Chondrocyte-seeded hydroxyapatite for repair of large articular cartilage defects. A pilot study in the goat

doi:10.1016/S0142-9612(98)00158-6

Biomaterials

Volume 19, Issue 24, December 1998, Pages 2367-2374

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0142-9612(98)00158-6 Get rights and content

Abstract

The aim of this study was to evaluate the potential for restoration of a large cartilage defect in the goat knee with hydroxyapatite (HA) loaded with chondrocytes. Isolated chondrocytes were suspended in fibrin glue, seeded on top of the HA, and then the composite graft was implanted in the defect. After transplantation, cell behaviour, newly synthesised matrix and the HA–glue interface were assessed histologically after 2, 4, 12, 26 and 52 weeks. Special attention was paid to the incorporation process of HA in the subchondral bone and interactions between this biomaterial and the fibrin-glue–chondrocyte suspension.

Chondrocytes in the glue proved to survive the transplantation procedure and produced new metachromatically stained matrix two weeks after implantation. The glue–cell suspension had penetrated the superficial porous structure of the HA. Four weeks after surgery, islands of hyaline-like cartilage were observed at the HA–glue interface. A layer of fibrous tissue was formed surrounding the HA graft, resulting in a relatively instable fixation of the HA in the defect. This instability of the graft in the defect, possibly together with early weight bearing, resulted in a gradual loss of the newly formed hyaline cartilage-like repair tissue. Progressive resorption of the HA occurred without any sign of active bone remodelling from the host site. One year after surgery part of the defect which extended down to the cancellous bone had been predominantly restored with newly formed lamellar bone. Only small HA remnants were still present at the bottom of the original defect. Resurfacing of the joint had occurred with fibrocartilaginous repair tissue.

The absence of adequate fixation capacity of the HA near the joint space resulted in a relative instability of the graft with progressive resorption. Therefore, HA is not a suitable biomaterial to facilitate the repair of large articular cartilage defects.

References (0)

Cited by (86)

