Determinants of foreign ownership in international R&D joint ventures: Transaction costs and national culture
Introduction
R&D and technology innovation have long been important issues in management research (e.g., Gunasekaran, 1997). In general, there are three ways to enhance a firm's innovation capability and expand its technology capacity: (1) acquisition of technology from outside; (2) internal R&D activity; and (3) collaboration with partners. In recent years, there has been a proliferation of research in international R&D collaboration (e.g., Gunasekaran, 1997, McArthur and Schill, 1995). This interest reflects the fact that technological advances and globalization create the need for inter-firm R&D cooperation in order to stay competitive. In this paper, we focus on international R&D joint ventures as the research locus, since joint ventures have been a frequently used form of R&D collaboration (Gunasekaran, 1997).
The purpose of our study is to examine the factors that are related to multinationals' equity ownership in international R&D equity joint ventures (henceforth referred to as simply international R&D joint ventures). Compared to wholly owned overseas R&D subsidiaries, the major advantage of R&D joint ventures is sharing the costs and risk of in-house R&D activities with partners. However, the risk of technology spillover to rival firms and partner opportunism also increases the control costs of such R&D collaboration. Therefore, selecting the appropriate equity ownership level to enter an equity R&D joint venture is a very important strategic decision facing managers.
In the last decades, researchers have analyzed ownership strategies as well as governance structures in international business, for example, wholly owned versus joint ownership (e.g., Buckley and Casson, 1976, Hennart, 1982). In particular, a number of studies have explored the equity ownership strategies of multinationals when they form joint ventures (e.g., Blodgett, 1991, Gatignon and Anderson, 1988, Hennart, 1991, Pan, 2002). The R&D joint venture, as one governance mode, has been compared with other types of non-equity R&D alliances (e.g., Oxley, 1997). However, little research, to date, has examined equity ownership strategy within the domain of R&D joint ventures. Considering the unique characteristics of R&D joint ventures, such as the high risk of partner opportunism and R&D spillover, the issue of equity ownership and governance structure in such joint ventures deserves further research. In addition, equity ownership strategy in R&D joint ventures may be more sensitive to factors that are related to these characteristics than are non-R&D joint ventures (e.g., purely marketing and/or manufacturing joint ventures).
Our study contributes to the literature by integrating the transaction costs economics (TCE) and national culture perspectives. TCE more or less assumes risk neutrality on the part of organizations. It is the situation–the uncertainty, the transaction frequency, and the asset specificity–that determines the mode of ownership and control desired. The national culture perspective takes a more behavioral view, as opposed to an economic one. Culture will impact not only attitudes toward risk, but also the mode or degree of control desired.
Our study also contributes to the literature on international joint ventures because of its multi-country sample. Prior studies on equity ownership tend to be limited to a single source country (e.g., Gatignon and Anderson, 1988, Hennart, 1991) or to a single host country (e.g., Pan, 1996, Pan, 1997, Pan, 2002, Pan and Li, 2000). Our sample consists of 543 R&D joint ventures located in four countries: China, India, Japan and the United States. First, we believe that our sample provides a diversity of both host countries and source countries, and makes our results robust, since it consists of two major developed countries: the United States and Japan, and the two largest emerging economies: China and India.
Second, prior international joint venture studies have focused on R&D activities only in developed countries (e.g., Vonortas, 1997, Katz et al., 1996). However, multinational companies are now starting to enter research partnerships in emerging economies, since research infrastructures are improving there, local markets are growing, and R&D labor costs are low. We expect some variables that influence the R&D decisions of multinational companies in emerging economies may be different from those in developed countries.
Section snippets
R&D equity joint ventures and equity ownership strategies
This study specifically focuses on R&D equity joint ventures. Typically, this venture is an independent business entity created by two or more separate organizations with shared equity ownership for the purpose of technology research and development. R&D joint ventures are one approach to R&D collaboration. The transaction cost theory of joint ventures (Hennart, 1988) argues that joint ventures arise from the simultaneous failure of both markets. This failure may be due to asset specificity. As
Hypothesis development
In this section, we elaborate on each hypothesized relationship between different uncertainty dimensions (environmental vs. behavioral) and equity ownership structures in international R&D joint ventures. Furthermore, we integrate transaction cost analysis with the national culture perspective. Specifically, we examine how uncertainty avoidance interacts with uncertainty through different managerial risk perceptions and preferences, and ultimately influences different equity ownership
Sample characteristics
This study focuses on R&D equity joint venture agreements between two partners (one local and one foreign) in China, India, Japan, and the United States. China and India are important developing countries, while Japan and the United States represent large developed economies. The unit of our analysis is the joint venture agreement. Our final sample includes 543 R&D joint venture agreements announced between 1985 and 2004.5
Results
We used ordinary least squared regression models to examine the relationships between the independent variables and the foreign partner's equity ownership of an international R&D joint venture in China, India, Japan, and the United States. All variables used for interactions were centered. The results are reported in Table 5.
