The volcanic ash problem
Abstract
Explosive volcanic eruptions are the result of intensive magma and rock fragmentation, and they produce volcanic ash, which consists of fragments <2 mm in average diameter. The problem with volcanic ash is that its formation is poorly understood from the standpoint of eruption energetics. Because the source of explosive eruption energy should be the thermal energy of magma, and because an explosion requires rapid conversion of energy into a mechanical form, and because of the physical properties of magma thermal energy is dominantly released by conduction, the energy release on a short time scale (explosion) in volcanic processes has to be the result of a special mechanism, probably a positive feedback mechanism of fragmentation and heat exchange. In fact, the most explosive volcanic explosions are characterized by the most intensive fragmentation. In any fragmentation mechanism the generated particle sizes reflect the kinetic energy available (i.e. the fragmentation energy density). Consequently, fine ash (≤64 μm) provides information on fragmentation mechanisms that are the most energetic and related to the highest explosive energy release. In this letter we discuss mechanisms of formation of fine volcanic ash, using experimental results, theoretical considerations, and field observations. We focus on the potency of these mechanisms to explain fine ash produced by explosive volcanism. We conclude that quantitative analysis of fine ash particles is necessary to estimate the mechanical energy of volcanic explosions.
Section snippets
Acknowledgements
The work by K.W. was done under the auspices of the US Department of Energy. The experimental work was supported in the frame of the DFG Schwerpunktprogramm SPP 1055.
References (9)
- O. Navon et al.
Bubble growth in highly viscous melts: theory, experiments, and autoexplosivity of dome lavas
Earth Planet. Sci. Lett.
(1998) - R.S.J. Sparks
Dynamics of bubble formation and growth in magmas – review and analysis
J. Volcanol. Geotherm. Res.
(1978) - R. Büttner et al.
Identifying modes of magma/water interaction from the surface features of ash particles
Nature
(1999) - Chandrasekhar, S., 1968. Hydrodynamic and Hydromagnetic Stability, 2nd edn. Oxford Univ. Press,...
Cited by (124)
Observing ocean ecosystem responses to volcanic ash
2023, Remote Sensing of EnvironmentVolcanic eruptions can be catastrophic events, particularly when they occur in inhabited coastal environments. They also play important roles in climate and biogeochemical cycles, including through nutrient deposition in the ocean. Volcanic ash studies in the ocean have focused on the phytoplankton response, generally quantifying changes in chlorophyll-a concentration. Many gaps remain in addressing fundamental questions regarding why volcanic ash deposition may enhance or limit both phytoplankton growth and/or drive community composition shifts. Here we outline a wide, multidisciplinary vision for monitoring volcanic eruptions near ocean ecosystems from satellites, including considerations for characteristics of airborne volcanic ash and ash geochemistry in seawater. Ultimately, observations beyond chlorophyll-a are needed to quantify phytoplankton communities (including harmful algal blooms) and possible impacts across higher trophic levels. We synthesize relevant research from volcanic studies as well as atmospheric and ocean sciences to identify the ‘known unknowns’ in ash-ecosystem studies. Our goal is to move toward an improved understanding of how real-time and near-real-time monitoring of volcanic eruptions can help address societally relevant questions.
Morphological and textural analysis of basaltic pyroclasts (Atexcac maar, central Mexico): Implications for fragmentation and conduit processes
2022, Journal of South American Earth SciencesAtexcac is a maar volcano, which forms part of the monogenetic volcanic field of the Serdán-Oriental Basin, in the eastern sector of the Mexican Volcanic Belt. This volcanic landform was originated by a combination of phreatic, magmatic and phreatomagmatic explosive eruptions. During the formation of the distinct depositional facies, fluctuations in the water availability of the local aquifer, as well as in the magma flux, were probably responsible for the different mechanisms of magmatic and phreatomagmatic fragmentation and the production of the two main populations of fragments (breccia and cross-bedded deposits particles), whose morphological features, allow us to infer the dominant regime (brittle or ductile), fragmentation mechanism (magmatic or phreatomagmatic) and conditions of bubble growth dynamics and fragmentation processes during the ascent of magma through the conduit. We conclude that the breccia particles were derived from dominant magmatic explosions while the cross-bedded deposits particles are thought to be generated from explosive phreatomagmatic events. 3D imaging based on high-precision X-ray microtomography was used to determine the vesicularity of juvenile fragments of the Atexcac maar. Calculated vesicularity index, vesicle number density (VND) and vesicle morphology indicate important processes of coalescence of gas bubbles, during the ascent of the magma. VND's Atexcac clasts suggests vesicle mechanisms similar to medium-intensity eruptions, reported in the literature. The elongated and polylobular vesicle morphology of the Atexcac clasts reveals early acceleration of magma and subsequent coalescence events at most stages of gas bubble growth.
