Compressive fatigue behavior of bovine trabecular bone

doi:10.1016/0021-9290(93)90009-4

Journal of Biomechanics

Volume 26, Issues 4–5, April–May 1993, Pages 453-463

https://doi.org/10.1016/0021-9290(93)90009-4 Get rights and content

Abstract

We studied the fatigue behavior of bovine trabecular bone specimens under stress control using a sinusoidal uniaxial compressive load profile with a frequency of 2 Hz. The stress range was determined from the corresponding initial global platen-to-platen strain range, where the maximum initial strain was between 0.8 and 2.1% and the minimum strain was 0.6%. The local strain distribution was measured on the same type of specimen by affixing glass spheres and photographing them in the unloaded and loaded positions using multiple exposures. The number of cycles to failure (defined as a 5% decrease in secant modulus) was strongly correlated with the initial global maximum strain (r²=0.78) and ranged from 20 cycles at 2.1% strain to 400,000 cycles at 0.8% strain. All of the fatigue specimens showed a region of transverse failure approximately 1 mm from the end of the specimen. Microscopic examination of the failure zones revealed two failure modes: a straight transverse brittle-like fracture through the trabeculae, most often found in trabeculae transverse to the loading direction, and buckling-like failure, common in oblique trabeculae, involving bending and splitting. The local strain increased towards the ends of the specimens to a value 2–4 times that in the middle. Modulus degradation with the number of cycles was distinctively different for high-cycle and low-cycle fatigue, suggesting the possibility that both creep and damage accumulation contribute to fatigue failure of trabecular bone.

References (31)

D.B. Burr et al.
Bone remodeling in response to in vivo fatigue microdamage
J. Biomechanics
(1985)
W.E. Caler et al.
Bone creep-fatigue damage accumulation
J. Biomechanics
(1989)
D.R. Carter et al.
Fatigue life of compact bone—I. Effects of stress amplitude, temperature and density
J. Biomechanics
(1976)
D.R. Carter et al.
Compact bone fatigue damage—I. Residual strength and stiffness
J. Biomechanics
(1977)
D.R. Carter et al.
Fatigue life of compact bone—II. Effects of microstructure and density
J. Biomechanics
(1976)
L.J. Gibson
The mechanical behavior of cancellous bone
J. Biomechanics
(1985)
F. Linde et al.
Stiffness behaviour of trabecular bone specimens
J. Biomechanics
(1987)
A. Odgaard et al.
Compressive axial strain distributions in cancellous bone specimens
J. Biomechanics
(1989)
A. Odgaard et al.
The underestimation of Young's modulus in compressive testing of cancellous bone specimens
J. Biomechanics
(1991)
M.B. Schaffler et al.
Mechanical and morphological effects of strain rate on fatigue of compact bone
Bone
(1989)

M.B. Schaffler et al.

Long-term fatigue behavior of compact bone at low strain magnitude and rate

Bone

(1990)

A. Seireg et al.

Behavior of in vivo bone under cyclic loading

J. Biomechanics

(1969)

H.J. Burrows

Fatigue infraction of the middle of tibia in ballet dancers

J. Bone Jt Surg.

(1956)

D.R. Carter et al.

Cycle dependent and time dependent bone fracture with repeated loading

J. biomech. Engng

(1983)

D.R. Carter et al.

A cumulative damage model for bone fracture

J. Orthop. Res.

(1985)

Cited by (90)