Instabilities induced by mechanical loading determine the viability of chondrocytes grown on porous scaffolds
2023, Journal of Biomechanics
Tissue-engineered cartilage constructs have shown promise to treat focal cartilage defects in multiple clinical studies. Notably, products in clinical use or in late-stage clinical trials often utilize porous collagen scaffolds to provide mechanical support and attachment sites for chondrocytes. Under loading, both the local mechanical responses of collagen scaffolds and the corresponding cellular outcomes are poorly understood, despite their wide use. As such, the architecture of collagen scaffolds varies significantly among tissue-engineered cartilage products, but the effects of such architectures on construct mechanics and cell viability are not well understood. This study investigated the effects of local mechanical responses of collagen scaffolds on chondrocyte viability in tissue-engineered cartilage constructs. We utilized fast confocal microscopy combined with a strain mapping technique to analyze the architecture-dependent instabilities under quasi-static loading and subsequent chondrocyte death in honeycomb and sponge scaffolds. More specifically, we compared the isotropic and the orthotropic planes for each type of collagen scaffold. Under compression, both planes exhibited elastic, buckled, and densified deformation modes. In both loading directions, cell death was minimal in regions that experienced elastic deformation mode and a trend of increase in buckled mode. More interestingly, we saw a significant increase in cell death in densified mode. Overall, this study suggests that local instabilities are directly correlated to chondrocyte death in tissue-engineered cartilage constructs, highlighting the importance of understanding the architecture-dependent local mechanical responses under loading.
Analysis of the mechanical effects of defect shape on damage evolution of articular cartilage under rolling load
2018, Materials Science and Engineering C
Citation Excerpt :
Gratz et al. [15] found that the slip deformation of a notch with an 80° trapezoidal cross section was larger than that of a 100° trapezoidal cross section in full thickness cartilage under compressive loading. The literature also confirmed that the repair of cartilage with a 100° trapezoidal cross section defect, used by van Susante et al. [44], was better than cartilage with an 80° trapezoidal section, as used by Raub et al. [45]. We can infer that damage evolution velocity of cartilage with a rectangular cross-sectional defect is the slowest in our results, and a gap with a cylindrical shape is optimal in cartilage repair.
To study the mechanical effects of defect shape on the damage evolution of knee cartilage and find the causes of fragments, so as to obtain damage evolution rules and determine the most appropriate shape used in a clinical repair. A porous viscoelasticity fiber-reinforced 2D numerical model with different micro-defect shapes was established which considered the depth-dependent Young's modulus, fiber distribution, porosity and permeability. The stress-strain relationship, interstitial hydraulic and interstitial flow velocity was obtained under rolling load. The results showed that damage developed at the bottom corner of the defect, preferentially deep within the cartilage tangential to the fibers direction, and then extended to the surface along adjacent fibers, finally forming fragments. In the early stages of damage, the shear stress and interstitial flow velocity within cartilage with a rectangular cross-sectional defect were the lowest, while interstitial hydraulic pressure was the highest, followed by 100° trapezoid and semicircle, and finally 80° trapezoid defects. In the later stage of damage, the results were very similar. The shear strain, interstitial flow velocity and interstitial hydraulic pressure decreased with increasing defect depth. Therefore, defect shape only affected damage evolution in the early stages. The fragments in cartilage were the result of the damage evolution which sizes were correlated with the initial defect depth. The damage velocity of cartilage with a rectangular section-incision was the slowest. Finally, we concluded that cylindrical incisions are optimal in clinical surgery. These results provide a theoretical basis for the clinical interpretation of pathological degeneration and repair therapy.
Elastomeric biomaterials for tissue engineering
2013, Progress in Polymer Science
Citation Excerpt :
The fibrin clot structure and composition, concentration of fibrinogen and protein factor XIII (which mediates crosslinking) considerably influence the elastic modulus and tensile strength of fibrin clots [504–507]. The modulus of fibrin was reported to be ∼50 Pa [508], and insufficient mechanical support was reported to be the main drawback of fibrin for its application in articular cartilage repair strategies tested in animal models [509]. Fibrin is subject to enzyme-mediated hydrolytic degradation, known as fibrinolysis both in vivo and in vitro.
Biomaterials play a critical role in engineering of tissue constructs, working as an artificial extracellular matrix to support regeneration. Because the elastic stretchability is a major mechanical property of many tissue types, huge efforts have been invested into the development of elastomeric biomaterials that mimic that of native tissue. Indeed, for the repair of most soft tissue types, one of the major problems encountered by biomaterials scientists has been difficulty in simply replicating this complex elasticity. This article provides a comprehensive review on the elastomeric biomaterials used in tissue engineering. Definitions of biomaterials, biocompatibility and elasticity in the context of tissue engineering are introduced. This is followed by systematic review of thermoplastic rubbers, chemically crosslinked elastomers, elastic proteins and elastomer-based ceramic-filled composites. Each section includes a detailed description of the chemical synthesis of the polymer critical to understanding of its unique properties, followed by discussion of its biocompatibility and biodegradability, two essential features of biomaterials in most tissue engineering applications. The mechanical properties and applications in tissue engineering are then reviewed for each polymer in great detail, with identification of specific challenges for its current and ongoing application in the field. Finally, the major achievements and remaining challenges for elastomeric biomaterials are summarized, with emphasis on the most important candidates to date.
