Hydrogen storage station location selection in sustainable freight transportation via intuitionistic hesitant decision support system
Introduction
The transition from fossil to renewable energy modes is one of the major societal issues in Europe nowadays. At this juncture, hydrogen is gaining popularity to become a major vehicle fuel type promising to be a sustainable and clean energy source [1]. This development has increasingly penetrated almost all European countries, implying that there is differentiation from centralized supply chain models. In parallel, multi-agent and fully decentralized supply chains seem to overcome all obstacles emanated by the region's complicated topography [2]. However, there are still considerable issues related to the efficiency of hydrogen production and consuming using various renewable energy sources. Furthermore, in order to achieve truly sustainable hydrogen-oriented transportation [3], hydrogen must not only be produced but also stored, used and consumed in sustainable ways [4]. Despite all aforementioned obstacles, hydrogen road transportation demonstrates great potential for financial returns, setting the supply station locations to be essential for the technical and financial viability of the transportation sector [5]. At the same time, low carbon supply chains have become a critical factor for achieving a green economy. Optimized transportation management in supply chains promises to reduce carbon emissions across the whole process. In this context, the key challenge is not only to select a low carbon supplier but also to reduce the communication cost selecting near optimal locations of the supplier stations [6]. The sector of freight transportation is the most critical mode due to its significant involvement in the logistics chain [7].
The current state of technology involves mostly a centralized approach towards commercialization of hydrogen consuming in urban areas. As a result, the same holds for freight transportation [8]. This approach has been preferred so far since it minimizes the functional and operational cost. However, for heavily urbanized areas and especially for multiple freight distribution sites, single supplier locations increase the communication cost. On the opposite site, if hydrogen supplier and distributor sites coexist at the same location, functional and communication cost are minimal. Unfortunately, in lots of cases there are several risk considerations that do not allow for the later to be operated [9]. Based on the arguments above, in this paper we are interested in a location selection strategy of hydrogen supplier stations in a fuel-vehicle transportation mode network that must be imposed based on the freight requirements oof urban areas. More precisely, we measure the sustainable transport indicators and how these impact a performance model of minimum environmental impact. Moreover, assuming resource infrastructure and technology availability, we concentrate on the social (e.g., risk of the fuel usage, emergency rescue facilities infrastructure etc.), economic, and environmental aspects of such transportation strategic planning [10].
It is crucial and generally realized to shift from the current status of transport sector fuel consumption (sector is responsible of causing a big negative impact on climate change as the primate source of fuel is still crude oil [11], consuming 61.2% of the globe's oil resources) by adopting alternatives such as eco-driving. Moreover, there is need to establish Multi-Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) methodologies to evaluate biofuel alternatives such as hydrogen to determine ideal solutions. Focusing on the hydrogen supplier station selection problem, this carries fuzzy characteristics due to the interoperability of several diverse aspects such as associated infrastructure, demography, economy environment and other social issues that should be taken into account. However, there are two inter-correlated components that must be addressed, regardless of the methodology used: (a) the dimension element of the hydrogen refueling infrastructure (urban limits within the infrastructure should be extended) and (b) number and locations of hydrogen refueling stations. Limited number of placed stations extends underutilization of the network where, conversely limited area coverage does not cover transportation needs increasing the communication cost. The quality/performance of such network must be the most critical priority due to the high capital expenditures needed for the infrastructure and due to the risks/uncertainties initiated to the society and the stakeholders of such projects. For this MCDM problem several fuzzy methodologies have been proposed, most of them however without dealing with the idea of weighted average of the degree of hesitation between their membership functions, the involving of score functions in the ranking of various criteria attributes and the necessary sensitivity analysis [12].
To cope with these uncertainties, in this paper we introduce a repertoire of intuitionistic fuzzy set methods in an extended framework of the fuzzy set theory including: (a) the Weighted Aggregated Sum Product Assessment (IFWASPAS) [13], (b) the Complex Proportional Assessment (IFCOPRAS) [14], (c) the Evaluation based on Distance from Average Solution (IFEDAS) [15], and the Combinative Distance based Assessment (IFCODAS), [16].
