Strength determination for rough substrate-coating interfaces with three-dimensional defect structure
Graphical abstract
Introduction
In many applications the performance of components exposed to tribological loads is enhanced by thin ceramic coatings. For example, protective hard coatings are an established solution to enhance the productivity of metalworking tools in production processes such as milling, turning or drilling [1]. The loss of the coating in application is highly detrimental to the performance of the coated structure, e.g. a cutting edge of a milling tool that experiences accelerated wear when deprived of its coating [2]. Coating loss may be caused by wear or formation of cracks, e.g. those that propagate along the substrate-coating interface and lead to coating decohesion. Gradual coating wear is often the preferred failure mode of coated structures, since it does not occur suddenly as the formation of cracks. Coating decohesion is influenced by numerous factors such as the magnitude of load stresses compared to the substrate's yield strength [3], the load stress ratio [4] as well as residual stresses in coating [5,6] and substrate [7], respectively. Tensile load components are most critical with respect to crack initiation and growth in homogeneous materials, as well as at interfaces between metallic phases [8] and even more so between ceramic materials [9]. This is especially relevant when interfaces themselves are not planar but three-dimensionally rough. A very general definition of three-dimensional (3D) interfaces was suggested in [10] as “interfaces with hetero-phase character that extend out-of-plane into the two phases they join, and are chemically, crystallographically, and / or topologically divergent in three dimensions”. A good example for such a case are diamond thin films on WC-Co hard metal substrates [11]. In this system, the metallic Co binder acts as a catalyst for the formation of graphite during chemical vapor deposition of the coating. Therefore, the Co is etched out of the substrate material to facilitate the growth of the coating in diamond structure and avoid the formation of graphite [12]. The etching gives rise to a binder-depleted zone in the WC-Co substrate with a rough surface and complex-shaped partially interconnected cavities that are in part filled by the coating during its deposition [13].
Coating decohesion was reported to hinder the further propagation of the use of the described coating-substrate example system in machining of parts made of non-carbide forming metals, in which it has shown great potential to improve machining productivity [14]. A thorough understanding of the strength of interfaces between coatings and their substrates is essential when trying to understand and avoid coating decohesion. Most methods available for the characterization of the strength of interfaces only yield qualitative rankings for certain loading scenarios, but no quantitative interface strength information [15]. Typically, they also do not take account of the possible influence of a variation of the orientation of the external load on the determined strength value, i.e. a possible texture of a 3D interface defect structure. An example for the mentioned shortcomings are indentation techniques that lack the quantitative and inter-situative comparability of their results and currently do not allow for a direct control of the directions of the stresses that lead to interface failure [15,16]. Also scratching-based methods lack quantitative result comparability due to the complex and transient stress fields arising at the tested interfaces [17,18]. Micromechanical testing and interpretation of the stress-strain evolution during testing, combined with electron microscopy-based investigation of the μm-sized specimens can be used to address the discussed issues [19]. Some of the proposed methods enable to study interface strength by bending to impose a tensile load at interfaces [19,20], use a push-to-shear device to impose shear stresses [21], or load interfaces that are inclined with respect to the direction of a compressive load [22,23]. The last-mentioned techniques are interesting since in many applications, tension, compression and shear load components act simultaneously [24] and should thus be induced in laboratory test setups. Some documented efforts to do so have fallen short of demonstrating fracture at the studied strong interfaces [25], or induced strong plastification before plastic shear-off close to the studied metal/metal [22] and metal-ceramic interface [23] instead of interface fracture. Many proposed micromechanical test methods evaluate fracture properties of structures notched by focused ion beam (FIB) milling, also under multiaxial loading, but are not directly applicable for determination of substrate-coating interface strength [26,27].
Another micromechanical test method uses a micro shear compression (MSC) specimen to induce fracture at ceramic-ceramic interfaces by the sought combination of tension, compression and shear load [28]. In this approach, the tensile load component, determined quantitatively as the maximum principal stress pointing in an out-of-interface-plane direction, is referred to as the interface strength [28]. The MSC testing test setup was applied to determine interface strength between the microstructural constituents of high speed steel and a TiN hard coating [28]. The used MSC specimen geometry [28], however, is not yet useable for varying the applied load direction. Such possibility would be useful when studying the strength behavior of interfaces with a 3D defect structure and the possible influence of defect-orientation effects, i.e. defect texture, on the observed strength.
The current work presents a material testing method involving modifications of an MSC specimen geometry. Its already demonstrated capability to induce interface fracture and to deliver quantitative interface strength values will be advanced to study the strength of larger interface areas with a 3D defect structure under variable external loading directions.
Section snippets
Investigated materials
The samples investigated in the current work were made of a WC-Co hard metal (provided by Ceratizit Austria) with a Co binder content of 6 wt% and an average WC grain size of 500 nm to 800 nm. The used samples had a cuboid shape with dimensions of 12.7 mm × 12.7 mm × 3.18 mm. The samples were job-coated with the commercially available nanocrystalline diamond coating of type BALINIT DIAMOND PLUS by Oerlikon Balzers [12] in a chemical vapor deposition (CVD) process, often applied for wear
Results and discussion
The load-displacement data recorded during specimen loading from initial indenter-specimen contact until the moment of specimen fracture are displayed in Fig. 4. All tested samples exhibit brittle behavior, with linear elastic loading followed by rapid catastrophic failure. Note that the observed different slopes for the individual experiments result from different compliances of the respective indenter-specimen geometry combinations. However, for the further quantitative considerations
Conclusions
The current work investigated the strength properties of the interface between a nanocrystalline CVD diamond coating and the near-surface zone in a WC-Co hard metal substrate that was depleted of its metallic Co binder by etching. The formed interface featured a three-dimensional defect structure influenced by partial penetration of the coating into cavities present in the substrate. Micromechanical testing was performed using a micropillar and five geometry variants of the micro shear
Dedication
In the early stages of the current work, our dear colleague Dr. Roland Barbist unexpectedly passed away. The authors want to acknowledge the inspiration he provided to his younger colleagues with his passion for research. We want to express our compassion with his family that will miss him the most.
CRediT authorship contribution statement
T. Klünsner: Conceptualization, Methodology, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Project administration, Funding acquisition, Supervision. M. Krobath: Formal analysis, Visualization, Writing – review & editing. R. Konetschnik: Investigation. C. Tritremmel: Project administration. V. Maier-Kiener: Investigation, Writing – review & editing. D. Samardzic: Formal analysis. W. Ecker: Resources, Writing – review & editing. C. Czettl: Resources, Funding acquisition. C. Mitterer: Writing – review
Declaration of Competing Interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Acknowledgements
The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support under the scope of the COMET program within the K2 Center “Integrated Computational Material, Process and Product Engineering (IC-MPPE)” (Project No 886385). This program is supported by the Austrian Federal Ministries for Climate Action, Environment, Energy, Mobility, Innovation and Technology (BMK) and for Labour and Economy (BMAW), represented by the Austrian Research Promotion Agency (FFG), and the federal states of Styria, Upper
References (50)
- et al.
Mechanism of adhesion failure during interrupted cutting with cemented carbide tools: experimental and ab-initio perspective
Int. J. Refract. Met. Hard Mater.
(2021) - et al.
Influence of localized cyclic substrate plastification on residual stress, load stress and cracking near the interface between hard coating and WC-co hard metal substrate
Int. J. Refract. Met. Hard Mater.
(2019) - et al.
Effect of microstructure on fatigue properties of WC-co hard metals
Process. Eng.
(2010) - et al.
Residual stress gradients in α-Al2O3 hard coatings determined by pencil-beam X-ray nanodiffraction
Surf. Coat. Technol.
(2015) - et al.
Shot peening-induced plastic deformation of individual phases within a coated WC-co hard metal composite material including stress-strain curves for WC as a function of temperature
Surf. Coat. Technol.
(2019) - et al.
Fatigue life equality of polished and electrical discharge machined WC-co hard metal achieved solely by wet blasting
Int. J. Refract. Met. Hard Mater.
(2016) - et al.
Tension behavior of interfaces between ZrCu metallic glass and Si or Zr
Appl. Surf. Sci.
(2015) - et al.
Effects of three-dimensional Cu/Nb interfaces on strengthening and shear banding in nanoscale metallic multilayers
Acta Mater.
(2020) - et al.
Diamond deposition on hardmetal substrates - comparison of substrate pre-treatments and industrial applications
Int. J. Refract. Met. Hard Mater.
(2010) - et al.
Effect of substrate surface texture on adhesion performance of diamond coating
Int. J. Refract. Met. Hard Mater.
(2021)