Application of albumin-grafted scaffolds to promote neocartilage formation
2012, Colloids and Surfaces B: Biointerfaces
Citation Excerpt :
Thus, the pore surface of scaffolds is usually modified by bioactive motif. For example, human fibronectin, hydroxyapatite, polyethyleneimine, heparin, chondroitin sulfate, and laminin-derived peptide have been coated on the material surfaces for culturing chondrocytes [18–28]. Human serum albumin comprises 585 amino acid residues with a molecular weight of 66.5 kDa and contains 35 cysteinyl residues with one sulfhydryl group and 17 disulfide bonds [29].
This study investigates the capacity of albumin-grafted biomaterials as tissue engineering scaffolds to regenerate cartilaginous components. Porcine knee chondrocytes were seeded and cultivated in porous ternary matrix consisting of polyethylene oxide, chitin, and chitosan with surface albumin. The results revealed that the quantity of albumin did not affect the viability of porcine knee chondrocytes in the constructs. However, a high grafting concentration of albumin favored the adhesion of porcine knee chondrocytes on the scaffolding pore surface. After cultivation over 4 weeks, an increase in the concentration of albumin enhanced the quantities of porcine knee chondrocytes, glycosaminoglycans, and collagen in the constructs. The histological staining of porcine knee chondrocytes showed an active chondrocytic growth in the albumin-grafted constructs. In addition, the safranin-O staining indicated that the surface albumin could stabilize the secretion of glycosaminoglycans. Moreover, the immunochemical staining against type II collagen exhibited a regular production of collagen by phenotypic porcine knee chondrocytes in the constructs. Albumin-grafted polyethylene oxide/chitin/chitosan scaffolds can be a promising biomimetic substrate in neocartilage formation.
Construction of osteochondral-like tissue graft combining β-tricalcium phosphate block and scaffold-free centrifuged chondrocyte cell sheet
2011, Journal of Orthopaedic Science
The combination of a β-tricalcium phosphate (βTCP) block with a scaffold-free chondrocyte sheet formed by the centrifugation of chondrocytes in a well was investigated with the aim of constructing an osteochondral-like structure.
Human and porcine articular cartilage chondrocytes were respectively centrifuged in a 96-well plate or cell culture insert (0.32 cm²) that was set in a 24-well plate, cultivated in the respective vessel for 3 weeks, and the cell sheets were harvested. In some cases, a cylindrical βTCP block (diameter 5 mm, height 3 mm) was placed on the sheet on days 1–7. The sheet size, cell number, and sulfated glycosaminoglycan accumulation were determined.
The use of a 96-well plate for not suspension but adhesion culture and the initial centrifugation of a well containing cells were crucial to obtaining a uniformly thick cell sheet. The glycosaminoglycan density of the harvested cell sheet was comparable to that of the pellet culture. An inoculum cell number of more than 31 × 10⁵ cells tended to result in a curved cell sheet. Culture involving 18.6 × 10⁵ cells and the 96-well plate for adhesion culture showed no curving of the cell sheet (thickness of 0.85 mm), and these were found to be the best of the culture conditions tested. The timing of the addition of a βTCP block to the cell sheet (1–7 days) markedly affected the balance between the thickness of cell sheet parts on and in the βTCP block.
Centrifugation and subsequent cultivation of chondrocytes (18.6 × 10⁵ cells) in a 96-well plate for adhesion culture led to the production of a scaffold-free cartilage-like cell sheet with a thickness of 0.85 mm. A combined osteochondral-like structure was produced by putting a βTCP block on the cell sheet. The thickness of the cell sheet on the βTCP block and the binding strength between the cell sheet and the βTCP block could be optimized by adjusting the inoculum cell number and timing of βTCP block addition.
Calcification of cartilage formed in vitro on calcium polyphosphate bone substitutes is regulated by inorganic polyphosphate
2010, Acta Biomaterialia
A major challenge to the successful clinical application of bioengineered cartilage remains its integration to surrounding tissues upon implantation. One way to address this consists of generating biphasic constructs composed of articular cartilage formed in vitro on the top surface and integrated with the porous sub-surface of a bone substitute material – in the case of this study, calcium polyphosphate (CPP). To improve the mechanical integrity of the cartilage–bone substitute interface, attempts have been made to generate a zone of calcified cartilage (ZCC) within the CPP–cartilage interface, thereby mimicking the native joint architecture. The purpose of this work was to establish the effects of the degradation products of CPP on cartilage calcification in order to explain the observed positioning of a ZCC away from the interface junction. It was determined that polyphosphate released from the CPP accumulates within in vitro-grown cartilage and inhibits cartilage calcification in a concentration and chain length (i.e. molecular weight) dependent manner. It was found that this effect is transient as chondrocytes express exopolyphosphatases which hydrolyze polyphosphate to release orthophosphate. Hence, the generation of biphasic constructs with a properly located ZCC will require tailoring of CPP substrates with lower degradation rates or the upregulation of exopolyphosphatases by chondrocytes.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text