The innovation of this paper lies on the creation of an inventive DSS that proposes hydrogen storage location selection policies in a region. For this selection criterion (locations of hydrogen refueling stations) no prior research exists. Additionally, the DSS outcome is based on a unique ensemble of intuitionistic fuzzy systems that does not consider only the positive responses by the experts but also counts in the hesitation and uncertainty aspects on their opinion. This promotes the DSS significance as, its outcome is directly related to the environmental, social, economic, and safety impacts of a region. Furthermore, the design of the DSS is open-ended, allowing participant expansion in aggregating criteria evaluations. The dynamic criteria selection allows the framework to be adopted for a variety of policy making problems while at the same time, it may include additional methodologies related to intuitionistic fuzzy theory such as Pythagorean and interval valued.
Section snippets
Relevant work
MCDM is a well-established methodology that helps all types of decision-makers and corporations to make reasonable judgments in a quantitative and qualitative way. It employs a collection of analytic techniques and methodologies to evaluate the influence of all relevant information on the decision-making process and to make recommendations for optimizing a goal alternative/utility. In other words, MCDM is a “goal-directed behavior” process to provide the support to reach this goal. In most
Materials and methods
Europe recognizes hydrogen as the next most important transportation and energy fuel with the lowest possible CO2 environmental charge. Thus, it is expected that hydrogen fleet and refueling facilities are likely to spread from metropolitan cities to rural regions and less populated areas. Therefore, designing the infrastructure and deciding about the locations of the refueling stations at this pre-commercial stage is crucial. In choosing the right locations, many critical aspects must be
Implementation of the IFWASPAS, IFCORPAS, IFEDAS and IFCODAS for the case study of larissa city, central Greece: analysis and results
To develop a sustainable and eco-friendly urban environment, we need to optimize the utilization of energy sources. Especially for the case of renewable energy projects, and this can be achieved when policy makers (decision makers) consider all relevant qualitative and quantitative variables that affect the final decision. Focusing on the problem of identifying the ideal location(s) of hydrogen refueling stations in an urban area such as Larissa, Greece, this is tackled by: (a) identifying the
Discussion of results
In this section, a qualitative discussion of the findings in Chapter 4 rather than a quantitative one is provided. This is always important for policy making frameworks, as we focus on the ranking data as opposed to the individual performance of each model used in the evaluation/ranking process. It is important therefore to evaluate the whole framework as a tool for the policy maker to support his/her decision. All models resulted the same ranking of the three alternatives. On one hand, this
Conclusion
One of the most important challenges for green projects from the standpoint of investors is ensuring a safe and lucrative project operation while conforming to severe national and international environmental criteria. Although it is widely acknowledged that hydrogen has the potential to achieve far greater sustainability than other traditional fueling methods and is seen as a viable option to balance the world's reliance on fossil fuels, its economic feasibility remains dubious. Aside from the
Author statement
Konstantinos Kokkinos: Conceptualization, Methodology, Formal analysis, Software, Writing – original draft preparation; Eftihia Nathanail: Investigation, Formal analysis, Writing – review & editing; Vassilis Gerogiannis: Formal analysis, Data curation, Validation; Konstantinos Moustakas: Resources, Visualization, Validation; Vayos Karayannis: Conceptualization, Writing – review & editing, Supervision
Declaration of competing interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
References (73)
Techno-economic assessment of various hydrogen production methods – a review
Bioresour Technol
(2021)- et al.
Fully-decentralized coordination for simultaneous hydrogen, power, and heat interaction in a multi-carrier-energy system considering private ownership
Elec Power Syst Res
(2020) - et al.
Energy system analysis of the implications of hydrogen fuel cell vehicles in the Swedish road transport system
Int J Hydrogen Energy
(2015) - et al.
Parcel delivery in urban areas: opportunities and threats for the mix of traditional and green business models
Transport Res C Emerg Technol
(Feb. 2019) - et al.
A new Pythagorean fuzzy-based decision-making method through entropy measure for fuel cell and hydrogen components supplier selection
Energy
(2021) - et al.