Table 5 reports the relationships between the independent and control variables and the percentage of equity ownership held by the foreign partner in the R&D joint venture.
Discussion
The objective of this study was to explain the equity ownership decision by multinational enterprises in their international R&D joint ventures. We integrated the transaction costs economics and national culture perspectives to achieve this objective. Our arguments focused on: (1) environmental uncertainty, and (2) behavioral uncertainty faced by the foreign partner, (3) two components of national culture-power distance and uncertainty avoidance, and (4) the moderating effects of uncertainty
Acknowledgments
Authors are listed alphabetically. Both authors contributed equally to this manuscript. The authors would like to thank Keith Brouthers, Daniel Indro, John Schaubroeck, and three anonymous reviewers for their comments and suggestions on earlier versions of this paper.
References (65)
Essentials of international and joint R&D projects
Technovation
(1997)- et al.
Partnering strategies and performance of SMEs' international joint ventures
Journal of Business Venturing
(2006) - et al.
International cooperative technology arrangements: improving their role in competitive strategy
Journal of Business Research
(1995) - et al.
Joint venture research and development activity: an analysis of the international biotechnology industry
Journal of International Management
(2003) Research joint ventures in the US
Research Policy
(1997)- et al.
Location specificity and the transferability of downstream assets to foreign subsidiaries
Journal of International Business Studies
(1997) - et al.
Expropriation and inventions: appropriable rents in the absence of property rights
American Economics Review
(1994) Licensing tacit knowledge: intellectual property rights and the market for know-how
Economic Innovation New Technology
(1995)- et al.
What differences in the cultural backgrounds of partners are detrimental for international joint ventures?
Journal of International Business Studies
(1997) Partner contributions as predictors of equity share in international joint ventures
Journal of International Business Studies
(1991)
The Future of Multinational Enterprise
Models of the multinational enterprise
Journal of International Business Studies
Host-country managerial behavior and learning in Chinese and Hungarian joint ventures
Journal of Management Studies
Integrating variable risk preferences, trust, and transaction cost economics
Academy of Management Review
Impact of strategic alliances on firm valuation
Academy of Management Journal
The eclectic paradigm of international production: a restatement and some possible extensions
Journal of International Business Studies
The influence of Hymer's dissertation on the theory of foreign direct investment
High tech in China: is it a threat to Silicon Valley?
BusinessWeek
Nationality and subsidiary ownership patterns in multinational corporations
Journal of International Business Studies
Service firms' international entry-mode choice: a modified transaction-cost analysis approach
Journal of Marketing
The development of buyer–seller relationships in industrial markets
European Journal of Marketing
Firm ownership preferences and host government restrictions: an integrated approach
Journal of International Business Studies
Multinational corporation degree of control over foreign subsidiaries, an empirical test of a transaction cost explanation
Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization
Does familiarity breed trust? The implications of repeated ties for contractual choice in alliances
Academy of Management Journal
A Theory of Multinational Enterprise
A transaction costs theory of equity joint ventures
Strategic Management Journal
The transaction costs theory of joint ventures: an empirical study of Japanese subsidiaries in the United States
Management Science
The impact of culture on the strategy of multinational enterprises: does national origin affect ownership decisions?
Journal of International Business Studies
Critical contingencies in joint venture management: some lessons from managers
Organization Science
Is an international joint venture in R&D for you?
Research & Technology Management
Culture's Consequences: International Differences in Work-Related Values
Culture: Software of the Mind
Cited by (54)
Power distance diversification, ownership structure, and business group performance
2022, Journal of Business ResearchInternationalization of R&D and Innovation Performance in the Pharma Industry
2022, Journal of International ManagementMapping five decades of international business and management research on India: A bibliometric analysis and future directions
2022, Journal of Business ResearchEffective cooperation modes based on cultural and market similarities in interfirm relationships
2022, Journal of International Management
- 1
Tel.: +1 978 934 2813; fax: +1 978 934 2064.