African Mining, Gender, and Local Employment
Introduction
Africa’s opportunities are being transformed by new discoveries of natural resources and their rising prices (Collier, 2010), and the mining sector is the main recipient of foreign direct investment in Sub-Saharan Africa (World Bank, 2011). Whether the discovery of natural resources is a blessing or a curse to the economy and to a country’s citizens is a contentious issue (see Frankel, 2010 or van der Ploeg, 2011 for overviews), and natural resource dependence is linked to various outcomes at the national level: institutions (e.g., Mehlum, Mehlum), corruption (e.g., Leite & Weidmann, 2002), civil war and conflict (e.g., Collier and Hoeffler, 2004, Collier and Hoeffler, 2005), rent appropriation by an elite (e.g., Auty, 2001, Auty, 2007), democracy (e.g., Barro, 2000, Jensen and Wantchekon, 2004), and female labor force participation (Ross, 2008, Ross, 2012).1
While the country-level economic and political effects of extractive industries are well explored, the research on their local economic effects is nascent. The present paper adds to recent literature on local effects of natural resources (e.g., Allcott and Keniston, 2014, Aragón and Rud, 2013, Berman; Caselli and Michaels, 2013, Chuhan-Pole, Kotsadam, Michaels, 2011, Wilson, 2012), by investigating the effects of large-scale industrial mining on local labor markets.2 We use the best available survey data for Africa, Demographic and Health Surveys (DHS). The main focus is on women’s labor market opportunities, and we contrast our findings with the effects for men. Access to employment improves women’s lives and is listed among the top five priorities for promoting gender equality in the 2012 World Development Report (World Bank, 2012).
It is theoretically ambiguous whether industrial mining increases or decreases female employment. The African Mining Vision, formulated by the member states of the African Union, together with the African Development Bank and the United Nations, emphasizes that extractive industries may hurt women (UNECA, 2011). Similarly, Ross, 2008, Ross, 2012 claims that exploitation of natural resources hurts women’s employment via both demand and supply channels. In his model, female labor supply is reduced via a household income effect, spurred by higher male incomes and/or increased government transfers. The demand for female labor decreases as export-oriented and female-dominated manufacturing is crowded out by Dutch disease effects. He tests his theory using cross country regressions of female labor force participation on oil wealth and finds that oil rich countries have fewer women working, a finding he claims is also valid for mining. There is, however, little reason to expect these effects in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA). First, the manufacturing sector in rural SSA is small (see Bigsten & Söderbom, 2006 or Isham, Woolcock, Pritchett, & Busby, 2005 for an overview).3 Second, if women have the opportunity to shift to the service sector, the demand for female labor need not decrease. Women are overrepresented in sales and services in SSA, but underrepresented in production and manufacturing, as shown by data from ILO’s Key Indicators of the Labour Market database (ILO, 2011).
The effects of natural resource extraction on the local economy are often described in terms of linkages and multipliers (e.g., Aragón and Rud, 2013, Eggert, 2002). Local multipliers describe the effect of an employment increase in one sector on employment in other sectors. Moretti (2010) shows that an increase in the production of tradable goods leads to increased local demand for non-tradables as the number of workers and their salaries increase. However, the multipliers for tradables depend on local changes in labor costs, since tradable goods have prices set nationally or internationally (Moretti, 2010, Moretti and Thulin, 2013).
The strand of literature on linkages and multipliers argue for positive local employment effects. If the multipliers are small, we will find economically and statistically insignificant effects. Such findings would support the traditional view of mines as having few or no linkages to the local community. This “enclave” theory was first hypothesized by Hirschman (1958) and became a stylized fact in the second part of the last century (UNECA, 2011, see also Ferguson, 2005). There is limited empirical evidence for this theory. Numerous case studies on artisanal and small-scale mining show that mining enables livelihood diversification (e.g., Fessehaie and Morris, 2013, Hirons, 2014, Hilson and Garforth, 2013, Okoh and Hilson, 2011, Spiegel, 2012). However, small-scale and large-scale mining differ in many respects: One important aspect is the labor to capital ratio, assumed high in small-scale mining and low in large-scale mining. Quantitative case studies of the large-scale sector find mixed results. The coal mining boom of the 70s in the US resulted in modest local employment spillovers but increasing wage rates (Black, McKinnish, & Sanders, 2005), and contemporary oil and gas booms in the US have increased district employment levels (Allcott & Keniston, 2014). A study of local welfare effects around the world’s second largest gold mine in Peru found support for the enclave hypothesis in absence of policies for local procurement of goods (Aragón & Rud, 2013).
If the multiplier effects are stronger, we expect an increase in male and female labor force participation with female employment concentrated in services and sales and male employment concentrated in manual labor, reflecting the gender segregation in the Sub-Sahara African labor markets. Qualitative studies have found that women dominate the provision of goods and services around small-scale mines in Africa (Hinton, 2006, ILO, 1999), while they are not much engaged in the mining sector directly.4 Spillover effects on the tradable sector are less likely to substantially affect the demand for female labor because women are not strongly represented in the tradable sector, including manufacturing and construction.