Fatigue behaviour of load-bearing polymeric bone scaffolds: A review
2023, Acta Biomaterialia
Bone scaffolds play a crucial role in bone tissue engineering by providing mechanical support for the growth of new tissue while enduring static and fatigue loads. Although polymers possess favourable characteristics such as adjustable degradation rate, tissue-compatible stiffness, ease of fabrication, and low toxicity, their relatively low mechanical strength has limited their use in load-bearing applications. While numerous studies have focused on assessing the static strength of polymeric scaffolds, little research has been conducted on their fatigue properties. The current review presents a comprehensive study on the fatigue behaviour of polymeric bone scaffolds. The fatigue failure in polymeric scaffolds is discussed and the impact of material properties, topological features, loading conditions, and environmental factors are also examined. The present review also provides insight into the fatigue damage evolution within polymeric scaffolds, drawing comparisons to the behaviour observed in natural bone. Additionally, the effect of polymer microstructure, incorporating reinforcing materials, the introduction of topological features, and hydrodynamic/corrosive impact of body fluids in the fatigue life of scaffolds are discussed. Understanding these parameters is crucial for enhancing the fatigue resistance of polymeric scaffolds and holds promise for expanding their application in clinical settings as structural biomaterials.
Polymers have promising advantages for bone tissue engineering, including adjustable degradation rates, compatibility with native bone stiffness, ease of fabrication, and low toxicity. However, their limited mechanical strength has hindered their use in load-bearing scaffolds for clinical applications. While prior studies have addressed static behaviour of polymeric scaffolds, a comprehensive review of their fatigue performance is lacking. This review explores this gap, addressing fatigue characteristics, failure mechanisms, and the influence of parameters like material properties, topological features, loading conditions, and environmental factors. It also examines microstructure, reinforcement materials, pore architectures, body fluids, and tissue ingrowth effects on fatigue behaviour. A significant emphasis is placed on understanding fatigue damage progression in polymeric scaffolds, comparing it to natural bone behaviour.
Bone as a material: Lessons from nature
2021, Encyclopedia of Materials: Technical Ceramics and Glasses
Bone is a remarkable material that provides structure to the human body, protects internal organs and transmits movement. These functions are facilitated by this unique composite material consisting of an organic phase, largely comprised of collagen that provides shape and structure, and a mineral hydroxyapatite phase, which imparts bone strength. The quantity and mechanical integrity of each component phase, their structural organization and interactions at various hierarchical length scales create a material that is both lightweight and strong. Unlike engineering composite materials, bone can adapt itself and constantly renew and repair throughout life to replace aged or damaged bone with healthy bone tissue, which is facilitated by the activity of bone cells. This renewal and adaptive nature also enables redesign of the material and structure to optimize bone function in response to the ever changing demands of external loads. Disease and ageing impair the tissue leading to fractures, pain and immobility. Alternative materials have been explored to replace degenerative bones as part of medical devices or to encourage bone repair for tissue engineering applications.
Porosity and pore design influence on fatigue behavior of 3D printed scaffolds for trabecular bone replacement
2021, Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials
Citation Excerpt :
Fatihhi et al. also fatigue tested bovine trabecular bone, obtaining a dynamic modulus of 1297 MPa, for an 84% bone density and a maximum applied load of 50% UCS (Fatihhi et al., 2016). Michel et al. analyzed bovine trabecular bone under fatigue, reporting that under low-stress regime, trabecular specimens showed an initial modulus increase, while under high-stress regime, there was a progressive modulus decrease (Michel et al., 1993). 3D printed scaffolds showed an opposite behavior.
Polymeric scaffolds provide several advantages when compared with other bone replacement and regenerating techniques. Namely, when compared with the current gold standard, bone autografts, there is no shortage of supply nor donor site morbidity. Contrarily to metallic implants, their mechanical properties are similar to those of cortical bone and they are biodegradable, therefore stress shielding is not expected to occur, and they will be gradually replaced by new bone tissue. Yet, there are still several challenges to overcome. After implantation scaffolds are subjected to dynamic loads, thus understanding polymeric scaffolds’ fatigue behavior plays a major role on the design of better products. In this work PLA scaffolds were manufactured using 3D printing with optimized parameters. A total of six configurations were tested under static and dynamic load conditions. Static compression testing and numerical simulation showed good correlation. Numerical simulation provided a viable resource for scaffold design and innovation. Four different low-cycle fatigue loads were applied, during 3600 cycles with a frequency of 0.25 Hz. While under dynamic conditions, with a maximum stress of 24 MPa and R = 0.1, the apparent compressive modulus reached 973 MPa, due to pore collapse. Even after 3600 cycles no significant fatigue damage mechanisms were found on low porosity scaffolds, rendering them useful for trabecular bone replacement under dynamic conditions.
Fatigue behavior of subchondral bone under simulated physiological loads of equine athletic training
2020, Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials
