West Africa across the Sahara to the Swahili coast and the Persian Gulf.
55 Risso, P., Oman and Muscat: An Early Modern History (London 1986) 201.Google Scholar
56 Subramanian, L.K., Indigenous Capitalism and Imperial Expansion: Bombay, Surat and the West Coast (Delhi 1996)Google Scholar. What seems to have happened was that - very much because of the silting of the Tapi - Surat's long-distance trade shifted to ‘new’ ports in Kathiawar, whereas trade was still financed from Surat.
57 On Kilwa see Chittick, H.N., Kilwa: An Islamic Trading City on the East African Coast I-III (Nairobi 1974).Google Scholar
58 Nichols, C.S., The Swahili Coast: Politics, Diplomacy and Trade on the East African Littoral 1789–1856 (London 1971) 77.Google Scholar
59 Chaudhuri, Kirthi, Trade and Civilisation in the Indian Ocean: An Economic History from the Rise of Islam to 1750 (Cambridge 1986).Google Scholar
60 Civilization and Capitalism, 15th–18th Century III (Berkeley 1992), The Perspective of the World (London 1985) 30.
61 And the valis of Mocha were often heavily involved in trade themselves, see: Algemeen Rijksarchief in de Provincie Utrecht, Collectie Huydecooper 621, ‘Instructie door den opperkoopman Johan Jozua Kettelaar op zijn vertreck aen deselfs vervanger Daniel Hogendoorn gegeven d.d. 1 Augustus 1709’ (unpaginated).
62 See Verin, P., The History of Civilisation in Northern Madagascar (Rotterdam 1986)Google Scholar and compare Campbell, G., ‘The Structure of Trade on Madagascar 1750–1823’, International Journal of African Historical Studies 26/1 (1993) 111–148.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
63 See Perlin, F., ‘South Asia and Western Penetration from the Sixteenth to the Nineteenth Century: A Problem of Epistemological Status’, Review 6/2 (1980) 267–306.Google Scholar
64 As in Coupland, R.'s classic East Africa and its Invaders: From the Earliest Times to the Death of Seyyid Said (Oxford 1956).Google Scholar
65 See de Vere Allen, J., Swahili Origins (London 1993).Google Scholar
66 Essai d'histoire global I-III (Paris 1989–1990).
67 Breman, J., Hel dorp in Aziëe als koloniale schijngestalte (Amsterdam 1987).Google Scholar
68 Goodine, R.N., ‘Report on the Village Communities of the Deccan’, Selections from the Records of the Bombay Government IV (Bombay 1865).Google Scholar
69 As Thomas Metcalfe actually well recognised, see Spear, P., Twilight of the Mughals (Cambridge 1951) 85.Google Scholar
70 Kazanov, A., Nomads and the Outside World (Cambridge 1979).Google Scholar
71 See Gommans, J., ‘The Silent Frontier of South Asia AD 1100–1800’ Journal of World History 9/1 (1998) 1–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
72 Garthwaite, S.K., ‘Pastoral Nomadism and Tribal Power’, Iranian Studies 11 (1978) 173–97CrossRefGoogle Scholar; J. Smith, ‘Turianian Nomadism and Iranian Polities’, Ibid., 57–83.
73 As in Beck, L., The Qashga'i of Iran (Yale 1986) 44–52Google Scholar or in the Qajar genealogy of e-Fasai, Hasan's, History of Persia under Qajar Rule [transl. Busse, H.] (New York 1972)].Google Scholar
74 Lapidus, I.M., ‘Tribes and State Formation in Islamic History’ in: Khoury, P.S. and Kostiker, J. eds, Tribes and State Formation in the Middle East (London/New York 1991) 42.Google Scholar
75 On late Safavid administration see Mathee, R., ‘Administrative Stability and Change in Late Seventeenth Century Iran’, International Journal of Middle Eastern Studies 26/1 (1994) 77–98CrossRefGoogle Scholar and, of course, V.V. Minorsky ed., The tadhikarat al-muluk: A Manual of Safavid Administration (London 1943) for- though in common with Islamic statecraft in general - there was in the Safavid administration a tendency to leave offices empty rather than scrap them, so that much of the central administration described in the Tadhikarat was empty.