The effect on labor supply in agriculture is a priori ambiguous. A mine expansion can change local agriculture through a variety of channels: competition over land use, expropriation and changes in land prices (UNECA, 2011), pollution (Aragón & Rud, 2015), intra-household reallocation of labor including substitution effects, and demand changes for agricultural goods. The literature on small-scale mining often finds a shift from agriculture to mining (e.g., Lu & Lora-Wainwright, 2014), although some leave agriculture without finding new livelihood opportunities (Bebbington, Bebbington, Bury, Lingan, Muñoz, & Scurrah, 2008). Furthermore, the shift may not be sustainable in the long run as mines have limited life-spans (Cartier and Bürge, 2011, Jaskoski, 2014, Maconachie and Binns, 2007). We contribute by analyzing if these patterns hold for large-scale mining and through a gender lens. Moreover, we contribute by quantitatively assessing the long-run sustainability of the large-scale mining sector by separately analyzing mine closures. A limitation of the study is that it cannot compare the employment effects of small-scale versus the large-scale mining sector. Such a comparative analysis could inform national and international strategic policies on the total mineral sector. However, the study is policy relevant as it is, to our knowledge, the first quantitative assessment of the African large-scale mining sector’s ability to generate local employment.
A novelty of the present paper is that it connects production data on 874 industrial mines starting in 1975 to DHS household survey data for women aged 15–49. The unique combination of datasets with more than 500,000 sampled women and almost 300,000 partners in 29 countries enables us to investigate local spillover effects on employment by a difference-in-difference method. By exploiting the spatial and temporal variation in the data, we compare people living close to a mine with those living further away, and individuals living close to a producing mine with those who live in the vicinity of a mine that is yet to open. We include sub-national region fixed effects and thereby control for time-invariant differences between countries and sub-national regions, such as time-stable mining strategies, institutions, trade patterns, openness, sectoral composition, level of economic development and gender norms. In addition, by including regional-specific time trends we make the identification strategy less reliant on assumption of similar trends across areas.
We show that industrial mine openings constitute a mixed blessing for women. They trigger a local structural shift, whereby women shift from agricultural work to the service sector, or out of the labor force. More women leave self-employment in agriculture (seven percentage points, or 25% decline) than enter into services (two percentage points, or 50% increase), but the service sector jobs are less seasonal and cash earnings opportunities increase with 7.4 percentage points (16%). A back-of-the-envelope calculation estimates that more than 90,000 women get service sector jobs as a result of industrial mining in their communities, and more than 280,000 women leave the labor force. Male partners shift to skilled manual labor, and some find jobs within mining. The effects of mine openings wear off with distance and are close to zero at 50 km from a mine. Mine closing causes the expanded sectors to contract. The results are robust to a wide battery of robustness checks, such as using different measures of distance and excluding migrants from the sample.
There are large and persistent differences in value added per worker in agriculture and non-agricultural sectors in developing countries (Gollin, Jedwab, & Vollrath, 2014). The difference indicates misallocation of workers, with too many workers in low yielding agriculture. In this paper, we show that mining has the power to locally stimulate non-agricultural sectors and provide cash earning opportunities. However, more people leave agriculture than access jobs in the growing sectors, and the jobs in the growing sectors are seemingly temporary. The findings indicate that large-scale mining is creating local boom-bust economies in Africa, with transient and gender-specific employment effects.
In the next section we present the data. In Section 3, we lay out the empirical strategy. In Section 4, we present the empirical results and in Section 5, we show robustness tests and heterogeneous effects, and in Section 6, we conclude.
Section snippets
Data
We use a novel longitudinal data set on large-scale mines in Africa, from IntierraRMG. We link the resource data to survey data for women and their partners from the Demographic and Health Surveys (DHS), using spatial information. Point coordinates (GPS) for the surveyed DHS clusters, a cluster being one or several geographically close villages or a neighborhood in an urban area, allow us to match all individuals to one or several mineral mines.
From a mine center point, given by its GPS
Empirical strategy
With several waves of survey data combined with detailed information on mines, the estimation relies on a spatial–temporal estimation strategy, using multiple definitions of the mine footprint area based on different proximity measures and alternative definitions of the control group.
