Modeling ecotoxicity impacts in vineyard production: Addressing spatial differentiation for copper fungicides

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2017.10.243Get rights and content

Highlights

  • USEtox 2.02 was used to compare the freshwater ecotoxicity impacts of 12 fungicides AI.

  • Impacts for Cu(II) vary ~ 3 orders of magnitude among the 7 European water types analyzed.

  • Site-dependent characterization factors for Cu(II) in 15,034 European vineyards soils were derived.

  • Soil impacts for Cu(II) vary 2 orders according to different agricultural scenarios.

  • Including spatial differentiation in copper hazard for LCA provide more accurate results in toxicity impact evaluation.

Abstract

Application of plant protection products (PPP) is a fundamental practice for viticulture. Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) has proved to be a useful tool to assess the environmental performance of agricultural production, where including toxicity-related impacts for PPP use is still associated with methodological limitations, especially for inorganic (i.e. metal-based) pesticides. Downy mildew is one of the most severe diseases for vineyard production. For disease control, copper-based fungicides are the most effective and used PPP in both conventional and organic viticulture. This study aims to improve the toxicity-related characterization of copper-based fungicides (Cu) for LCA studies. Potential freshwater ecotoxicity impacts of 12 active ingredients used to control downy mildew in European vineyards were quantified and compared. Soil ecotoxicity impacts were calculated for specific soil chemistries and textures. To introduce spatial differentiation for Cu in freshwater and soil ecotoxicity characterization, we used 7 European water archetypes and a set of 15,034 non-calcareous vineyard soils for 4 agricultural scenarios. Cu ranked as the most impacting substance for potential freshwater ecotoxicity among the 12 studied active ingredients. With the inclusion of spatial differentiation, Cu toxicity potentials vary 3 orders of magnitude, making variation according to water archetypes potentially relevant. In the case of non-calcareous soils ecotoxicity characterization, the variability of Cu impacts in different receiving environments is about 2 orders of magnitude. Our results show that Cu potential toxicity depends mainly on its capacity to interact with the emission site, and the dynamics of this interaction (speciation). These results represent a better approximation to understand Cu potential toxicity impact profiles, assisting decision makers to better understand copper behavior concerning the receiving environment and therefore how restrictions on the use of copper-based fungicides should be considered in relation to the emission site.

Introduction

Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) is a comprehensive methodology that aims at quantifying the potential environmental impacts of any product system over its entire lifecycle (ISO-14040, 2006). Within the agricultural sector, LCA has proven to be useful for assessing the environmental performance of many cropping systems (Boone et al., 2016, Parajuli et al., 2017, Torrellas et al., 2012). However, often a limited number of impact categories is evaluated in comparative LCAs of agricultural systems (Meier et al., 2015). Although plant protection products (PPP) are routinely applied in agriculture, one of the critical points within the life cycle impact assessment (LCIA) phase in LCAs of agricultural systems is the lack of characterizing potential toxicity-related impacts for PPP use in crop production. This lack is even more apparent when it comes to the evaluation of inorganic pesticides (i.e. metal-based pesticides), approved for organic farming, as these are not as well understood and characterized as synthetic1 pesticides. Furthermore, freshwater ecotoxicity is among those LCIA impact categories that, only in recent years, has started to be considered mature enough for inclusion in LCA studies.

Nowadays, the European Commission authorizes > 500 active ingredients2 (AI). Around 340,000 tons of PPP are used each year in Europe (EU28), from which fungicides represent the most used AI in conventional and organic agriculture, with a total annual use in the EU28 of 169,000 t for 2014. Furthermore, Inorganic fungicides account for 39–55% of the total applied fungicides in the EU (European Comission, 2009, Eurostat, 2016). PPP have become vital elements in modern agriculture as they provide many benefits, but their extensive and continuous applications also have several negative implications for the environment. Some of these implications include human exposure to crop residues (Fantke et al., 2012), potential impacts on non-target organisms (Felsot et al., 2010), a shift in dominating pest species and increasing pest resistance (Pimentel, 2005). The two latter problems, in turn, push crop growers towards an even more intensified use of PPP, and consequently, crop production costs rise, and potential risks of toxic impacts on humans and the environment may further increase (Nesheim et al., 2015).

European vineyards represent > 50% of the total world area of vines (OIV, 2016), and the long-term use of PPP in vineyards has contributed to increased concentrations of these substances in different environmental compartments (Hildebrandt et al., 2008, Ribolzi et al., 2002, Wightwick et al., 2008). Concerning PPP use, one of the main differences between conventional and organic viticulture production is that in general synthetic pesticides are not allowed for use in organic pest management, whereas inorganic pesticides are indispensable for organic vine cultivation.

Furthermore, copper-based fungicides are the most efficient and widely used PPP in Europe in both conventional and organic viticulture to control vine fungal diseases, such as downy mildew caused by Plasmopara viticola, one of the most severe and devastating diseases for grapevine (Agrios, 2005). Therefore, the extensive use of fungicides to control this and other fungal pests has posed significant environmental problems, such as unwanted residues in plants and water, reduction of the quality and degradation of soils, as well as some ecotoxicological threats in non-target organisms (Fantke et al., 2011a, Komarek et al., 2010).