76 Forrest, Selections I, 183: ‘the coolies to the northeast of the Myhie are indeed ready to receive anyone who flees to them for protection and they are to be hired in numbers for any purpose’.
77 Chowdhury, S. Nag, The Vagrant Peasant: Agrarian Distress and Depression in the Bengal Presidency (Wiesbaden 1982).Google Scholar
78 Heesterman, J.C., ‘The Hindu Frontier’, Itinerario 12/1 (1989) 1–17.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
79 ‘Merchant-State Relations in Surat’ in: Haynes, S.D. and Prakash, G. eds, Contesting Power: Resistance and Everyday Social Relations in South Asia (Delhi 1991).Google Scholar
80 Bouchon, G., ‘Les Musulmans du Kerala à l'époque de la découverte portugaise’, Mare Luso Indicum 2 (1973) 3–59.Google Scholar
81 Bibliotheca National, Lisbon, Fundo Geral, Códice, 580, fo. 28.
82 Punekar, V.B., The Son Kolis of Bombay (Bombay 1959).Google Scholar
83 Schrieke, B., Indonesian Sociological Studies I-II (The Hague 1955–1957).Google Scholar
84 Whitcombe Clarke, Central Gujarat, 43, passim.
85 And for this reason, despite my admiration for his intentions I am not quite sure whether mid-nineteenth century revenue-material can really be used to reconstruct Indian agrarian history during the last millennium as Ludden, David does in his Peasant History in South India (Princeton 1973).Google Scholar
86 Jervis, T.B., Geographical and Statistical Memoir of the Konkan (Calcutta 1840).Google Scholar
87 Most Portuguese agrarian legislation relating to the gavcari-system has been published in: F. Nero Xavier, Bosquejo histórico das communidades das ilhas de Goa, de Bardes e de Salcete I-II (Nova Goa); Souza, T.R., Medieval Goa: A Socio-Economic History (New Delhi 1976).Google Scholar
88 Bilgrami, Azad, Khizana i-'amira (Cawnpur 1871) 47Google Scholar quoted in I. Habib, ‘The Eighteenth Century in Indian Economic History’, 225.
89 Sharma, G.R., Saraswata Bhusana (Bombay 1950)Google Scholar; Conlon, F.F., A Caste in a Changing World: The Chitrapur Saraswat Brahmins (New Delhi 1977).Google Scholar
90 ‘Littoral et intérieur de l'Inde’ in: Wesseling, H. ed., History and Underdevelopment (Leiden 1979) 91.Google Scholar
91 ‘Dyo e melquajaz e suas rendas’ (re-published) in: K.S. Mathews ed., Portuguese and the Sultanate of Gujarat (1500–1573) (Delhi 1986) 152–155.
92 Birdwood, K.C., Report on the Old Records Preserved in the India Office (London 1861) 65.Google Scholar
93 ARA, Collectie Hoppe Koloniaal Archief no. 8448, ‘Consideratieen van de directeur Jan Schreuder over de vrije vaart en handel’ and 124.
94 Murphy, Roads, The Outsiders: The European Experience in India and China (Ann Arbor 1977).Google Scholar
95 Next to the newer work of Subramanyan and Torri a good study of British expansion is still Nightingale, P., Trade and Empire in Western India 1784–1806 (Cambridge 1970).Google Scholar
96 Thompson, E. and Garret, S.T., Rise and Fulfilment of British Rule in India (London 1935).Google Scholar
97 If at the same time - as the evidence seems to suggest - more money was flowing into Western India via the Gulf than was being involved in the drain to Britain, then the drain would have had merely local effects in Bengal and Bihar, rather than on the Indian economy as a whole. As has, for example, been argued by Habib, I., ‘Colonisation of the Indian Economy’, Essays in Indian History (New Delhi 1995) 303.Google Scholar
98 Rajasthan being the exception here: Singh, D., The State, Landlords and Peasants: Rajasthan in he Eighteenth Century (New Delhi 1990)Google Scholar and Gupta, S.P., The Agrarian System of Eastern Rajasthan c. 1650–1750 (Delhi 1986).Google Scholar
99 Markowits, C., The Global World of Indian Merchants 1750–1947 (Cambridge 2000).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
100 Goldstone, J., Revolutions and Rebellions in the Early Modern World (Berkeley 1991) 459.Google Scholar
