Original research
Mitigating the risk of musculoskeletal injury: A systematic review of the most effective injury prevention strategies for military personnel

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsams.2017.09.014Get rights and content

Abstract

Objectives

To update the current injury prevention strategy evidence base for making recommendations to prevent physical training-related musculoskeletal injury.

Design

We conducted a systematic review to update the evidence base on injury prevention strategies for military personnel.

Methods

Literature was systematically searched and extracted from five databases, and reported according to PRISMA guidelines. Sixty one articles meeting the inclusion criteria and published during the period 2008–2015 were selected for systematic review.

Results

The retrieved articles were broadly categorised into six injury prevention strategies; (1) conditioning, (2) footwear modifications, (3) bracing, (4) physical activity volume, (5) physical fitness, and (6) leadership/supervision/awareness. The majority of retrieved articles (n = 37 (of 61) evaluated or systematically reviewed a conditioning intervention of some nature. However, the most well-supported strategies were related to reducing physical activity volume and improving leadership/supervision/awareness of injuries and injury prevention efforts.

Conclusions

Several injury prevention strategies effectively reduce musculoskeletal injury rates in both sexes, and many show promise for utility with military personnel. However, further evaluation, ideally with prospective randomised trials, is required to establish the most effective injury prevention strategies, and to understand any sex-specific differences in the response to these strategies.

Introduction

Musculoskeletal injuries (MSkI) are the primary cause of medical discharge and medical downgrade in the United Kingdom Armed Forces.1 Given the impact of MSkI on deployability and combat effectiveness, understanding how to most effectively mitigate against this risk is crucial for achieving, maintaining and retaining a healthy, effective and operationally deployable workforce. Physical training (PT) is a primary cause of, and risk factor for, MSkI,2 yet developing and maintaining physical capability is a critical aspect of military training and employment. Acquiring and maintaining a high level of physical fitness (aerobic endurance, anaerobic endurance, muscle strength and muscle endurance) is necessary for successful performance of military-specific tasks during training and operations. Optimising this cost-benefit trade-off between PT-mediated combat effectiveness and injury risk is critical for achieving and maintaining the required performance standards, and reducing injury rates, of Service personnel. Mitigation strategies for MSkI therefore include, but are not limited to, optimising PT and injury prevention.

Women are at higher risk of MSkI than men throughout military training and employment.1 Accordingly, female sex is often considered a major risk factor for injury.3 However, this risk may be reflective of lower aerobic fitness in women than men, rather than a fundamental sex difference in injury risk.3 Currently, it is not known whether different injury prevention strategies should be adopted for men and women to promote recovery from injury and protect against future injury. During initial military training, rates of MSkI, and particularly rates of debilitating injuries including hip and pelvic stress fractures, are higher in women and Infantry males than men undergoing Standard Entrant military training.1 If women are to be successfully incorporated into the Combat arms, the projected increased risk of MSkI in this demographic group will require attention. Understanding the most effective strategies for injury prevention will facilitate this mitigation of risk and promote a healthier Force that is effective in combat.

We undertook a systematic review of the literature relating to prevention strategies for PT-related injuries. This review was undertaken to update the existing evidence base reported by Bullock and colleagues in 2010.4 Evaluation of 31 PT-related injury prevention strategies by Bullock et al.4 resulted in identification of 6 strategies that were graded as having a strong evidence base for the working group to make implementation recommendations for the military. These 6 strategies included; (1) prevent overtraining, (2) perform multiaxial, neuromuscular, proprioceptive and agility training, (3) wear mouthguards during high-risk activities, (4) wear semi-rigid ankle braces for high-risk activities, (5) consume nutrients to restore energy balance within 1 h following high-intensity activity, and (6) wear synthetic-blend socks to prevent blisters. Within all successful injury prevention strategies, 4 components were deemed critical to their success. These critical components (‘essential elements’) included; (1) education of military leaders, (2) leadership support, (3) unit injury surveillance, and (4) adequate resources for injury research and programme evaluation.

Our aims were to: (1) update the current injury prevention strategy evidence base for making recommendations to prevent PT-related MSkI covering the period 2008–2015; (2) prioritise the recommendations for MSkI prevention programmes, strategies and policies, with consideration for the influence of sex, and (3) highlight areas for further research to evaluate interventions likely to reduce PT-related MSkI. The years 2008–2015 were chosen as the date parameters for our literature search to directly follow on from the papers reviewed by Bullock et al.4

Section snippets

Methods

Our methodological approach closely followed that outlined in the paper by Bullock et al.4 Literature was searched and extracted from five databases (PUBMED, COCHRANE, ATHENA, Defense Technical Information Centre Scientific and Technical Information Network, Google Scholar), with papers also identified from the reference lists of appropriate articles. Searches included the terms “injury prevention”, AND “physical training” OR “physical fitness”. A total of 764 articles were identified from the

Results

The eligible full-text reviewed intervention studies were broadly categorised into 6 types of injury prevention intervention. These intervention categories included; (1) conditioning (n = 266, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31), (2) footwear modification (n = 632, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37), (3) bracing (n = 218, 38), (4) physical activity volume (n = 539, 40, 41, 42, 43), (5) physical fitness (n = 344, 45, 46) and, (6)

Discussion

We provide an updated position to the injury prevention evidence base detailed by Bullock et al.4 Combined findings support a reduction in physical activity volume, and bracing for high-risk activities, to reduce injury rates, particularly in military cohorts. However, using multiaxial, neuromuscular, proprioceptive and agility training to reduce injury rates was not supported by the additional studies in our review. Although no negative effects of these types of conditioning programmes were

Limitations of the review

The systematic literature search was limited to a few, specific search terms. Although we feel that these search terms enabled us to retrieve the most appropriate articles, we can not be sure that equally relevant articles were not missed. The searches were performed by only one author (SW). However, the strategy for searching, identifying and screening articles was agreed by both authors and discussed with our wider research group to ensure consistency of approach. Some of the evaluated

Conclusion

Prevention strategies can be implemented effectively to reduce MSkI rates in both sexes, even in military training environments where competing demands and the requirement to achieve desired output standards are high. Appropriate leadership, improving physical fitness in the absence of high physical activity volumes, and bracing for high-risk activities/rehabilitation appear beneficial for reducing PT-related MSkI, whereas modification of footwear and conditioning exercises would not be

Practical implications

  • Appropriate leadership, and awareness of injury prevention strategies by individuals in leadership positions, are important contributors to the effectiveness of injury prevention strategies.