Assuming that people are not restricted to only one mine but rather seek employment at or around any mine falling within a cut-off distance, our main identification strategy includes three groups with the baseline
Results
We start by exploring the evolution of employment over time. Fig. 2 shows the trends in service-level employment for those within 20 km and those between 20 and 200 km from a mine. The x-axis shows the time in years in relation to when the mine opens and the y-axis shows the average levels of service employment in each year in relation to mine opening. The treatment group follows a similar trend as the control group in service sector employment until mine opening, but at a lower level. This
Heterogeneous impacts
Mining can create non-agricultural job opportunities, allowing women to earn more cash and work outside the traditional and dominating agricultural sector. The uptake of jobs for women will likely depend on income and substitution effects. The income effect is linked to the supply side argument in Ross, 2008, Ross, 2012, where women’s employment is modeled to decrease as their husbands earn more money with the increase in extractive activities. If this channel is correctly hypothesized, the
Conclusion
The discovery of natural resources across the African continent brings hope for millions of poor people, but there are also fears that the resources will be a curse rather than a blessing (Collier, 2010). In particular, one fear spelled out in The Africa Mining Vision is that gender inequality in economic opportunities may increase with mining (UNECA, 2011). Using detailed data on industrial mining in Sub-Saharan Africa, we explore whether mining generates local employment opportunities for
Acknowledgments
We thank Maria Eriksson Baaz, Benedikte Bjerge, Christa Brunnschweiler, James Cust, Klaus Deininger, James Fenske, Henning Finseraas, Solomon Hsiang, Niklas Jakobsson, Amir Jina, Jo Thori Lind, Deirdre McCloskey, Halvor Mehlum, Kyle Meng, Edward Miguel, Andreea Mitrut, Dale Mortensen, Hanna Mühlrad, Ola Olsson, Maria Persson, Juan Pablo Rud, Måns Söderbom and Francis Teal, and three anonymous referees for helpful comments. The paper has also benefited from comments by seminar and conference
References (78)
The political economy of resource-driven growth
European Economic Review
(2001)Natural resources, capital accumulation and the resource curse
Ecological Economics
(2007)- et al.
Mining and social movements: Struggles over livelihood and rural territorial development in the andes
World Development
(2008) - et al.
The Resource curse revisited and revised: A tale of paradoxes and red herrings
Journal of Environmental Economics and Management
(2008) - et al.
Local determinants of African civil wars, 1970–2001
Political Geography
(2006) Migrancy, masculine identities and AIDS: The psychosocial context of HIV transmission on the South African gold mines
Social Science & medicine
(1997)Small-scale mining, poverty and economic development in sub-Saharan Africa: An overview
Resources Policy
(2009)Family hardship and cultural values: Child labor in malian small-scale gold mining communities
World Development
(2012)- et al.
Can microcredit services alleviate hardship in African small-scale mining communities?
World Development
(2011) Shifting sand, shifting livelihoods? Reflections on a coastal gold rush in Ghana
Resources Policy
(2014)
Environmental licensing and conflict in peru’s mining sector: A path-dependent analysis
World Development
Historicizing sustainable livelihoods: A pathways approach to lead mining in rural central China
World Development
Farming miners or mining farmers?: Diamond mining and rural development in post-conflict Sierra Leone
Journal of Rural Studies
Governance institutions, resource rights regimes, and the informal mining sector: Regulatory complexities in Indonesia
World Development
Learning by doing and the Dutch disease
European Economic Review
Economic booms and risky sexual behavior: Evidence from Zambian copper mining cities
Journal of Health Economics
Mode of transport to work by government employees in the Kumasi metropolis, Ghana
Journal of Transport Geography
Rural windfall or a new resource curse? Cocoa, income, and civil conflict in Colombia
The Review of Economics and Statistics
Natural resources and local communities: Evidence from a Peruvian Gold Mine
American Economic Journal: Economic Policy
Polluting industries and agricultural productivity: Evidence from mining in Ghana
The Economic Journal
Democracy and the rule of law
What have we learned from a decade of manufacturing enterprise surveys in Africa?
World Bank Research Observer
The economic impact of the coal boom and bust
The Economic Journal
International commodity prices, growth and the outbreak of civil war in Sub-Saharan Africa
The Economic Journal
Linking natural resources to slow growth and more conflict
Science
Natural resources and violent conflict: Resource abundance, dependence, and the onset of civil wars
Oxford Economic Papers
Agriculture and artisanal gold mining in sierra leone: Alternatives or complements?
Journal of International Development
Do oil windfalls improve living standards? Evidence from Brazil
American Economic Journal: Applied Economics
The plundered planet
Greed and grievances in civil war
Oxford Economic Papers
Resource rents, governance, and conflict
Journal of Conflict Resolution
Mines, migration and HIV/AIDS in Southern Africa
Journal of African Economies
Commodity price shocks and civil conflict: Evidence from Colombia
Review of Economic Studies
Wages and labor management in African manufacturing
Journal of Human Resources
Seeing like an oil company: Space, security, and global capital in neoliberal Africa
American Anthropologist
Cited by (118)
Mother Africa: The long run effects of income shocks on fertility
2024, Journal of Economic Behavior and OrganizationWhere's our share: Agenda for gender representation in mining industry
2024, Resources PolicyGender gaps in labor market outcomes in a resource-dependent country
2024, Resources PolicyThe evolution and persistence of women's roles: Evidence from the Gold Rush
2023, Journal of Economic Behavior and OrganizationRoads, women's employment, and gender equity: Evidence from Cambodia
2023, World DevelopmentFuel or power Africa? The impact of Chinese foreign aid on energy poverty
2023, Energy Research and Social Science