Fatigue-induced subchondral bone (SCB) injuries are prevalent among athletes due to the repetitive application of high magnitude loads on joints during intense physical training. Existing fatigue studies on bone utilize a standard fatigue test approach by applying loads of a constant magnitude and frequency even though physiological/realistic loading is a combination of various load magnitudes and frequencies. Metal materials in implant and aerospace applications have been studied for fatigue behavior under physiological or realistic loading, however, no such study has been conducted on biological materials like bones. In this study, we investigated fatigue behavior of SCB under the range of loads likely to occur during a fast-workout of an equine athlete in training.
A loading protocol was developed by simulating physiological loads occurring during a fast-workout of a racehorse in training, which consisted of a sequence of compression-compression load cycles, including a warm-up (32, 54, 61 MPa) and cool-down (61, 54, 32 MPa) before and after the slow/fast/slow gallop phase of training, also referred to as a training loop. This loading protocol/training loop was applied at room temperature in load-control mode to cylindrical SCB specimens (n = 12) harvested from third metacarpal medial condyles (MCIII) of twelve thoroughbred racehorses and repeated until fatigue failure. The mean ± standard deviation for total time-to-failure (TTF) was 76,393 ± 64,243 s (equivalent to 18.3 ± 15.7 training workouts) for n = 12 specimens. We observed the highest relative energy loss (REL, hysteresis loss normalized to energy absorbed in a load cycle) under loads equivalent to gallop speeds and all specimens failed under these gallop loads. This demonstrates the importance of the gallop speeds in the development of SCB injury, consistent with observations made in live racehorses. Moreover, specimens with higher mean REL and lower mean stiffness during the first loop had a shorter fatigue life which further confirms the detrimental effect of high energy loss in SCB. Further studies are required to reconcile our results with fatigue injuries among equine athletes and understand the influence of different training programs on the fatigue behavior of subchondral bone.
Impact of scapular notching on glenoid fixation in reverse total shoulder arthroplasty: an in vitro and finite element study
2020, Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery
The high incidence of scapular notching in reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (RTSA) has spurred several methods to minimize bone loss. However, up to 93% of RTSAs accompanying scapular notching have been reported to maintain good implant stability for over 10 years. This study was conducted to investigate the relationship between scapular notching and glenoid fixation in RTSA.
Cadaveric testing was performed to measure the notch-induced variations in strain on the scapular surface and micromotion at the bone-prosthesis interface during arm abductions of 30°, 60°, and 90°. Finite element analysis was used to further study the bone and screw stresses as well as the bone-prosthesis micromotion in cases with a grade 4 notch during complicated arm motions.
The notch resulted in an apparent increase in inferior screw stress in the root of the screw cap and at the notch-screw conjunction. However, the maximum stress (172 MPa) along the screw after notching is still much less than the fatigue strength of the titanium screw (600 MPa) under cyclic loading. The bone-prosthesis micromotion results did not present significant notch-induced variations.
Scapular notching will lead to few impacts on the stability of an RTSA on the glenoid side. This finding may explain the long-term longevity of RTSA in cases of severe scapular notching. The relationship between scapular notching and weak regions along the inferior screw may explain why fractures of the inferior screw are sometimes reported in patients with RTSA clinically.
Fatigue-caused damage in trabecular bone from clinical, morphological and mechanical perspectives
2020, International Journal of Fatigue
Citation Excerpt :
We observed three principal types of fracture: (i) a diagonal fracture, generally occurring in the top region of the sample and being 45°-oriented (Fig. 3a), (ii) an orthogonal fracture to the longitudinal direction, generally occurring in the mid-region of the sample (Fig. 3b), and (iii) a splitting fracture, generally occurring as a lateral separation of part of the trabecular bone sample, causing a buckling-like failure (Fig. 3c). These failure modes are in agreement with previous findings in literature [57]. In particular, the transverse failure represents a brittle-like failure and is generally associated with trabeculae orthogonally oriented to the loading direction.
Bone quantity and quality are considered the main predictors of bone mechanical properties (i.e., strength and fracture resistance). These factors deal with the morphology and chemical composition of bone and can be assessed by non-invasive techniques such as dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (DXA), providing the bone mineral density (BMD) and the trabecular bone score (TBS). These parameters, and in particular BMD, are currently used as clinical predictors of fracture risk but do not provide information regarding the fatigue life. Bone is continuously subjected to fatigue loading and fatigue-induced damage can be crucial in fragility fractures. To probe the effect of fatigue-induced damage on bone microarchitecture and elucidate the effect of such damage on the bone clinical parameters, we combined fatigue testing on ex-vivo porcine trabecular bone samples with DXA measurements and μCT imaging. In addition, we performed interrupted cyclic tests at different load levels and measured fatigue-induced damage accumulation in the form of stiffness degradation. We also highlighted the change of clinical and microstructural parameters during the accumulation of fatigue-induced damage in interrupted fatigue tests. Our results suggest that the parameters obtained from the current non-invasive diagnostic protocols (i.e. μCT and DXA) are not able to assess the amount of fatigue-induced damage. This can be due to the fact that such techniques provide global parameters, whereas fatigue-induced damage is a local phenomenon, closely connected to the microarchitecture.

View all citing articles on Scopus

^‡: Also at Division of Applied Sciences, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA 02138, U.S.A.

View full text