Quantitative risk analysis of a hazardous jet fire event for hydrogen transport in natural gas transmission pipelines
Int J Hydrogen Energy
(2021) Status quo of China hydrogen strategy in the field of transportation and international comparisons
Int J Hydrogen Energy
(2021)A new generalized improved score function of interval-valued intuitionistic fuzzy sets and applications in expert systems
Appl Soft Comput
(Jan. 2016)A systematic review and meta-Analysis of SWARA and WASPAS methods: theory and applications with recent fuzzy developments
Appl Soft Comput
(Aug. 2017)- et al.
A comprehensive MCDM-based approach using TOPSIS, COPRAS and DEA as an auxiliary tool for material selection problems
Mater Des
(May 2017)
A modified interval valued intuitionistic fuzzy CODAS method and its application to multi-criteria selection among renewable energy alternatives in Turkey
Appl Soft Comput
1.19 - multicriteria decision-making methods
Hydrogen energy storage method selection using fuzzy axiomatic design and analytic hierarchy process
Int J Hydrogen Energy
A multi-objective optimization approach for selection of energy storage systems
Comput Chem Eng
Benchmarking and selection of Power-to-Gas utilizing electrolytic hydrogen as an energy storage alternative
Int J Hydrogen Energy
A review of technologies and applications on versatile energy storage systems
Renew Sustain Energy Rev
A review of hydrogen station location models
Int J Hydrogen Energy
On reliability and flexibility of sustainable energy application route for vehicles in China
Renew Sustain Energy Rev
Methodology for the design of industrial hydrogen networks and the optimal placement of purification units using multi-objective optimisation techniques
Assessment of mono and multi-objective optimization to design a hydrogen supply chain
Int J Hydrogen Energy
Design of a hydrogen supply chain with uncertainty
Int J Hydrogen Energy
Optimization model for the design and analysis of an integrated renewable hydrogen supply (IRHS) system: application to Korea's hydrogen economy
Int J Hydrogen Energy
Contribution of upcycling surplus hydrogen to design a sustainable supply chain: the case study of Northern Spain
Appl Energy
A hydrogen supply chain with spatial resolution: comparative analysis of infrastructure technologies in Germany
Appl Energy
Assessment of hydrogen production methods via integrated MCDM approach under uncertainty
Int J Hydrogen Energy
A novel hesitant fuzzy WASPAS method for assessment of green supplier problem based on exponential information measures
J Clean Prod
IIVIFS-WASPAS: an integrated Multi-Criteria Decision-Making perspective for cloud service provider selection
Future Generat Comput Syst
A novel EDAS approach on intuitionistic fuzzy set for assessment of health-care waste disposal technology using new parametric divergence measures
J Clean Prod
Ranking of renewable energy sources for regions in Turkey by fuzzy entropy based fuzzy COPRAS and fuzzy MULTIMOORA
Renew Energy
Fuzzy TOPSIS and fuzzy COPRAS based multi-criteria decision making for hybrid wind farms
Energy
A modified interval valued intuitionistic fuzzy CODAS method and its application to multi-criteria selection among renewable energy alternatives in Turkey
Appl Soft Comput
More on intuitionistic fuzzy sets
Fuzzy Set Syst
A novel approach to extended fuzzy TOPSIS based on new divergence measures for renewable energy sources selection
J Clean Prod
A comparative study on material selection of microelectromechanical systems electrostatic actuators using Ashby, VIKOR and TOPSIS
Mater Des
How local authority decision makers address freight transport in the urban area
Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences
The potential role of hydrogen as a sustainable transportation fuel to combat global warming
Int J Hydrogen Energy
Cited by (13)
Hydrogen station allocation under stochastic user-equilibrium network flow
2024, International Journal of Hydrogen EnergySustainable stationary hydrogen storage application selection with interval-valued intuitionistic fuzzy AHP
2024, International Journal of Hydrogen EnergyTwo-stage site selection of hydrogen refueling stations coupled with gas stations considering cooperative effects based on the CRITIC-ITFAHP-MABAC method: A case study in Beijing
2024, International Journal of Hydrogen EnergyA comprehensive resilience assessment framework for hydrogen energy infrastructure development
2024, International Journal of Hydrogen EnergyMulti-scenario analysis on hydrogen production development using PESTEL and FCM models
2023, Journal of Cleaner ProductionHydrogen station allocation based on equilibrium traffic flow
2023, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy