Regionalism as resistance: Governance and identity in Western Australia’s Wheatbelt
Highlights
► Rural regions are under major change pressures. ► Regionalisation is a contested policy response. ► Rural local governments oppose state-defined regions. ► Opposition is viewed as defensive regionalism. ► Regionalism is explained through collective identities of resistance.
Section snippets
Introduction: sustainable development in rural regions
Rural landscapes and communities in developed countries are experiencing profound environmental, political and socio-economic change (Woods, 2005, Cocklin and Dibden, 2005, Pemberton and Goodwin, 2010). In extensive agricultural regions these changes stem from economic and agricultural restructuring under neo-liberal policy settings, combined with environmental degradation from patterns of largely unrestrained agricultural and pastoral development (Gray and Lawrence, 2001). Without alternate
Oppositional identities, local actors and regionalism
Regionalism is discernable from regionalisation, as it stems largely from local actors self-organising around a ‘regional’ identity for a particular purpose (Herrschel, 2007). That purpose can and does include local resistance to imposed identities or policy agendas of actors outside the region. Regionalism is thought ‘strongest’ “where the elements of geography, economic cohesion, cultural identity, administrative apparatus, popular identity and territorial mobilisation coincide in space” (
Methods
The study employed qualitative techniques of semi-structured and unstructured interviews, along with more structured workshop-based discussions within an interpretivist methodology. This approach was adopted to suite both the conceptual and operational context of the research that relied on understanding the relational dynamics between local and regional actors. In total 28 semi-structured interviews were conducted in two separate rounds. The first round involved seven largely unstructured
Local perceptions of sustainability imperatives
Forefront in the minds of local government officers was the task of limiting the negative effects of changes in economic activity, community structure and land use underway in their shires. One local government officer for instance described an increase in the aggregation of smaller family farms into larger corporate agricultural entities in her north-eastern shire. This trend was then linked to concerns of local population decline and the ability of council to maintain adequate local service
A defensive rural regionalism?
Several factors have contributed to region-building amongst rural local governments in the Wheatbelt of Western Australia. These factors are in essence threats to local governments’ autonomy and identity that emanate from both historical and contemporary circumstances. The first of these factors is the imperative to maintain viable rural localities. This involves for many local councils wrestling with the problems of environmental degradation and rapid land use change; declining state support
Conclusion
Local governments in the Avon River Basin of Western Australia’s Wheatbelt have adopted a posture of resistance to state threats of structural reform; environmental degradation and economic decline; and state-defined regions for policy implementation. Where State and national governments’ preference is clearly for vertical ‘partnerships’ to deliver sustainable development outcomes through their own regional architecture, local governments’ preference is equally clearly for horizontal networks
Acknowledgements
The field component of this research was jointly funded by the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation and the Avon Catchment Council through the Australian Governments’ Natural Heritage Trust. The author gratefully acknowledges the assistance of Ben Harman, Sonja Heyenga, Nick Abel, and Linda Vernon in the conduct of interviews throughout the Avon region and helpful discussion on preliminary findings. Thanks also to the two anonymous reviewers for helpful and detailed
References (75)
- et al.
Pragmatic localism uncovered: the search for locally contingent solutions to national reform agendas
Geoforum
(2008) - et al.
Contesting the neoliberal project for agriculture: productivist and multifunctional trajectories in the European Union and Australia
Journal of Rural Studies
(2009) - et al.
Revaluing planning
Progress in Planning
(2000) - et al.
Reluctant rural regionalists
Journal of Rural Studies
(2009) - et al.
Ad hoc rural regionalism
Journal of Rural Studies
(2008) Contemporary strategies for rural community development in Australia: a governmentality perspective
Journal of Rural Studies
(2000)Regions between imposed structure and internally developed response. Experiences with twin track regionalisation in post-socialist eastern Germany
Geoforum
(2007)- et al.
Environmental governance and the hybrid regime of Australian natural resource management
Geoforum
(2010) - et al.
Neoliberal nature and the nature of neoliberalism
Geoforum
(2004) River-basin planning and management: the social life of a concept
Geoforum
(2009)
New community governance in small rural towns: the Australian experience
Journal of Rural Studies
Rethinking the changing structures of rural local government: state power, rural politics and local political strategies?
Journal of Rural Studies
Regional theory and regionalism: towards rethinking the regional question
Geoforum
Devolution, regional governance and planning systems in Belgium
International Planning Studies
Science and Policy in Natural Resource Management: Understanding System Complexity
Regional Western Australia: A Better Place to Live – Regional Development Policy
From convergence to divergence: reforming Australian local government
Australian Journal of Public Administration
Developmentalism and its environmental legacy: the western Australia Wheatbelt, 1900–1990s
Australian Journal of Politics and History
Regional governance and regionalism in Australia
The information age according to Manuel Castells
Journal of Communication
Localism, self-interest, and the tyranny of the favored quarter: addressing the barriers to new regionalism
Georgetown Law Journal
The Power of Identity
Governing Rural Development: Discourses and Practices of Self-help in Australian Rural Policy
Examining Corporate-sector Involvement in the Governance of Selected Mining-intensive Regions in Australia
Australian Geographer
Sustainability and Change in Rural Australia
Landcare: approaching the limits of voluntary action
Australian Journal of Environmental Management
Changing electoral structures and regional representation in Western Australia: from country mindedness to one vote one value
Space and Polity
Community development
Contesting competition: governance and farmer resistance in Australia
Regional renaissance? New forms of governance in nonmetropolitan Australia
Environment and Planning C – Government and Policy
Participation and Governance in Regional Development: Global Trends in an Australian Context
Catchment management arrangements
Changing governance structures and the environment: economy-environment relations at the local and regional scales
Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning
Politics in Place: Social Power Relations in an Australian Country Town
Power relations in rural communities: implications for environmental management
A Future for Regional Australia: Escaping Global Misfortune
Cited by (17)
Mobilizing through local agency to support place-based economic transition: A case study of Tumbler Ridge, BC
2023, Extractive Industries and SocietyDecoding national new area development in China: Toward new land development and politics
2019, CitiesCitation Excerpt :For instance, its accession to the EU underscores Greece's rescaling experimentation to advance local competitiveness under the EU's regional policy agenda (Chorianopoulos, 2012). Rescaling innovations of territorial organization have also been witnessed in rural Australia owing to tensions between national economic development policies and agricultural restructuring and environmental degradation (Taylor, 2012). Rescaling and devolution can be rolled out as a result of civil society activism and regionalist politics (Purcell, 2007).
Local institutions and farmer participation in agri-environmental schemes
2015, Journal of Rural StudiesCitation Excerpt :The imposition of central government priorities on local networks and identities can lead to disenfranchisement and even co-option of those local communities (Farrelly, 2005; Ferreyra et al., 2008). Conversely, the involvement of farmer associations, local rural communities and landholders in scheme design can result in broader program-level environmental priorities being subverted by local interests and implementation efforts stalled and resisted (Morrison, 2007; Taylor, 2012; Taylor and Lawrence, 2012). So while decentralization has the potential to create conflict by displacing or challenging existing norms or relations in farming communities, it also presents the prospect of improving the local relevance and the operational efficiencies of schemes.
Arranging public support to unfold collaborative modes of governance in rural areas
2013, Journal of Rural StudiesCitation Excerpt :In the European Union, place-based approaches to rural development are increasingly favoured, because they aim to strengthen the resilience of rural areas against global pressures by decreasing state dependencies and increasing the economic competitiveness of rural areas (Amin, 2004; Barca, 2009; Bristow, 2010; Healey et al., 2003; Lowe et al., 1995; Marsden and Bristow, 2000; Murdoch, 2000; Nienaber, 2007; O'Brian, 2011; OECD, 2006; Ray, 2006; Reimer and Markey, 2008; Shucksmith, 2010; Taylor, 2012; Tomaney, 2010).
When old and new regionalism collide: Deinstitutionalization of regions and resistance identity in municipality amalgamations
2013, Journal of Rural StudiesCitation Excerpt :The removal of one's ‘own’ municipality can be hard to accept, especially if this region does not seem to be facing any immediate economic threats and the merger is justified only by using vague arguments such as abstract rhetoric of competitiveness. Under these circumstances defensive resistance movements emerge (Taylor, 2011). The role of identity is complex in such cases.