Different studies have evaluated the environmental profile of viticulture and wine production from a life cycle perspective (Bartocci et al., 2017, Benedetto, 2013, Point et al., 2012). In line with LCA studies of other agricultural systems, one of the repeatedly assessed impact category for viticulture is the evaluation of global warming potential (Bosco et al., 2011, Steenwerth et al., 2015) with particular focus on water or carbon footprint indicators (Bonamente et al., 2016, Bosco et al., 2013, Lamastra et al., 2014). In contrast, impact categories related to toxicity are often disregarded, partly due to missing data for all involved chemicals including PPP and partly due to high perceived and real uncertainties (Fantke et al., 2016, Rosenbaum et al., 2015). Consequently, PPP and their effects on freshwater and terrestrial ecosystems are frequently omitted, even though they are one of the significant environmental concerns linked with agriculture (Meier et al., 2015). Furthermore, including ecotoxicity in LCA does not necessarily mean that the toxic effects of PPP use are being considered. For instance, Benedetto (2013) reports PPP emissions without including the related impact factors despite available characterization models. Other studies evaluated ecotoxicity impacts related to PPP production but do not quantify the impacts in the use phase (Jimenez et al., 2014, Point et al., 2012). Although numerous studies acknowledge the use of copper in vineyard production, and the impacts of the production of copper-based fungicides are included in a few of them (Point et al., 2012, Villanueva-Rey et al., 2014), the impact resulting from the use of these fungicides is not considered.

Freshwater ecotoxicity can be characterized with different available methods, such as the UNEP-SETAC scientific consensus model for toxicity characterization of chemical emissions in LCIA (Rosenbaum et al., 2008) that is endorsed by the UNEP-SETAC Life Cycle Initiative (Westh et al., 2015). In the case of soil ecotoxicity characterization, several emerging approaches exist (Haye et al., 2007, Lofts et al., 2013, Owsianiak et al., 2013), but no method has yet been widely adopted. Finally, there is a lack of agreement on how to assess ecotoxicity-related impacts of metal-based PPP that are currently not adequately characterized by any existing model (Hauschild and Huijbregts, 2015, Meier et al., 2015).

Characterization of the toxic effects of metal-based emissions in LCIA assumes that the toxicity is a function of the activity of the free metal ion (Campbell, 1995, Owsianiak et al., 2015), which is related to the relevant chemical species, Cu(II). Factors such as water pH, dissolved organic carbon (DOC) and water hardness (Allen and Janssen, 2006, Gandhi et al., 2010), and soil organic carbon (SOC), soil pH and texture (Komarek et al., 2010) control metal speciation and thus its potential toxic effects. Consequently, incorporating and defining these geographically distinct characteristics in which the inventory flows (i.e. pesticide emissions) occur will have a significant influence on the ecotoxicological impact assessment of copper-based fungicide AIs in LCA (Gandhi et al., 2011b, Potting and Hauschild, 2006).

The main objective of the present work is to improve the consideration of copper-based fungicides in LCA with focus on three specific aims: First, to characterize fungicide emissions and freshwater ecotoxicity impacts to compare results of copper-based fungicides with commonly used AIs to control downy mildew in European vineyards. Second, to introduce soil ecotoxicity characterization for copper-based fungicides. Third, to include spatial differentiation on the assessment of freshwater and soil ecotoxicity characterization associated with the application of copper-based fungicides in European vineyards.

Section snippets

Materials and methods

We identified the most relevant aspects for modeling ecotoxicity in freshwater and soil as direct impact pathways for PPP use. We quantified the freshwater ecotoxicity potential of the main AI (synthetic and copper-based) used to control downy mildew in European vineyards using USEtox 2.02 as characterization model (http://usetox.org). Thereafter, we estimated characterization factors (CF) for non-calcareous soils based on the multiple linear regression model developed by Owsianiak et al. (2013)

Potential freshwater ecotoxicity impacts

Results of the freshwater ecotoxicity impact assessment for the 12 AIs aggregated over all emission compartments are shown in Fig. 1 and impact results for the individual emission compartments are presented in Fig. 2. There was up to 6 orders of magnitude variation in the ISfw for the 12 different fungicide AIs (Fig. 1), with dimethomorph (23.5 PAF m3 d ha 1) as the least potentially toxic substance and copper-based fungicides (4.6 million PAF m3 d ha 1) as the most potentially toxic AI.

In the case of

Application of our results and implications for decision making

While the evaluation of global warming potentials in viticulture has been extensively analyzed in most studies, vineyard or wine-related LCAs often neglect to assess ecotoxicity-related impacts, despite their importance at a local and regional level in vineyard areas. Moreover, to the best of our knowledge, the current study constitutes an extended vision of LCIA to an agricultural product, not only through freshwater and terrestrial soil ecotoxicity evaluation but also through the inclusion of

Acknowledgments

This work was financially supported by a scholarship granted by the Colombian Government through COLCIENCIAS, by the Marie Curie project Quan-Tox (grant agreement no. 631910) funded by the European Commission under the Seventh Framework Program, and by the OLCA-Pest project financially supported by ADEME (GA No. 17-03-C0025). Authors would also thank the support from “CERCA Program - Generalitat de Catalunya”, Anna Levinsson for the proofreading and Immaculada Funes for her contributions to the

References (70)

  • S. Haye et al.

