The epidemiology of rape and sexual coercion in South Africa: an overview
Introduction
In 1995, the Human Rights Watch report on domestic violence and rape, dubbed South Africa the ‘rape capital of the world’ and, citing a figure which had been quoted for some years by NGOs, asserted that there were 35 rapes for every one reported to the police (Human Rights Watch, 1995). When this figure was made centre piece in a prime time TV advertisement, the President responded defensively by questioning its basis. Investigation suggested that the figure had possibly just been made up. There was an ensuing high profile debate about the use of statistics on rape and although consensus that there was too much rape in South Africa was readily reached, disagreement about the magnitude of the problem has continued. The aim of this paper is to review the available data on the epidemiology of rape in South Africa. The data is prefaced by a discussion of the difficulties in arriving at the rape statistic for the country, both conceptual difficulties and barriers to reporting. In the final section we discuss the findings of the review and the implications of our experiences of rape research in South Africa for understanding of rape and sexual coercion internationally.
Section snippets
What is rape?
In terms of common law, rape is committed by a man having intentional and unlawful sexual intercourse with a woman without her consent (South African Law Commission, 1999). New sexual offences legislation is currently being drafted and discussion documents (South African Law Commission, 1999) have indicated that it will include a declaration that sexual penetration is unlawful if it occurs in coercive circumstances, which include the application of force, threats, abuse of power or authority,
Causal and contributory factors in sexual coercion
The question: why do we have so much rape? Is much more difficult to answer. Research on causal and contributory factors in rape internationally is some what limited and fragmented. In South Africa, most of the work has been based on rape in the relationships of youth, rather than on stranger rape, rape of children or of older women and important work based on very long term fieldwork amongst young men and women is still in progress (Wood K., pers. comm.). Rape is a difficult area to study.
Discussion
This paper set out to provide an overview of available statistics on rape from crime information systems and results of representative studies of rape and sexual coercion and to piece together the fragments of data which are available from other research which provide additional insights into the problem of sexual coercion in South Africa. It has shown that national data on rape is highly sensitive to the source of information, the way in which questions are framed and the definition of rape.
Uncited References
Statistics South Afirca (2000).
Acknowledgements
Many thanks to Jonathan Levin who analysed the data for the Three Province Study and Desiree Pieterse who made the table for the SA Demographic and Health Survey. Also to Katharine Wood who has helped to shape many of the ideas about rape causal and contributory factors.
References (47)
- et al.
Relationship dynamics and adolescent pregnancy in South Africa
Social Science and Medicine
(2001) - Abrahams, N., Jewkes, R., & Laubscher, R. (1999). I do not believe in democracy in the home. Men on relationships with...
- Araji, S., Finkelhor, D. (1986). Abusers: a review of research. In: D. Finkelhov (Ed.) A source book on child sexual...
- Artz, L. (1999). Access to Justice for Rural Women: Special Focus on Violence Against Women. Report: Institute of...
- AVSC. (1998). Men as partners. New York:...
- et al.
Sexual behaviour, contraceptive practices and reproductive health among school adolescents in rural Transkei
South African Medical Journal
(1996) - CIET Africa. (1998). Prevention of sexual violence. A social Audit of the role of the police in the jurisdiction of...
- CIET Africa. (2000). Beyond victims and villains. The culture of sexual violence in south Johannesburg. Johannesburg:...
- Crime Information Analysis Centre. (2000). South African police service crime statistics....
- Department of Health. (1999). 1998 South Africa. Demographic and Health Survey: Preliminary report. Pretoria:...