  • Improving physical fitness, in the absence of excessive time on foot, is an effective strategy to reduce musculoskeletal rates and may reduce female injury rates.

  • There is no existing evidence to suggest that different injury prevention strategies should be adopted by men and women separately, although

Conflict of interest statement

No conflict of interest declared.

Acknowledgements

We wish to acknowledge the Women in Ground Close Combat research team for their input into the study design and data interpretation. No financial support was received directly for this piece of work.

References (72)

  • D. Moher et al.

    Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement

    J Clin Epidemiol

    (2009)
  • Interim Report on the Health Risks to Women in Ground Close Combat Roles...
  • E.J. Zambraski et al.

    Prevention and rehabilitation of musculoskeletal injuries during military operations and training

    J Strength Cond Res

    (2012)
  • Thacker SB, Stroup DF, Branche CM, et al. The prevention of ankle sprains in sports. A systematic review of the...
  • C. Brushøj et al.

    Prevention of overuse injuries by a concurrent exercise program in subjects exposed to an increase in training load: a randomized controlled trial of 1020 army recruits

    Am J Sports Med

    (2008)
  • A.L. Owen et al.

    Effect of an injury prevention program on muscle injuries in elite professional soccer

    J Strength Cond Res

    (2013)
  • R.L. Goodall et al.

    Balance and agility training does not always decrease lower limb injury risks: a cluster-randomised controlled trial

    Int J Injury Cont Safety Prom

    (2013)
  • R.J. Coppack et al.

    The effects of exercise for the prevention of overuse anterior knee pain: a randomized controlled trial

    Am J Sports Med

    (2011)
  • P. Hölmich et al.

    Exercise program for prevention of groin pain in football players: a cluster-randomized trial

    Scand J Med Sci Sport

    (2010)
  • H. Silvers-Granelli et al.

    Efficacy of the FIFA 11+ injury prevention program in the collegiate male soccer player

    Am J Sports Med

    (2015)
  • L. Goossens et al.

    A multifactorial injury prevention intervention reduces injury incidence in Physical Education Teacher Education students

    Eur J Sport Sci

    (2016)
  • M. de Hoyo et al.

    Effects of a 10-week in-season eccentric-overload training program on muscle-injury prevention and performance in junior elite soccer players

    Int J Sports Physiol Perform

    (2015)
  • D.R. Grooms et al.

    Soccer-specific warm-up and lower extremity injury rates in collegiate male soccer players

    J Athl Train

    (2013)
  • H. Gatterer et al.

    Effects of the performance level and the FIFA “11” injury prevention program on the injury rate in Italian male amateur soccer players

    J Sports Med Phys Fitness

    (2012)
  • K.W. Janssen et al.

    Bracing superior to neuromuscular training for the prevention of self-reported recurrent ankle sprains: a three-arm randomised controlled trial

    Br J Sports Med

    (2014)
  • E. Cumps et al.

    Effect of a preventive intervention programme on the prevalence of anterior knee pain in volleyball players

    Eur J Sport Sci

    (2008)
  • J.D. Childs et al.

    Effects of traditional sit-up training versus core stabilization exercises on short-term musculoskeletal injuries in US army soldiers: a cluster randomized trial

    Phys Ther

    (2010)
  • J. Parkkari et al.

    Neuromuscular training with injury prevention counselling to decrease the risk of acute musculoskeletal injury in young men during military service: a population-based, randomised study

    BMC Med

    (2011)
  • E. Eils et al.

    Multistation proprioceptive exercise program prevents ankle injuries in basketball

    Med Sci Sports Exerc

    (2010)
  • A.H. Engebretsen et al.

    Prevention of injuries among male soccer players: a prospective, randomized intervention study targeting players with previous injuries or reduced function

    Am J Sports Med

    (2008)
  • J. Gilchrist et al.

    A randomized controlled trial to prevent noncontact anterior cruciate ligament injury in female collegiate soccer players

    Am J Sports Med

    (2008)
  • G. Jamtvedt et al.

    A pragmatic randomised trial of stretching before and after physical activity to prevent injury and soreness

    Br J Sports Med.

    (2010)
  • K. Pasanen et al.

    Neuromuscular training and the risk of leg injuries in female floorball players: cluster randomised controlled study

    BMJ

    (2008)
  • A.M.C. van Beijsterveldt et al.

    Effectiveness of an injury prevention programme for adult male amateur soccer players: a cluster-randomised controlled trial

    Br J Sports Med

    (2012)
  • M.D.W. Hupperets et al.

    Effect of unsupervised home based proprioceptive training on recurrences of ankle sprain: randomised controlled trial

    BMJ

    (2009)
  • S.W. Bredeweg et al.

    The effectiveness of a preconditioning programme on preventing running-related injuries in novice runners: a randomised controlled trial

    Br J Sports Med

    (2012)
  • View full text