Diverse evidence for grasslands since the Eocene in Patagonia
2021, Journal of South American Earth SciencesTiming and ecological steps of the rise and expansion of grasslands differ not only geographically but also according to the type of available information. Patagonia (Argentina) was largely considered the region where grasslands and grazers early evolved in the Eocene, mostly based on functional morphology of mammals. However, recent paleobotanical studies question this traditional view and maintain that this occurred after early Miocene. To tackle this discrepancy, we conduct a multidisciplinary and integrative approach using diverse lines of evidence obtained from middle Eocene - middle Miocene tuffaceous deposits of central and northern Patagonia. Gathered data correspond to sedimentary facies, paleosols, insect trace fossils, opal phytoliths and fossil mammals (tooth morphology, body size). Long-lasting and frequent volcanic ashfalls caused permanent disturbances in physical scenarios, biotic systems and grassy habitats; just like herbivory of mammals through coevolutionary grass-grazer mechanisms. The results indicate that soils, vegetation, insects and mammal herbivores begun synchronously to record diverse traits related to grasslands showing mosaic vegetation since middle Eocene (~44 Ma). These traits include mollic paleosols, abundant and persistent dung beetle trace fossils (Coprinisphaera ichnofacies), phytolith assemblages attributable to savannas and medium to large-size hypsodont mammals. We also track the evolutionary history after the reduction of closed forests, recognizing alternating subhumid savannas with riparian forests, where the relative frequency between grasses, palms, trees and shrubs fluctuated in time and space; and desert vegetation (shrublands) dominated by palms and shrubs during dryer periods. The advent and expansion of grasslands can be linked to the cooling and drying period subsequent to the Early Eocene Climate Optimum.
Geochemical and mineralogical composition of the 2018 volcanic deposits of Mt. Anak Krakatau
2021, Geoderma RegionalMount Anak Krakatau erupted on 22nd December 2018, resulting in a large deposit of fresh volcanoclastic materials on the island's surface. As the age of these new soil materials is known precisely, and the island is isolated from human activities, studying the ash and pyroclastic materials of Anak Krakatau will provide insights on the first stages of pedogenesis in tropical volcanic regions. This paper reports for the first time the chemical and geochemical characteristics of the fresh volcanic materials of Mt. Anak Krakatau. Samples were collected at 63 days and 82 days after the eruption. Remobilization of newly deposit volcanic materials occurred immediately after the eruption. Rill and gully erosion were observed on the surface of the island. Two types of samples were collected and analysed: volcanic ash (< 2 mm) and lapilli (2–64 mm). The pHH2O of the samples had a mean value of 5.9 (std. dev. 0.6). The CEC of the materials was very low but variable (3.11 ± 2.3 cmolc kg−1) and the cations were easily leached (Mg > Ca > K > Na). Microscopic analysis and XRD patterns showed that the materials were dominated by plagioclases, with labradorite being the dominant species. XRF analysis indicated that there were two types of volcanic materials: the first group had lower SiO2 concentration (mean 39%) and lower Al2O3 (mean 10%) but a higher concentration of Fe2O3 (mean 18.9%), CaO (15.6%), K2O (1.7%), SO4 (2.9%), P2O5 (2.8%), and heavier elements (Mn, Zn, Cu, Ti, Sr, Zr, Cr) and Ag2O (0.76%). The second group was more common with basaltic-andesitic composition with a mean concentration of 54.9% SiO2, 17.2% Al2O3, and 8.5% Fe2O3. Anak Krakatau eruptions and volcanic deposits are rare events; basic information provided in this report offers valuable information on the initial stage of pedogenesis and can be used as a baseline for future pedogenesis study.