    Terrestrial ecotoxicity and effect factors of metals in life cycle assessment (LCA)

    Chemosphere

    (2007)
  • A. Hildebrandt et al.

    Impact of pesticides used in agriculture and vineyards to surface and groundwater quality (North Spain)

    Water Res.

    (2008)
  • M. Komarek et al.

    Contamination of vineyard soils with fungicides: a review of environmental and toxicological aspects

    Environ. Int.

    (2010)
  • L. Lamastra et al.

    A new approach to assessing the water footprint of wine: an Italian case study

    Sci. Total Environ.

    (2014)
  • S. Lofts et al.

    Modelling the effects of copper on soil organisms and processes using the free ion approach: towards a multi-species toxicity model

    Environ. Pollut.

    (2013)
  • M.S. Meier et al.

    Environmental impacts of organic and conventional agricultural products - are the differences captured by life cycle assessment?

    J. Environ. Manag.

    (2015)
  • B. Notarnicola et al.

    Life cycle assessment (LCA) of wine production

  • M. Owsianiak et al.

    Assessing comparative terrestrial ecotoxicity of Cd, Co, Cu, Ni, Pb, and Zn: the influence of aging and emission source

    Environ. Pollut.

    (2015)
  • R. Parajuli et al.

    Environmental life cycle assessments of producing maize, grass-clover, ryegrass and winter wheat straw for biorefinery

    J. Clean. Prod.

    (2017)
  • G. Pergher et al.

    The effect of spray application rate and airflow rate on foliar deposition in a hedgerow vineyard

    J. Agric. Eng. Res.

    (1995)
  • G. Pergher et al.

    Assessment of spray deposition and recycling rate in the vineyard from a new type of air-assisted tunnel sprayer

    Crop. Prot.

    (2013)
  • E. Point et al.

    Life cycle environmental impacts of wine production and consumption in Nova Scotia, Canada

    J. Clean. Prod.

    (2012)
  • O. Ribolzi et al.

    Speciation and origin of particulate copper in runoff water from a Mediterranean vineyard catchment

    Environ. Pollut.

    (2002)
  • P. Villanueva-Rey et al.

    Comparative life cycle assessment in the wine sector: biodynamic vs. conventional viticulture activities in NW Spain

    J. Clean. Prod.

    (2014)
  • G. Agrios

    Plant pathology

  • H. Allen et al.

    Incorporating bioavailability into criteria for metals

  • J.R. Aybar

    Principals Plagues I Malalties De La Vinya : Reconeixement, Prevenci Ó I Control. Servei de Sanitat Vegetal. DAR- Reus

    (2008)
  • P. Balsari et al.

    Influence of canopy parameters on spray drift in vineyard

  • S. Bosco et al.

    Greenhouse gas emissions in the agricultural phase of wine production in the Maremma rural district in Tuscany, Italy

    Ital. J. Agron.

    (2011)
  • S. Bosco et al.

    Soil organic matter accounting in the carbon footprint analysis of the wine chain

    Int. J. Life Cycle Assess.

    (2013)
  • P.G.C. Campbell

    Interactions between trace metals and aquatic organisms: a critique of the free-ion activity model

  • Commission, E

    EU pesticides database

  • T.J. Dijkman et al.

    PestLCI 2.0: a second generation model for estimating emissions of pesticides from arable land in LCA

    Int. J. Life Cycle Assess.

    (2012)
  • EEA

    CORINE land cover project

  • EFSA

    Conclusion on the peer review of the pesticide risk assessment of confirmatory data submitted for the active substance copper (I), copper (II) variants namely copper hydroxide, copper oxychloride, tribasic copper sulfate, copper (I) oxide, Bordeaux mixture

    EFSA J.

    (2013)
  • Cited by (39)

    • Connecting the evidence about organic pollutant sorption on soils with environmental regulation and decision-making: A scoping review

      2022, Chemosphere
      Citation Excerpt :

      Although the studies found consider soils of different texture, content and composition of SOM, temperature, geography and climate, an explicit analysis of these aspects would help to understand the dynamics of sorption inside soils in different scenarios of environmental concern and make reliable predictions on a case-by-case basis. This would agree with studies detected for decision-making and policy, where spaciotemporal variability was relevant to describing agricultural practices (Malaj et al., 2020; Peña et al., 2018), monitor of pollution by sampling or using datasets (Cui et al., 2020; Manamsa et al., 2016; Yu et al., 2020), and modeling the EF (Lammoglia et al., 2018). However, only 6% and <1% of articles aimed at modeling and databases generation, respectively (IT47), implying that most of the articles focused on the prediction used external data (principally discarded by “Theoretical” criterion, Fig. 2 a).

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text