Late Pleistocene to Holocene activity of Alchichica maar volcano, eastern Trans-Mexican Volcanic Belt
2020, Journal of South American Earth SciencesDetailed volcano-stratigraphy and 40Ar/39Ar dating are used for the first time to reconstruct the eruptive evolution of the Alchichica maar and to contribute to the understanding of maar volcanism within the eastern Trans-Mexican Volcanic Belt (TMVB). The maar excavated in an area where previous eruptions included Hawaiian, Strombolian, and phreatomagmatic types. Alchichica is characterized by an irregular shape tephra ring with a bulk volume of ∼0.088 km3 based on high-resolution digital terrain model calculations. The maar deposits comprises two stratigraphic units (lower and upper) with contrasting lithofacies characteristics suggesting different depositional conditions and variations in eruption behavior. These units correspond to: (1) vent-clearing stage with explosions producing a succession of massive tuff-breccia intercalated with massive lapilli-tuffs; (2) pulsating phreatomagmatic eruptions producing a series of accretionary lapilli-rich tuffs that alternate with dominantly well-stratified tuffs and lapilli-tuffs deposited from pyroclastic density currents. The geochronological data provide first constraints about the young age (Late Pleistocene-Holocene) of the Alchichica maar. The presence of the maar and some of the other pre-maar eruptions suggest long-lasting dispersed volcanism in a well-defined, but small area, where rejuvenated monogenetic vents cut into earlier ones, having significant implications for hazard assessments in the region.
SO<inf>2</inf> scrubbing during percolation through rhyolitic volcanic domes
2019, Geochimica et Cosmochimica ActaAccurate estimates of the atmospheric impacts of large eruptions on the environment are complicated by a paucity of models for gas-magma or gas-rock interactions that can occur in the subsurface. It is in these environments that high-temperature scavenging of magmatic gases, released during eruptions, may play a major role, resulting in significant time-dependence of the bulk gas budget of the major erupted volatile species. Recent experimental work has identified the principal mechanisms involved in high-temperature scavenging in SO2- and HCl-dominated gas environments, but has neglected the effect of humidity and in-dome gas-magma reactions. Here we present scaled experimental results for the scavenging potential in SO2-H2O mixtures using rhyolitic glass particles above the acid dew point at 200–800 °C. First, we reproduce previous results for anhydrous SO2 scavenging. Such scavenging is accommodated by the growth of CaSO4 crystals on the surface of glass present on ash and limited by the temperature- and particle size-dependent diffusion of Ca2+ to the surface of the glass. Subordinate concentrations of Na2SO4 and potassium-bearing salts also grow on the glass surfaces. Na+ and K+ diffusion appear to be the limiting mechanisms for the formation of these salts, but once the bulk glass network is relaxed and equilibrates oxidation state above ∼600 °C, the diffusion of these cations is inhibited by charge compensation with Fe3+. In SO2-H2O mixed-gas atmospheres, the diffusion of Ca2+ appears unaffected by the activity of H2O on the ash surface. In contrast, the diffusion of Na+ and K+ toward the ash surface is enhanced. We speculate that this occurs by alkali exchange with inward diffusing H+. In hydrous atmospheres, the diffusion of Na+ and K+ is also markedly less at the threshold oxidation temperature. This oxidation temperature is reduced to lower values as the water activity at the surface is increased by increasing the partial pressure of H2O. Taken together, these results enable the exploration of scenarios for in-dome processes where either open-system or batch outgassing prevails through fractures filled with populations of welding volcanic ash. Such scenarios predict that a large fraction of the SO2 flowing through the ash-filled fracture networks may be scavenged in permeable fractured domes, which act as scrubbing filters, potentially explaining some unexpectedly low SO2 emissions from rhyolitic dome-forming eruptions.